Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 20 February 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 17 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01889)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am sure that the whole Parliament will want to join me in congratulating Eve Muirhead and her rink on winning the bronze medal at the winter Olympics. Perhaps that is a demonstration that we all can be

“Heroes

Just for one day.”

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Of course, we on this side of the chamber also congratulate our curlers. We are very proud of them as Scots and as part of team GB.

I ask the First Minister to turn and face the strain. In the past seven days, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, the shadow chancellor, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, the permanent secretary of the Treasury, the Scottish Trades Union Congress, the Confederation of British Industry and the Institute of Directors have said that the First Minister’s plans A and B for the currency are non-starters. The President of the European Commission and the President of the European Council said that his Europe plans are, at best, extremely difficult. Instead of arguing why he is right and they are wrong, the First Minister has just insulted them. Now that David Bowie—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I did not realise that the Scottish National Party members had not realised that the First Minister was insulting people rather than arguing with them.

However, now that David Bowie has come out for the union, can the First Minister explain to us why Bowie is preposterous, bluffing, and bullying?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Most people in Scotland would feel that George Osborne has insulted the intelligence of the Scottish people.

This might be the last—the only—time that I quote from the Daily Mail. When Johann Lamont is facing Daily Mail headlines saying that the row over the pound is driving the yes vote, the reasonable conclusion might be that so far the joint enterprise between George Osborne and Ed Balls has backfired on the two unionist parties in spectacular fashion.

I watched television the other night and I saw Gordon Brown walk off an interview on STV because he was asked whether Ed Balls was wise to make an alliance with George Osborne. I have known Gordon Brown for a long time, and I have never seen him walk off an interview. Perhaps people in the Labour Party should realise the damage that has been done to them by their being hand in glove with the likes of George Osborne.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Perhaps the First Minister might reflect on the damage that is being done to this Parliament by the insults he presents to our intelligence and the people of Scotland because of the way in which he dismisses those who disagree with him. It takes an extraordinary lack of self-awareness for the First Minister to accuse other people of not telling the truth as a campaign tactic. Truly, as we live our lives, we judge our neighbours. The fact of the matter is that these issues are too serious for the First Minister to insult us in this way.

This week Alex Salmond, John Swinney, and Nicola Sturgeon have been asked repeatedly to put a figure on the transaction costs to Scottish business of giving up the pound in the event of a yes vote, but they have refused to come up with an answer. The Scottish Parliament information centre has come up with some numbers. Transaction costs for the rest of the UK—the so-called George tax—work out at £9 per head for people in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. However, if the Scottish Government’s own figures are to be believed, the cost in Scotland would be £75 a head, which is eight times greater. No wonder they would not answer the question. Given that that would be the consequence of the First Minister’s plan to break up the United Kingdom, why should Scottish business pay the Alex tax?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Our proposal is to share the pound and not have the transaction costs. It is Johann Lamont’s proposal—that is, it is Ed Balls’ and George Osborne’s proposal—to force Scotland into using a different currency and to impose transaction costs on Scottish and English business.

The point that is being made by the Scottish Government is a reasonable one; I do not think that English businesses will take kindly to being forced to pay the George or Johann tax. I do not think that Johann Lamont wants to have her name attached to that tax.

I said earlier that that would be the only time that I would quote the Daily Mail, but I am going to quote it again. [Laughter.] That is twice in one First Minister’s question time. I apologise for quoting Labour’s house journal. However, I note that another aspect of the poll this morning showed that our proposal to share the pound is the most popular proposal among the Scottish people. Does not that suggest that perhaps there is a resonance in support of what we are saying, and that the Labour Party is struggling because of its association with the Conservative Party?

I hope that Johann Lamont continues with this theme, because I might go for the hat trick and start talking about the party ratings that the poll indicated. The Labour Party has done itself huge damage by associating with the Conservatives—in particular with George Osborne. The reaction of the Scottish people to being told, or instructed, from on high that our currency—the currency that we jointly built up—does not actually belong to us but to George Osborne is entirely understandable, and will be deeply uncomfortable for the Labour Party in Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
If we are talking about associations with Tories, it is only the SNP that wants to cut corporation tax by 3p more than any Tory chancellor would propose. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
If we are talking about polls, the same poll says that two thirds of the people in this country want to know what the First Minister’s proposal is for a plan B for the currency. It is about time he told them, because the reality is this: the rest of the United Kingdom, including Carwyn Jones, have said that they do not want a currency union. They do not want a currency union. We cannot make them have a currency union if we are not in the same country. What does the First Minister not understand—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
What does the First Minister not understand about his proposal to take Scotland out of the United Kingdom? It has come to this, Presiding Officer.

The Scottish Government, as we have seen, is prepared to deny, deflect, assert and insult in order to win the referendum. They say that they want to keep a currency union. They say that they want to keep an unfettered single market without transaction costs. They say that they want to keep borrowing costs in line with current levels. They say that they want to stay in the European Union with a rebate and the current opt-outs. Then they ask, “What is the positive case for the union?” Is not it the truth that the only way we can guarantee keeping those things is by staying in the United Kingdom?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Let me support Johann Lamont’s call for a calm and considered debate as we look forward to those things.

We have argued, and the fiscal commission has said, that the best option for Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom is to share the currency. That was the basis on which the fiscal commission working group proposed the policy. I think that it is the right policy. It is the right policy for Scotland and the right policy for the rest of the United Kingdom.

I say to Johann Lamont that the debate has, in relation to Mr Barroso’s comments, moved on. I am looking at the Scotsman website for today in respect of evidence being presented to Parliament.

“Scottish independence: Barroso ‘incorrect’ on EU”.

That is not me speaking, but Jim Currie, the former European Commission director general, who said that Mr Barroso was

“extremely unwise and incorrect”.

If that is not enough, we have the speech in Ireland by the secretary general of the European Commission.

“On Scotland’s position regarding membership should it vote for independence, Ms Day said comments by European Commission president José Manuel Barroso over the weekend had been misunderstood.”

I think that that is civil service speak for “perhaps the comparison between Scotland and Kosovo was not the wisest comparison for Mr Barroso to make.”

Johann Lamont should look at the evidence that is being presented to the Parliament’s committees. Evidence has been presented in significant form by people as eminent as David Edward, and by many others, that shows absolutely that, as Scotland has been part of the European Union for 40 years and has built up rights and entitlements as part of that structure, and as it conforms to the democratic imperatives that the EU represents, we are of course entitled to our rights as European citizens. The idea that the rest of Europe wants to deny us those rights is a total illusion that has been cooked up by the unionist parties. Scotland is a European nation, and we will continue to be a European nation.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The real problem here is that the First Minister listens only to people who agree with him.

Members: Oh!

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
That works in here, but it does not work in the rest of the world. It is not in the First Minister’s gift to tell people in England, Northern Ireland, Wales and Europe what is in their best interests. It is in their gift, and he has to deal with that.

The permanent secretary to the Treasury has rejected a currency union if there is a yes vote, and so has the Chancellor of the Exchequer, the shadow chancellor and the Chief Secretary to the Treasury. The Confederation of British Industry, the Institute of Directors and the Scottish Trades Union Congress reject the idea, too.

It is not good enough simply to listen to oneself; the First Minister has to accept that other people have credible positions.

The President of the European Commission and the President of the European Council have said that for Scotland to get the agreement of all the other member states after a yes vote would be extremely difficult, if not impossible. Business costs would go up by £75 a head and average mortgage costs would go up by an eye-watering £100 a week. I am sure that people throughout the country will reflect on how little seriousness the SNP back benchers place on the consequences for ordinary people.

Despite all that, the First Minister still simply steams ahead. Is not it the case that the only preposterous, bullying bluffer in this fight is the First Minister?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will quote Professor Christine Bell, who is a professor of constitutional law at the University of Edinburgh. I have no knowledge whatever of her politics or of whether she agrees with me politically. She says:

“Legally under international law the position is clear: if the remainder UK keeps the name and status of the UK under international law, it keeps its liabilities for the debt. The UK took out the debt, and legally it owes the money. Scotland cannot therefore ‘default’.”

As Johann Lamont knows, we have set out in the white paper our proposal that we should share the United Kingdom’s assets and liabilities, which is the fair and responsible thing to do. One of those assets is, of course, the Bank of England, which was nationalised in 1946 and is undoubtedly a public asset. We think that that is a fair proposition.

We pointed out very reasonably that the implication—or the certainty, in fact, because the Treasury had to state this to the markets last month—of arguing, as the Treasury is now doing, along with the UK Government and all the eminent people that Johann Lamont has cited, that the UK is the continuing state and so it will keep all the assets of the United Kingdom, is that it follows, as night follows day, that it will end up with the liabilities.

I believe that George Osborne and Ed Balls are bluffing not just because it would be against the interests of the English people to impose transaction costs on Scotland, but because I do not believe that we will reach a situation in which George Osborne wants to make every person in Scotland £25,000 richer, which is what would happen if the UK had to accept all the national debt.

I would find agreeing with George Osborne extremely uncomfortable—unlike Johann Lamont, which is why the Labour Party is suffering serious and perhaps permanent damage in Scotland as a result of its alliance with the Conservative Party.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Rail Services (Reston and East Linton) Questions · 4
  2. Scottish Welfare Fund Questions · 6
  3. People who are Deaf or Hard of Hearing Questions · 4
  4. Pumped Storage Questions · 4
  5. Helicopter Accidents (Fatal Accident Inquiries) Questions · 4
  6. Flooding (South of England) Questions · 4
  7. Transport Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 4
  8. Independent Scotland (Welfare Reform) Questions · 8
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
  10. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. Care Services (Inspection) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Commonwealth Games (Financial Administration) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Promoting Family Recovery Across Scotland Members’ business · 9
  16. Syrian Refugees Members’ business · 10
  17. Procurement Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 85
  18. Procurement Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.