Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

High-speed Rail Link (Edinburgh to Glasgow)

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 13 November 2012 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 19 contributions · 8 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link


2. To ask the Scottish Government what plans are being made to introduce a high-speed rail link between Edinburgh and Glasgow. (S4T-00120)

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
I call Keith Brown.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link
Not very high speed today, minister. [Laughter.]

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
You deserved that, minister.

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
It is vital to link the key economic centres in Scotland, as it is across the United Kingdom. We have carried out a high-level assessment, which demonstrates that a new high-speed line with journey times of less than 30 minutes could be built by 2024. The Scottish Government will enter talks with our partners in both cities and the rail industry to see how we can work together to realise the vision of an Edinburgh to Glasgow high-speed line that connects to England’s network.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link
Will the minister outline the benefits for Scotland’s two major cities of almost halving the journey time between Glasgow and Edinburgh?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
There will be substantial benefits. We are told that there is a substantial economic benefit every time that there is a reduction of even a minute in journey time between Glasgow and Edinburgh. There will be benefits in terms of accessibility and there will be social and environmental benefits from upgrading the link—and of course that will make a fifth option available.

There are wider benefits of a high-speed link for the rest of Scotland and the United Kingdom. Also, the announcement shows the Scottish Government’s intent to ensure that high-speed rail comes to Scotland as soon as possible.

Gordon MacDonald SNP Edinburgh Pentlands
link
Will the new high-speed line be linked to the cross-border service to London? Does the minister plan to meet the UK transport minister to discuss the UK plans for high-speed rail?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
I hope to meet the Secretary of State for Transport, Patrick McLoughlin, in the next week. Of course, the intention is to have a high-speed link all the way from London to Scotland. Indeed, if that does not happen, capacity constraints on the west coast main line, which will reach a critical stage by 2024-25, will be such that billions of pounds will again have to be spent on the line in advance of further high-speed rail connections. We will have a conversation about that with the UK Government.

In that context, I welcome the comments of the Secretary of State for Transport, who said at the Conservative Party conference that he hopes to have a three-hour rail journey time between London and Scotland. That will form the basis for some of our discussions.

Sarah Boyack Lab Lothian
link
Will the minister tell the Parliament about the proposed technology and route? Does he envisage conventional rail or maglev technology, as we proposed in the 2007 elections, being used? When will he publish details of his proposals? Does he not get it that cuts to the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme mean that commuters in the central belt are missing out on reduced journey times and that 2024 is a very long way off?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
The member does not take account of the fact that we are announcing an initiative that will halve the journey time between Edinburgh and Glasgow.

It is true that what we announced yesterday was our intent, just as I imagine happened when the Forth bridge and the Glenfinnan viaduct were proposed, or when the Secretary of State for Transport announced an aim to have a journey time of three hours.

We must now make the plans go forward, which includes working out the route. The intention is to use some of the existing network, although there is the possibility of having a largely new line. As far as plans that I have seen are concerned, it is not the intention to use maglev technology, for fairly fundamental reasons.

It is the intention to start looking into the issue in some detail. We are right to say that we have the ambition to introduce a high-speed rail link between Edinburgh and Glasgow. Such ambition is important and is the hallmark of this Government.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link
Given the timescale and indeterminate budget for the proposal, would it not have been better to invest a little resource in improving the existing service and cutting journey times? Is the proposal simply an excuse for not investing in the Edinburgh to Glasgow route between now and 2024?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
Given that we recently announced a £650 million package of investment in that very line, the question points to the absurdity of the Conservative position. The Conservative Secretary of State for Transport recently announced an aim to have a three-hour journey time between London and Edinburgh but gave no detail on the study and its costs or the possible costs of new construction. I did not criticise him for that and I note that neither did Alex Johnstone, although he criticises the Scottish Government for its intention to improve the link between Edinburgh and Glasgow.

It is right that we state our ambitions. What is not right—and not surprising—is the Conservative Party’s complete lack of ambition on the issue. We have the ambition for Scotland. We have stated our intention and we will get to work on ensuring that it happens.

Willie Rennie LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Yesterday, the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities was quoted as saying, “We now know” that building a high-speed link within 12 years that cuts journey times to 30 minutes is possible. Can the minister point to a single piece of documented evidence that backs up that claim?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
If Willie Rennie looks at “Fast Track Scotland: Making the Case for High Speed Rail Connections with Scotland”, which we published some time ago, and at the work that has subsequently been done by the Scottish partnership group for high-speed rail, he will see the rationale that has been put together.

It is extremely important that we recognise that we have made a statement of our intention. As the cabinet secretary said yesterday, we have work to do on planning for the new link and we must identify the funding for it. However, we have stated our ambition, as we have done on many transport projects. If someone does not have the idea in the first place, they are not going to make those vital changes to the infrastructure for the people of Scotland. It is probably a good thing for Scotland that we have a Government that is willing to take on those big projects, to state that ambition and to follow it through by completing those projects on time and on budget.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link
In an article in The Herald on 5 July the minister is quoted as saying that one of the reasons for revising EGIP was the need to tie it in with a future high-speed rail network in Scotland. How will this new announcement impact on EGIP and is the minister still committed to seeing the future phases of EGIP implemented as previously stated?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
I give Mark Griffin my assurance that we intend to see EGIP through. As I said at the time, I reckon that we can achieve around 80 per cent of the benefits that the original £1 billion scheme had proposed. There is every possibility that we can increase that percentage—perhaps not to 100 per cent, but getting towards 100 per cent of the benefits of the previous scheme. We remain absolutely committed to the EGIP works taking place.

Neil Findlay Lab Lothian
link
Given the desperate situation following the Hall’s closure, will the minister look again at EGIP and the cuts to it and reflect on the advantages that we would get from a new station at Winchburgh?

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
I think that that is a bit wide of the original question.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Stow College Questions · 10
  3. High-speed Rail Link (Edinburgh to Glasgow) Questions · 19
  4. Universal Benefits Debate · 215
  5. Decision Time Decision time · 10
  6. British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly (Autumn Plenary 2012) Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.