Our second new petition is PE1501, by Stuart Graham, on public inquiries into self-inflicted and accidental deaths following suspicious death investigations. Members have a note by the clerk, the SPICe briefing and the petition. Willie Rennie MSP is attending because he has a regional interest. I welcome him to the meeting and will ask him to make a few comments once we have heard from the petitioners.I welcome to the meeting the petitioner, Stuart Graham, and Tony Whittle, who is a retired detective chief superintendent from West Yorkshire Police. I invite Mr Graham to make a short presentation of about five minutes just to set the scene, after which Mr Rennie will make a few comments, then I will kick off with some questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Self-inflicted and Accidental Deaths (Public Inquiries) (PE1501)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stuart Graham 24
- David Stewart Lab 14
- Chic Brodie SNP 8
- John Wilson SNP 8
- Tony Whittle 7
- Willie Rennie LD 3
- Anne McTaggart Lab 2
The record
66 contributionsWe have agreed that I will do a lead-in and Tony Whittle will do a pitch. I will talk about my personal experience, then Tony will bring in real-life experience of inquests and I will close. We have timed it, and it is close to five minutes, so we hope that it fits.
As long as you keep to five minutes, I am perfectly happy with that.
We have a very strict script, so there should not be any waffling. That will come later.Our family’s personal six-year fight to clear Colin’s name has been excruciating, and what angers us most is that it was altogether avoidable. A system of public review, disclosure and family participation should have been in place, and we want to ensure that no other family has to endure a fight such as we have had to endure.An excerpt from a novel helps to capture the family plight in Scotland. The book is called, “Where The Dead Men Go” by Liam Mcllvanney, and the excerpt reads as follows:“It was Clare. She was crying, drunk. Couldn’t we press for an inquest into Martin’s death? I told her it was a waste of time. This wasn’t England. Down south, almost every unnatural death, every suicide and accident, triggered an inquest. We didn’t do that here. A Fatal Accident Inquiry was a rare beast, it was ordered for deaths that occasioned ‘serious public concern’. Other than Clare, me ... was anyone seriously concerned about Martin’s death? If we wanted answers we’d have to find them ourselves.”That is actually what many families have to do: they hire experts, have to read autopsies of loved ones and seek help wherever they can to get answers, despite the shortcomings in our system. No family should have to do that; if investigations were as thorough as they should be and made public, there would be no need.In our case, we were told that we had an open-and-shut case of suicide. We were then faced with manipulation of evidence by Fife Police, but in the fatal accident inquiry the sheriff stated that there was no evidence that Colin took his own life.Is our case unique? Professor Pounder, a pathologist in Dundee, informed the procurator fiscal before the Fife investigation in 2009 that great care should be taken before jumping to conclusions in Colin’s case, because he had only ever seen one case like it before, which had been written off as suicide until, in the end, someone came forward and admitted homicide. Where is the review of that? How do we learn? In our case, it is obvious that the professor’s input was ignored.If the committee understood how little is required to determine a verdict of suicide in Scotland, it would see that there should be a counterbalance in order to avoid such gross errors and malpractice.
I spent 30 years as a police officer and retired as head of the criminal investigation department in West Yorkshire Police, which is one of England’s biggest police forces. Since my retirement, I have trained detectives in various United Kingdom police forces, and I have worked in other countries overseas.I spent many years as a senior investigating officer specialising in cases of homicide, and in that work I was constantly closely involved with scores of bereaved families. I know that every family needs, as part of the grieving process that they have to go through, answers to two key questions. The first is to ask what happened to their loved one and the second is to ask why it happened. Without answers to those questions, bereaved families find it impossible to make sense of their loss and move on. I firmly believe that the state, through the police and justice systems, has a duty to do all that it can to thoroughly and openly investigate all suspicious deaths, and to provide answers to those questions. That principle has been accepted for many years, and is now part of article 2 of the European convention on human rights, and part of UK law.In all my investigations, I worked with the knowledge that I owed a duty to the bereaved family, the community and the law. I also knew that my work would, quite rightly, be scrutinised by the criminal court or by an inquest, where I would be questioned and held to account for my actions. I believe that that level of accountability is crucial to public confidence in the police and the criminal justice system.The impact on the bereaved family of a sudden and violent death is massive; that is particularly the case when it is a suicide. The stigma and guilt that are attached to such a finding and the difficulties that are faced by the bereaved are hard to imagine. I believe that a finding of suicide should be made only after the most thorough investigation and careful and open consideration of all the facts.11:15
The inquest system that I am familiar with provides for that level of investigation and consideration. Every suspicious death is thoroughly and independently examined and a finding of suicide cannot be arrived at unless the inquest is satisfied, beyond reasonable doubt, by evidence that has been given under oath and subjected to cross-examination.According to “The Scottish Suicide Information Database Report 2012”, there were 830 probable suicides in Scotland in 2012. As far as I can find out, those findings of suicide seem to have been reached without any public hearing or any opportunity for those involved to question the evidence that led to that conclusion. Consequently, I am led to question whether the system that applies in Scotland meets the needs of the bereaved or of the community as a whole.
Thank you very much for that and for keeping to time.
I am sorry, but I have something to add. Do we have time?
If you are very brief, Mr Graham; if you take too long we will not have time for questions.
We do not believe that the process is only about the bereaved families; another important aspect to consider as regards the value of public inquests is the significant success of our fatal accident inquiries. The number of FAIs has fallen significantly over the years. That fall has been driven in part by feedback and learning that have been found through our FAIs. Why on earth would we not want to extend that positive approach to many other causes of death?In the end, regardless of the legal requirements, surely the right decision—the only decision that there can be from a progressive nation—is to have inquests. This is an area in which we are already 100 per cent independent as a nation and can blame no one but ourselves. I think that the process has to change.
link
I have been involved with Stuart and Margaret Graham’s case on Colin’s death for about six years now. Their tenacity is to be commended and they have turned a grieving process into something constructive. The case that they have made is quite compelling. It is important to have an independent element to the process of determining the outcomes because trust—not just in the police but in the prosecution service—has broken down. If there is an element of distrust in a process, you need some independent process to adjudicate, to determine what has happened and to take things forward. The fact that such a process has been missing for so long is something that we must correct.Obviously there are cost and time considerations, but I think that we can implement a system that does not involve a considerable cost and which will get satisfaction for families such as Stuart and Margaret Graham.
I thank Willie Rennie for those comments. I have two questions before I bring in other colleagues.If your petition was successful, there would clearly be a rise in the number of FAIs in Scotland—
No, I need to make a clarification. An FAI is a full judicial review and it would be overburdensome on the state if we tried to implement FAIs as a broad base. Inquests do not have to be as formal as that. We are talking about inquests, not about having FAIs as the only mechanism. An FAI is a very procedurally dominant thing. To take the extreme of that, I do not see why you could not have the release of information to a family under legal care of documentation. Just having access to the documents may be enough to satisfy a family. There is a gradient of scale involved.
Thank you for that clarification. You are saying that you are looking for some sort of halfway house—you are not asking for a full FAI every time there is an accidental death. You would sometimes seek some lesser form of inquiry, which would be some form of public inquiry.
There could be two or three levels leading to an FAI as a final outcome—as a judicial review.
Thank you. My other question was in relation to article 2 of the ECHR, which Mr Whittle mentioned. I looked up article 2 earlier and there is clearly a Europe-wide duty to investigate suspicious deaths. Is it your submission that the Scottish system is not compliant with the ECHR in that regard?
No, I am not saying that at all. I think that the Scottish system complies with article 2—Lord Cullen clearly thought so and he is a lawyer. Why would I argue with him? The principle is much wider than that. I think that article 2 sets out the minimum standard that you have to comply with—you have no choice about that. However, the inquest system that I am fairly familiar with puts the family and the community at the centre of it all. It does not just comply with the law; it goes further, by involving the family in the whole process and dealing with their needs.
Although we are here as a team, I take a different view on article 2 with regard to a suspicious death. If a suspicious death is investigated and you are told only the outcome based on information from a single side and there is no right to question that, there is no public transparency. How do you determine that the investigation has been thorough in the first place when the person who is telling you that that is the case is the same person who carried it out? Transparency is lacking. Although an investigation might meet article 2 requirements, the test has never been put in place, hence the need for an inquest.
Thank you very much—that is very helpful. I bring in my colleagues.
I understand the particular nature of the petition and share Willie Rennie’s concerns. Like the convener, I thought that you were asking for an FAI to be held for any suspicious death. Will you clarify that that is not what you are asking for?
We are not asking for that. The nation has a blind spot in that we see FAIs as the only vehicle that we can use. We have failed to develop a mechanism that could lead to an FAI. For example, a gradient step could lead to an FAI, whereas we go from an investigation to an FAI with nothing in between. That is a huge hole in the system. We need a structural process that develops within the law. That is about not changing the law but embracing article 2 and using it pragmatically for the people.
There are other mechanisms in which to do that; I am sure that John Wilson will talk about one of those in a minute.There is no point in conducting an FAI if no new evidence is likely. What is being questioned is the independence of the evidence and that that evidence should be made available to those closely involved. Is that the case? Is information in a lot of cases, some cases or very few cases withheld from those who are directly impacted by a death that is perhaps unexplained? Perhaps Mr Whittle can address that.
That is how it appears to me. My problem is that I am used to a completely different system in which every death is investigated independently. In that system, the police get a phone call to say that there has been a murder. When I was a policeman I would, for example, turn out at 3 o’clock in the morning. At 3.30 am the coroner’s office would get a phone call and someone from there would attend. They would be involved with the family from a very early stage and would meet them to share information. The family and local community would be embraced immediately in that investigation and kept up to speed with it. The investigation would proceed and, if we reached the stage at which we were not likely to find the offender, there would be an inquest. As a policeman, I would attend that inquest and give evidence about the investigation and the resources that we used. I would also be questioned routinely by the bereaved family. I was held to account by the bereaved for my work and I have been in some very uncomfortable positions in inquests. Although inquests may not be pleasant, they are essential. As a policeman, it was my job to satisfy the public and the family that the police service had done all that it could to find a killer. That is not always possible, but at least the family goes away understanding that we have done the very best that we can. That open information sharing is crucial, but that does not seem to apply in the Scottish system, from what I have seen so far.
By your demeanour, I imagine that you would be very forthright in any inquest and helpful to the families concerned. Are you saying that—perhaps using the phrase “cover-up” would be a bit strong—full evidence is not given by the authorities to families in Scotland who are impacted by an unknown death?
That is certainly the perspective of Colin Marr’s family. It seems that there is resistance to providing information. It must be asked for, pursued and dragged out—it is almost like pulling teeth. In the English regime that I am used to, the family would have that information. They have lost a loved one. They should know what has happened, why it happened and what has been done by the state. That information is openly shared and the family can question every part of it. Not allowing that seems to be a massive gap in the Scottish system.
I will be definitive: there were cover-ups that documentary evidence can prove.
We need to be careful. You are obviously privy to information that we are not.
I agree, but you asked a question and I can give a definitive answer.
I suggest that we discount that comment. I am sure that you can and I emphasise and sympathise with you.
I understand the position, but you asked Tony Whittle a question and he does not—
I was talking in general terms, which Mr Whittle addressed. He was saying that the Scottish system allows—that there are windows through which information may not fly.
Okay.
My question has partly been answered. It was about the structural steps before the FAI, which you have clearly illustrated.My other question is about costings. Have you looked at costings?
No. The first part of any implementation is principle: you agree a principle, then figure out a way to implement it. I do not think that it is my duty to do a full analysis. We know that a full FAI is very costly if you get Queen’s counsels involved. To deal with a QC costs about £6,500 before you even get to a meeting: it is a massive cost to the system that we do not want to put on families. It is a very difficult thing to gauge.You should start from a pragmatic point of view and look for the lowest implementation cost possible, to make it accessible to most people.
Some of it can be cost free. If to share information is to press a button on a printer and hand the result out, there is no cost. You get the family involved and tell them what you have found—what the pathologist found and what the investigators found, and what they have done—and ask them whether they are happy with it. If they are, it is job done. If they are not, a second review process is needed to ask questions. It could be cost free.
There is a precedent. We are not pushing for anything for our case. We found that in the FAI full information was released directly to Colin’s father, without going through our legal team. All he had to do was sign it off. The precedent has been set and the principle can be that a family can have access to a full package of information. That has happened, in a situation in which there was a potential homicide type of dialogue. The question is how you make it far more available. We are saying that the FAI was a critical step for us and asking how we make such access more available to others.
I want to draw out the difference between an FAI and the coroner’s court. As we know from newspaper headlines, an FAI can be long running and can cost hundreds of thousands of pounds to conduct.Mr Whittle, you have had experience of a coroner’s court. Would the creation of a coroner’s court-type establishment in Scotland be a good option to help families get the type of information that you want them to have? Would it avoid having to get full establishment of an FAI-type of court system?
Yes; I think so. I will give an analogy. On 11 May 1985, 56 people died in Bradford at a football match. I was involved in the investigation team and there was an inquest and a public inquiry. The inquest looked at the cause of death: who died, when they died, how they died and why they died. The public inquiry looked at safety at sports grounds. The inquiry went on for months and months, whereas the inquest took about four or five days with a jury. It can be done very quickly.I am not familiar with the regime in Scotland—you are, of course—but many parts of Scotland may just need an ad hoc coroner. Coroners in England and Wales are either medically or legally qualified and are appointed by the crown but paid by the local authority. Some parts of England and Wales have so few such people that they do not have a full-time coroner but have someone who is on call ad hoc: a lawyer who perhaps specialises in family law, who was brought in on Friday, could be running an inquest. Such people deal with all the inquests. David Hinchliff is the coroner for the Leeds part of west Yorkshire, which has a population of well over 1 million. He deals with 500 inquests a year. Some of those are paper inquests that last half an hour: the family says that it does not want to come along, he reads the papers, a decision is made and recorded, a death certificate is issued and it is finished. Some of them last three or four days, but it is not unusual for him to deal with two or three a day.
As a family we requested that once we had access to the information we did not want an FAI. We wanted to use that information but what we finally got was another investigation. That FAI was very costly and, from our point of view, was not necessary. We would rather it had not been carried out, because FAIs cannot question investigations and the very thing that we wanted was to question the investigation. An inquest allows a family to do that. There is a misbelief that an FAI answers all questions. It has serious limitations because it does not satisfy some of those aspects.11:30
That is the point that I am trying to draw attention to. In your submission you referred to “flawed decisions” being made by the police or whoever in relation to the outcome of the circumstances around someone’s death.
What becomes important is that the sheriff has to assume that the investigation is 100 per cent thorough and that therefore all the information is valid. We cannot question the decision of the sheriff, because his decisions are valid based on what has been presented. However, the problem is that we are not allowed to question the source of the material used. It is fundamental to every investigation that if we cannot question source material, then there have to be limitations.
The point is that if there was a coroner’s court type of scenario, then people such as the police and medical staff would be under oath to give evidence to that type of court, whether it involved a sheriff or not. My understanding of the coroner’s court in England and Wales is that families are allowed to ask questions, whereas in Scotland at present to go through an FAI means taking a very costly legal route to get the same answers that could be got if a coroner’s court was set-up in Scotland.
Yes.
Always.
Ironically, we have a great advantage here because we do not have such a system. As we have discussed, the system in England has its limitations because it is as if article 2 has been superimposed on a coroner’s court system. Here, we can stand back and ask, “What’s the best way to fully implement article 2?” We have the opportunity, from a fresh standpoint, to develop something that really fits the 21st century and is pragmatic and cost effective.
Mr Whittle made a point earlier about families being involved. His example was that, as a serving police officer he would get a call about a death at 3 o’clock in the morning and the coroner would get a call at 3.30. The coroner would then liaise with the family and advise them, and take any questions from them at that point. If that type of system was established in Scotland, would it assist many families to come to an earlier conclusion as to the outcome of the death of a loved one?
I am conscious that I was very specific earlier. We have had discussions with a number of families. I think that the quicker people are involved—the quicker they are allowed to participate in the questioning process—the better. If I am honest, because so many things were done wrong in our case, I do not even know how our system should work. We never saw how the system was supposed to work; our case was an aberration. If people had listened to what our family had had to say on the night, the process would have had a different trajectory—that is just a fact. However, that did not happen.
One of the questions that you asked in the petition was about flawed decisions, particularly as they affect insurance claims by family members.
Yes.
What responses did you receive to that question?
Again, I put that issue down to our personal experience. Colin was a young man and the concept of insurance did not even hit us. We had a written decision that on that night Colin took his own life. That decision goes on the books and it does not get changed, regardless of whether a year later the case is moving to a suspicious death. That decision does not get changed and the insurance company does not pay out. The insurance company did not pay out until we got the FAI that said that there was no evidence, but that was after four years. Transfer that to another situation and imagine that it involved a young father or mother who was the sole provider for a family—that must happen. Again, I think that there is a key point here that people perhaps do not understand, which is that in Scotland suicide is deemed as being “probably” suicide, or as we took it, “maybe”. In England, it must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. There is one hell of a difference between those two positions, but we use the statistics as if they have the same meaning. It is interesting that Scotland has one of the highest suicide rates in Europe. I do not know the answers, but I think that there are pertinent questions in there.
Thank you very much.
We are a bit short of time, so I ask for a quick question from Chic Brodie and perhaps a quick response.
I have a quick question for Willie Rennie. How have you progressed the issue with the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and associated bodies?
link
My primary involvement has been in getting justice for Colin, which has involved liaison with the police—in Fife Constabulary and the new Police Scotland—and with the procurator fiscal and the Crown Office in relation to getting a new investigation. That has been the primary focus. The situation has been incredibly frustrating because of the errors that were made at the beginning of the case, from which we have never recovered.I have not pursued the proposal in the petition with the Scottish Government. The petition is the route that the family has chosen to pursue and I am giving them all the support that they require.
An important point is that, after the Strathclyde Police investigation, we started to synthesise what we had learned. Our objective was to get an independent investigation; we were never involved in dialogue on anything other than that. We were conscious of failings in the system, which we memorised and built up. Only after we had gone through the process of getting our objective did we start to develop our proposal.
The rationale for my question to Mr Rennie was to understand how we can address faults in the system, if they exist.
On six occasions, we tried to speak to Mr MacAskill, but he has never spoken to our family. I do not know whether that is because he thinks that we want to talk about Colin’s case, whereas we are using Colin’s case as an example of how the system works. We understand that Mr MacAskill cannot get involved in the investigation, and that was never our intention. Our aim is to highlight failings of the system. The one thing that I have learned through work is that, if there is an opportunity for things to be wrong or manipulated, it will happen, so a system must be built to be robust against that. We wanted to talk to Mr MacAskill about that.
You probably picked up from our consideration of the previous petition that we now have a summation, during which the committee decides on the next steps. My view is that the petition is important and that the petitioner has raised interesting points. I also thank Willie Rennie for coming along.In the longer term, I would be keen to have the Lord Advocate before us so that we can ask searching questions. However, before that, it would be best to write to the Crown Office. Our note suggests writing to the Scottish Government, the Law Society of Scotland and the Sheriffs Association. I would be interested in asking Victim Support Scotland for its views, as I have had quite an interest in victims.
We are in touch with a lot of families. I do not think that any of them goes to Victim Support, because we do not fit into any camp. Our case is not quite a suicide or a homicide and we have never been able to find someone to talk to. Most of the families who are in the same place are in the same position. We do not feel represented by the system.
That is why it would be useful to speak to such groups.I suggest that we consider taking evidence from the Lord Advocate in the longer term and that, in the meantime, we should write to the Crown Office for information before considering next steps.
I suggest writing to Police Scotland, too.
I would like us to write to Police Scotland, which Anne McTaggart suggested. When we write to the Crown Office and Police Scotland, I would like us to ask them to detail how they engage with families in such circumstances, so that we have an idea of whether they engage with and consult families and discuss the issues that surround the suspicious death of a family member. There might be lessons to learn and it would be useful to find out how such consultation is done, if it is done at all.
Do members agree to the course of action that is in the clerk’s note and to write to Victim Support Scotland and Police Scotland?Members indicated agreement.
We will continue the petition, which raises an important issue. When we get further information, we will discuss the petition further. The clerks will inform the witnesses of developments. I thank Stuart Graham, Tony Whittle and Willie Rennie for coming along.
link
I thank the committee for continuing the petition.
I suspend the meeting to allow our witnesses to leave.11:39 Meeting suspended.
11:40 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Jan 2014 →- 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 60
- 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 66
- 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 13
- 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 23
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.