I thank the 43 MSPs, representing the independents and all five political parties in the Parliament, who signed the motion to make the debate possible. I also thank the Community of Arran Seabed Trust—COAST—and the Sustainable Inshore Fisheries Trust for their briefings, and in particular I thank James Mackenzie for his energy, drive and enthusiasm. It is also good to see people in the gallery who have travelled a considerable distance for the debate, including a number of my Arran constituents, with whom I travelled on the boat from Brodick this morning.
The Firth of Clyde is vital to Scotland’s economic, cultural and environmental good health. It is one of the deepest coastal waterways in the British Isles and supports fishing, shipping, and tourism. Twenty per cent of all Scottish cargo passes through Clyde ports and about 60 per cent of all ferry traffic in Scotland travels across the Clyde. The Clyde also hosts Scotland’s only naval base. Recreational boating is becoming increasingly important, not least in my constituency, and about 40 per cent of all Scottish boats berth in the Clyde.
In recent decades, the Clyde has suffered severe losses in ecological and economic wellbeing. Overfishing has led to declining fish biodiversity, which has over the years caused many marine species to become increasingly rare and, in fact, smaller. The fishing industry has been forced to turn from its traditional finfish landings to an industry that is based increasingly on nephrops and scallops.
Fisheries have also led to a decrease in the recreational angling boats that were once so popular. Trawlers undoubtedly disrupt the natural ecosystem; trawls and dredges are invasive, because they drag the seabed bottom. Such fishing methods enabled the expansion of fishing opportunities and for decades there were increased fish landings each year. However, in 1889, only nine years after trawls were introduced to the Clyde, a 3-mile ban was placed on trawls because there had been a noticeable decline in fish catches. The ban helped to protect marine ecosystems, and although it had many beneficial effects, it was lifted in 1984, which allowed for expanded fishing opportunities, but at high environmental and economic costs.
The Clyde was once very productive, with a wide variety of finfish and marine life including shoals of herring, cod, whiting and others, but the introduction of more invasive fishing methods intensified fishing past sustainable levels. The removal of the 3-mile ban was surely a contributory factor to the near collapse of bottom fisheries. The range of marine Clyde fish species has changed drastically, because many species are unable to cope with trawling or with pollution. Fishermen have to put in more hours to catch the same amount of fish as they caught in previous years.
In 1985, about 75 per cent of all Firth of Clyde landings consisted of finfish; now, they account for only 2 per cent of landings. As fish availability has declined drastically, the fishing industry has developed an overdependence on shellfish.
Over time, sea angling has also faltered. Recreational sea angling was once a flourishing and profitable business that attracted people from far and wide to the waters of the Clyde. All the trophy-sized fish have disappeared, however, so many leisure fishermen stay away, and many areas around the Clyde have lost the tourism that sea angling brought in, which has damaged local economies.
Clyde 2020 is a Scottish Government initiative to meet the European Union’s environmental requirements, as outlined in the marine strategy framework directive, which promotes environmental practices to allow EU waterways to maximise their economic potential while supporting and maintaining healthy marine environments.
On 23 April, a Clyde 2020 summit will be held in Glasgow to discuss what measures should be taken to bring the Firth of Clyde up to good environmental standing by 2020. The event is intended to bring together representatives from the fishing industry, environmental groups, the tourism industry and leisure organisations to explore different options, including improved fisheries management to re-establish a healthy marine ecosystem in the Clyde.
It is important that the summit and the Clyde marine regional planning partnership give equal standing to all stakeholders, and that they are not seen to favour a handful of bottom trawlers and scallop dredgers to the detriment of the Clyde environment and the wider economy.
Environmental initiatives to be created during the Clyde 2020 summit should allow Scotland to become a leader in ecosystem restoration. The Scottish Government is already committed to a research programme that supports the restoration of marine biodiversity in the Clyde. Many proposals have been brought to the table, and the summit will consider the possible environmental and economic benefits of provisions covering mobile and static gear zones, small protection zones and no-take zones.
The economic and environmental benefits of the Lamlash Bay no-take zone have been evident since its establishment in 2008, following more than a decade of campaigning by COAST. The first of its kind in the Clyde and in Scotland, the no-take zone is only 2km2—a tiny fragment of the 3,700km2 Clyde estuary. Five years after its creation, scientific surveys show that scallops are 50 per cent more abundant than they were before the NTZ was introduced. Queenies are 45 per cent more abundant, and the larger sizes of both means that their reproductive capacities have increased more than a hundredfold.
The Lamlash Bay NTZ is a success story, so there is some frustration that Marine Scotland and the Scottish Government are apparently so shy about singing its praises. The spillover effect alone can have only positive benefits for our fisheries. We need to recognise that success and to apply similar zones elsewhere in the Clyde and beyond, given the opportunities that are presented to establish marine protected areas—not least the proposed south Arran MPA.
One of the biggest supporters of Clyde 2020 is the Sustainable Inshore Fisheries Trust, which promotes a sustainable management approach to all Scotland’s waterways. SIFT is committed to projects that will rebuild marine biodiversity in the Clyde and promote sustainable fishing practices. The trust believes that combining those two objectives can create a sustainable and economically workable mixed fishery that would benefit Clyde communities and all of Scotland.
SIFT is currently consulting on how organisations can work together to bring the Clyde to good environmental standing by 2020. It is attempting to submit a regulating order under the authority of the Sea Fisheries (Shellfish) Act 1967, to place sustainable management of the Clyde in the hands of local stakeholders. Such a scheme already operates successfully in Shetland’s waters; it would put in place licensing management, an independent management organisation and more marine protected areas to assist with restoration.
Sadly, the Clyde is no longer a first-choice fishery. Clyde 2020 is about bringing diverse groups together to create a mutually beneficial management system. Short-term environmental and economic restoration is an integral part of the Clyde initiative, but we also need to focus on the bigger picture—a long-term solution that will deal with issues such as pollution and littering and will ensure that the Firth of Clyde, through improved sustainability, will sustain ecosystem biodiversity and bring economic prosperity for many generations to come.
17:39