Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 21 March 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 23 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

23 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of this hugely historic day. (S4F-01266)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will be making a parliamentary statement on Scotland’s referendum, which will include the date on which the people of Scotland will be able to decide their own future.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
This week, John Swinney defied the First Minister in a key policy: he actually answered a question. John Swinney said that a separate Scotland would consider no currency option other than the pound sterling. That would, of course, put Scotland in a very weak negotiating position with the rest of the United Kingdom and the Bank of England if there was a yes vote, with nowhere else to go.

Presiding Officer, you will know that I am an eternal optimist, and we all live in hope. [Interruption.] In fact, I am such an optimist that I even harbour the hope that, at some point, a Scottish National Party back bencher will do something other than shout to order. [Interruption.] Will the First Minister—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Will the First Minister tell the people of Scotland what his plan B is if the deal that the Bank of England offers is bad for the country?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I think that Johann Lamont describing herself as “an eternal optimist” constitutes misleading the chamber. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont has many outstanding qualities, but she is not a ray of sunshine when she comes before us.

As Johann Lamont should well know, the Government’s policy on a sterling area for an independent Scotland was set out in huge detail by the fiscal commission. We discussed the matter last week, and the policy has not changed over the past week. That is the policy, which has been hugely considered. We think that it is the best option for Scotland, and I suggest that, at last, Johann Lamont should read the report and try to digest what it says.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
It is the First Minister who has form on misleading the chamber, not me. True to form, he did not, of course, answer the question that was asked.

I agree with the First Minister that George Osborne is bad for Scotland, but I just do not understand why he thinks that George Osborne would be good to Scotland if we left the United Kingdom.

Let us look at the First Minister’s negotiating skills. We should remember that, when Westminster offered to give him the power to hold the referendum, he said that that was an attack on Scottish democracy. He then backed down on having his own electoral commission, he backed down on having a second question, and he backed down on spending limits. He then called the climbdown “the historic Edinburgh agreement”.

It is clear that the First Minister has shown his hand to George Osborne. Will he now tell the people what the Bank of England would control if there was a separate Scotland?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I think that Johann Lamont being depressing before the event—in suggesting that we could not organise the referendum, that there would not be an agreement, and that there would be all sorts of difficulties—is part of her nature. However, on being depressing after the event, the Edinburgh agreement is agreed, we are about to announce the referendum bill and the date of the referendum, and Scotland’s referendum will have the highest standards of democratic legitimacy in international terms. What possible justification does the Labour Party have for being negative about the agreement and what we are about to announce?

I know that it must be an awful disappointment to the Labour Party that none of the extraordinary difficulties that it forecast has come to pass, but, on this day, let us welcome the fact that that agreement has come forward and that Scotland will have the right to choose its own future.

I agree that the chancellor controls Scotland. Johann Lamont says that she is opposed to that—as I am—but I wish that she would tell her colleague Gordon Banks, who on television last night, when faced with a choice on whether to condemn the cut in Scotland’s resource that is happening this coming year, decided instead to side with the Conservative Party.

Basically, there is a difference between monetary and fiscal policy. In fiscal terms, last year for example, Scotland would have had the opportunity to take advantage of the £4.4 billion relative surplus, which is £800 for every man, woman and child. In anyone’s terms, that is a major advantage and freedom for the people of Scotland to have.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I found it astonishing last night that Stewart Hosie supported the Tories in cutting corporation tax.

Yesterday, Joe FitzPatrick said that today was going to be a “historic” day, but that clearly does not reach as far as the First Minister ever answering the question that he is asked. The First Minister does not like George Osborne, but he is saying that, in an independent Scotland, George Osborne would have more power here than he currently has.

Members: Oh!

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Of course he would, because the First Minister is relying—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister has said that he will rely on sterling and has no plan B. That is not a strong negotiating position.

Ultimately, the First Minister is saying that the people of Scotland just have to take his word for it that everything will be fine. Let us therefore look at the First Minister’s record on keeping his word—and I am not talking just about giving the most accurate answer ever given to any Parliament anywhere.

Last year, at his party conference, the First Minister promised the best childcare package anywhere but, a year on, not one more childcare place has been created as a result of that announcement. Last year, he boasted about hospital waiting times, but we now know that the figures were fiddled. Do members remember when he told the people of Glasgow how they were going to vote weeks before the polls opened? That turned out well. Does the First Minister understand why an increasing number of people simply do not believe a word that he says?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I have a whole menu to select from on a variety of subjects, but let me return to what I think Johann Lamont’s question was about, which is monetary and fiscal policy.

Monetary policy is controlled by the Bank of England, which is an independent operation, and fiscal policy is controlled by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. I thought that that point would be well understood, because the Labour Party and the other Opposition parties at Westminster had been arguing for a change in fiscal policy yesterday. Unfortunately, that major and significant change did not come about.

The big advantage of controlling our own fiscal policy is that, in an independent Scotland, the Parliament, on behalf of the people of Scotland, would have control over taxation and spending. That would include the ability to mobilise the relative surplus, which was £4.4 billion last year, and put it to the advantage of the Scottish economy, by saving for the future or by bringing about the transformation in the Scottish economy that everyone supports. That is the advantage of controlling our own fiscal policy.

On the range of policies that the Labour Party has attacked and that the Government has carried through, Johann Lamont is doing nothing different from what her predecessors did in the previous session of Parliament. Time after time, they said, “Look, this isn’t working and that’s not working.” Yet, when it came to the people’s judgment two years ago, the people of Scotland looked at the incredible negativity of the Labour Party and its lack of ambition, ideas and thoughts for the future, and then they looked at the track record, team and vision of the Government and they returned us with an overwhelming majority.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister started to answer the question that I asked previously. I asked about his record on waiting times and childcare, but he started talking about something else. There is nothing more cynical in government than, when challenged about what is happening now, saying that it will all be right at some point in future if we could just have independence. That is cynicism.

This afternoon we will find out whether the First Minister did tell Rupert Murdoch the date of the referendum first or whether he gave Rupert one of the most accurate tip-offs ever given to any newspaper proprietor, anywhere. We will find out how long Scotland is to remain on pause while the First Minister tries to sell Scots a deal that Scotland rejects.

What we have now is Scotland on pause: a Scotland with 120,000 fewer students in our colleges, a Scotland with pensioners languishing on trolleys in hospital corridors—

Members: Doom and gloom!

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I will try again, because it is true. We have a Scotland in which pensioners are languishing for hours on trolleys in hospital corridors, without getting treatment. We have a Scotland that is suffering from Tory cuts, which the First Minister doubles—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
A Scotland that is suffering from Tory cuts—[Interruption.] I will just wait until you are quiet, and then I will say it so that you can hear it—that worked when I was in the classroom and there is no reason why it should not work now. I do not know what time the bell goes. [Laughter.]

I will say it again: a Scotland suffering from Tory cuts that the First Minister doubles and passes on to our communities.

When Scotland rejects him, how will the First Minister explain to the student, the pensioner and the patient why he wasted so many years concentrating on his obsession and not on their needs?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I really think that it is difficult for the Labour Party to complain about Tory cuts in Scotland when they are in alliance with the Conservative Party in an attempt to deny Scotland the right to determine its own future.

On nursery education, we are moving to 600 hours for three and four-year-olds in Scotland—[Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
We inherited 412 hours from the Labour-Liberal Democrat coalition. That seems to me to be, in anyone’s terms, a substantial improvement for the people of Scotland.

We have guaranteed and delivered real-term spending for the health service in Scotland—something that would not have been done by the Labour Party if it had come to power in Scotland and which was not done by the Labour Party in Wales.

This very week we have seen important reductions in youth unemployment, which is down by 8 per cent—a third—over the past year. Yet Labour spokesmen, such as Jenny Marra just two days ago, talk about youth unemployment in Scotland at 25 per cent. It is down to 17 per cent, which is still far too high but is a dramatic improvement over the past year. Either Labour does not know that that has happened or it prefers to portray the rate as 25 per cent, as if the improvement and guarantees to young people had never happened.

Those are all improvements under devolution. Not to understand that, when Westminster sets the budget of Scotland and, as it did yesterday, cuts the budget of Scotland, this devolved Parliament cannot manufacture finance from nowhere, as Westminster is in control of our budget, is to misunderstand the basic challenge in Scottish politics.

This week, Labour abstained on workfare in the House of Commons, it abstained on Trident in this very chamber and it even abstained on the Iraq war in this very chamber. What Scotland needs is a Government that does not abstain but which takes control of the fiscal policy of Scotland and takes us forward into a prosperous and just future.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. European Arrest Warrant (United Kingdom Opt-out) Questions · 4
  2. Independence (Income Tax Rates) Questions · 6
  3. Bedroom Tax (Help for Tenants and Social Landlords) Questions · 4
  4. Bedroom Tax (Impact on Social Landlords) Questions · 14
  5. Air Services (Skye) Questions · 6
  6. Engineering Questions · 4
  7. Sustainable and Renewable Energy (Manufacturing) Questions · 8
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 23
  9. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  10. International Development Fund (Support for Malawi) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  11. United Kingdom Budget 2013 First Minister’s Questions · 14
  12. Medical Secretaries First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. National Health Service Staff (Whistleblowing) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  14. Scottish Association of Young Farmers Clubs (75th Anniversary) Members’ business · 9
  15. Independence Referendum Statement · 69
  16. Scotland’s Financial Strength Debate · 158
  17. Decision Time Decision time · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.