Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 15 May 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 19 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02087)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

In 2012, the then health secretary, Nicola Sturgeon, proposed changes to mental health services in Lanarkshire. They were opposed by her Cabinet colleague and local MSP Alex Neil. She addressed his concerns and the professional medical advice was that the changes should go ahead. When Alex Neil became health secretary in September 2012, he ordered that the changes be reversed, against medical and patient opinion. He then deceived this Parliament and deceived the people of Scotland by saying—

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

—that he would take no part in the decision he had already made. If Alex Neil will not resign for deceiving Parliament, will the First Minister sack him?

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We will not have members accusing each other of deceiving across the chamber.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

The answer is no.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Perhaps the First Minister should look at the documents that my colleague John Pentland obtained through freedom of information, because we now know that, on 26 September 2012, Alex Neil’s office emailed this instruction to officials. I quote:

“Mr Neil is clear in his view that acute mental health facilities should be retained in both Wishaw and Monklands. The Cabinet Secretary has asked that you seek agreement from NHS Lanarkshire to reconfigure their plans accordingly.”

With that order, he reversed Nicola Sturgeon’s policy, which was made on the advice of medical professionals and backed by patients. He then told the Parliament, the head of the national health service and the head of the civil service that he would absent himself from a decision on those services, even though he had already made the decision.

If Alex Neil will not resign because of this behaviour, will the First Minister sack him?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

That is the same question that she asked before, and I gave her the answer in answer to the first question. Just because she says deceiving instead of misleading, it does not remove the responsibility to try to give some substance to the charges that she is making.

I looked at this issue on 14 February 2013. I gave a substantial reply to Ms McMahon, the MSP who raised it with me, in terms of her question as to whether Alex Neil was in breach of the ministerial code. I pointed out the following—I will read it to Johann Lamont:

“In the light of questions in the Scottish Parliament on 26 September 2012”—

that is the date that Johann Lamont mentioned, but she forgot to say about the questions in the Parliament—

“about these proposed changes and the narrowing parliamentary focus on the impact of proposals for Monklands Hospital, Mr Neil became concerned that there could be a perception of a conflict of interest.” [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I will continue:

“Accordingly, he agreed, that day, with the Director General of Health and Social Care, Derek Feeley, that all matters relating to mental health services at Monklands Hospital should be dealt with by the Minister for Public Health. Mr Feeley informed the Permanent Secretary on 27 September.”

That is exactly how ministers should behave under these circumstances. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I can say to the Labour Party that there is another aspect to this that it should bear in mind. The question of mental health services in Lanarkshire affects the whole area of the health board. It has a constituency aspect, as it has an aspect to all constituencies in that health board area. To define it purely as a constituency issue ignores the fact that the health service affects and serves all of the population. I looked at the issue carefully last year and I came to the conclusion that Mr Neil had acted perfectly properly. I replied in those terms to the member concerned, and if Johann Lamont would like to look at that reply and acknowledge the sequence of events, she will see that that reply is validated by the evidence.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

The First Minister needs to look at the sequence of events, because it is all about the timing. Let me help him.

At 9.43 am on 26 September 2012, Alex Neil’s office issued the order to reverse Nicola Sturgeon’s decision. At 2 pm, which is after 9.43 am, Alex Neil told this chamber that NHS Lanarkshire was reviewing its decision—but he had already ordered the board to change its position. On 19 December 2012, when asked about that decision, he told this Parliament:

“I decided early on in my tenure to give responsibility for that matter to my deputy Michael Matheson, as I did not want any perception of any potential conflict of interest between my role as the MSP for Airdrie and Shotts—where Monklands hospital resides—and my role as cabinet secretary.”—[Official Report, 19 December 2012; c 14922.]

The fact is that there was no perception of potential; there was the reality of the decision that Alex Neil had already taken and then tried to cover up. I ask the First Minister again: if Alex Neil will not resign, will the First Minister sack him?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Asking the question for the third time elicits the same answer: no, I will not, because I reviewed the evidence and came to the conclusion that Mr Neil acted perfectly properly.

All that Johann Lamont has done is cite exactly what I said to her colleague all those months ago. At that time, I detailed the sequence of events on 26 September 2012, and that sequence of events has been validated. The great revelation that Johann Lamont brings to the chamber is merely a confirmation of the sequence of events that was detailed to her colleague last year. [Interruption.] Of course that was the sequence of events. As said in the letter, after question time on 26 September, Mr Neil asked for advice and took the requisite action.

The ministerial code makes it quite clear how ministers should act. It also makes quite clear the First Minister’s role in judging that. Unlike the Labour Party, we are the only Administration that has put in independent oversight of the ministerial code. On six occasions, people such as Johann Lamont have come to this chamber and said that there has been an enormous scandal. Because that affected me, and because I have been under question, I have referred those things to independent oversight. On six occasions, I have been cleared by that commission, and—do you know what?—hardly ever after I have been cleared have the people who made allegations in this chamber of dreadful doings been prepared to acknowledge the independent oversight.

I looked at Mr Neil’s conduct and gave an explanation to Johann Lamont’s colleague that said exactly what happened. In reasonableness, unless she has some dramatic revelation to bring—which she has not—she should accept that Mr Neil not just acted to the benefit of his constituents but discharged his responsibilities as health secretary. That is why he took the action that he did and that is why the answer to Johann Lamont’s question is no—for the third time.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

That was just noise; it did not answer the question. Alex Neil made a decision and then extracted himself and said that if there were further decisions, somebody else would make them, but he had already made the decision in the morning.

We have established that Alex Neil has not been clear on what he did in relation to services in NHS Lanarkshire, but we wonder how far up the Government the process went. Peter Housden wrote to Siobhan McMahon and said:

“I would reiterate that should a ministerial decision be required ... this will be taken by the Minister for Public Health.”

Clearing Alex Neil, the First Minister, as we heard, wrote to Siobhan McMahon, saying the same thing. However, there was no need for a ministerial decision to be made by Michael Matheson, because Alex Neil had already made his ministerial decision. Were Peter Housden and the First Minister in on this—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

—or did Alex Neil play them for fools? I ask again: if Alex Neil will not resign for this behaviour, will the First Minister sack him?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I suppose that in the sense that I am the First Minister of Scotland, I am in on everything that happens in the Government. All that Johann Lamont is doing by asking something for the fourth time is making herself and her party look ridiculous.

Alex Neil has a long record of campaigning for the health service in Lanarkshire. If Alex Neil had not campaigned as a candidate, there would not be an accident and emergency department in Monklands. It is quite clear that the Labour Party’s interest in mental health services in Lanarkshire is not to do with facilities for patients; it is just an argument to try to get at a Scottish National Party minister.

Having heard a detailed explanation of events from the permanent secretary and the First Minister all that time ago, will Johann Lamont not accept that the answer to her question is no? Perhaps the next time that she comes to the chamber, she will talk about the substantive issues that affect the people of Scotland.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Roads (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
  2. National Health Service Boards (Private Finance Initiative Contract) Questions · 4
  3. Opencast Coal Sites (East Ayrshire) Questions · 4
  4. Hearing Loop Equipment (Local Authority Provision) Questions · 4
  5. Blood Glucose Test Strips Questions · 4
  6. Ophthalmology Services (Shetland) Questions · 6
  7. Accident and Emergency (Waiting Times) Questions · 8
  8. Cataract Operations Questions · 4
  9. Independent Scotland (State Pension) Questions · 5
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
  11. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  12. Tax Avoidance First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Retirement Age First Minister’s Questions · 10
  14. Courts Reform (Scotland) Bill First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Scottish Business Development Bank First Minister’s Questions · 5
  16. Point of Order Procedure · 13
  17. Animal Rights and Human Responsibilities Members’ business · 14
  18. Presiding Officer’s Ruling Procedure · 1
  19. Homecoming Scotland 2014 Debate · 103
  20. Decision Time Decision time · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.