Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Cremation

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 16 April 2013 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 12 contributions · 5 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link


1. To ask the Scottish Government whether it will update legislation and guidance to ensure that ashes are always treated appropriately following cremation. (S4T-00311)

Michael Matheson SNP The Minister for Public Health · Falkirk West
link
Losing a loved one is a painful experience and to grieve their loss means, during the mix of joy and agony, remembering their life and living with the memory of them. When the loss is of a child, the pain and grief are amplified because of the futility of the passing of a life never fully lived.

I believe that the recent cases of the treatment of ashes of very young children demonstrate that the existing legislation and current industry practice are falling short of what the public deserve. Today, I announce that I am establishing an independent commission to examine the policies and practices that are in place for handling ashes and cremated remains. The commission will be tasked with producing recommendations before the end of this year to inform new legislation and guidance on cremation and burials. Central to the new legislation will be that it must ensure a consistent approach to the treatment of ashes throughout Scotland and that families are treated sensitively and given the support and information that they need.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link
I sincerely thank the minister for that reply. I am sure that the many people who have contacted me and others will sincerely thank him also, particularly given that the legislation that underpins much of this is more than 100 years old.

Does the minister agree that local authorities such as Glasgow City Council must not shy away from their responsibility to investigate any case that is brought to them and give answers to parents? Will the Scottish Government provide best practice guidance to local authorities on the conduct of their investigations, and will the minister ask the national health service to co-operate with any local investigations?

Michael Matheson SNP The Minister for Public Health · Falkirk West
link
I agree. It is important that local authorities and other owners of crematoria are accountable for their historical practice. They must respond to any complaints or concerns that are raised by individuals or families, and they should duly investigate those complaints or concerns.

I confirm that the Government will provide advice and information to local authorities around best practice in undertaking such investigations or any audits that may be required as a result of complaints that they have received. I also confirm that the national health service will comply fully with any local investigation that takes place.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link
I have been making representations on the issue to Glasgow City Council since I was contacted by a constituent, and I welcome the minister’s comments about establishing a commission to consider the legislative situation.

I agree that each local authority needs to examine its practices and be clear that the information has been provided to individuals who have concerns. Does the minister share my view that part of people’s concern relates to the fact that different practices have been followed in different parts of the country and that, for that reason, national co-ordination is needed regarding the investigation of complaints as well as regarding the consideration of any legislative proposals?

Michael Matheson SNP The Minister for Public Health · Falkirk West
link
I recognise the point that the member raises, particularly in relation to the recent case in Glasgow that was highlighted by my colleague Nicola Sturgeon on behalf of her constituent, who raised an issue of concern that I believe Glasgow City Council should investigate. The City of Edinburgh Council has set out a very good way in which that type of investigation can be undertaken independently to inform the council of any issues that may have arisen through its practice. I encourage Glasgow City Council to reflect on the measures that are being taken by the City of Edinburgh Council in considering the approach that it could take to investigating the particular case that has been highlighted by Nicola Sturgeon.

The member talked about inconsistency in practice, which is an issue that I have concerns about. It is important that there is consistency in approach regarding how ashes from the cremation process are handled for young children. I am anxious to ensure that the commission is able to look at what practice has given rise to the inconsistency that has occurred in different local authority areas as well as, potentially, private crematoria, so that it can make recommendations that will allow us to produce legislation and guidance to ensure that a consistent approach is taken across the country.

Mark McDonald SNP North East Scotland
link
I welcome the minister’s response to Sandra White’s question and the establishment of the commission. He will be aware of concerns that have been raised around the policies that are in place at Aberdeen crematorium. The situation has led to the parents of babies who are born asleep and those who have miscarried becoming confused and uncertain whether they might have been entitled to receive ashes following cremation, and such uncertainty has reopened grief for many. Does the minister anticipate the commission making clear recommendations for situations in which the return of ashes is not possible that would provide clarity and, in many cases, closure for parents?

Michael Matheson SNP The Minister for Public Health · Falkirk West
link
One of the commission’s roles will be to ensure that there is consistency in the information that is provided to families on whether ashes may be available or are not available at that particular point. I understand that there are a number of technical issues that may affect whether ashes are available, but it is important that families are informed of that at the very start of the process, that the process is transparent, and that families can have confidence in it. One role that the commission will have is to explore the different practices and policies that have been taken forward in different crematoria in the country in order to ensure that there is a consistent approach and consistency in the information that is provided to parents at that time.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link
The minister referred to the City of Edinburgh Council investigation as a good model of how things could work. I remind the minister that that investigation is not properly under way yet, and that it cannot proceed until the police have concluded their investigations.

I have eight constituents whose lives are currently devastated by the revelations at Mortonhall. They want answers, justice and a public inquiry. Why is the minister not willing to have a public inquiry? I welcome his announcement, but those parents will take some comfort from an assurance from the minister that their voices will be heard by the commission and specifically that it will be able to call witnesses and that they will be asked to give answers.

Michael Matheson SNP The Minister for Public Health · Falkirk West
link
It is important to remember that the police investigation is the reason that the City of Edinburgh Council’s investigation has not been able to take the full range of evidence that it would have liked to take at this stage. It is important that that due process is recognised, because of the potential for using evidence at a later stage, should any criminal prosecutions take place.

I understand that Dame Elish Angiolini and her team have undertaken preliminary work to look at issues that they can establish at an early stage and which do not impinge on the police investigation. Dame Elish Angiolini’s independence in undertaking that investigation into the historical practices at Mortonhall provides a good model that other local authorities, such as Glasgow City Council, could use in considering issues of concern that have been raised.

The purpose of the commission is to look at what practices and policies gave rise to the situation occurring in the first place. Its purpose is to establish that and then look at what measures are necessary to ensure that the situation does not happen again and that a consistent approach is taken across all our crematoria in Scotland, and by those in the NHS who may be involved in the process and those in the funeral care industry. It is important that we have a consistent approach and that we look at involving a number of individuals who can provide the support and advice that are necessary to take that forward.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link
I welcome that answer, but the minister did not respond to the point about how he will ensure that parents’ voices are heard in the process.

Michael Matheson SNP The Minister for Public Health · Falkirk West
link
I said that I intend to have commission members who can help to ensure that the process includes as many individuals as possible in considering what practice issues need to be addressed with any future legislation. I will consider who can be on the commission and who could represent parents and their interests when it comes to appointing the commission.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Business Motion Business motions · 2
  3. Cremation Questions · 12
  4. “Shaping Scotland’s Court Services” Questions · 16
  5. Universal Services Debate · 176
  6. Decision Time Decision time · 12
  7. Save Wemyss Ancient Caves Society Members’ business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.