Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 5 December 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01735)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
With your permission, Presiding Officer, it might be useful for members if I give a brief update on the severe weather disruption facing Scotland.

As members will know, we have had gusts of wind of more than 100 mph in many areas. The Scottish Government resilience operation has been in operation all day. The Minister for Transport and Veterans is in the Transport Scotland control room, where he will be until the emergency passes.

I confirm that one weather-related fatality has been reported in Scotland. There have been a number of injuries but thankfully none yet has been reported as serious. There has been significant disruption to road, rail and ferry infrastructure. Our utility companies have reported that 100,000 customers have been offline, but 15,000 reconnections have already been made, and those will continue through the day.

In light of the tragedy at the Clutha bar, we all have very good reason to pay tribute to the outstanding work of our emergency services. I reassure members that that work is on again today, as we respond to the on-going emergency of the weather conditions.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I thank the First Minister very much for that update. Our thoughts are with those families who have been sorely affected by the bad weather, but also with all the brave people of the emergency services and other agencies who are working to get Scotland safe again, so that people can move about the country.

The First Minister put childcare at the heart of his white paper on independence. Can he tell me what the final stage of his plans would cost, how many jobs would be created and what the average salary of the jobs would be if a separate Scotland was going to recoup the cost of the policy—[Interruption.] Forgive me, but I thought that the policy was a serious one. I asked what the average salary—[Interruption.] SNP back benchers are laughing, but perhaps we can get the answer to my question. How many jobs would be created and what would the average salary of those jobs be if a separate Scotland was going to recoup the cost of the policy, as the white paper says it would, in income tax?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
In the first term of office with an independent Scottish Parliament, the policy would cost £700 million a year. It would require a doubling of the childcare workforce, which is an increase of 30,000 jobs. One of the great economic benefits would be in releasing more women to be available to move back into the workforce. That estimate is just short of 100,000 women, assuming that we could raise women’s participation rates in the workforce in Scotland to the same level as in Sweden.

The Swedish example was taken for a number of reasons, but it has a lot of credibility on the basis that male participation in the Scottish and in the Swedish workforce is virtually identical at present. There seems no other good reason why there should be a 6 per cent differential in female participation rates in the workforce except for Sweden’s extraordinary supported childcare arrangements, which provide the opportunity for more equality in the workforce by allowing women not only to care properly for their children, but to fully participate in the workforce and society.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Whatever that was, it was not an answer to the question that I asked. Perhaps the First Minister will want to reflect on the fact that modern women are not too impressed by men who promise the earth without providing any evidence that they are serious about doing so. On that evidence, he is not serious about the matter, so let me try and help him.

The Scottish Parliament information centre estimates the cost of the policy to be at least £1.2 billion a year, and that is without the cost of new buildings and facilities to meet increased demand. Since the First Minister has promised for months that the white paper would answer all the questions about independence, he must have worked out how many jobs would need to be created, and at what average salary, for the policy to pay for itself. Unfortunately, in 670 pages, there was enough room to explain what time zone we would be in, but not those details. Will the First Minister give Scottish families, men and women the details that they deserve to know?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont asked me a question about the number of jobs to be created. I pointed out that we would require 30,000 extra jobs in the childcare workforce, and the policy would release an estimated almost 100,000 people, mainly women, back into the workforce, to be available to work. By the end of the first session of Parliament, if we remember—and that is the question that I answered—around 50 per cent of two-year-olds and all three and four-year-olds would be entitled to 1,140 hours of childcare a year. That would be one of the great benefits of having the freedom of independence. That would require an investment of £600 million a year in addition to the £100 million in the first year to make the improvements that were specified.

That is an argued transformational change in childcare provision in Scotland. We have consistently pointed out the benefits in terms of increased taxation revenue from releasing that additional workforce into the community of Scotland and the range of benefits in terms of employers’ national insurance, employees’ national insurance, income tax, VAT and the range of economic expansion and that those revenues will flow into the Scottish exchequer in an independent Scotland. Under the devolution position that we have now and the one proposed by Johann Lamont, they would go into the back pocket of George Osborne. As we are finding out from the autumn statement today, when it comes to increasing Scottish expenditure, we do not want to look to the Tory chancellor in London, who looks forward to further years of austerity.

That is why the difference is opening up: by showing that that transformational policy in childcare can be afforded and can be pursued in an independent Scotland, just as it is pursued at the present moment in an independent Sweden.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
First of all, the First Minister reread the answer to the question that I did not ask him. He has not yet explained how he would cost the bit beyond the first term. He simply ignored that. He then says that the policy is transformational but does not give us the figures. We need to know the figures for it to be more than simple assertion.

I have done some estimates of my own. [Interruption.] In order to be of assistance to the First Minister, of course. Let us give the First Minister the maximum benefit of the doubt. There are currently 90,000 women unemployed. Let us imagine that they all get jobs because of the policy, even the ones without children. To give the First Minister the biggest possible tax base to draw from, let us say that the 35,000 jobs that he says will be created in childcare do not go to any of those women but all go to unemployed men. That is 125,000 people off the dole, saving at the most £370 million in jobseekers allowance. Those people need collectively to pay £830 million in income tax for the policy to pay for itself as the much-vaunted—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am only quoting what the white paper says. It is supposed to be the bible. It is the white paper that says it, and presumably the First Minister will rest on the figures in the white paper.

Does that not mean that, on average, every single one of them would have to earn more than £42,000 a year, almost twice the average wage, for an independent Scotland to recoup the money?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
No, because the calculation of additional income to Government is about a calculation of the increase in output that is generated by that increase in the labour force. That increase in output goes across the economy; it benefits lots and lots of people. If we have more people in employment, spending more—[Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
—it does not just mean that they pay more tax. The people who benefit from the economic expansion also contribute more tax.

Incidentally, I would have thought that that would be recognised by the Labour Party since it has deployed this argument time after time in debates in the Westminster Parliament. Unfortunately, that instruction has not drifted its way up to Scotland. It is about the benefits of an economic expansion, as opposed to the austerity policies that we have been suffering from over recent years from both Labour and Tory Governments at Westminster.

I am surprised that Johann Lamont does not embrace that expansion and transformational change in childcare. She came to see me some months ago, but she still cannot explain how she would pay for any increase in childcare provision in Scotland. She did not have a single positive idea or suggested amendment to the budget to tell us what Labour’s plans to make any change in the provision of childcare would be.

Johann Lamont seems to suggest that it would be extremely difficult to get the proposed expansion in the number of women in the workforce but, thanks to John Swinney’s initiatives on the matter, employment among women in Scotland has increased by 3 per cent over the past year or two. Therefore, I do not think that it is overambitious to suggest that, through a transformational offer on childcare, a 6 per cent increase could be achieved, and the talent and ability that are locked away at the moment could be used for the benefit of the families concerned and of the wider Scottish economy.

I am absolutely delighted to get the debate on to the benefits of independence. Let us talk about jobs, let us talk about families and let us talk about the transformation of childcare and society.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Now we have the truth of it—this is not about men and women struggling with childcare; it is about getting on to the benefits of independence. How disgraceful it is that the First Minister is using the issue as an opportunity to argue about independence, rather than to address the needs of families across Scotland.

The First Minister says that the policy will benefit lots and lots of people. I hate to tell him that that is not good enough. His white paper is predicated not on output, but on the money that would be recouped through income tax. He has not been able to show us the figures. If he is telling us that his white paper does not tell us the truth, that will come as no surprise to us, but it might come as some surprise to the members behind him.

If the First Minister does not like my figures—and as his own figures do not appear to exist—I will give him some figures that he has not provided today. According to Scottish Government figures, if 105,000 women joined the workforce—that is more than the number of women who are currently unemployed—the tax revenues would be less than half of the most optimistic estimates of the cost of the proposed policy.

Last week, the First Minister googled his answers, but even Google cannot make those figures work. In order that we do not have to wait for a freedom of information request to get the fag packet that the policy was worked out on—crudely, to win votes for independence, not to meet the needs of families—will he now publish full costings of his flagship policy, or admit that it is a shameless attempt to con the people of Scotland, which we have all seen through?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
From that line of questioning, we still do not know whether the Labour Party is for or against a transformation in childcare provision in Scotland. We do not know, because Labour has not laid out its policies and has not said how it will pay for them. We know that the cuts commission is looking in detail at cutting free transport and free personal care and at reintroducing tuition fees, but I do not think that those options will be palatable to the people of Scotland.

I will be delighted to lay down the calculations that show how an expansion in economic activity will result in a £700 million increase in Scottish revenues. Of course, that increase in Scottish revenues would occur at present, but what happens is that the vast majority of those revenues go to the Westminster Exchequer. Let us imagine for a second that Labour decided to cut everything else and to go for a transformation in childcare, and that those additional revenues were generated. Do we think that George Osborne would say, “That is fantastic. I’ll immediately return these additional revenues to Scotland. I shall help Scotland, because I think its policy on childcare should be supported”? That is not the fate that any of the no parties has in store for Scotland in the event of a no vote. We know what that fate is: it is a £4,000 million cut from the existing position in the Scottish public finances. We also know that that is supported by an all-party group—it is supported not just by the Tories, but by the Labour Party as well.

Not only do we have the prospect of a transformation in childcare and all that that means for families, women and equality in Scotland, and a policy that can result in a huge increase in jobs and economic output; we know what the alternative is—no improvements in childcare and a slashing of the Scottish budget. That is what would follow a no vote.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Tax System (White Paper Proposals) Questions · 6
  3. Independence (Currency Options) Questions · 6
  4. Fuel Poverty Questions · 4
  5. Independence (Compatibility of Tuition Fee Charges with European Union Law) Questions · 8
  6. Independence (Share of United Kingdom National Debt) Questions · 6
  7. Prestwick Airport Questions · 6
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  9. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  10. Barnett Formula First Minister’s Questions · 6
  11. Land Ownership (Devolution of Powers) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. “Coping with the cuts? Local government and poorer communities” First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. World AIDS Day 2013 Members’ business · 8
  14. Food Train Members’ business · 8
  15. Taking Children into Care Debate · 63
  16. Commissioner for Ethical Standards in Public Life in Scotland Debate · 3
  17. Decision Time Decision time · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.