1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01992)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
In the light of Johann Lamont’s absence, I say on the career and life of Tony Benn that he was not just a substantial parliamentarian, but a great campaigner and writer. He will be much missed by his family, obviously, but also by his many friends across the political spectrum. [Applause.]
I thank the First Minister for his generous comments, which sentiments we on this side of the chamber share.
The First Minister and his deputy refused to back Labour’s plans for an energy price freeze to help hard-pressed families to cope with rising bills. Indeed, his Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism, Fergus Ewing, said that a price freeze would be “completely unworkable” and would lead to blackouts.
Now that SSE has agreed a price freeze and the Office of Gas and Electricity Markets is reviewing how the entire energy industry charges consumers, will the First Minister admit that Labour was right and that he and his ministers were wrong?
Jackie Baillie omitted to mention in her declaration of “We was right” that the Scottish National Party proposed a £70 cut in family energy bills, which is, by definition, rather better than an energy price freeze.
I welcome the monopoly investigation into the energy market. That is a far more sustainable way to look at matters, and to ensure that families are protected than would be the case with the other suggestions that have been made. Such a competition review must look at the entire energy market’s production processes and, in particular, at the recently offered nuclear generation contract and its potential impact on household bills over the next 30 years.
The SNP’s proposals would save companies money and load the cost on to the taxpayers. Labour’s proposals would deliver a higher saving—a saving for ordinary people—instead of increasing the profits of the big six energy companies. That is the difference between the two proposals.
From the beginning of the debate, the First Minister has been on the side of the energy companies rather than on the side of ordinary Scots who are struggling to pay their bills. He has stood shoulder to shoulder with David Cameron and said, “You can’t freeze prices. The market does not need reform.” [Interruption.]
Order.
SNP members make a lot of noise. The big six energy companies have made an obscene £867 million in profits while families struggle. Those profits would be even higher after a yes vote because of the First Minister’s planned corporation tax cuts.
As SSE announces a price freeze and Ofgem announces plans for market reform, I will give the First Minister another chance to answer the question. Will he admit that he was wrong not to back Labour’s proposals?
Even for Jackie Baillie, that “shoulder to shoulder” remark was something—given that it comes the morning after the night before, as just yesterday, Labour MPs marched through the lobby in the House of Commons “shoulder to shoulder” with the Tories. [Applause.]
Order.
I say to Jackie Baillie that, when she is in a better together campaign in which the Labour Party is not just shoulder to shoulder, but hand in glove and umbilically linked to the Conservative Party, it is not the best idea to come to Parliament and accuse others of guilt by association with the Conservative Party. The Labour Party is an extension of the Conservative Party.
To take £70 off household bills might be irrelevant to Jackie Baillie and to the Labour Party, but it will be greatly welcomed by families in Scotland as a substantial proposal.
The review of competition in the electricity market is welcome. It offers the opportunity to fully examine the marketplace. I hope and believe that the Labour Party will see the sense of extending that review to nuclear power and the contract that has been offered to Hinkley Point. I hope that for the very obvious reason that, if it continues to support that contract, which is at double the current wholesale price for electricity, there will be only one direction for electricity bills in the future, and that is upwards. Let us have a review and an examination of competition and the conduct of the big six electricity companies, and of the huge nuclear subsidy that is threatening to overwhelm electricity bill payers in this country.
That answer has demonstrated that it does not matter who asks the questions—the First Minister still does not answer them.
The First Minister is clearly suffering from amnesia, so I remind him that he is at odds with his deputy and his MPs in that he supports a cap on benefits. At least, he told the Sunday Post so.
Of course, the First Minister’s white paper proposes weaker regulation of the energy companies than we have just now. Labour legislated to abolish fuel poverty by 2016, but on his watch, the number of households that are in fuel poverty has reached an all-time high of 900,000. The fuel poverty budget is underspent, and installers are going to the wall. Instead of plans to help those 900,000 households that are struggling to heat their homes, the First Minister plans to make a huge tax cut for the big six companies that are ripping Scottish families off. As ever with the First Minister, big business comes first, and real Scots are at the end of the queue.
For the third time of asking, as SSE freezes prices, and Ofgem announces that it will reform the market, surely even the First Minister has the humility to admit that Labour was right and he was wrong.
It does not matter who is asking the questions because they all read from the same script week after week. We were all waiting with bated breath to see who would be the chosen one; the next leader apparent. There were so many candidates on the back benches. The reason why the Labour Party is in trouble in Scotland is its association with the Conservatives in better together, and its script does not change from week to week.
For the third time, I say that we support the competition review of the electricity industry. It will provide a sustainable way of protecting consumers. We support the £70 reduction in electricity bills that we proposed and which most people would understand is, by definition, rather better than a freeze in electricity prices. We think that that is the right way to proceed.
We also understand that if a couple of companies are offered a contract at Hinkley Point at double the wholesale price of electricity, that means that, under Labour, the direction of electricity bills will be upwards if Labour continues to support nuclear power.
In supporting the monopoly review of the current “big six” structure of the electricity industry, which requires examination, let us reflect on who was the architect of that structure. My goodness me! It was not David Miliband, but Ed Miliband.
We operate in a United Kingdom market. We get one third of the overall UK budget for renewables, despite our population share being one tenth. Independence would remove that. Independence would cost an extra £875 per year for each household to make up the renewables shortfall. That is the price of independence for families that are already struggling to pay their bills.
In all of what he said, I did not hear an apology from the First Minister. When Ed Miliband called for the price freeze six months ago, this Government’s energy spokesperson said:
“never has a measure introduced by the leader of a major political party in the UK received such widespread, utter and total condemnation as being completely unworkable.”—[Official Report, 3 October 2013; c 23271.]
Now that Labour’s policy has been adopted by one of our major energy companies, and now that Ofgem is following Labour’s lead, will the First Minister finally admit that he was wrong and that he has let down families who are struggling with gas and electricity bills—or is “sorry” simply the First Minister’s hardest word?
Everybody—the Conservative Party and SSE—is following Labour’s lead, we are told. Unfortunately, what SSE said yesterday about Labour’s proposals is that they
“would not significantly reduce energy prices or provide energy investors with the long-term certainty they require to invest in the energy infrastructure consumers depend on.”
If Jackie Baillie’s interpretation is that SSE is following Labour’s lead, she has some considerable explaining to do.
On the question of the umbilical link between Labour and the Conservatives—Jackie Baillie’s first point was the “shoulder to shoulder” point—how far does that link go through society? I have here an extract from Argyll & Bute Conservative & Unionist Association’s website, which lists an event of the Cowal Conservatives lunch club. It states:
“Venue: Argyll Hotel ... Secretary: Pamela Bellaby ... Lunch with tea or coffee £10 ... Speaker: Jackie Baillie MSP”—[Interruption.]
Order.
I have heard of being shoulder to shoulder, but I say to the Labour Party, if you sup with the Tories, you should do so with a long spoon.