1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01192)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 4
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
18 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01192)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Ruth Davidson—I mean Johann Lamont.
In June 2011, the Scottish Government told us that only 3 per cent of patients had to wait more than nine weeks for an in-patient appointment. The truth was not 3 per cent, but 23 per cent—that is not three out of 100, but one out of four patients waiting. Why did the Scottish Government so mislead patients in need of hospital treatment in that way?
The waiting lists have always had areas of social and medical unavailability. That is part and parcel—[Interruption.]
I hear some disgruntlement from the Labour benches. As members will remember, one of this Government’s first acts was to abolish the availability status code that was established under Labour. That represented 33 per cent of the in-patient waiting list. Presumably, at that time, the Labour Party thought that there were reasons for that figure being 33 per cent. Therefore, Johann Lamont must accept that the 23 per cent figure—which I am quite happy to go into detail about—is, by definition, 10 per cent less than the figure that was inherited from the Labour Party.
I hear some disgruntlement from the Labour benches. As members will remember, one of this Government’s first acts was to abolish the availability status code that was established under Labour. That represented 33 per cent of the in-patient waiting list. Presumably, at that time, the Labour Party thought that there were reasons for that figure being 33 per cent. Therefore, Johann Lamont must accept that the 23 per cent figure—which I am quite happy to go into detail about—is, by definition, 10 per cent less than the figure that was inherited from the Labour Party.
The people of Scotland might expect the First Minister to take what I said a little more seriously. It is not good enough for him to come here week after week and to say—this is his new defence—“It wasnae just me who did it.” The fact is that the figures represent real people waiting for real help from the national health service. However, the First Minister’s response is about something entirely different—his is a political game, which is not the key issue.
If the First Minister took his job seriously, he would know that in March 2010 the then health secretary, Nicola Sturgeon, said:
“no one—no one—is on a hidden waiting list.”
Even after we found out that NHS Lothian was fiddling the figures, her replacement, Alex Neil, told the Parliament last December that
“the waiting times that are published by boards are reliable and accurate.”—[Official Report, 20 December 2012; c 15052]
The systems that Nicola Sturgeon and Alex Neil used to make those claims are described by the Royal College of Nursing as
“inadequate for the job and ... letting patients down, time and again”
Is not the truth that, far from abolishing hidden waiting lists, Nicola Sturgeon—for her own political convenience—reinvented and reinforced them?
If the First Minister took his job seriously, he would know that in March 2010 the then health secretary, Nicola Sturgeon, said:
“no one—no one—is on a hidden waiting list.”
Even after we found out that NHS Lothian was fiddling the figures, her replacement, Alex Neil, told the Parliament last December that
“the waiting times that are published by boards are reliable and accurate.”—[Official Report, 20 December 2012; c 15052]
The systems that Nicola Sturgeon and Alex Neil used to make those claims are described by the Royal College of Nursing as
“inadequate for the job and ... letting patients down, time and again”
Is not the truth that, far from abolishing hidden waiting lists, Nicola Sturgeon—for her own political convenience—reinvented and reinforced them?
The social unavailability figures are published so, by definition, they cannot be hidden. [Interruption.] Published figures cannot be hidden.
Johann Lamont says that I am talking about two different things. I am not: I am talking about exactly the same thing. The availability status code was a hidden waiting list because people were placed on that code—33 per cent of people on in-patient waiting lists—and then had no patient guarantee for their pathway through the health service.
There are a variety of reasons why people will not have operations at a particular time. They might have a medical condition that prevents them from having an operation, such as high blood pressure or a heart condition, or they could be pregnant, which would make a medical procedure inadvisable. Those reasons are in the report, if indeed Labour members have read it.
The report points to the fact that the information technology systems in the health service are not robust enough to give the proper examination across the health boards. That is exactly why the IT systems are being enhanced and improved. Therefore, it is not just a tale of two Governments. It is a tale of changing a system that was clearly a hidden waiting list, which affected 33 per cent of patients; of constant improvement to get the IT systems into a position that enables us to have robust figures; and of making the changes that are required so that patients round Scotland can have confidence in the figures. That shows that the Government is facing the issues, as opposed to the position that we inherited, in which people were dumped on the availability status code and left there ad infinitum.
Johann Lamont says that I am talking about two different things. I am not: I am talking about exactly the same thing. The availability status code was a hidden waiting list because people were placed on that code—33 per cent of people on in-patient waiting lists—and then had no patient guarantee for their pathway through the health service.
There are a variety of reasons why people will not have operations at a particular time. They might have a medical condition that prevents them from having an operation, such as high blood pressure or a heart condition, or they could be pregnant, which would make a medical procedure inadvisable. Those reasons are in the report, if indeed Labour members have read it.
The report points to the fact that the information technology systems in the health service are not robust enough to give the proper examination across the health boards. That is exactly why the IT systems are being enhanced and improved. Therefore, it is not just a tale of two Governments. It is a tale of changing a system that was clearly a hidden waiting list, which affected 33 per cent of patients; of constant improvement to get the IT systems into a position that enables us to have robust figures; and of making the changes that are required so that patients round Scotland can have confidence in the figures. That shows that the Government is facing the issues, as opposed to the position that we inherited, in which people were dumped on the availability status code and left there ad infinitum.
The First Minister’s first defence is that there is nothing wrong; his second defence is, “A big bad computer did it and ran away”; and then he says, “However, we are changing things.” If he does not understand what the problem is, I am bemused about how he can work out what the changes should be.
Let me make it simple for the First Minister. In June 2011, Nicola Sturgeon was given a set of figures that said that only 3 per cent of patients waited for more than nine weeks for hospital treatment when the truth was that it was 23 per cent. At the same time, she was given figures that said that the number of people who were too busy to go to get the treatment that they needed had tripled. She was told that one Scot in three on waiting lists had said that they were too busy to be cured.
Nicola Sturgeon knew what was happening. Did she not have the wit to notice that waiting lists were being falsified or did it simply suit her purpose?
Let me make it simple for the First Minister. In June 2011, Nicola Sturgeon was given a set of figures that said that only 3 per cent of patients waited for more than nine weeks for hospital treatment when the truth was that it was 23 per cent. At the same time, she was given figures that said that the number of people who were too busy to go to get the treatment that they needed had tripled. She was told that one Scot in three on waiting lists had said that they were too busy to be cured.
Nicola Sturgeon knew what was happening. Did she not have the wit to notice that waiting lists were being falsified or did it simply suit her purpose?
Let us have a look at why patients might not be able to have their operation in the timescale of a waiting list. [Laughter.] Okay, let us point to page 30 of the report. Audit Scotland recognised that medical unavailability
“has remained fairly constant … at around six to eight per cent over recent years”.
There is an element, which has been consistent over recent years, of people who, for medical reasons, are not in a position to have their procedure within the waiting time. That is medical unavailability. There is also a range of reasons why people might not want to have an operation at a specific time, such as work reasons or because they are on holiday. That is also perfectly legitimate.
The report points to the IT systems not being robust enough to provide that examination. That is the point of the report. If we have a problem with our information technology systems, is it not a good idea to introduce the TrakCare system to sort it out? Would it be preferable to leave it alone, as the Labour Party did, and not improve these things in the health service?
We can point to areas that are not about social or medical unavailability. We know that 88 per cent of patients are satisfied with the waiting times in the national health service. Although 88 per cent is not 100 per cent and means that the national health service is not perfect, it is a very high figure indeed. That means that, although the national health service is not perfect, it is an outstanding health service and every member in the chamber should be proud of the work that it does.
“has remained fairly constant … at around six to eight per cent over recent years”.
There is an element, which has been consistent over recent years, of people who, for medical reasons, are not in a position to have their procedure within the waiting time. That is medical unavailability. There is also a range of reasons why people might not want to have an operation at a specific time, such as work reasons or because they are on holiday. That is also perfectly legitimate.
The report points to the IT systems not being robust enough to provide that examination. That is the point of the report. If we have a problem with our information technology systems, is it not a good idea to introduce the TrakCare system to sort it out? Would it be preferable to leave it alone, as the Labour Party did, and not improve these things in the health service?
We can point to areas that are not about social or medical unavailability. We know that 88 per cent of patients are satisfied with the waiting times in the national health service. Although 88 per cent is not 100 per cent and means that the national health service is not perfect, it is a very high figure indeed. That means that, although the national health service is not perfect, it is an outstanding health service and every member in the chamber should be proud of the work that it does.
It is precisely because of the importance of the national health service that we deserve better than a Government that looks at health figures in order to gain political advantage rather than to serve the interests of patients. In December, Alex Neil said that there was nothing wrong. Today, the First Minister again says that there is nothing wrong. The rest of the world knows that the figures were manipulated to avoid the Government having to confront the failures in its own policy.
Of course, one policy, one code and one belief runs through everything at the heart of the Government: the nationalists think that, whatever the truth, if they say something often enough, they can fool the people of Scotland into believing it. [Interruption.]
Of course, one policy, one code and one belief runs through everything at the heart of the Government: the nationalists think that, whatever the truth, if they say something often enough, they can fool the people of Scotland into believing it. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Alex Salmond believed that, if he compared his protégé Nicola Sturgeon to Nye Bevan often enough, we would see her in the same light. I have to tell members that Nye Bevan never put press releases above patients. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
We have found out from Audit Scotland that patients come second to propaganda with this Government. Someone should tell Nicola Sturgeon that false statistics and public perceptions do not cure patients, and they do not win referendums either.
It has been said that, in politics—[Interruption.] It has been said that, in politics, there are two types of health ministers: failures and those who get out in time. Today, is not the truth laid bare that, despite the spin, Nicola Sturgeon did not get out in time?
It has been said that, in politics—[Interruption.] It has been said that, in politics, there are two types of health ministers: failures and those who get out in time. Today, is not the truth laid bare that, despite the spin, Nicola Sturgeon did not get out in time?
I was going to say that there are three types of health minister. There was Andy Kerr, who tried to close accident and emergency wards before we sorted that out.
Let us address the issue. First, the Audit Scotland report examined 273,000 transactions and the internal health board audits examined a further 200,000 transactions. The conclusion was:
“Our sampling found a small number of instances in which unavailability codes were used inappropriately.”
Only a small number of such instances were found out of the vast number of transactions that were investigated.
I have already pointed out the level of patient satisfaction with the health service and waiting times—
Let us address the issue. First, the Audit Scotland report examined 273,000 transactions and the internal health board audits examined a further 200,000 transactions. The conclusion was:
“Our sampling found a small number of instances in which unavailability codes were used inappropriately.”
Only a small number of such instances were found out of the vast number of transactions that were investigated.
I have already pointed out the level of patient satisfaction with the health service and waiting times—
link
That does not make a waiting time guarantee.
Jackie Baillie says that that disnae matter; that is what matters. That is the point.
We can also measure how the health service is doing above and beyond the issue of social unavailability. Since 2008, the median time wait for treatment in Scotland—that is the mid-point in waiting times, which includes those who have been marked as medically or socially unavailable—reduced from 40 days to 32 days. That tells us that there has been an improvement in the national health service over that period.
In reading out her prepared question, Johann Lamont gave the game away. We were told that this Government is obsessed by the politics. This issue is not about the health service; it is all about the Labour Party trying to get Nicola Sturgeon. Did the statement that it released say, “We want improvement in the health service; we want the computer system to be fast-tracked”? No. It said, “Sturgeon knew of hidden waiting lists.” That is the point. Nicola Sturgeon knew of Labour’s hidden waiting lists, which is why she changed things as health secretary.
Jackie Baillie said that when it came to hospital-acquired infection, Scotland was the “superbug capital of Europe”, until she found out that the relevant figures were from 2006, when the Labour Party was in office. The relevance of that is that it typifies Labour’s attitude to the NHS, which is not about improving the service or being jointly proud of the greatest public service in our country, but is about making demeaning political attacks on health secretaries. Instead of coming to the chamber to ask about the improvements that must take place, Labour accuses the Government. My goodness me. Is the Labour leader not aware of the unintentional comedy in her question over the most serious issue of all—the NHS? The NHS is not without failings or faults, but it is an outstanding health service, of which every one of us should be proud.
We can also measure how the health service is doing above and beyond the issue of social unavailability. Since 2008, the median time wait for treatment in Scotland—that is the mid-point in waiting times, which includes those who have been marked as medically or socially unavailable—reduced from 40 days to 32 days. That tells us that there has been an improvement in the national health service over that period.
In reading out her prepared question, Johann Lamont gave the game away. We were told that this Government is obsessed by the politics. This issue is not about the health service; it is all about the Labour Party trying to get Nicola Sturgeon. Did the statement that it released say, “We want improvement in the health service; we want the computer system to be fast-tracked”? No. It said, “Sturgeon knew of hidden waiting lists.” That is the point. Nicola Sturgeon knew of Labour’s hidden waiting lists, which is why she changed things as health secretary.
Jackie Baillie said that when it came to hospital-acquired infection, Scotland was the “superbug capital of Europe”, until she found out that the relevant figures were from 2006, when the Labour Party was in office. The relevance of that is that it typifies Labour’s attitude to the NHS, which is not about improving the service or being jointly proud of the greatest public service in our country, but is about making demeaning political attacks on health secretaries. Instead of coming to the chamber to ask about the improvements that must take place, Labour accuses the Government. My goodness me. Is the Labour leader not aware of the unintentional comedy in her question over the most serious issue of all—the NHS? The NHS is not without failings or faults, but it is an outstanding health service, of which every one of us should be proud.
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Question 2, Ruth Davidson.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 21 Feb 2013 →- Local Produce Questions · 4
- Scottish Police Authority Questions · 6
- School Closures Questions · 7
- Child Protection (Alleged Sexual Abuse) Questions · 4
- Access to Further Education (Fife) Questions · 4
- Passport System Questions · 6
- Renewables Target 2020 Questions · 10
- Flood Protection (North East Scotland) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- BBC Scotland (Redundancies) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Obesity First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Speed Limits (Heavy Goods Vehicles) Members’ business · 8
- “Management of patients on NHS waiting lists” Statement · 34
- Renewable Energy Targets Debate · 83
- Scottish Parliamentary Contributory Pension Fund (Trustees) Debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.