1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01206)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 2
- Richard Lyle SNP 1
The record
15 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01206)
I will be looking at the situation in Raasay, because I was asked at First Minister’s question time last week what could be done about the issue of sporting rights on the island. I am happy to inform the Parliament that the Minister for Environment and Climate Change, Paul Wheelhouse, spoke to the crofters of Raasay this morning to inform them that he has been able to extend their lease for sporting rights on the island for another year. The contract that was awarded to South Ayrshire Stalking has been withdrawn by mutual consent—we welcome its positive attitude to resolving the issue. Mr Wheelhouse will meet community representatives on the island tomorrow to discuss the matter and underline the Government’s continued support for furthering the land reform agenda, including the championing of community management and ownership wherever possible.
I thank the First Minister for that information. We will want to know, of course, what will happen in a year’s time. The decision was one of the most astonishing by any minister in this Parliament since 1999. If the First Minister is making a commitment to sort it, then of course we are very grateful to him.
The latest figures on waiting times in accident and emergency units in Scotland show that the guarantee of treatment within four hours is being breached the length and breadth of the country. Does the First Minister agree with Margaret Watt, chair of the Scotland Patients Association, that the latest figures for accident and emergency waiting times are shocking?
The latest figures on waiting times in accident and emergency units in Scotland show that the guarantee of treatment within four hours is being breached the length and breadth of the country. Does the First Minister agree with Margaret Watt, chair of the Scotland Patients Association, that the latest figures for accident and emergency waiting times are shocking?
There is no doubt that this winter has been a challenging time for accident and emergency units across Scotland. The reasons for that are well known and well understood, being norovirus and the incidence of respiratory infections that have resulted in hospitalisation.
The plan announced by the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing to switch £50 million of new investment into accident and emergency departments is a substantial effort to ensure that our accident and emergency units around Scotland are able to cope with extreme pressures. That decision by the health secretary and the welcoming response that it has had across the health service should also be welcomed across the chamber.
The plan announced by the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing to switch £50 million of new investment into accident and emergency departments is a substantial effort to ensure that our accident and emergency units around Scotland are able to cope with extreme pressures. That decision by the health secretary and the welcoming response that it has had across the health service should also be welcomed across the chamber.
We know that when the First Minister abandons his usual bluster for his wee quiet voice and calls for all of us across the Parliament to be concerned, the reality of what the Scottish National Party is presiding over must be absolutely appalling. We know that we have to plan for winter. If £50 million was available, why was it not made available earlier, rather than in response to a crisis?
What the First Minister says is simply not good enough. Members will recall that we were told by Alex Neil that the case of John McGarrity, the 84-year-old man who spent eight hours on a hospital trolley after being rushed to hospital with a chest infection, was not a true reflection of the national health service under the SNP. In one way he was right. It turns out that last December alone more than 300 John McGarritys waited even longer than eight hours. The reason for a four-hour waiting target for A and E treatment was to guarantee quality care to those patients in the greatest need. Can the First Minister tell me, when was the last time that the four-hour target was met for Scotland as a whole?
What the First Minister says is simply not good enough. Members will recall that we were told by Alex Neil that the case of John McGarrity, the 84-year-old man who spent eight hours on a hospital trolley after being rushed to hospital with a chest infection, was not a true reflection of the national health service under the SNP. In one way he was right. It turns out that last December alone more than 300 John McGarritys waited even longer than eight hours. The reason for a four-hour waiting target for A and E treatment was to guarantee quality care to those patients in the greatest need. Can the First Minister tell me, when was the last time that the four-hour target was met for Scotland as a whole?
The monthly figures on accident and emergency have been substantially improving over the period. Of course, meeting the four-hour waiting-time target, in terms of the percentage, has been increasing as part of the general move towards improvement in the health service.
The reason why I respond to issues such as the health service in the way that I do is that they are extremely serious issues. The health service is a subject, particularly in terms of patient care, that should be treated in that manner. There are points to make, of course, about the support that this Government has given to the health service. We have guaranteed the health service—and ring fenced—its resource funding. It was not clear that the Labour Party would do that, either in 2007 or, indeed, in the run-up to the 2011 election. If I remember correctly, the number of consultants in accident and emergency units across Scotland has doubled over the past few years. However, it is quite clear from the winter pressures on the health service over the past few months that the accident and emergency units must be further strengthened to meet such strong conditions, which is exactly what the health secretary has done.
It is significant that that positive action, which I think will mean the recruitment of another 200 staff in accident and emergency units around Scotland, has been broadly welcomed across the country as a serious response to a serious issue. I hope that it can also be welcomed across this chamber, since it affects the constituents of each and every one of us.
The reason why I respond to issues such as the health service in the way that I do is that they are extremely serious issues. The health service is a subject, particularly in terms of patient care, that should be treated in that manner. There are points to make, of course, about the support that this Government has given to the health service. We have guaranteed the health service—and ring fenced—its resource funding. It was not clear that the Labour Party would do that, either in 2007 or, indeed, in the run-up to the 2011 election. If I remember correctly, the number of consultants in accident and emergency units across Scotland has doubled over the past few years. However, it is quite clear from the winter pressures on the health service over the past few months that the accident and emergency units must be further strengthened to meet such strong conditions, which is exactly what the health secretary has done.
It is significant that that positive action, which I think will mean the recruitment of another 200 staff in accident and emergency units around Scotland, has been broadly welcomed across the country as a serious response to a serious issue. I hope that it can also be welcomed across this chamber, since it affects the constituents of each and every one of us.
There have been six First Minister’s question times since January this year. I can only assume that, on the other four occasions on which the First Minister shouted and bawled in defence of his NHS policy, he was not being serious about the challenges that were put to him.
This is a really serious matter. What do you do in Government when reality confronts you? The last thing that you do—as we have seen again just now—is retreat to debating points rather than focus on what has happened to people. [Interruption.]
This is a really serious matter. What do you do in Government when reality confronts you? The last thing that you do—as we have seen again just now—is retreat to debating points rather than focus on what has happened to people. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The First Minister is not serious if he continues to contend that the problem is that it is winter and that the miraculous appearance of £50 million will solve the problem. He has not listened to staff and he has not listened to patients.
The First Minister did not answer the question, either. It would appear that he either has not read his own report or does not want to admit the answer in the chamber. The report says that
“the last time compliance was met across Scotland was September 2009.”
That is more than three years of letting patients down at one of the most vulnerable times in their lives.
Yesterday, the Auditor General told us that Nicola Sturgeon ignored warning signs when it came to waiting times. Did she also choose to ignore the warning signs about A and E?
The First Minister did not answer the question, either. It would appear that he either has not read his own report or does not want to admit the answer in the chamber. The report says that
“the last time compliance was met across Scotland was September 2009.”
That is more than three years of letting patients down at one of the most vulnerable times in their lives.
Yesterday, the Auditor General told us that Nicola Sturgeon ignored warning signs when it came to waiting times. Did she also choose to ignore the warning signs about A and E?
What Johann Lamont forgets is that the target has been increasing throughout the past four to five years as a result of the targets of continuous improvement in the health service. That has to be taken into account when measuring the figures. By any reasonable estimation, the response that the health secretary has made is a substantial response to prepare for winter pressures and to reinforce accident and emergency units across Scotland.
I disagree with Johann Lamont about the evidence of the Auditor General. What I saw the Auditor General say at the Public Audit Committee yesterday was:
“We have not found evidence of manipulation at all.”
[Interruption.] I am quoting the Auditor General. That is in direct contrast to the Labour Party’s claims to the contrary over the past few months. Now, I know that, from the Labour Party point of view, it must be inconvenient that the Auditor General said that at the Public Audit Committee yesterday, but nonetheless she did.
I am sure that Johann Lamont will be the first to acknowledge the range of statistics that were released on Tuesday 26 February, which showed that 90.9 per cent of patients were seen and treated within 18 weeks from initial referral to the start of treatment. Out of 58,070 patients, only seven missed their 12-week treatment time guarantee. That means that 99.99 per cent were treated within the guaranteed time.
Let us have an acknowledgement that the health service, even under the significant pressures on it this winter, is performing extremely well across a range of measures. That does not mean that it is perfect or that it does not make mistakes—it can make mistakes, like any human organisation—but the basis of our treatment of the health service should be that of a public service that is performing extremely well.
I disagree with Johann Lamont about the evidence of the Auditor General. What I saw the Auditor General say at the Public Audit Committee yesterday was:
“We have not found evidence of manipulation at all.”
[Interruption.] I am quoting the Auditor General. That is in direct contrast to the Labour Party’s claims to the contrary over the past few months. Now, I know that, from the Labour Party point of view, it must be inconvenient that the Auditor General said that at the Public Audit Committee yesterday, but nonetheless she did.
I am sure that Johann Lamont will be the first to acknowledge the range of statistics that were released on Tuesday 26 February, which showed that 90.9 per cent of patients were seen and treated within 18 weeks from initial referral to the start of treatment. Out of 58,070 patients, only seven missed their 12-week treatment time guarantee. That means that 99.99 per cent were treated within the guaranteed time.
Let us have an acknowledgement that the health service, even under the significant pressures on it this winter, is performing extremely well across a range of measures. That does not mean that it is perfect or that it does not make mistakes—it can make mistakes, like any human organisation—but the basis of our treatment of the health service should be that of a public service that is performing extremely well.
Whether the First Minister says it in a quiet voice or a loud voice, the same problem remains: he is entirely in denial about what is happening in the national health service. He may come and say, “Yes, I hear what you say, but actually everything is fantastic”, but that is not the lived reality of people in hospitals the length and breadth of Scotland and it is not what his staff in the NHS are telling him.
Does the First Minister not realise how ridiculous he sounds, protecting his former health secretary and defending his record in this way? Apparently, to be like Nye Bevan, you have to get an amber warning from Audit Scotland, mislead the country on waiting times and ignore the warning signs of failing accident and emergency wards that are struggling to cope.
Does the First Minister not realise that this is about policy, not slogans? It is not about him winning or losing votes but about saving people’s lives. Does he not see that, by denying the truth—
Does the First Minister not realise how ridiculous he sounds, protecting his former health secretary and defending his record in this way? Apparently, to be like Nye Bevan, you have to get an amber warning from Audit Scotland, mislead the country on waiting times and ignore the warning signs of failing accident and emergency wards that are struggling to cope.
Does the First Minister not realise that this is about policy, not slogans? It is not about him winning or losing votes but about saving people’s lives. Does he not see that, by denying the truth—
That is not true.
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Does the First Minister not see that, by denying the truth of the scale of the problem, he is denying the sick and the vulnerable the treatment that they so desperately need?
Obviously, if Johann Lamont reads out a pre-prepared question, she cannot take account of the answers that she has been given in response to the previous three questions. Because of the nature of the issue I have tried to deal with it seriously. By any estimation, the health secretary’s response to the pressures on accident and emergency departments is serious indeed.
On the overall position and whether or not the NHS is improving on its treatment of patients, the median—the mid-point, or the average, in that sense—waiting time for all patients, including people who are medically and socially unavailable, has reduced from 40 to 32 days since 2008. The average, or median, across the waiting list has improved—that is a fact from the figures. That indicates a health service that has been responding extremely well.
We also know a number of other things. This Government strives to protect the revenue budget of the health services and it has done so. That is not an uncontroversial political move and it was not supported by the Labour Party in 2007 or in the run-up to the 2011 election. The proof of the pudding is, of course, to look at the only place remaining in these islands where the Labour Party is in administration, which is Wales. In Wales, Labour has not protected the health service’s revenue budget because of the pressures that that Administration has been under as a result of the cuts from London. Therefore, it is instructive to look at the comparisons between Scotland and Wales on the statistics that are being produced. From initial referral, 90.9 per cent of patients in Scotland were treated within 18 weeks. In Wales, under Labour, where there is a 26-week target, 81.3 per cent of patients were treated within that target.
I make the point to the Labour Party that this Government has pledged to protect the revenue budget of the health service. The performance of the health service for all patients has, undoubtedly, been increasing over the past few years. The Labour Party did not come to the recent budget negotiations with any plan to increase the funding of the health service. Indeed, the consequence of its plan on housing—if it can be called a plan—would be to reduce funding for other key public services.
I am entitled to say that this Government has protected, under the most extreme public finance circumstances, the resource provision of the health service. The overall performance of the health service has undoubtedly been improving—the health service is not perfect and makes mistakes, as any human organisation does—and we have a health secretary who has shifted key resources into accident and emergency to deal with the winter crisis. That is an indication of a Government that defends the most crucial public service in Scotland, and defends it to the absolute utmost.
On the overall position and whether or not the NHS is improving on its treatment of patients, the median—the mid-point, or the average, in that sense—waiting time for all patients, including people who are medically and socially unavailable, has reduced from 40 to 32 days since 2008. The average, or median, across the waiting list has improved—that is a fact from the figures. That indicates a health service that has been responding extremely well.
We also know a number of other things. This Government strives to protect the revenue budget of the health services and it has done so. That is not an uncontroversial political move and it was not supported by the Labour Party in 2007 or in the run-up to the 2011 election. The proof of the pudding is, of course, to look at the only place remaining in these islands where the Labour Party is in administration, which is Wales. In Wales, Labour has not protected the health service’s revenue budget because of the pressures that that Administration has been under as a result of the cuts from London. Therefore, it is instructive to look at the comparisons between Scotland and Wales on the statistics that are being produced. From initial referral, 90.9 per cent of patients in Scotland were treated within 18 weeks. In Wales, under Labour, where there is a 26-week target, 81.3 per cent of patients were treated within that target.
I make the point to the Labour Party that this Government has pledged to protect the revenue budget of the health service. The performance of the health service for all patients has, undoubtedly, been increasing over the past few years. The Labour Party did not come to the recent budget negotiations with any plan to increase the funding of the health service. Indeed, the consequence of its plan on housing—if it can be called a plan—would be to reduce funding for other key public services.
I am entitled to say that this Government has protected, under the most extreme public finance circumstances, the resource provision of the health service. The overall performance of the health service has undoubtedly been improving—the health service is not perfect and makes mistakes, as any human organisation does—and we have a health secretary who has shifted key resources into accident and emergency to deal with the winter crisis. That is an indication of a Government that defends the most crucial public service in Scotland, and defends it to the absolute utmost.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 28 Feb 2013 →- Homecoming 2014 Questions · 6
- Housing Associations (Bedroom Tax) Questions · 7
- Air Services (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 8
- Number Plate Cloning Fraud Questions · 4
- Food Banks Questions · 6
- Post-mortems (West of Scotland) Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Medical Negligence Claims) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Economy (Downgrading of Bond Rating) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Education (New National Qualifications) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Economy (North Sea Oil Investment) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Enough Food for Everyone If Campaign Members’ business · 9
- Food Safety Body Statement · 30
- Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 45
- Crime and Courts Bill Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.