The reason why Campbell Gunn did not write personally to Clare is that she asked that that not happen. The apology, which was comprehensive, was issued in the way it was because Clare specifically requested that it not be made directly.
I said that Campbell Gunn had, in my view, committed a mistake and a misjudgment. I do not think that, as Johann Lamont has indicated, he was engaged in a vile personal attack on Clare Lally. To point out to a journalist that Clare Lally is a member of Labour’s shadow cabinet—which is correct—and, mistakenly, that she is the daughter-in-law of former Labour lord provost Pat Lally is not a vile personal attack and cannot be construed as such. It was a mistake to do it, for obvious reasons. It was a misjudgment, for the reasons I have already stated. I take very seriously the ministerial code and the special advisers code. I know exactly what is in the code and I know exactly why it is there. It is not reasonable to suggest that Campbell Gunn, in any way, shape or form, was responsible for internet abuse directed at Clare Lally.
Everyone in the chamber and everyone in Scottish society should condemn the few mindless idiots who commit such abuse on whoever they perpetrate it on. As just about everyone in the chamber has had the privilege of knowing Campbell Gunn over many years, no one in the chamber seriously believes that Campbell Gunn was responsible for orchestrating any such abuse. None of us seriously believes that, so let us accept that Campbell Gunn made a mistake and a misjudgment for which he has comprehensively apologised. That is the right way to deal with these things, instead of accusing Campbell Gunn of something that he would never, ever have done.