Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 31 January 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01153)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Later today I will be meeting the managing director of Microsoft UK to discuss the company’s plans for its apprenticeship programme. As the chamber will know, this week we have had some fantastic analysis showing that 92 per cent of the youngsters in the greatly expanded modern apprenticeships programme are in work six months after completing their modern apprenticeship. A great deal of interest has been stimulated among companies and the commitment that Microsoft UK will make today is that, in the run-up to 2016, it and its partners, suppliers and stakeholders will guarantee a minimum of 2,016 new young modern apprenticeships.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
We must obviously welcome any opportunities for our young people. We would only hope that the Government had more of a focus on the issues of youth unemployment and the challenges that young people face. Some of the figures on young people being in jobs after an apprenticeship are because they were in those jobs before they got the apprenticeships.

The process of the referendum is almost agreed, bar the date. Now we can get down to the substance of the debate, but how will the First Minister conduct that debate? The people of Scotland have made it clear that they want clear, honest information. When we have said that an independent Scotland would have to apply to join the European Union and that those negotiations could take time, we have been accused by the First Minister of scaremongering. When the Irish Minister for European Affairs says that an independent Scotland would have to apply to the EU and that the negotiations could be lengthy and complex, what is she guilty of?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am glad that there is so much agreement now on the processes of the referendum. I am glad that Johann Lamont and I can go forward on that basis and I look forward to the debate.

I recommend that Johann Lamont reads the information from the Irish European affairs minister. What the minister said, of course, looking at the Scottish National Party timetable for negotiating our position from within the European Union, from a yes vote in the referendum to the independence election in 2016, was that she regarded that position as entirely satisfactory. Coming from the minister of a country that has presidency of the European Council at the moment, that seems to me to be a strong endorsement of the SNP position.

Johann Lamont asked how we would conduct the debate in Scotland. We will conduct our debate for an independent Scotland in a positive manner. I wonder if the bitter together campaign of Labour and the Tories can match that commitment.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I am not sure how positive it is to misrepresent what people say when they raise legitimate concerns and express a view on what the Scottish Government claims to be the case, because the Irish European affairs minister’s comments fall well short of Nicola Sturgeon’s definitive claim that Scotland’s membership of the EU would be “automatic”. In her clarification, Lucinda Creighton says:

“I think it is clear that a newly independent state would have to ... negotiate the terms of membership.”

She adds that those terms

“would undoubtedly be somewhat different to the existing terms”.

What part of that does the First Minister disagree with?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
We have always said that there would be negotiations. The crucial point is that those negotiations will take place from within the European Union. The Irish European affairs minister, Lucinda Creighton, says that the SNP position of, between 2014 to 2016, negotiating our position within the European Union,

“sums up the situation ... well.”

That is an exact quote.

I do not know the terminology that Johann Lamont uses, but it seems to me that that is something of an endorsement of the position that the SNP has been putting forward.

Johann Lamont will have to catch up with how the terms of the European debate have changed. Her unionist partners in the better together campaign want negotiations perhaps to take the United Kingdom out of the European Union altogether. Is it not entirely possible that negotiating for Scotland and Scotland’s interests from within the European Union—wanting to stay part of the European Union—will be rather more successful than an in-out referendum, as postulated by her allies in the Conservative Party?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Anyone would think, to listen to the First Minister, that Nicola Sturgeon had never said that our membership of the EU would be—I quote—“automatic”. The problem with the First Minister is that he lives in a world in which we are never supposed to remember what he said yesterday and we are never supposed to expect that tomorrow will match what he says today. The people deserve better. If the independence debate is to be conducted in what he describes as positive terms, heaven help us all.

When the BBC reported Lucinda Creighton’s comments, it was accused by the SNP of misconstruing what she said. Scandalously, one SNP member suggested that the report had been “heavily spliced”, yet what she said, and what was reported, is backed by the comments of the President of the European Commission José Manuel Barroso, the Czech foreign minister, the Spanish Europe minister and anyone who understands the European Union. What was it that was misconstrued and provoked such a hysterical response from the SNP? Why could not the SNP just admit the truth?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I ask Johann Lamont to cast her mind back to First Minister’s question time a year ago. Patricia Ferguson congratulated the Government on publishing its consultation document, which said that there would be negotiations with the European Union. I replied:

“I say that it has never been our position that there would not be negotiations; the point is that negotiations would be held from within the context of the EU.”—[Official Report, 25 January 2012; c 5613-14.]

Maybe it takes a year to clarify the position between Patricia Ferguson and Johann Lamont. Perhaps if Ms Lamont sorts out her internal communications within the Labour Party, it will be easier to challenge.

Johann Lamont gets very upset about any suggestion that the BBC might be misconstruing the remarks of the Irish Minister for European Affairs. I quote exactly the Irish European affairs minister, who said:

“I am concerned that an interview which I conducted with the BBC is being misconstrued”.

She went on to endorse the SNP position in the way that I have just outlined. In fairness to the BBC, it should be said that she said that the BBC position is being misconstrued. When it comes to finding misconstruers in Scottish society, the best place to look is the better together campaign of Labour and the Conservatives.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
This is the man who went to court to cover up the fact that he did not have legal advice. He has never been able to explain what he understands by the term, “terms of the debate.” We do not need a lecture from the First Minister about clarity; what we need from him is a degree of honesty.

Everyone agrees that the people of Scotland have the right to the best, most accurate information in the run-up to the referendum, but how can they have faith—[Interruption.]

I know that members are doing their job, which is to make a racket. It is the only internal communication that the First Minister requires from them.

How can the people of Scotland have faith in the information supplied by the Scottish Government when so often—remember—it has been forced to admit that it is wrong and when those giving accurate facts are ridiculed, bombarded with complaints and pilloried by the cybernats?

What does it say about Scotland when the minister of a foreign country is bombarded with abuse for telling the truth and news organisations from The Scotsman to The Herald to the BBC are traduced for reporting facts that turn out to be true?

People want information so that they can make a judgment on what an independent Scotland would look like. So far, is it not the case that all we know is that it will be a land where no one is allowed to disagree with Alex Salmond?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I know that Johann Lamont would not want to descend into the language that was used by some of her colleagues in the House of Commons a couple of weeks ago, when some actually questioned the democratic credentials of this proportional Parliament and upheld the legitimacy of the House of Commons as a model of modern democracy.

I have quoted the exact words of the Irish minister, Lucinda Creighton. It was she who said that she thought that the BBC’s coverage of her remarks was being misconstrued. That is a reasonable thing for Ireland’s Minister for European Affairs to say, and I think that it is important to note that she found that the SNP’s position was entirely sensible and endorsed it. Hopefully, that sort of confidence in Scotland’s European future will translate itself to the unionist parties in this Parliament, which cannot seriously doubt that energy-rich, oil-rich, renewables-rich, fishing-rich Scotland would be anything other than—as the Irish minister indicated—welcome in the ranks of the European Union.

I was intrigued by the reference to cyberspace, because I have been looking at a bit of cyberspace myself. The Facebook site of Labour for Scotland has been tweeted all over the place. I was particularly interested in the comments on the page by Robert McNeill, who is the chair of East Lothian constituency Labour Party and a better together campaign co-ordinator. He wrote:

“the labour party in scotland, in my opinion have a long way to go before we will once again become a party which is electable to the scottish people. however until the party recognise what the problems are then i am afraid it may take much longer”.

That is one of Johann Lamont’s own constituency chairmen and a co-ordinator of the better together campaign. I think that Johann Lamont better get a grip of him. He is probably listening to the Tories who he is campaigning with in East Lothian.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Tax Payments (Companies in Receipt of Government Grants) Questions · 6
  2. Orkney Ferry Services (Service Model Assessment) Questions · 6
  3. Blacklisting Questions · 6
  4. Concessionary Travel Scheme (Government Support) Questions · 6
  5. Mortonhall Crematorium (Stillbirth and Neonatal Death Society Lothians) Questions · 6
  6. Local Planning Decisions Questions · 6
  7. Renewable Energy Investment Fund Questions · 4
  8. Offpeak Train Travel (Discussions with Transport Scotland) Questions · 4
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  10. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  11. European Union Member States’ Foreign Ministries (Contact) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Nursing and Midwifery Staff (Numbers) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Police Staff Redundancies First Minister’s Questions · 8
  14. Non-profit-distributing Model Projects First Minister’s Questions · 11
  15. Musicians Union Work not Play Campaign Members’ business · 7
  16. Child Benefit Debate · 137
  17. Decision Time Decision time · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.