Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 12 June 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

The reason why Campbell Gunn did not write personally to Clare is that she asked that that not happen. The apology, which was comprehensive, was issued in the way it was because Clare specifically requested that it not be made directly.

I said that Campbell Gunn had, in my view, committed a mistake and a misjudgment. I do not think that, as Johann Lamont has indicated, he was engaged in a vile personal attack on Clare Lally. To point out to a journalist that Clare Lally is a member of Labour’s shadow cabinet—which is correct—and, mistakenly, that she is the daughter-in-law of former Labour lord provost Pat Lally is not a vile personal attack and cannot be construed as such. It was a mistake to do it, for obvious reasons. It was a misjudgment, for the reasons I have already stated. I take very seriously the ministerial code and the special advisers code. I know exactly what is in the code and I know exactly why it is there. It is not reasonable to suggest that Campbell Gunn, in any way, shape or form, was responsible for internet abuse directed at Clare Lally.

Everyone in the chamber and everyone in Scottish society should condemn the few mindless idiots who commit such abuse on whoever they perpetrate it on. As just about everyone in the chamber has had the privilege of knowing Campbell Gunn over many years, no one in the chamber seriously believes that Campbell Gunn was responsible for orchestrating any such abuse. None of us seriously believes that, so let us accept that Campbell Gunn made a mistake and a misjudgment for which he has comprehensively apologised. That is the right way to deal with these things, instead of accusing Campbell Gunn of something that he would never, ever have done.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

This is not a simple mistake about getting somebody’s family connections wrong. This is about a woman with a proud record of campaigning—a mother of a disabled child—who was called a “liar”, a “Quisling” and a “collaborator”. It does not get much more serious than that. That information was taken from a website.

We know that Clare Lally has fought for better rights for carers throughout the country. She has spoken to every party that will listen in the hope that something will be done to improve the lives of children such as her daughter Katie. That is why she has been involved in politics. For Campbell Gunn, that passion, that care and that spirit is for nothing because Clare Lally wants Scotland to stay in the United Kingdom. For Alex Salmond’s most senior adviser, her life experience and her struggle did not matter. For him, Clare Lally could be undermined and abused because she supports the union. Personal attacks by special advisers should lead to automatic dismissal according to the special advisers code. The First Minister has admitted that this was a personal attack. Campbell Gunn has admitted that it was a personal attack. The only thing missing is a dismissal. Does the First Minister not realise that, if Campbell Gunn is not sacked, we can only conclude that the First Minister has the same level of contempt for people such as Clare Lally as his most senior adviser?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

I recognise Campbell Gunn’s reputation as a fine journalist; one just wonders what has happened to him since he came into the employ of the First Minister.

The personal attack that was made on Clare Lally was that, somehow, the fact that she wanted to engage with politicians on the issue of how you care for children undermined her ability to describe herself as an “ordinary” mother. That is the thing that she has found more hurtful than everything else.

Of course, from Clare Lally to J K Rowling and from Barack Obama to David Bowie, there is no target who is too ordinary or too powerful not to be attacked. Clare Lally is the kind of person whom we should encourage to take part in public life, not someone who should be abused, threatened and chased out of our national conversation.

Today, Clare Lally is not just a carers champion; she is a champion of everyone who believes in free speech. She is a champion for every woman in Scotland who has had the courage to lean in and offer a view, despite the sexist abuse. She is a champion for everyone who believes that a bullying Government should be stood up to and everyone who refuses to be shouted down by thugs with an iPad.

Does the First Minister not realise that, if he does not sack Campbell Gunn, we can only conclude that all the bullying that goes on, wherever it comes from, is done by order, by design by him?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

No. I have already made it clear that I hold Clare Lally in the highest regard. Her contribution, both in her life story and struggle, and the opinion that she has put forward on how we can make the lot of carers in Scotland better are valuable and important.

Campbell Gunn has not admitted that he made a vile personal attack. He has said that he made a misjudgment and a mistake and got his facts wrong. There is nothing in Campbell Gunn’s email that fits the description of a vile personal attack. Saying that someone is a member of Labour’s shadow cabinet and, wrongly, that they are the daughter-in-law of former Labour lord provost of Glasgow Pat Lally does not constitute a vile personal attack. No one seriously believes that Campbell Gunn is guilty of orchestrating vile abuse on the internet. It demeans Campbell Gunn to suggest that.

I remind Johann Lamont that, last year, Campbell Gunn got a lifetime achievement award for his contribution to journalism in Scotland over 46 years. This is what she said last year:

“Campbell has proven himself to be a tough but fair journalist, a thoughtful and wise observer of politics and thoroughly good company ... Few ... reporters can claim to”

be

“on good terms with all of those he writes about ... and this is a testament to his professionalism and his good nature.”

Does Johann Lamont really believe that the person she spoke about in such glowing terms only last year is guilty of orchestrating the sort of abuse that the Labour press release suggested he was orchestrating? It is just not true. Nothing in the email constituted that. Johann Lamont would serve her cause better if she said that it is accepted that Campbell Gunn committed a mistake and a misjudgment. He has apologised comprehensively. Surely that is the right way to deal with the matter, instead of suggesting that he was guilty of things that, palpably, he was not guilty of.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I hope that, at some point, Johann Lamont will reflect on those last remarks. If she has evidence for what she has said, she should bring it forward; if not, she should desist from making such remarks.

I remind Johann Lamont what the code for special advisers says and why it says what it says. It was drawn up three days after the resignation of Damian McBride, the special adviser to Gordon Brown, because he was caught disseminating material across the internet and making up stories about the private life of Opposition politicians, which was described by the Labour Party as conduct that was vile and evil. The code says that disseminating inappropriate material will lead to automatic dismissal.

The email that Campbell Gunn sent to The Daily Telegraph could in no way be construed as being vile and evil. It pointed out that Clare Lally is in the Labour Party shadow cabinet and it stated, wrongly, that she is the daughter-in-law of former Labour lord provost of Glasgow Pat Lally. Is anyone seriously saying that that email is equivalent to the activities of Damian McBride? It is nonsense to suggest so.

Secondly, to conflate the mistake and the misjudgment that Campbell Gunn made with abuse on the internet does not serve Johann Lamont’s argument at all. Every one of us should condemn abuse on the internet. Every one of us should condemn that handful of mindless idiots who engage in such things in the early hours of the morning, but nothing in Campbell Gunn’s email could be construed as vitriolic, mindless abuse. He made a mistake and a misjudgment, but Johann Lamont does herself no credit and no service by trying to conflate the issues.

Instead, as a Parliament and as a society, we should stand up against that handful of people who are attempting to pollute the independence debate. The most invigorating and enlivening debate almost in political history is taking place in Scotland, and if all of us condemn such internet abuse and stand together, we have a good chance of driving it out of the debate. We will not do that by attempting to suggest that what Campbell Gunn did is the equivalent of the activities of Damian McBride. Nobody believes that and Johann Lamont should not say it. Instead, we should stand together and condemn true evil in society.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02165)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Last week, I announced a judge-led inquiry into the Edinburgh trams project. Today, I confirm that the inquiry will be chaired by the former Lord Advocate and senior judge Lord Hardie. The terms of reference for the inquiry have been agreed with him. They will be to inquire into the delivery of the Edinburgh trams project to establish why it incurred delays, cost considerably more than originally budgeted for and delivered significantly less than was projected through reductions in scope. I assure the chamber that Lord Hardie will establish the inquiry immediately. We look forward to a swift and thorough inquiry.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Clare Lally is a woman whom I am proud to know. She is a loving mother of twins and a former mother of the year. Her seven-year-old daughter Katie has multiple disabilities. Clare’s experience of caring for Katie has inspired her to fight for better rights for all carers and, in this week of all weeks—carers week—we should reflect on how tough that fight is. The First Minister has acknowledged Clare Lally as a carers champion. He has even been to her house. Why did she deserve to have his most senior adviser undermine her credibility and unleash a torrent of vile abuse on the internet?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

First, Johann Lamont is quite right: I know Clare Lally. I have met her twice. I hold her in the highest regard. Not only in terms of her own family—let me say that I do not regard her as an “ordinary” mother; I regard her as extraordinary for the challenges that she has met, faced and overcome—but, more importantly in terms of her contribution to society, her views on carers and the challenges that they face in general have substantially informed the Government’s approach in what has been done and in what was outlined in the consultation earlier this year and will be carried forward into legislation. I and the carers organisations believe that that will improve the lot of carers throughout Scotland, who do valuable and important work.

As for Johann Lamont’s description of Campbell Gunn, I do not accept that he was responsible for a torrent of abuse across the internet. I do not think that anybody who knows him would give that a moment’s credence.

Campbell Gunn made a mistake and a misjudgment. The mistake was obvious: saying that Clare is Pat Lally’s daughter-in-law when she clearly is not is a mistake. The misjudgment is believing that drawing attention in an email to someone’s Labour Party connections, whether it is that they are a member of the shadow cabinet or any other connection, was appropriate to do. That was a misjudgment because Clare’s views on caring and other matters stand regardless of her Labour Party connections.

Because he made a mistake and a misjudgment, I asked Campbell to apologise, which he did immediately and comprehensively.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Those who saw Clare Lally’s tears on the television last night will not think much of that as an answer. If we are talking about a response being ill judged, it could not be more ill judged than what the First Minister has said.

Clare Lally’s crime, as far as the First Minister’s most senior adviser was concerned, was to describe herself as an “ordinary” mother. In that, as the First Minister has reflected, she was being modest: she is an extraordinary mother. Her crime, as far as Campbell Gunn was concerned, was to say as a mother that she thought that her daughters’ future will be better if Scotland stays in the United Kingdom. She did not deserve to be undermined by Alex Salmond’s most senior adviser and then to be so abused on the internet that she had to shut down her Facebook and Twitter accounts.

The First Minister’s office contacted Clare while she was in Yorkhill hospital for her daughter’s appointment. It then sent her Campbell Gunn’s press release. Instead of sending a copy of a press release, should the First Minister not enforce the special advisers code and sack his adviser for a personal attack on a member of the public?

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Environmentally Friendly Public Transport Questions · 4
  2. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  3. Prioritisation of Road Repairs (Fix it First Campaign Survey) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  4. Breastfeeding Debate · 16
  5. Cashback for Communities Debate · 79
  6. Farm Produce (United Kingdom Market) Questions · 8
  7. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  8. Capital Investment (Non-profit Distribution Finance) Questions · 4
  9. Ernst & Young 2014 UK Attractiveness Survey First Minister’s Questions · 4
  10. Commonwealth Games (Special Reserve Fund) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  11. Public Bodies (Abolition of Food from Britain) Order 2014 Debate · 2
  12. Decision Time Decision time · 11
  13. Support for Rape Victims (Edinburgh and the Lothians) Questions · 6
  14. Problem Gambling Questions · 5
  15. “Hybrid Bills” Debate · 3
  16. Fishing (Support) Questions · 6
  17. Local Authority Transport Appraisal Guidance Reports Questions · 6
  18. Independence (Start-up Costs) Questions · 4
  19. “EU Legislative Proposals: Review of Standing Orders” Debate · 3
  20. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.