1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02036)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02036)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Does the First Minister still have full confidence in his Cabinet Secretary for Justice?
Yes.
There you go. No surprise there.
I welcomed the Government’s interest in corroboration because, like many others in this chamber, I have genuine concerns about whether corroboration achieves justice for every victim, particularly women. However, it has become clear, through the passage of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill, that the process has been flawed and that serious reservations have not been addressed. I believe, therefore, that the cabinet secretary has taken the right decision in delaying the plans. I also thought that that was the right decision six weeks ago, when my colleague Graeme Pearson, formerly one of Scotland’s most senior police officers, suggested that course of action.
I remind the First Minister of Kenny MacAskill’s considered response to that suggestion six weeks ago. He said:
“We know that Labour members take their cue from Cameron and Osborne.”
He continued:
“Labour has sold its soul and is in danger of selling out the victims of crime.”—[Official Report, 27 February 2014; c 28373 and 28376.]
Does the First Minister agree with his cabinet secretary that previous moves to delay the legislation were part of a Tory-led conspiracy, or was it just the right thing to do?
I welcomed the Government’s interest in corroboration because, like many others in this chamber, I have genuine concerns about whether corroboration achieves justice for every victim, particularly women. However, it has become clear, through the passage of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill, that the process has been flawed and that serious reservations have not been addressed. I believe, therefore, that the cabinet secretary has taken the right decision in delaying the plans. I also thought that that was the right decision six weeks ago, when my colleague Graeme Pearson, formerly one of Scotland’s most senior police officers, suggested that course of action.
I remind the First Minister of Kenny MacAskill’s considered response to that suggestion six weeks ago. He said:
“We know that Labour members take their cue from Cameron and Osborne.”
He continued:
“Labour has sold its soul and is in danger of selling out the victims of crime.”—[Official Report, 27 February 2014; c 28373 and 28376.]
Does the First Minister agree with his cabinet secretary that previous moves to delay the legislation were part of a Tory-led conspiracy, or was it just the right thing to do?
It is certainly true that it was very difficult to reconcile Labour’s manifesto commitment to look at the matter of corroboration with the position that the Labour Party adopted with regard to the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill. Removing the general law and practice of corroboration from Scotland will, we believe, secure access to justice for hundreds of people who are otherwise denied it by the present situation, in which cases cannot be brought to trial because they do not have the standard of corroboration that is unique within the Scottish criminal justice system.
That is why the moves that Kenny MacAskill made, and this Government proposed, to look again at the general law of corroboration, to remove it and to put in its place proposals on the standard of evidence as opposed to the quantity of evidence, have been widely welcomed by the organisations that care most about the people who suffer most from the situation—Rape Crisis Scotland and Victim Support Scotland.
As I understand it, this week the three Opposition parties asked at the Parliamentary Bureau whether we could look again at delaying the legislation until after Lord Bonomy’s review group reported. The justice secretary acceded to that request. Given that, would it not be gracious and reasonable for the Labour Party to try to focus on the issue of access to justice—which, I hope, all of us want to secure—for people who have been subjected to some of the vilest crimes in Scotland?
That is why the moves that Kenny MacAskill made, and this Government proposed, to look again at the general law of corroboration, to remove it and to put in its place proposals on the standard of evidence as opposed to the quantity of evidence, have been widely welcomed by the organisations that care most about the people who suffer most from the situation—Rape Crisis Scotland and Victim Support Scotland.
As I understand it, this week the three Opposition parties asked at the Parliamentary Bureau whether we could look again at delaying the legislation until after Lord Bonomy’s review group reported. The justice secretary acceded to that request. Given that, would it not be gracious and reasonable for the Labour Party to try to focus on the issue of access to justice—which, I hope, all of us want to secure—for people who have been subjected to some of the vilest crimes in Scotland?
I think that the First Minister, if he was serious about that, would be addressing the fact that the cabinet secretary’s response to people who raised concerns was to impugn the motives of those who were doing so. I ask the First Minister again to reflect on the cabinet secretary’s response to the Labour Party’s request for delay. The gap between that and what the First Minister is now saying could not be greater.
Let us look at the process from the start. When the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill was introduced, senior legal figures raised valid concerns about corroboration. Those were dismissed by the justice secretary, who told his party conference:
“laws are made by Parliament not one profession. This is ... not a debate between learned legal friends.”
When the Justice Committee raised more concerns, Kenny MacAskill came up with the genius idea of setting up an expert group to scrutinise the bill, which would report after the legislation was passed.
After Kenny MacAskill’s disgraceful performance in the chamber six weeks ago and his embarrassing climbdown, I ask the First Minister, in all seriousness, does he believe that this has been an appropriate way to take through legislation on an issue of this importance?
Let us look at the process from the start. When the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill was introduced, senior legal figures raised valid concerns about corroboration. Those were dismissed by the justice secretary, who told his party conference:
“laws are made by Parliament not one profession. This is ... not a debate between learned legal friends.”
When the Justice Committee raised more concerns, Kenny MacAskill came up with the genius idea of setting up an expert group to scrutinise the bill, which would report after the legislation was passed.
After Kenny MacAskill’s disgraceful performance in the chamber six weeks ago and his embarrassing climbdown, I ask the First Minister, in all seriousness, does he believe that this has been an appropriate way to take through legislation on an issue of this importance?
This Government is taking forward legislation because we absolutely believe that the issue is of vital importance. That has been our motivation for taking forward the legislation, because we have listened to the arguments and, indeed, the pleas of the organisations that I have listed.
I cannot help but contrast the observations of Johann Lamont on this issue with the observations of the organisations that have been campaigning for ways to redress this injustice and supporting the Government’s attempts to do so, such as the welcome from Rape Crisis Scotland and Victim Support Scotland for the Government’s continuing commitment to removing the general law of corroboration. Annabel Goldie yesterday described the cabinet secretary’s decision as “courageous”—I think that she did that not in a Sir Humphrey way but in a genuine way.
Therefore, when this Government, which has a majority in this Parliament, listens to the arguments that have been put forward by the Opposition parties and tries to get the maximum unity behind our proposal, is it not reasonable—given our bona fides on this issue and our desire to secure access to justice for the victims of crime—that that should have a general welcome and support?
The determination of this Government is to redress this situation, and that is exactly what we are going to do.
I cannot help but contrast the observations of Johann Lamont on this issue with the observations of the organisations that have been campaigning for ways to redress this injustice and supporting the Government’s attempts to do so, such as the welcome from Rape Crisis Scotland and Victim Support Scotland for the Government’s continuing commitment to removing the general law of corroboration. Annabel Goldie yesterday described the cabinet secretary’s decision as “courageous”—I think that she did that not in a Sir Humphrey way but in a genuine way.
Therefore, when this Government, which has a majority in this Parliament, listens to the arguments that have been put forward by the Opposition parties and tries to get the maximum unity behind our proposal, is it not reasonable—given our bona fides on this issue and our desire to secure access to justice for the victims of crime—that that should have a general welcome and support?
The determination of this Government is to redress this situation, and that is exactly what we are going to do.
It is precisely because I care so deeply about these issues that we were determined to build a consensus on the making of such a decision. That is why the cabinet secretary’s hostility to anyone who disagreed with him was inappropriate. I ask the First Minister to go back and look at what his cabinet secretary said six weeks ago and ask whether that was an appropriate way for him to conduct himself.
Of course, this is not Kenny MacAskill’s first mess. His sectarianism legislation was described as “mince” and “horribly drafted”, and his police reforms have ended up in an embarrassing turf war.
Although I believe that the decision that has been announced this week is the right one, this Parliament still has a problem. We have to find a way of building a consensus to address the issues of corroboration and low conviction rates for rape. From the beginning, the Labour Party has said that we will do so. However, given Kenny MacAskill’s approach and his expressed hostility to those who raised genuine concerns about what he was doing, does the First Minister really believe that it is possible for this Parliament to reach that critical consensus on corroboration with Kenny MacAskill as cabinet secretary?
Of course, this is not Kenny MacAskill’s first mess. His sectarianism legislation was described as “mince” and “horribly drafted”, and his police reforms have ended up in an embarrassing turf war.
Although I believe that the decision that has been announced this week is the right one, this Parliament still has a problem. We have to find a way of building a consensus to address the issues of corroboration and low conviction rates for rape. From the beginning, the Labour Party has said that we will do so. However, given Kenny MacAskill’s approach and his expressed hostility to those who raised genuine concerns about what he was doing, does the First Minister really believe that it is possible for this Parliament to reach that critical consensus on corroboration with Kenny MacAskill as cabinet secretary?
In terms of accepting the role of Lord Bonomy’s review group and the detailed examination of the issue that it will perform, and of helping people towards acceptance and ensuring that that consensus is built, the answer is yes, of course. Do I believe that the Labour Party will look upon this issue as being an issue in itself? Probably not. However, the consensus that Kenny MacAskill is building is across Scottish society. That consensus, as we see—[Interruption.]
I say to Johann Lamont that it is precisely because we care about this legislation so much that we pursued it with such vigour, and we will continue to do so.
I am interested in the question that Johann Lamont asks about the confidence that I have in the justice secretary. I will tell the chamber why I have confidence in him. We have 1,000 extra police in the streets and communities of Scotland, thanks to this justice secretary. Recorded crime in Scotland is down by 35 per cent, thanks to this justice secretary. Violent crime is down by almost a half under the office of this justice secretary. Crimes of handling offensive weapons are down by 60 per cent. Above all, people’s fear of crime in Scotland is dropping for the first time.
All those achievements of the justice secretary contrast with the position when the Labour Party was last in government, and the people of Scotland know and appreciate those things. They know that this Government has discharged its responsibilities to the communities of Scotland in a way that no previous devolved Administration managed. The real issues that matter to the people are contained in those vital statistics.
When we address the general rule of corroboration, we will do it on the basis of giving justice to the victims of crime. That will be the performance on which the Government and the justice secretary will be judged.
I say to Johann Lamont that it is precisely because we care about this legislation so much that we pursued it with such vigour, and we will continue to do so.
I am interested in the question that Johann Lamont asks about the confidence that I have in the justice secretary. I will tell the chamber why I have confidence in him. We have 1,000 extra police in the streets and communities of Scotland, thanks to this justice secretary. Recorded crime in Scotland is down by 35 per cent, thanks to this justice secretary. Violent crime is down by almost a half under the office of this justice secretary. Crimes of handling offensive weapons are down by 60 per cent. Above all, people’s fear of crime in Scotland is dropping for the first time.
All those achievements of the justice secretary contrast with the position when the Labour Party was last in government, and the people of Scotland know and appreciate those things. They know that this Government has discharged its responsibilities to the communities of Scotland in a way that no previous devolved Administration managed. The real issues that matter to the people are contained in those vital statistics.
When we address the general rule of corroboration, we will do it on the basis of giving justice to the victims of crime. That will be the performance on which the Government and the justice secretary will be judged.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 24 Apr 2014 →- Oil and Gas Revenues (Forecasts) Questions · 11
- Scottish Enterprise Chief Executive (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Healthcare Improvement Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Alternatives to Superfast Broadband Questions · 4
- Levenmouth Rail Link Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Airport (Weekend Flights) Questions · 4
- College and University Places (Fee-paying Foreign Students) Questions · 4
- Renewable Energy (United Kingdom Share) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Food Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Gender Equality Gap First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Red Road Flats Site First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Scotland’s Labour Market Conditions First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Emergency Control Room Closures) Members’ business · 30
- Housing (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 69
- Housing (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.