I do not think that the issue is the number of personnel; I think that the issue is the functions.
Official Report · Committee
Police Reform
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 89
- Vic Emery Scottish Police Authority 60
- Chief Constable House 45
- Alison McInnes LD 16
- Graeme Pearson Lab 15
- Andrew Laing Her Majesty’s Chief Inspector of Constabulary for Scotland 14
- John Finnie Ind 14
- Sandra White SNP 5
- Colin Keir SNP 4
- Jenny Marra Lab 3
- David McLetchie Con 2
- Chief Constable Stephen House Police Service of Scotland 1
- Roderick Campbell SNP 1
The record
269 contributions · showing 201–269It is the personnel, in terms of from where a common set of policies and procedures is orchestrated. That does not undermine for one second the responsibility of the chief constable to have a senior HR person reporting to him, in his command team, looking after all the souls who report.
We accept that this is still a difficult area for the two of you and has still to be negotiated.
There is very little change between what has been proposed in the legislation and what we have at the moment. A unitary authority such as Fife is the employer of all non-warranted police officers, but direction and control are devolved to the chief constable, who operates the system and has an HR director, a director of finance and so on. Interestingly, about three years ago, there was a significant proposal to amend those arrangements and put senior support staff back into the local authority. HMI and Audit Scotland were invited to contribute to the significant and fairly public debate that followed, the outcome of which was that the status quo was the best option and that it was best for direction and control—including of the HR director and the director of finance, who are both police staff—to rest with chief constables so that they had the flexibility to make the necessary operational decisions. There is history to all of this, and to some extent it is repeating itself.
That is helpful.
Can I ask a question on that matter, convener?
Please be quick, because Rod Campbell has been very patient.
What I have to say might help Mr Emery. Back in July, the national police reform team signed off a kind of civil service structure, in which the director of finance, the HR director and the director of communications and public affairs would all report through the chief constable to the authority. As Mr Laing has pointed out, there is a real rationale behind such a structure that holds together and which might help in future discussions.That is all that I wanted to say, convener.
It is as if you are giving evidence, Mr Pearson.
I miss it, convener.
I will be very brief, convener, because most of my points have already been raised.Mr Laing, you said earlier that it was critical for the respective roles of the SPA, the police service and others to be clearly understood. However, from what I can determine from this morning’s discussion, we are still some way from that point. Do you have a role in trying to assist that understanding between your two colleagues—with or without legal advice? How will you be able to do your job properly after 1 April if you do not have that clarity?
At this stage, our primary role is to assist with the evidence that we have gathered on the history of policing and policing governance. Almost two years ago, HMI published a fairly substantial report on governance and accountability in policing that set out some clear principles, many of which have been taken forward or incorporated into the legislation, and we are now working very closely with the Auditor General on what we think are good models of governance and accountability. In those discussions, we are drawing on the findings of the eight best-value audits and inspections that have been carried out and, with the overview report, we have been able to provide some insight with regard to the best practice that we have found and what approach should be taken to the model of governance. We are in dialogue with both Vic Emery and Steve House on some of those aspects.Our role in the interim period is very much about encouraging the parties to reach a conclusion on those matters, but the reality is that the devil is in the detail. Until the chief constable, the authority and the board are able to consider options in the context of previous findings and can come to a conclusion, and until we can see how that conclusion will work and what the scheme of delegation—in other words, how much will be devolved to the police service—the scheme of administration and the various relationships will look like, it is difficult to offer critical commentary on the matter. I guess that what I am saying is that, in the meantime, we are acting as a source of advice and academic evidence, which we will add into the pot.Once we see what develops, our role next year, post 1 April, will be to work very closely with the Auditor General on developing a scheme of inspection and audit that will test out the various relationships. Those discussions are at an advanced stage. I also note that the legislation places a responsibility on me to have an inspection plan in place by the early part of next year. We will do that in consultation, and I hope that the plan will be presented to the committee to assure members that the work is being carried out.
Good morning, gentlemen. I thought that I would get a wee bit of clarity this morning, but the picture is now even more mixed up—certainly in my mind, anyway.I am trying to get to the nub of the issue as regards HR and finance. I have listened to your evidence and I have written down the word “dispute” under “HR and finance”. Please will you clarify the position for me?Mr Emery, you mentioned that the act is prescriptive in some areas, with mandatory provisions, and we have talked about the words “shall” and “may”, but you did not touch on the fact that responsibility for the forensic service is absolutely yours. That is in the act, it has been seen by everyone, and you have accepted it.As far as I can see from my reading of the act, forensics is the only aspect that the SPA has responsibility for. Did something in the act click in your mind and cause you to go and get legal advice about finance and HR? Where were you coming from in that respect? Given that the rest is up to the chief constable, why were you—I do not want to use the word “suspicious”—concerned that some other areas should be within the responsibilities of the SPA?
First, forensics is not the only bit on which the act is prescriptive. It clearly states that only the SPA—which is a corporate body, unlike the police service of Scotland—can buy things, as Steve has already said. He used the example of cars. He will present a business case that says that he needs four cars to fulfil a specific role, and then someone in the SPA will go and buy them. That is quite prescriptive.The reason why there is an on-going discussion on finance and HR is that they are key drivers in the governance of the whole—
Sorry to interrupt. That is why we are here today—to get some clarification.You mentioned that the SPA is a “corporate” body, but that is not a word that I would use regarding the police, and I do not think that the public out there would see it as a corporate entity, either. They see it as a service that is designed to protect and serve them.What I am trying to get at is that finance and HR are the sticking point and we have still not resolved it. Why did you think that you needed legal advice given that the act is not prescriptive or mandatory regarding human resources and finance?
My legal advice was not simply directed at finance and HR. I do not want you to think that that was its sole purpose. The purpose of my legal advice was to ensure that the other 12 members of the board knew exactly what the act was asking them to do and what liabilities and responsibilities they were taking on. It is the first port of call. If we go into a corporate organisation, we look at its articles of association to see what it is there to do. The act describes that, and we need to understand the limits of what it allows the board to take responsibility for.
Thank you for that clarification. I think—
I think that Vic Emery is referring to section 3(1)(b) of the act, which states:“the Authority may provide and maintain anything necessary or desirable for the carrying out of police functions”.Then there is a list:“including vehicles, equipment, information technology systems, land, buildings and other structures”.That is the discretionary part.
Yes. That part is discretionary, but I think that Sandra White’s question was about finance and HR.
I think that the nub of the whole situation is finance and HR. That is the ultimate talking point or sticking point.I thank you for what you have said. You constantly mention the SPA being a corporate body. That is the language that you use, but it is certainly not the language that I would use when talking about the police force. However, I will leave that aside.You talked about operational matters, and I think that my colleague Alison McInnes got to the nub of that issue. As she said, if the person who is in charge of the police force wishes to have extra people put in certain places, surely that should be the responsibility of the chief constable, who has operational responsibility. That is the human resource part.On the finance part, I note that you said earlier that HR and finance are best left until there is agreement with the chief constable as to exactly what finances are required. I noted that that was the language that you used. You said, “best left until we have an agreement”—not “an agreement between the two”, but, “until we have an agreement with the chief constable”.You then mentioned that “the budget belongs to the SPA”—that was the language that you used. Would you not agree that the person who is at the forefront of the operational management of the police not only should but must—I will use that word—have some input into how many police officers are put on the beat or whatever and that that person will need the finances to be able to carry out that operation?11:15
Already this morning we have covered the fact that there is no dispute about that.
Sorry, I hate to dispute that, but I think that there is a dispute. I know that you are both being very nice about it and saying that you will be talking about the issue at your meeting on 5 December, which is only a couple of days away, but the act passed by Parliament is very important and will come into force in April. It is fine for people to say, “We are working it out between us”, but I think that basically the committee has a right to know exactly what is going on. I certainly do not feel comfortable with, or comforted by, the evidence that I have heard today. There still seems to be a dispute between the chair and the chief constable about finance and human resources, which are perhaps the most important parts. Certainly, what I have heard today does not give me comfort.
The chief constable can speak for himself, but there is no dispute between us on who controls policing—the chief constable does that. We agree an organisation structure and we agree a budget. He has 17,234 police and a considerable number of police staff, who become police staff when, as a result of the discussions that we are having, they are allocated to the chief constable to perform tasks. There will be fewer police staff in the future than there are now because the reform programme will take some of them out—we are trying to do that on a voluntary basis so that there is no harm to anyone. However, once those staff are within the police service of Scotland, they are under the control and direction of the chief constable and he can do whatever he needs to with them to satisfy the objective of the safe policing of Scotland.
I am sorry if I have sounded complacent up until now in saying that we are having a debate and that it is a sensible debate. I have not meant to sound complacent, and I understand that it causes some concern. I certainly think that the issue is important and I am grateful for the committee spending time looking at it.We are down to differences of opinion around control over HR and finance. To go back more or less to where I started, the level of debate that we are now having is over where the director of finance will have his or her office and where the director of HR will actually work from. Will they report to the chief constable on a daily basis, or will they work in the SPA headquarters building away from the chief constable’s headquarters? The answer is very clear—I think that this has been repeated several times today—that the directors of HR and finance will work next to the chief constable on my senior management team on a daily basis, and I will be responsible on a daily basis for direction and control.We will also be developing a forward-looking strategy on HR and finance, but we would completely expect to discuss that strategy with the authority. We would do that mainly as we did in the past, which is by preparing a business case and providing papers for the authority’s consideration. The change here will be that the authority will be far more proactive and far more demanding in its scrutiny because the budget is the authority’s budget, which is given to it by the taxpayer. To me, all that sounds relatively healthy and if that is how it is thrashed out—whether it appears in writing is not the point, because what matters is how it works in practice—I am content that that gives me the flexibility that I need to direct and control the police service on a daily basis.Of course there will be tensions and rubs with the authority. I was chief constable of Strathclyde Police for five years, and we had tensions and rubs all the time on different things. However, all in all—sometimes despite what Audit Scotland and HMI thought—I think that we did a pretty good job together, and I think that most chief constables across the board would say the same. There are always going to be issues and problems. Again, I am not being complacent. I am not saying that the problem is solved and fixed. I hope that we do not have to come back in front of the committee in a few weeks’ time and say “Oh well, we are still thrashing it out”, as I would not want to do that.There is a time for debate and there is a time for getting on with it, and we are at the time for getting on with it. As the chair clearly said, the authority has a meeting on 5 December at which it will consider the governance arrangements. That is the timescale. I hope that the authority will pretty much agree what we have laid out this morning.
Why are the SPA and the police service to be based at different locations? Is that necessary?
Actually, I think that it is necessary. Fairly early on, I stuck my oar in and suggested that that should be the case. The public have to understand that there is a clear distinction and definition between the two bodies. I do not know whether the police service is a corporate body, but it is a police service, and then there is a Police Authority that oversees the police service.
So it is about perception.
It is about perception. The motorway miles between the two locations might be a pain in the neck, because there will be constant meetings of staff and so on.
That is what I meant.
Actually, perception is important—it is important that we are not perceived as being in each other’s pockets.
I see Andrew Laing nodding, but I know large legal firms in which one partner could act for one side in a contract and another partner could act for the other side. There are walls between them, real and metaphorical. I understand why you are doing that, but it seems that there will be a lot of duplication.
If I may come back on that, much of the debate this morning has been about whether I, as chief constable, can assure the committee that I have operational control of the police service and that Mr Emery will not tell me what to do. If we worked in adjacent offices, to a huge degree, people would think, “Hang on, he might not be telling the chief constable what to do, but the relationship is very cosy.” It is not meant to be a cosy relationship.
I did not think that for one minute.
It is meant to be a slightly arm’s-length relationship. Politically, being in separate buildings is probably the right thing to do.
Okay. I would not place you cheek by jowl. You could be at separate ends of a large building with a big corridor between, but there we are—it is not going to happen.
I have a couple of questions. The audit report that was referred to earlier noted:“Across all of our audits/inspections we consistently found that police authorities do not provide strategic leadership”on “equality and diversity issues.” It goes on to recommend:“Training programmes for members of the SPA and those involved in agreeing local policing plans should include an appropriate level of training on equalities duties.”What arrangements have been put in place and what priority is being given to that issue?
I think that the report refers to the police authorities, not the individual police forces, and that certainly will not be the case for the police service of Scotland, because equality and diversity will be shot through all our strategies. Obviously, the service has not been involved in the selection of members of the Police Authority, so that is an issue that the chair might wish to address, rather than me. However, we stand ready to provide training on equality and diversity to any member of the authority or its staff, which is just as important as anything else that they will need.
At present, the board has not even met to agree the standing orders. Therefore, that is a piece of business that needs to be transacted. As soon as we get an HR organisation in place, we can put in place all those policies. As an ethos, we agree absolutely with the diversity agenda. Members will see that that is more than adequately demonstrated at board level in the SPA.
You are making appointments almost as we speak—you made some yesterday—without an equality and diversity policy or statement.
Yes. We have no internal policy written yet, because we are only a month old. However, the chief constable and I sat on the interview panel, and diversity was part of our agenda in the interviews.
I am trying to establish the importance that the board will give to the issue. Will the issue be covered in one of the first papers that you bring to the board?
Yes, it will be in one of the early papers. I would not say that it will be the first paper, but it will be an early paper. I am committed to diversity. I have worked all round the world, so I am committed to diversity.
In the best-value overview report, we found that the commitment to equalities and diversity in policing per se was good. The authorities have two functions. First, they have to provide a strategic oversight of what the police do. We found that that was largely passive. The second is that the authorities in their own right have a responsibility on equalities and diversity, which was not being picked up and adhered to.In the recent appointment process, I sat as an independent adviser on the panel—alongside Vic and Steve—to ensure that all those aspects were covered. Given the timescale, it would be unreasonable to ask the authority to have those policies in place.
It is reassuring to hear that an independent voice was at the table.On a separate question, it would be interesting to hear an update on your regional plans and how you see the operational structure of the police going forward. We have seen reports in the newspapers and so on, so I want to hear your view.
I am happy to talk you through that. As you will all know, policing is an inherently hierarchical organisation, and we love designing organisational charts. The chief constable is in place, and we now have four deputies in place. As the Police Authority chair said, we are in the middle of early selection and sifting for the seven ACCs who will be in place.We have done a lot of planning on that over the past 12 months. There will be three territorial assistant chief constables: one covering the north of the country, one covering the west and one covering the east. There will be 14 divisional commanders reporting to those ACCs; in effect, they are already in place because a number of forces—as you probably know from your representation around the country—have already moved in that direction.Tayside Police has moved to a single territorial division for the whole organisation, and so have Fife Constabulary, Central Scotland Police and Northern Constabulary. We are building on that structure in an attempt not to upset or alarm in any way our local council partners and the chief executives and leaders in particular. We are trying to keep that change to an absolute minimum.We are identifying designated local police commanders, as I am obliged to do under the law. I am also obliged to consult the local authority on the identity of those individuals. I have written to the vast majority of councils in Scotland, identifying someone as the local police commander, which is without exception the person who is currently in place. Letters are now starting to come back from the councils saying that they are very happy with the nominations. There is the odd query, and one or two councils have asked whether they have to be united in one division and why they cannot stand on their own as a police division. We are meeting representatives from those councils and talking them through the process, and so far we have been able to resolve concerns in that regard.Once the divisional commanders are identified, that allows us to ensure that they have the type of mandate under the new act to go ahead with discussions with local councils and other local partners to create the 32 local policing plans that we are required by law to create for 1 April.In the same timescale, we have to consult on the Government’s four strategic priorities, and that consultation is under way. The authority will then create a three-year strategic policing plan, and I will develop an annual policing plan. That all has to fit together. However, to give the 32 councils and the local commanders a heads-up on that and give them some lead time, we are asking them to get on and start talking locally now to develop local plans, which will be inherently local. Although the plans will be informed by strategic directives et cetera, they are about the locality. If they are not relevant to the local area, they are not relevant at all. We want councils to start developing those plans, and they are at various stages in the process of doing so.Underneath that, I have given instructions that I want each of the 353 council ward areas throughout Scotland to have its own policing plan up and running for 1 April. Those plans will be even more local, and will concentrate on the top three concerns that the public have in the ward areas in which they live and what the police are going to do about those concerns over the next 12 months.That is how the structure is developing. We are moving forward with it because we have to. We are approaching December, and it has to be up and running for 1 April. I cannot have officers not knowing what the direction of travel is, what they are expected to focus on and what we are measuring them on, so we need that structure to be in place as soon as possible.
There may be an issue about where the various headquarters will be. Is that part of the planning?
There will be only one police headquarters and there will be a debate about that. The interim headquarters is at Tulliallan. The jury is out on whether that is, operationally, the right place to have a headquarters, but no alternative has been identified and we are not doing any work on that at the moment.11:30
I talked about having an assistant chief constable in the west. That person will cover the west but work from headquarters. The ACC for the east will cover the east but work from headquarters. The exception will be the northern ACC who, simply because of distance and geography, will have to spend a fair amount of their time in the north of the country. I would expect them to come to most of our major meetings either through videolink or in person, but they need to be on the ground.
So there will not be three other headquarters. That has been raised with me.
We all live and learn on communications. I have spoken about the three regions and, as I have said, police are madly into hierarchy and will build structures, so the easiest thing for them to do was to think that, because there was going to be an ACC west, he or she would need their own headquarters. However, they will not have their own headquarters; there will be one headquarters and we will all work there alongside the directors of HR and finance.
Thank you for that clarification.
I want to clarify something that came up earlier. I was interested in Sandra White’s first question, but I do not think that we got a clear answer to it.Mr Emery, why did you seek legal advice on whether you had jurisdiction over HR and finance or whether the act was clear that they came under the chief constable’s control?
I think that I already answered that. I did not seek legal advice with regard to HR and finance; I got legal advice on the interpretation of what the act empowers the 12 members of the board plus me to do. The advice was not concentrated on HR and finance. It is clear that the SPA is responsible for the complete budget—every last penny of it—and, therefore, has an obligation to ensure best value.
So your legal advice does not include advice on whether you have jurisdiction over HR and finance.
It is advice on the act, which says in various places that some things are prescriptive and some things are permissive.
I feel that I have gone round in a dizzy circle on that, but we will see the legal advice anyway and—who knows—we may have to take legal advice on the legal advice.
I ask the witnesses to update us on progress on the proposed reductions in the numbers of police staff.
I am happy to start off on that. We are, I hope, very near agreement. That does not imply any dispute at all. We are simply working through the process of designing a voluntary redundancy and early retirement package, which we hope to get out in the next few weeks. That has to go to the authority’s meeting on 5 December to be agreed, which is entirely appropriate.We are pretty well advanced in designing the proposed structures and staffing numbers for civilian support staff across the service. We have plans showing how many people we would want within HR, finance and our vehicle workshops, for example. To a degree, we still need to discuss where some of those units will be based. We have not finalised that yet, so we are not ready to go to the workforce and the unions to tell them exactly what we have in mind.We have entered negotiations, but we need to get into really detailed discussions with the unions and various representative bodies on our proposals and what they think about them. They have valid opinions and might come back and challenge some proposals or say that there is a better way of making the changes. We must also ask the staff themselves whether they can see a better way of redesigning the service.All that is in train. All eight police forces and the SPSA are experienced at running such processes. I hope that we will take the best experience that we have had of doing that and run a fully engaged and open process that will allow a number of staff to leave the service under voluntary redundancy ahead, I hope, of 1 April. The earlier that we can move people out voluntarily, the quicker we can restructure the organisation and start to make some real savings, which we need to do to hit our budget for 2013-14.
I agree. A number of reform projects for doing things more efficiently have been going on for the past 12 months. We will be talking about a number of different VR options—in fact, Steve and I will meet yet again this afternoon to go through some of that stuff, which we will present to the SPA board on 5 December so that we can move forward. Steve’s point is absolutely correct: we need to get a four-year effect, as far as that is possible, so we need to move rapidly on a VR arrangement.
What reduction in the number of police staff do you anticipate that there will be over the next three financial years?
It is very premature to project that. We hope that quite a few people will seek to look for alternatives to their current employment before 1 April. Over the next two to three years, there will be a number of twists and turns in the road, and it would be premature to speculate on how many people might be affected.
You must be brief, Mr Pearson, because we are all tiring.
I will be very brief. In the context of staffing and the plan for the future, it is evident that in slimming down the executive—the ACPOS members—a substantial number of current posts will go by the wayside. Is there a plan to deal with those executive posts? Can you share any information with us on where we stand on that over the next 12 months? We are talking about significant posts that are a heavy draw on finance.
It is a difficult area.
I am glad that I brought it up.
We are right in the middle of the process. We appointed deputies only on Friday—those appointments were announced publicly yesterday—so we are only starting to identify that there are some individuals who are performing a day job in key leadership posts for whom there will not be a formal place in the organisation after 1 April. The issue is a highly personalised one for a small number of people. That number will increase in the next month, because we will be placing ACCs. I think that we have 15 or 16 applicants for seven posts. As the vast majority of applicants are internal applicants who are in the Scottish system, there will be some displacement there.There is no doubt that, during the business of reform, there will be a need for extra work streams to be carried out. Frankly, it will be for me and the authority to sit down with the director of HR and the director of finance to work out whether there is an exit strategy for the individuals concerned. I will give an example. Let us say that individual A has six months to go before they reach a pensionable retirement date. There is little point, I would suggest, in pursuing the section in the act that allows us to exit that person from the organisation when, in six months’ time, they will be going anyway. That would be the appropriate thing to do. On the other hand, if someone has 18 months, two years or a lot longer to wait, there must be an understanding that the public will get benefit from the continued employment of that individual. I believe that that will be eminently provable for a number of key people for the first little while in the new organisation.We are moving from a situation in which there are eight chiefs, eight deputies and just under 20 ACCs to a situation in which there will be one chief, four deputies and seven ACCs. One of the deputies and one of the ACCs will focus specifically on the Commonwealth games and other major sporting events so, in time, that number may reduce again. We are talking about a significant reduction in senior management. That is my view. My caveat is that the authority needs to see the proposals. That is what we are interviewing against. Time has pushed us to go ahead and do that. I am grateful to the chair of the authority for allowing us to do that. If we had had to wait until December to advertise any of the posts, we would be in trouble by now.
So a bit of thought is being given to the issue.
Thought is being given to it. We are balancing the need to treat individuals with respect with the need to treat public money with respect.
Indeed. Thank you.
It would be really nice to finish on a harmonious note. I know that Rod Campbell and Alison McInnes still have questions that they want to ask, but I suggest that we invite everyone back after 5 December, subject to their commitments, when we can have further questioning, if that is necessary. By that time, we will have seen the legal advice and we may have taken our own legal advice—who knows? We have had a fair crack at the issue; we have gone on for an hour and 40 minutes.I notice that the witnesses were calling each other “Vic”, “Steve” and “Andrew” at the end of the discussion, so the chemistry on the Justice Committee must be doing something. We can only hope that you come to a reasonable agreement on the directors of finance and HR in the interests of the Scottish public. Thank you very much for your evidence.11:40 Meeting suspended.
11:40 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Nov 2012 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Police Reform Evidence session · 269
- 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 33
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.