link
To ask the First Minister what steps revenue Scotland would take to prevent tax avoidance practices in the event that Scotland had greater responsibility for taxation. (S4F-02102)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what steps revenue Scotland would take to prevent tax avoidance practices in the event that Scotland had greater responsibility for taxation. (S4F-02102)
The Scottish Government intends to take the toughest possible line on aggressive tax avoidance. We are determined to act decisively on avoidance, for example, of devolved taxation. The Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill, which is currently before the Parliament, contains powers that will enable revenue Scotland to take robust action to counteract tax avoidance, including the introduction of a wide-ranging general anti-avoidance rule for devolved taxes, as Patrick Harvie knows.
The Scottish Government will seek to replicate that approach in developing the Scottish tax system following independence.
link
In recent days there have been further revelations about the scale of the scandal of tax avoidance in the United Kingdom, from the members of Take That and other wealthy individuals in the Icebreaker scam to Amazon’s corporate tax bill of £4.2 million after sales of £4.3 billion, while HM Revenue and Customs seems most concerned with selling citizens’ tax data to the highest bidder.
Will the First Minister join in the many and growing calls for a boycott of Amazon until it starts paying its fair share? Does he agree that only Europe-wide co-operation between countries on corporate tax levels can stop the loopholes that disreputable companies such as Amazon are so determined to wriggle through?
I will not join a call for a boycott. That would have an impact on Scottish workers and Scottish jobs, as Patrick Harvie should know. However, what I will say is that I deprecate aggressive tax avoidance. Tax evasion, of course, is illegal.
While deprecating such behaviour, we should look for the solution in the tax system itself. A simple, transparent tax system reduces the opportunity for aggressive tax avoidance. On page 121 of “Scotland’s Future: Your Guide to an Independent Scotland”, Patrick Harvie will find the actions that the Scottish Government in an independent Parliament would seek to take.
I draw Patrick Harvie’s attention to what we are already doing, in this Parliament, with the new tax powers that are being introduced. We have chosen not to ask HMRC to administer the new taxes but to set up revenue Scotland. Michael Clancy, the director of law reform at the Law Society of Scotland said in evidence to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee:
“In the evidence that we are giving on the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill, we are looking at its provisions on the Scottish general anti-avoidance rule. We have compared those provisions with the current general anti-abuse provisions in the Finance Act 2013 and we think that the Scottish GAAR provisions are much better. They are less complex and should prove to be more effective.”—[Official Report, Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, 19 March 2014; c 4205.]
I think that we have reason for hope and demonstration that what we are introducing with the new responsibilities that we are getting will provide a template for a tax system in an independent Scotland that will secure and protect us against the sort of unacceptable, aggressive tax avoidance that is widespread in the UK tax system.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.