1. To ask the Scottish Government what recent progress has been made in discussions with the UK Government on repatriating the annual £1.4 million of red meat levy income paid by Scotland’s farmers. (S4O-02352)
Official Report · Chamber
Red Meat Levy
Portfolio Question Time Rural Affairs and the Environment
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Richard Lochhead SNP 4
- James Dornan SNP 2
- Claire Baker Lab 1
- Alex Fergusson Con 1
The record
8 contributions1. To ask the Scottish Government what recent progress has been made in discussions with the UK Government on repatriating the annual £1.4 million of red meat levy income paid by Scotland’s farmers. (S4O-02352)
Given that this serious issue has been going on for far too long, the First Minister recently wrote to the Prime Minister to seek his support for repatriation of the levy that rightly belongs to Scotland. I inform members that the Prime Minister has responded to the letter but has declined our request, which is unfortunate. I know that that decision will disappoint the whole of the Scottish red meat industry, which is unanimous in the view that Scotland’s producers are being short-changed.
Quality Meat Scotland has cautiously accepted an invitation from the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs minister of state to join a forum to determine spending priorities for the disputed levy income. However, I hope that members agree that rather than make the new and spurious argument that the lost levy somehow benefits the Scottish industry, the United Kingdom Government would do better to focus on putting right the wrong.
Quality Meat Scotland has cautiously accepted an invitation from the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs minister of state to join a forum to determine spending priorities for the disputed levy income. However, I hope that members agree that rather than make the new and spurious argument that the lost levy somehow benefits the Scottish industry, the United Kingdom Government would do better to focus on putting right the wrong.
Given the UK Government’s negative response on this important issue, on which the Scottish Government has the support of Quality Meat Scotland and NFU Scotland, does the cabinet secretary share my disappointment at the Prime Minister’s unwillingness to change tack, although Scotland is so clearly losing out?
I think that there will be a huge degree of anger throughout the livestock sector in Scotland, particularly at a time when the levy income is desperately needed to promote the Scottish brands, so that producers can have a greater return from the marketplace.
As James Dornan said, it is estimated that we are losing £1.4 million of red meat levy over the border every year. The promotional levy in relation to animals that were born and reared in Scotland is being used to promote produce from outside Scotland, because the animals were slaughtered over the border. That is ridiculous, unacceptable and indefensible. I am very disappointed by the Prime Minister’s response, as are the First Minister and the Scottish Government.
As James Dornan said, it is estimated that we are losing £1.4 million of red meat levy over the border every year. The promotional levy in relation to animals that were born and reared in Scotland is being used to promote produce from outside Scotland, because the animals were slaughtered over the border. That is ridiculous, unacceptable and indefensible. I am very disappointed by the Prime Minister’s response, as are the First Minister and the Scottish Government.
link
There is certainly a need for discussions on the distribution of the red meat levy. However, if we are looking for a solution, we surely need to understand how the situation has come about. The availability of abattoirs in Scotland and competitive trading in livestock are key factors. What can the Scottish Government do to make available more viable options in Scotland?
Claire Baker made an important point. Because of the reduction in concentration and capacity of processing throughout Great Britain, more animals are going south of the border to be slaughtered. A number of moves are afoot to try to increase processing in Scotland, but as the member knows, those moves largely relate to sheep—we have very little processing capacity in Scotland for lamb. That is a long-standing issue, unfortunately.
As a result of a number of other factors, such as the closure of Vion, there are moves afoot to address the problem in relation to the pig sector.
We are working closely with the red meat sector to see whether we can increase capacity in Scotland. However, a very flawed formula is putting Scotland at an unfair disadvantage; that is what should be fixed.
As a result of a number of other factors, such as the closure of Vion, there are moves afoot to address the problem in relation to the pig sector.
We are working closely with the red meat sector to see whether we can increase capacity in Scotland. However, a very flawed formula is putting Scotland at an unfair disadvantage; that is what should be fixed.
I am broadly in favour of the principle behind a review of how the levy is deducted and distributed, but I think that the cabinet secretary has been tempted to go for headlines without thinking through the full consequences, which could include losing the benefit of up to £7 million that is ring-fenced for promotion and research on British meat.
The cabinet secretary mentioned the forum that the UK minister offered to set up, which will include all the meat-levy-raising bodies. Can he say why he has so robustly dismissed the forum’s benefits, given that its remit would be to look at all the issues and to determine priorities in the UK?
The cabinet secretary mentioned the forum that the UK minister offered to set up, which will include all the meat-levy-raising bodies. Can he say why he has so robustly dismissed the forum’s benefits, given that its remit would be to look at all the issues and to determine priorities in the UK?
I point out to Alex Fergusson that there have been reviews in the past. There was a review several years ago, and it is unfortunate that its recommendations were not acted on.
A spurious new argument came on the scene a few months ago, although there have been disputes and debates about the issue for several years. The UK Government is trying to defend the status quo for the levy arrangements by suggesting that somehow Scotland benefits from UK spend.
We want to promote the Scottish—not the British—brand and to secure the Scottish premium for red meat. That is why the current arrangements are flawed.
On the proposed new forum, I said at the time and continue to say that I would be very concerned if the forum was another fudge and simply a talking shop to soak up time and allow the current arrangements to stay in place a bit longer, to Scotland’s disadvantage.
A spurious new argument came on the scene a few months ago, although there have been disputes and debates about the issue for several years. The UK Government is trying to defend the status quo for the levy arrangements by suggesting that somehow Scotland benefits from UK spend.
We want to promote the Scottish—not the British—brand and to secure the Scottish premium for red meat. That is why the current arrangements are flawed.
On the proposed new forum, I said at the time and continue to say that I would be very concerned if the forum was another fudge and simply a talking shop to soak up time and allow the current arrangements to stay in place a bit longer, to Scotland’s disadvantage.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 11 Sep 2013 →- Portfolio Question Time Questions · 1
- Red Meat Levy Questions · 8
- Scotch Beef (Japan) Questions · 4
- Financial Support for Farmers (Extreme Weather Losses) Questions · 4
- Marine Protected Areas Questions · 8
- Air Pollution Questions · 6
- Food Recycling Questions · 4
- Gull Management Guidance Questions · 4
- North-east Fishing Representatives (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Solemn Procedure Recommendations Questions · 6
- Chief Constable (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Court Capacity Questions · 8
- Cycling Accidents (Dangerous Driving) Questions · 6
- “Inspection report on Lanarkshire Area of Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service” Questions · 4
- Police Stations (Police Scotland Review) Questions · 7
- Draft Budget 2014-15 Statement · 58
- Enterprise Networks Debate · 108
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 11
- End Revenge Porn Members’ business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.