The implementation of curriculum for excellence, including the new national qualifications, is on track. Our schools have made excellent progress and all partners are committed to ensuring that the new qualifications are delivered successfully and benefit pupils across Scotland.
The new highers, available from next session, are designed to prepare and support our young people for the changing world that lies ahead of them. They provide smooth progression from the new national 5 qualification and we have made it clear that we consider them the natural option for young people in Scotland next session. We also recognise that there needs to be some scope for local flexibility based on professional judgment, where teachers can work closely with their senior management, local authority and parent body to make a decision in the best interests of their learners.
Education Scotland, the Scottish Qualifications Authority, the Scottish Government and local authorities are delivering a wide range of support to help teachers introduce the new highers. We will continue to listen and respond wherever we need.
This is a very serious issue to do with our children’s education. The minister says that he will listen and has listened, but he must have delayed hearing. Over 18 months ago, the Government was warned by teachers, parents and Opposition members such as me about issues with teachers’ workload, so why has it taken until now to allow for a delay? When was that decision taken? If this climbdown was seamlessly planned and organised, why did Bill Maxwell of Education Scotland send a letter to directors of education just two weeks ago setting out
“the expectation that all schools and centres will adopt the new qualifications in line with the national timetable for implementation in 2014/15”?
Will the minister apologise for not listening sooner and for the shambolic mess that this has left us in?
Dr Alasdair AllanSNPThe Minister for Learning, Science and Scotland‘s Languages · Na h-Eileanan an Iar
The member has to get it clear in his head whether he and the Opposition are criticising the Government for pressing ahead too fast, as has been suggested, or for not pressing ahead fast enough. There is no doubt in my mind that the Government has been listening; indeed, we have been listening for some weeks now to the calls from the teaching community and schools for exceptional circumstances to be recognised. As for the expectations and the letter that Mr Bibby has mentioned, it remains the natural expectation and option that young people will be sitting the new highers in the coming session. Criticising the Government for recognising exceptional circumstances and the need to work with teachers is really a criticism that I find difficult to follow.
The listening mode did not last too long. I said that the situation could have been planned for and adequately resourced had the Government listened to concerns 18 months ago. Instead, an audit was commissioned on the state of readiness for the new qualifications, but those involved did not speak directly to a single teacher. Ministers had previously said that a delay would be damaging, but that is exactly what we will have in some circumstances and teachers, children and parents have been let down, with some children now not having a direct follow-on from their national 4 and 5 learning. Does the minister accept that his Government has got this badly wrong?
Dr Alasdair AllanSNPThe Minister for Learning, Science and Scotland‘s Languages · Na h-Eileanan an Iar
No—and it is also worth saying that, as far as the flexibility that has been discussed is concerned, it will not be enough for a single teacher to make such a decision. Any such decision would have to be made in consultation with the school, the local authority and, crucially, the parent body in that school. In any case, I am more than happy to be in the company of people such as Larry Flanagan of the Educational Institute of Scotland, who described this decision as
“a sensible approach ... in the best interests of ... pupils”,
and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, whose representative Douglas Chapman called it
“a pragmatic solution to exceptional circumstances”.
The Government has been listening and has acted, and I am more than pleased that it is ensuring that curriculum for excellence continues to be the success that we all know it is going to be.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.