Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 27 June 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 19 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01498)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I would first like to say a few words of tribute to Peter Fraser who, I say sadly, died last weekend.

Lord Fraser was never a member in this chamber, but he did us significant service in the Holyrood inquiry and, before that, as a distinguished Lord Advocate for Scotland. More recently, he agreed to serve as an independent adviser to the Scottish Government on the “Scottish Ministerial Code”, which was another public service that he performed without fear or favour, or any remuneration whatever. Scottish public life is much poorer for his passing. I know that the thoughts of members across the chamber, colleagues and friends are with his wife, Fiona, and their family at this sad time.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I agree with everything that the First Minister said. I pass on our condolences to the family of Peter Fraser and acknowledge the very significant contribution that he made to public life in Scotland.

John Swinney says that the choice for Scotland is between austerity and independence. Will the First Minister explain how a separate Scotland could possibly have a different economic policy from the rest of the United Kingdom, when the rest of the UK would decide what we could spend, what we could borrow and what our interest and taxation rates would be without any representation at all?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
There is a difference between fiscal policy and monetary policy. John Swinney has pointed this out many times, but I will repeat it for Johann Lamont’s benefit: if we take the most recent year for which figures are available, Scotland had a relative surplus of more than £4 billion in comparison with the rest of the UK. That £4 billion—a substantial sum—could have been used in a number of ways; it could have been used to provide more investment in the Scottish economy towards recovery, or it could have been used to enable us to borrow less, which would probably be a good idea. That stronger fiscal position could have worth and benefit for the Scottish people.

The choice between continued austerity and the prospect of mobilising the resources of Scotland is now crystal clear, because in the past few weeks the Labour Party has decided to accept the social welfare policies of the Conservative Party, and last week it decided to accept the economic policies of the Conservative Party. After generations of trying to find any group in Scotland that would support it, the Tory party has finally found an economic ally in the leadership of the Labour Party in Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Like most of what the First Minister says in this chamber, that is completely ludicrous. This is the man who calls a deficit a “relative surplus”. He says that there is a distinction between fiscal policy and monetary policy, but his own adviser, John Kay, makes the point that, if there was an independent Scotland,

“the rest of the UK would seek extensive fiscal oversight over the management of the Scottish economy and would be unwilling to concede analogous oversight from Scotland over the fiscal and other policies of the UK.”

The First Minister needs to get serious, because the fact of the matter is that he plans even greater austerity in an independent Scotland. [Interruption.] Mike Russell thinks that that is silly, but it is his First Minister’s policy. The First Minister is planning a 3 per cent cut in corporation tax for bankers and big business. In the real world, that will cost us £385 million—which, according to the Scottish Parliament information centre, is equivalent to 7,000 jobs each and every year.

When the First Minister says that he does not like George Osborne’s economics, is not that because he thinks that the Chancellor of the Exchequer has not gone far enough, as his own plan is to cut taxes deeper than the Tories have done?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will deal with that. We have already published an analysis on the impact of having a competitive corporation tax policy in Scotland. Such a policy would increase the level of gross domestic product in Scotland by 1.4 per cent, which is a substantial amount, increase employment in Scotland by 27,000 jobs, and increase total tax revenues, because when we enlarge the economy we draw in more taxes across the tax base.

I return to the question of whether the Labour Party is now adopting Tory economic policies wholesale. Johann Lamont seems to deny that—as if it had not happened—but it has been the major development in politics in the past few weeks. The Labour Party high command in London has decided to adopt the Conservative Party’s economic budgetary approach, as has been said by Ed Miliband and Ed Balls. I appreciate that Johann Lamont was not consulted on that in advance, but for her not to know about it 10 days after it has happened seems to be totally extraordinary.

Let us be absolutely clear: after trying for a generation to find any significant body of opinion in Scottish society to agree with its policies, the Conservative Party has finally found its true ally in the Labour Party.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Obviously the First Minister does not understand his own policy.

With regard to the First Minister’s great radical policy, members will remember that Professor Joseph Stiglitz—the Nobel laureate and adviser to the First Minister—said:

“Some of you have been told that lowering tax rates on corporations will lead to more investment. The fact is that’s not true. It is just a gift to the corporations increasing inequality in our society.”

For the First Minister, the policy is a pretence and a game, but in the real world his plans involve cutting jobs in the Scottish economy at the very point when we need them more.

Only the First Minister could take £385 million out of the Scottish economy and say that it will not affect anything. The rest of us know that it will have a direct impact on services. He says that, over 20 years, his tax cut for big business would create 1,350 jobs a year and that the economy would grow by a massive 0.07 per cent a year. What will the cost of that be?

We would, over that period, have given bankers and big business a £7.7 billion tax break, which would cost the equivalent of 140,000 jobs. Only in the First Minister’s mind could that possibly be a credible policy. It is the kind of Reaganomics that even the Tories do not believe in.

Is it not the case—[Interruption.] Members should do the sums and work it out.

Is it not the case that Alex Salmond has said that Scots do not mind Margaret Thatcher’s economics, and that he wants to apply her economics to an independent Scotland?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
In reply to Johann Lamont’s question, I quote:

“We have cut corporation tax twice and I want to go further. We will reduce the tax again when we are able.”

That was Gordon Brown’s first speech to the Institute of Directors as Prime Minister. I know, of course, that Gordon Brown is only the leader of the Labour no campaign, while his friend and ally Alistair Darling—who, we should remember, wanted cuts that were “deeper and tougher” than those of Margaret Thatcher—is leading the Tory-Labour no campaign.

However, the figures that we have published on corporation tax show that there would be an increase in GDP, a significant increase of 27,000 jobs and an increase in total tax revenues. That is the information that we have presented to the public. If Johann Lamont has a different analysis, she should present that. However, if it is the case, as we have put forward—[Interruption.] We have Johann Lamont asking what the impact will be, but the Scottish Government has published an analysis. If the Labour Party has a different analysis, then let it publish it. However, if it is the case that the policy that we propose will result in an increase in employment, an increase in investment, an increase in GDP and an increase in total tax revenues, then even the Labour Party should think that it is an excellent idea.

On the extraordinary alliance that has developed between the Conservatives and the Labour Party, can I congratulate Johann Lamont on writing the chancellor’s speech? One of his key points yesterday was to bemoan and attack the “something for nothing society”. It is now not just that the Labour Party has adopted the Tories’ policy programme wholesale; the Tories are also adopting Johann Lamont’s language as they seek to persuade people that continued austerity in the United Kingdom economy is worth voting for.

The shift of the Labour Party on to Tory ground is not just a fundamental mistake; it is a lesson for the Scottish people that the unionist parties—Tory-Labour; Labour-Tory—offer nothing but continued austerity. What is offered by an independent Scotland is investment, progress and social justice in this society.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am proud to say that we, on this side of the chamber, do not agree with the First Minister when he wants to give “something for nothing” to big business at the expense of jobs. I have to say that 27,000 jobs pales into insignificance against the 140,000 jobs that would be lost. If we have a choice between the analysis of the First Minister—given his record with arithmetic—and the analyses of the Scottish Parliament information centre and Professor Stiglitz, I know what side I am on. The First Minister’s choice is one that would be deeply damaging to the people of this country.

The fact is that the First Minister’s credibility is like his European Union advice: he will go to the ends of the earth to protect it, but we all know that it does not exist. The man who backed the plans that broke the Royal Bank of Scotland now asks us to trust an economic vision—[Laughter.] I am glad that Government party members think that it is funny that the First Minister used his office to encourage Fred Goodwin to do precisely that. [Interruption.]

John Scott Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · Ayr
link
Order! Christine Grahame!

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister is asking us to trust an economic vision that looks more like an hallucination. However, we know that in private the First Minister and his colleagues know that a separate Scotland would have huge economic problems. In private, they even question the affordability of pensions, but they think that in public they can treat the people of Scotland like mugs. [Interruption.] Do they know that in the real world everybody understands that there is a real challenge and that we need to protect ordinary people? The First Minister and his gang behind him—

Members: Oh!

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
—are too interested in prosecuting a case that they have believed all their political lives to look at the consequences of their proposals for ordinary working people. [Interruption.]

John Scott Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · Ayr
link
Can we have a little bit of calm, please?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The fact is that all of them—all of them—in public, no matter what they say in private, think that they can treat the people of Scotland like mugs. No promise is too nonsensical and none need be costed. The fact of the matter is, from the First Minister and his Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth down—[Interruption.]

John Scott Con The Deputy Presiding Officer · Ayr
link
Order! Mr Stevenson!

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
They say anything, without ever doing the hard job of proving how those things would actually be delivered.

Is not it the case that the First Minister—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister’s back benchers are never going to say this to him, so let me tell him what ordinary people believe. The First Minister must be daft to believe that the people of Scotland might be daft enough to believe his independence plan.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Before Johann Lamont lost the plot entirely in that question, she said something that I want to pick up on. She feels that 27,000 jobs “pales into insignificance”, as she put it. That is a net jobs increase of 27,000 jobs. I want people in the chamber and people in Scotland to know that the Labour Party leader is now reduced to saying that an increase of 27,000 jobs is, in her words, insignificant. The people of Scotland believe that 27,000 jobs are of great significance at the present moment.

I know that it is embarrassing for the Labour Party to have it pointed out in Parliament that its London leadership has decided to adopt wholesale the policies of George Osborne, but let us remember that when Johann Lamont talked about a “something for nothing society”, she was not talking about corporation tax. She was talking about taking away people’s bus passes, about introducing tuition fees for students and about taking away free personal care. She was talking about reversing all the great social gains that this Parliament has delivered for the people of Scotland.

Finally, I note that Johann Lamont thinks that the folk behind me are a “gang”. I point out to her that, after the Aberdeen Donside by-election, this gang is bigger than her gang.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Creative Industries (Assistance) Questions · 6
  3. Regional Selective Assistance (Amazon) Questions · 6
  4. Measuring Wellbeing Questions · 6
  5. Transport (West Scotland) Questions · 8
  6. Town Centre Regeneration Questions · 4
  7. Road Repairs (Fife) Questions · 6
  8. Beaches and Marinas (Blue Flag Status) Questions · 4
  9. Home Energy Efficiency Programmes for Scotland Questions · 4
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
  11. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Spending Review 2015-16 First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. China (Direct Air Link) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Assaults on Police Officers First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Type 2 Diabetes First Minister’s Questions · 7
  16. First World War (Centenary) Members’ business · 13
  17. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  18. Climate Change (Report on Proposals and Policies) Statement · 31
  19. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  20. Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 52
  21. Scottish Independence Referendum (Franchise) Bill Bill debate · 23
  22. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  23. Decision Time Decision time · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.