Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 29 November 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01012)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
For the rest of the day, I suspect that, like many members, I will be reading the Leveson report with great interest.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Indeed. I look forward to reading the report myself.

As the First Minister mentioned, Lord Leveson will publish his report on the regulation of the press in the next hour and a half. After the excesses of phone hacking, including into the phone of Milly Dowler, there has to be change. However, as we try to restore the public’s confidence in the press, we also need to protect press freedom, and we need to know that those who implement the Leveson recommendations will do so in the interests of the whole nation, not just themselves.

In that context, when did the First Minister last personally complain to a newspaper about its coverage?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will check the record and see whether I can help Johann Lamont with that.

On the substance of the Leveson report—which is a hugely important matter—as Johann Lamont will realise we cannot pre-empt the recommendations of a report that we have not yet seen, but we can assume that it will take a serious and considered view of the regulation of the press and of other, related matters that are devolved to Scotland, such as criminal prosecution, defamation and the functions of the police service.

I have made it clear that, personally, I favour not the state regulation of the press but a strengthened press council that has the support of the print media industry and—more importantly—the confidence of the wider public, who have rightly been angered by recent episodes concerning phone hacking, blagging and potential illegal activity. Such a system needs to ensure redress for people with no great resources, and a link to statute is also possible, as in the model that has been pursued in Ireland.

It is entirely possible that Lord Leveson may propose a more thoroughgoing statutory underpinning of regulation. It is therefore important that we in the Parliament have a proper process for considering how we will take forward the Leveson report in the Scottish context. I would like to set out a proposed process that the Parliament may wish to follow.

First, as I have already indicated, members of the Scottish Parliament will rightly have the opportunity to debate the Leveson report in further detail next week.

Secondly, I will invite all the other political parties in the Parliament to meet me to seek their views on the report. It is important to achieve cross-party agreement in Scotland on the best way forward.

Finally—and if agreed to—I propose the establishment of an independent implementation group that is chaired by a current or recent Court of Session judge with five non-politician members. The purpose of the group would be to consider how best to implement the Leveson proposals in the context of Scots law and the devolved responsibilities of the Parliament. That will allow the process and any proposed changes to go through the normal parliamentary procedures.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
There was a great deal in that, and I wonder whether it might have been more beneficial if, post Leveson reporting, we had had a full statement from the First Minister in that regard. I also note that the First Minister did not answer my question.

Politicians and press owners having an unhealthily close relationship is a big issue. I have no doubt that the First Minister will be able to give us a list of examples of various people in my party and others who have attended events that have been hosted by the Murdochs. We know that there was an unhealthily close relationship, but we also know that the First Minister is the only leader of a mainstream political party to host Rupert Murdoch since the stomach-turning revelations that one of his newspapers hacked Milly Dowler’s phone. Does the First Minister understand that his relationship with Murdoch undermines any confidence that we can have in him to set up a regulatory system for a free press?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I had hoped that Johann Lamont would rise to the occasion and the issues that are before us.

We know the frequency of meetings with various political leaders. We could debate the issue in terms of Gordon Brown’s 17 meetings with Rupert Murdoch over three years when he was Prime Minister, against my five meetings in five years. We could talk about going in the back door of Downing Street, rather than releasing a press statement immediately after a meeting. We could do all that, but is it not rather better to address the big issue facing the country and the Parliament?

The question is whether we in this Parliament can find a process to deal with the issue. Incidentally, that looks unlikely to happen at Westminster as my understanding is that the Prime Minister and Deputy Prime Minister will make conflicting statements in response to Leveson, but might it be possible in this Parliament, given all that has happened and given our responsibilities, to actually find a way forward?

Johann Lamont said that there is a lot in what I said, and I welcome that, but could we at least have a response on all-party talks and on finding a process to take forward Leveson’s recommendations and to look at them in a Scottish context? We might actually find a solution. Because of the importance of the issue, and in deference to the victims of the illegal and potentially illegal activities, might we just rise to the occasion and point a way forward?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Perhaps in deference to the victims of all those horrific activities and in an attempt to rise to the occasion, the First Minister might have apologised for being the only mainstream politician to meet Murdoch after the revelations came to a head.

The First Minister says that he does not want to pre-empt Leveson, but he then does exactly that by saying that he wants Scotland to have a separate regulatory system with a separate Scottish ombudsman. Considering that he would ultimately be responsible for their appointment, and given his track record, can he understand why the rest of us might fear that he sees Leveson as a chance for him to exercise control over the Scottish press on an unprecedented scale?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Let us see what Lord Leveson has to say. I just point out that one reason why I referred to the Irish system is that ministers in the Irish Government do not appoint the ombudsman. Some elementary checking of the system that I alluded to—which I certainly feel has some currency, considering the evidence to the Leveson inquiry—would perhaps have reassured Johann Lamont on that matter. Furthermore, in what I said earlier, I invited not just Johann Lamont but the other party leaders in the Parliament to a discussion about the issue to see whether we can find a way forward.

I have another point that is important to reassuring people in Scotland. The first occasion on which the police and prosecution authorities in Scotland had the information about Scottish victims was when they requested it from the Metropolitan Police in July last year. The Metropolitan Police had held that information since at least 2006. On receiving the information, Strathclyde Police immediately informed the potential victims of phone hacking and set up operation Rubicon. Since that was set up, as has been well publicised, three people have been detained on allegations of perjury or attempting to pervert the course of justice, and another four people have been questioned in relation to breaches of data protection law.

Those are responsibilities of the Scottish police and prosecution authorities. It should be reassuring for the Parliament to know that, as soon as the authorities in Scotland had information that pointed to abuses of Scottish citizens, the authorities took action. On that basis, we should have no doubt about the firmness of intent to uphold the criminal law in Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am keen to urge the First Minister to recognise that, in considering any regulatory system, he should not imply that, somehow, the problems in Scotland are different from those in the rest of the United Kingdom and that there cannot be a United Kingdom-wide solution.

The First Minister alludes to the Irish system. We need rigorous scrutiny of that option and any other options. As he knows, and as we agree, the Leveson process has been an attempt not just to regulate the press better but to restore the public’s faith in the press, which has been severely dented after the horrors that the Dowler family, the families of the Hillsborough victims and countless others went through.

I am sure that we can agree that this cannot be a debate in which politicians just talk about our relationship with the press and that there must be an understanding of the deep anger and concern that ordinary citizens feel, right across the United Kingdom.

It is important that we get this right, not just for this Parliament but for Parliaments to come. The First Minister has invited us to all-party talks. Will he commit himself, first, to building consensus throughout the country on how we regulate the press and, secondly, to being bound by the conclusions of the all-party talks?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I would not be inviting Johann Lamont and the other party leaders to all-party talks if I did not want and see the importance of getting a consensus on the issue.

What are the terms of what requires to be done? First and foremost—and my reason for mentioning the position of the police and the prosecution authorities—the law must be upheld and people must have confidence that criminal law will be upheld. I do not think that we have any reason, given what happened, to criticise the prosecution authorities and the police of Scotland for a lack of action as soon as they had the information on which to act.

Secondly, freedom of the press is hugely important within that context of law, as is the behaviour of the press. Thirdly, individuals—or groups, for that matter—who have no resources must have access to redress if they are wronged by the press. That is why the idea of an ombudsman is significant and attractive.

In terms of what we do, surely the key thing that has come out of the controversy, for all parties, is the publication and transparency of meetings with editors and newspaper proprietors. That is good.

Lastly, we have to point to a solution. We have to get beyond who did what to whom and when, and point to a solution that gives redress to victims of malpractice and illegality. That is why I hope that all parties in the Parliament will rise to the occasion and try to build all-party agreement.

I cannot promise all-party agreement, because I am not certain that that agreement exists, but if there is good will on all sides, surely the Parliament can devise a particularly Scottish suggestion and solution that meets our responsibilities, which include the prosecution authorities, the civil law of defamation, the criminal law of contempt of court, and press regulation. Those responsibilities are devolved to this Parliament. Other things are not devolved, such as broadcasting, the internet and the protection of information, but the matters that I set out are our responsibilities. For goodness’ sake, let us rise to the occasion, try to meet the circumstances and find a solution for the Scottish people.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Private Rented Housing (Scotland) Act 2011 (Implementation) Questions · 6
  2. Sewer Network (Guidance to Scottish Water) Questions · 4
  3. Commercial Radio (Office of Communications) Questions · 6
  4. Trunk Road Maintenance (South-west Scotland) Questions · 7
  5. Crofting Townships Questions · 10
  6. Common Agricultural Policy (Reform) Questions · 7
  7. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  8. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  9. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Local Government (Structure) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  11. National Health Service (Serious Incidents) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Oil Industry (Role in Economy) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  13. Scottish Media Panel Members’ business · 25
  14. Remploy Debate · 110
  15. Business Motion Business motions · 2
  16. Decision Time Decision time · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.