5. To ask the Scottish Government what the set-up and running costs would be of a new national, independent broadcaster in the event of Scotland becoming independent. (S4O-02416)
Fiona HyslopSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Culture and External Affairs · Linlithgow
Later this year, the Scottish Government will publish a white paper on independence, which will set out a positive prospectus for an independent Scotland, including for broadcasting.
It is clear that, if Scotland becomes independent, significant costs will be involved in setting up an independent broadcasting service that is separate from the BBC. If the Scottish National Party is so keen to keep the Queen, the United Kingdom pound and other things about Britain, why does it not support keeping the BBC? The SNP supports lots of other unions; why does it not support an entertainment union? People in Scotland value the BBC—what has the SNP got against it?
Fiona HyslopSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Culture and External Affairs · Linlithgow
I have been supportive of the BBC. I have commented in the chamber on cuts that are taking place and their impact on BBC Scotland, and I have clearly supported BBC staff in particular.
I remind Neil Bibby that BBC licence fee income from Scotland is £320 million but, in 2012-13, only £102 million of that was due to be spent in Scotland. In current proposals under the union, that figure will reduce to £86 million in 2016-17.
As for the BBC’s position after its charter renewal—or possible charter renewal—in 2016, I remind Neil Bibby, who is associated with the better together campaign, that two Conservative bills in the Westminster Parliament would decriminalise non-payment of the licence fee and privatise the BBC. He is associated with that campaign, which gives the Conservatives permission to continue to be involved in broadcasting, and Jackson Carlaw of the Conservatives wants to abolish the licence fee and have the BBC make its own way. If Neil Bibby can forecast where the BBC would be under the union in 2016, he is a better person than anybody in the chamber.
Given that Scotland subsidises the BBC with £218 million more than is spent here, what could that £218 million mean for jobs and production in Scotland?
Fiona HyslopSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Culture and External Affairs · Linlithgow
The whole point of having a broadcasting system that is built on BBC Scotland’s staff and assets is to ensure that we invest in productions and commissions in Scotland. For example, for its £290 million of expenditure, RTÉ has four distinct television services, four national radio services, an online presence and other services such as children’s broadcasting and an orchestra. Value for money and—importantly—job security for not only BBC staff but commissioners of TV production in Scotland can be best served by the people of Scotland and as put forward by the SNP.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.