Good morning. I welcome everyone to the 19th meeting of the Justice Committee in 2013. I ask everyone to switch off mobile phones and other electronic devices completely, as they interfere with the broadcasting system, even when switched to silent.Apologies have been received from David McLetchie; John Lamont is attending as his substitute.I welcome Lewis Macdonald, Iain Gray, John Pentland, Elaine Murray and Claudia Beamish, who are attending to participate in the debate on the Scottish statutory instruments on court reform, which we will consider under agenda item 3.Agenda item 1 is subordinate legislation. The committee will take evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Justice on the draft Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2013; the instrument is subject to affirmative procedure. I welcome the cabinet secretary and his officials to the meeting. Ian Fleming is a policy manager in the Scottish Government, Carla McCloy-Stevens is from the directorate for legal services, and Carolyn Rae is head of public protection in the Scottish Government.I invite the cabinet secretary to make an opening statement on the regulations.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 [Draft]
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 8
- Christine Grahame SNP 5
- Graeme Pearson Lab 5
- Sandra White SNP 1
- Jenny Marra Lab 1
The record
20 contributionsThank you, convener.The regulations will make two substantive changes to Scotland’s sex offender notification scheme. First, they will require homeless registered sex offenders to notify to the police certain personal information every week. That includes their notifying an address or location in the United Kingdom where they can regularly be found. Currently, such offenders are required only to renotify their information annually, or when it changes.Secondly, the regulations will require registered sex offenders to notify the police of any intended travel outside the UK, regardless of the length of the trip. Currently, only foreign travel for three or more days must be notified. The regulations also require notification of certain additional travel information. They make transitional provision so that the new travel notification requirements do not apply to any registered sex offender who intends to travel abroad for fewer than three days during the eight-day period after commencement.We consider that the measures are necessary and proportionate for preventing sexual reoffending and protecting the public—especially children—from sexual harm. Homeless sex offenders pose a greater risk and their whereabouts require more intensive monitoring. The current three-day threshold for travel notification can easily be exploited. It is necessary to know the whereabouts of all sex offenders who travel abroad to enable the police to manage better any identified risk and to prevent sexual harm from being done overseas. Having considered the evidence, we believe that the measures achieve an overall fair balance.I am happy to answer any questions.
Good morning.First, I note that legislation was introduced in England and Wales in July 2012. Can you give us some insight into why it took nearly a year to introduce similar provisions in Scotland?
There are requirements on us in terms of discussions and engagement with stakeholders. Matters have been complicated in Scotland; elections have interfered. We have seen that previously. We are catching up—you are correct about that—but what we propose is right. We are happy to have brought the regulations to Parliament, and we commend them.
Will there be any financial implications from enforcing the regime that the legislation seeks to introduce?
There will be no financial implications that I am aware of. The measures will basically be dealt with by stakeholders—in particular by the police and others who are responsible in multi-agency public protection arrangements, and who do it anyway. Their level of scrutiny might increase, but I do not think that that will have financial implications.
On embarkation and arrival at our airports and ports, is there capacity to know whether a sex offender has arrived in or has left the country, and is therefore in breach of regulations?
Clearly, co-operation with the UK Border Agency is required on such matters. However, one of the strengths of Police Scotland is that we now have a dedicated unit to ensure that staff who previously operated in ports through the previous individual constabularies now do so collectively through the national police service. With that, and through co-operation with the UK Border Agency, and given my recent discussions with the national crime agency on on-going matters, we are satisfied that the arrangements are as good as they can be. Clearly, improvements in police information technology are fundamental; that is work in progress.
Will you continue to pay additional attention to that work to ensure that it delivers?
I can give you an absolute assurance on that.
Thank you.
My questions are in a similar vein to Graeme Pearson’s. First, though, I welcome the regulations. We know that trafficking from certain countries is on the increase, so this is good legislation.Following what Graeme Pearson said on monitoring, will the legislation be monitored within a year or in six months to see how it is working? What will be the timescale?
Monitoring is already done, to an extent, through MAPPA. The framework exists and the legislation merely increases the available powers and level of scrutiny. I do not anticipate any delay in addition to the time that it will take to make the necessary progress in getting information and advice out there. The legislation is about enhancing MAPPA powers and about providing greater scrutiny of, and requirements for, registered sex offenders.
There have in the past few years been incidents involving sex offenders from other jurisdictions coming to Scotland and offending here. Has the Scottish Government made any progress on relationships with other Governments to get information so that such incidents can be prevented?
Yes; we do that at a range of levels. Obviously, one of the main ways is through Europol, but we also get information from other jurisdictions. However, in central and eastern Europe, the information that is collected is perhaps not as good and the information that is retained there is, sadly, not as accessible. Equally, closer to home, we have had difficulties with the Republic of Ireland. Such issues have been on the agendas of trilateral meetings that I have had with the Minister for Justice and Equality for the Republic of Ireland and the Minister of Justice for Northern Ireland. That is work in progress, much of which is not so much about what we require to do here but about how we create relationships and try to develop best practice.We work at all levels, including at the police and Europol levels. We also do work through the United Kingdom, because some matters require to be dealt with by the Home Secretary in terms of international relations. We have a close working relationship with the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland and we seek to ensure that we engage appropriately at all levels, whether through social work engagement with police officers, or whatever. As Graeme Pearson said, ultimately we want to improve our own information and communications technology, but we must ensure that we have the appropriate links that I have mentioned.
I allowed that question by Jenny Marra, although it is not directly related to the instrument. If the minister wishes to proceed on that, I am content, but it is really not what the committee is considering.
It is work in progress. We recognise the challenges, because tragedies have occurred. Sandra White alluded to the fact that people have come from other jurisdictions and perpetrated offences here. Sadly, we know, however, that also people from Scotland go elsewhere to perpetrate offences. There is a two-way street, so we must work with other jurisdictions. Some are not as advanced as we are, but whatever challenges we face, we must try to support those jurisdictions through Europol, and through our interaction with the national crime agency and the Home Secretary.Our proximity to our Celtic cousins in Ireland means that we must undertake work on offenders from Scotland who travel there—high-profile Scots offenders have gone there. We must also do work related to those who come here from there; there was, for example, the devastating tragedy in Dundee.
There are no further questions on the Scottish statutory instrument, so we move on to item 2. I ask the cabinet secretary to move motion S4M-06873 on the Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 draft.Motion moved,That the Justice Committee recommends that the Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 draft be approved.—Kenny MacAskill.Motion agreed to.
We are required to report on all instruments that are subject to affirmative procedure. Are members content to delegate authority to me to sign off the report on the instrument?Members indicated agreement.
The cabinet secretary is staying for the next item. I thank his officials for attending and suspend the meeting briefly to allow officials to swap over.10:10 Meeting suspended.
10:12 On resuming—
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportNo recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Jun 2013 →- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 204
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.