The order is required to fix a lacuna that has recently arisen in the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, which I will refer to as POCA.
Scottish courts can make confiscation orders against certain offenders under part 3 of POCA. In each case, the court must decide whether an offender has a criminal lifestyle and, if so, whether he or she has benefited from his or her general conduct. An offender is considered to have a criminal lifestyle if he or she is convicted of an offence that is specified in schedule 4 to POCA. Where that is the case, the court can assume that the offender’s income, expenditure and assets over the previous six years constitute or represent the offender’s benefit from his or her general criminal conduct for the purpose of calculating the amount to be confiscated, unless the assumption is shown to be incorrect or would otherwise result in a serious risk of injustice. That is basically how POCA works.
Schedule 4 to POCA lists a number of lifestyle offences, and the Scottish ministers can amend the list by order. In 2011, the Scottish Parliament approved such an order, which added to the list an offence under section 39(1) of the Consumer Credit Act 1974, concerning illegal money lending. The purpose was to target illegal money lenders who profit from exploiting vulnerable individuals and communities. However, the Consumer Credit Act 1974 was largely repealed by United Kingdom legislation on 1 April 2014. That included the offence provision in section 39; consequently, the offence was also removed from the list of lifestyle offences in schedule 4 to POCA.
The Scottish Government is committed to ensuring that schedule 4 to POCA continues to be an effective means of depriving criminals of the proceeds of their crime. The order aims to reinstate illegal money lending as a lifestyle offence. If approved, it will amend schedule 4 to respecify the offence in its new guise as an offence under section 23(1) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, as that is the act that now authorises and regulates consumer credit-related activity.
Although the current hiatus in schedule 4 to POCA has not affected any on-going confiscation proceedings, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service both welcome the amendment that the Scottish Government proposes to make through the order.
Basically, a gap was opened up by virtue of Westminster legislation. We are simply moving to close that gap again, in accordance with what we as a Parliament already agreed a couple of years ago.