Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 14 November 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 13 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

13 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. In a week in which I know that we are, across the chamber, mourning the loss of our friend and fine parliamentarian, Helen Eadie, I ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01670)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I thank Johann Lamont for the opportunity to express my personal condolences—which I know are shared by every single person in the chamber—on the passing of Helen Eadie. She was Johann Lamont’s party colleague, but she was the parliamentary colleague of us all. I understand that the Parliament will be given a chance next week to express its appreciation for Helen’s contribution.

In terms of Government business, we will be carrying forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I thank the First Minister for those kind words. I know that across the chamber there has been great comfort from the kind words that people have expressed at the loss, particularly for Helen’s very precious family.

On 20 March, a spokesperson for the First Minister said:

“The cast-iron position is that an independent Scotland will continue to use the pound”.

With less than a fortnight to go before the publication of the white paper, is that still the Scottish Government’s position?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
That is interesting, because I thought that we had experienced a historic day in Scottish politics. That is right—it would appear that someone in the Scottish Government has told the truth. Colin McKay, Alex Salmond’s chief strategist, told a conference this week:

“We cannot assert as an a priori fact we can achieve a currency union with the UK”.

The First Minister’s chief strategist is clear: no cast-iron guarantee can be given. Even in Alex Salmond’s world it cannot possibly be true that one can both have and not have a cast-iron guarantee. Given that rare moment of candour, what is the First Minister’s plan B if he is unable to successfully negotiate a currency union with the rest of the United Kingdom?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The point that was made is quite different from the one that Johann Lamont is pursuing. The report in today’s paper is wrong: the white paper will be definitive on the Scottish National Party Government’s policy positions.

The point that was made was entirely different and is illustrated in the newspaper report by the question of the bedroom tax, on which it was said that it is not inevitable in an independent Scotland that the bedroom tax would be repealed. It would be inevitable if there was an SNP Government in an independent Scotland.

The point being made is about the essence of independence; it is about choice. It might be inevitable if there was a Labour Government in an independent Scotland, assuming that they turned up to vote. The essence of the argument for independence is that it gives people in Scotland the choice about what they do. I assure Johann Lamont that, when the white paper is published, it will be definitive about the policy choices of the Scottish National Party on the currency and other matters. In that respect, the argument that was made was about something else entirely. If Johann Lamont will contain herself and wait, she will see that the white paper will give her the information that she desires.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
That was not so much cast iron as brass neck. The fact of the matter is that if the First Minister knows what his position is he has an obligation to share it not with me, but with the people of this country who are concerned about their pensions and mortgages and whether they will have the pound.

We know that the First Minister is a master negotiator. We saw that during the historic Edinburgh agreement when he went into a room with David Cameron and gave him everything that he wanted—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Alex Salmond will forgive me if I do not share his optimism about negotiating a currency union in the space of 18 months and getting a deal that works for the people of Scotland as well as the arrangement that we now have. Colin McKay, the First Minister’s chief strategist, is also concerned about that timeline. He says that it is “impossible” unless the UK Government wants to negotiate a smooth transfer of powers.

Given that Alex Salmond seems to believe that the people of England, Wales and Northern Ireland are so unreasonable that he has felt for all his political life the need to break away from them, how confident is he that he can strike a deal with a Westminster Government in just 18 months?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
It was, of course, the UK Government’s paid legal adviser, Professor James Crawford, who described the 18-month timetable for transition as realistic in terms of some of the major issues that would be discussed. Given that that is the average of all negotiations throughout the world, if the UK Government’s paid legal adviser—a distinguished professor of international law—describes that timetable as realistic, we are on pretty firm ground in putting it forward.

The essence of the argument for the sterling area is that it is in Scotland’s interests because England is our biggest customer and it is in England’s interests because Scotland is its second-biggest customer. We might even say that it was logical and desirable, except that I did not say that first: it was Alistair Darling, the leader of the no campaign, on “Newsnight” in January this year.

It takes a brass neck to write as Margaret Curran did to Liberal Democrat MPs—I have a letter here that starts “Dear Alistair”; it is to Alistair Carmichael—asking them to turn up to defeat the bedroom tax in the House of Commons and then for 47 Labour MPs, including 10 for Scotland, to forget to turn up to defeat the bedroom tax. When it comes to brass neck, the SNP will have to go a long way to beat the Labour Party’s on the bedroom tax. [Applause.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
This is an SNP that could not stay up to support the minimum wage and that would not go through the lobbies to protect people against the energy companies that are ripping them off.

The First Minister says that the UK adviser says that it can be done in 18 months. His own adviser says that it cannot be. That must be the first time that he has taken the UK Government’s advice ahead of that of his own advisers.

Alistair Darling has also said:

“But Mr Salmond must have a hidden fallback option because ‘no one but a fool would go into a negotiation if they hadn’t got a plan B’”.

It seems that we have here a fool who has no plan B on the currency.

I must admit some concern about the wellbeing of Colin McKay. Has anyone seen Alex Bell since he appeared on “Newsnight”? Did he get a visit from Shona Robison? Is he in the same gulag as Professor Chris Whatley?

Is the reality not that the First Minister does not want to give the people of Scotland the truth about independence in the debate because his case does not add up? Is the truth not that he cannot stand having a debate with the people of Scotland at all?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The last time that I saw Alex Bell he was appearing on television saying what a nice person I was, unlike Labour special advisers such as Damian McBride, who make lots of money by revealing the extent of bullying, intimidation and all sorts of other things within the previous Labour Government.

Let us put it this way: the report is wrong and the white paper will be definitive on the SNP policy positions. It will also say—of course it should say—that the essence of independence is choice for the people of Scotland so that they can choose their own Government as opposed to having another Government foisted upon them.

I cannot conceive of a circumstance in which the SNP and other parties in an independent Scottish Parliament would not repeal the bedroom tax. Therefore, that is an argument for independence. That assumes that people turn up for the vote and I really think that we deserve an explanation as to why this week, after appealing to Alistair Carmichael to turn up to vote against the bedroom tax, 10 of Scotland’s Labour MPs went missing—absent without leave—and allowed that vote to proceed against the people of Scotland.

Johann Lamont objects to my citing Professor James Crawford and Alistair Darling on the transition timetable and the arguments for a sterling area. I merely put it to her that, if I am able, as I am in this case, to cite them, it will not be the most difficult negotiation that we have ever had, as the people on the other side of the argument think that a sterling area is logical and desirable. It will not be the most difficult transition that we have ever had if even the paid legal adviser of the UK Government, Professor James Crawford, is honest enough to say that the timetable is realistic.

Given that reassurance, I think that we can genuinely say that we can all look forward enthusiastically to the white paper, which will chart Scotland’s new future, with the essence of the argument being, “Let’s get the future of this country into Scottish hands, and let’s make choices for the Scottish people based on the democratic view at election time.”

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Police Stations (Opening Times) Questions · 6
  2. Fuel Poverty Questions · 6
  3. Scottish Prison Service (Pensions) Questions · 4
  4. Detect Cancer Early Programme Questions · 4
  5. Crimes of Violence and Indecency (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 4
  6. Orkney Fish Producers Organisation Questions · 4
  7. China (Economic Opportunities) Questions · 4
  8. Review of Expenses and Funding of Civil Litigation in Scotland Questions · 6
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  11. Clyde Shipyards First Minister’s Questions · 7
  12. Medical Overtime First Minister’s Questions · 5
  13. China First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. HIV (Awareness and Understanding) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Edinburgh Zoo Members’ business · 9
  16. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  17. Scottish Independence Referendum Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 47
  18. Scottish Independence Referendum Bill Bill debate · 99
  19. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  20. Decision Time Decision time · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.