1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01241)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 9
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 4
The record
18 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01241)
I am sure that the whole chamber will want to join me in sending our warmest congratulations to Pope Francis—the first ever Pope from Latin America—on his election. His election will be a great encouragement to our Catholic community, who are such an important and highly valued part of the fabric of Scotland. The Pope’s first message, in which he urged greater bonds of understanding between peoples and nations, is one that will resonate around the world. We wish the church well under the new leadership of Pope Francis. [Applause.]
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
I join the First Minister in welcoming the new Pope and send him every good wish in the times ahead. We recognise the particular importance that the Pope’s election has for the Catholic community in Scotland.
Last week, a document that the First Minister did not want the people of Scotland to see revealed that what he and his ministers say in private is different from what they say in public. It was revealed that his finance minister and his chief economic adviser think that forecasting oil revenues is so difficult that, privately, John Swinney questions the affordability of pensions.
John Swinney’s private words holed the First Minister’s public position below the waterline so, after a feverish weekend and a hastily arranged press conference, the First Minister declared—from nowhere—an oil boom. Does the First Minister not think that we can see the join?
Last week, a document that the First Minister did not want the people of Scotland to see revealed that what he and his ministers say in private is different from what they say in public. It was revealed that his finance minister and his chief economic adviser think that forecasting oil revenues is so difficult that, privately, John Swinney questions the affordability of pensions.
John Swinney’s private words holed the First Minister’s public position below the waterline so, after a feverish weekend and a hastily arranged press conference, the First Minister declared—from nowhere—an oil boom. Does the First Minister not think that we can see the join?
I am glad that Johann Lamont thinks that the powers of the Scottish Government are such that it can present the detailed “Oil and Gas Analytical Bulletin” in the course of a weekend.
Unfortunately, Johann Lamont does not seem to remember that, two weeks ago at First Minister’s question time, I said:
“The Scottish Government will shortly publish the first in a series of analytical bulletins on oil and gas. The new analysis demonstrates the vast potential that remains.”—[Official Report, 28 February 2013; c 17161.]
Much as I welcome the accolade that the Scottish Government is so efficient that we can produce such a serious and detailed analysis over the course of a weekend, I have to say that the statement that I made two weeks ago should have given people a clue—if they had been listening—that the oil and gas bulletin was about to appear.
Why do not we leave it to the independent, impartial commentator, Douglas Fraser of the BBC, to comment on the matter? On 12 March, he said:
“If, as his critics claim, it was conjured out of thin air as a response to last week’s events, then some of the first minister’s team are not bad at magic.”
Unfortunately, Johann Lamont does not seem to remember that, two weeks ago at First Minister’s question time, I said:
“The Scottish Government will shortly publish the first in a series of analytical bulletins on oil and gas. The new analysis demonstrates the vast potential that remains.”—[Official Report, 28 February 2013; c 17161.]
Much as I welcome the accolade that the Scottish Government is so efficient that we can produce such a serious and detailed analysis over the course of a weekend, I have to say that the statement that I made two weeks ago should have given people a clue—if they had been listening—that the oil and gas bulletin was about to appear.
Why do not we leave it to the independent, impartial commentator, Douglas Fraser of the BBC, to comment on the matter? On 12 March, he said:
“If, as his critics claim, it was conjured out of thin air as a response to last week’s events, then some of the first minister’s team are not bad at magic.”
Our problem is that, too often, we listen but never hear an answer to the serious questions that the First Minister’s own document challenges us with. He says one thing in private and something else in public. Whatever he said on Monday does not address that problem.
The oil boom that was announced on Monday drowned the credibility of the First Minister’s chief economic adviser, Crawford Beveridge, and of his finance minister.
Let us move on to another of the First Minister’s advisers, Professor John Kay. He said:
“Scotland should be ready to adopt an independent currency.”
He also said that a new currency would have to be adopted quickly, or people could move their money out of Scotland before it was launched.
Does the First Minister agree with his adviser, or will he now rule out a separate Scotland having its own currency?
The oil boom that was announced on Monday drowned the credibility of the First Minister’s chief economic adviser, Crawford Beveridge, and of his finance minister.
Let us move on to another of the First Minister’s advisers, Professor John Kay. He said:
“Scotland should be ready to adopt an independent currency.”
He also said that a new currency would have to be adopted quickly, or people could move their money out of Scotland before it was launched.
Does the First Minister agree with his adviser, or will he now rule out a separate Scotland having its own currency?
In my answer to the first question—from which we have quickly moved on, I notice—I pointed out that, two weeks ago, I told the chamber that the oil and gas bulletin was about to be published.
From her second question, Johann Lamont does not seem to have read the report of the fiscal commission that was assembled over the course of a year and which has two Nobel laureates on it. That report explained exactly the best policy for Scotland on the currency and a Sterling area. I think that it was published four or five weeks ago, so I must conclude that not only does Johann Lamont not listen to what I say at First Minister’s question time, but she has not bothered to read the fiscal commission’s report.
That is exactly why we commissioned that serious piece of work: it puts forward the Government’s policy in a serious and comprehensive way.
I say to Johann Lamont that her difficulty is in trying to give the impression or to argue that, uniquely among the countries of the world, this nation of Scotland—with its immense natural and human resources—is somehow incapable of running its economy and society rather better than the disaster that is emanating from Westminster.
From her second question, Johann Lamont does not seem to have read the report of the fiscal commission that was assembled over the course of a year and which has two Nobel laureates on it. That report explained exactly the best policy for Scotland on the currency and a Sterling area. I think that it was published four or five weeks ago, so I must conclude that not only does Johann Lamont not listen to what I say at First Minister’s question time, but she has not bothered to read the fiscal commission’s report.
That is exactly why we commissioned that serious piece of work: it puts forward the Government’s policy in a serious and comprehensive way.
I say to Johann Lamont that her difficulty is in trying to give the impression or to argue that, uniquely among the countries of the world, this nation of Scotland—with its immense natural and human resources—is somehow incapable of running its economy and society rather better than the disaster that is emanating from Westminster.
It says quite a lot about what the First Minister thinks an answer to a question is if he imagines that what he said even began to respond to the question that I asked. We are arguing not about Scotland’s resources but about the First Minister’s risk-rich, assertion-rich and fantasy-rich plans for our country.
I note that the First Minister has not ruled out the question of a separate Scottish currency, which he used to want. Then he wanted the euro. Now the line is that we will keep sterling.
Professor Kay has made the point that any new currency would have to be launched suddenly; otherwise, wealth might flow out of Scotland before it was launched. It would be a gift for spivs and speculators. In a sense, perhaps it is something that the First Minister could not commit to publicly. Has he had any private conversations about a separate Scottish currency with Professor Kay or anyone else?
I note that the First Minister has not ruled out the question of a separate Scottish currency, which he used to want. Then he wanted the euro. Now the line is that we will keep sterling.
Professor Kay has made the point that any new currency would have to be launched suddenly; otherwise, wealth might flow out of Scotland before it was launched. It would be a gift for spivs and speculators. In a sense, perhaps it is something that the First Minister could not commit to publicly. Has he had any private conversations about a separate Scottish currency with Professor Kay or anyone else?
I have had conversations with a range of people, including the fiscal commission. It came up with what it believes is the best policy for Scotland, which is the policy of the Government and has been for a considerable time.
Johann Lamont says that we have changed our policy over the years. Yes, I can remember someone—what was his name again? He was a shadow secretary of state and Secretary of State for Scotland—he was called Alistair Darling. I remember him telling the House of Commons that not joining the euro would impose extraordinary costs on the economy. I remember Tony Blair saying that it was time to join the euro. I even remember Kenneth Clarke arguing for that. I remember all those things, so I think that Johann Lamont is on shaky ground in suggesting that we should look for policy consistency over 20 years from the Labour Party. It has not been evident.
The policy that the Scottish Government puts forward is that of being part of a sterling area, which we have debated many times. The fiscal commission—with its two Nobel laureates—consolidated and put forward that policy. That seems to be a great deal more examination and presentation than has ever been managed by the Labour Party or its unionist friends in Scotland.
Johann Lamont says that we have changed our policy over the years. Yes, I can remember someone—what was his name again? He was a shadow secretary of state and Secretary of State for Scotland—he was called Alistair Darling. I remember him telling the House of Commons that not joining the euro would impose extraordinary costs on the economy. I remember Tony Blair saying that it was time to join the euro. I even remember Kenneth Clarke arguing for that. I remember all those things, so I think that Johann Lamont is on shaky ground in suggesting that we should look for policy consistency over 20 years from the Labour Party. It has not been evident.
The policy that the Scottish Government puts forward is that of being part of a sterling area, which we have debated many times. The fiscal commission—with its two Nobel laureates—consolidated and put forward that policy. That seems to be a great deal more examination and presentation than has ever been managed by the Labour Party or its unionist friends in Scotland.
Despite the touch of amateur dramatics about that, the First Minister still did not answer the question. We know that Alex Salmond is known for his insults, but the problem—which is worse—is that he is insulting the intelligence of the people of Scotland.
Let me get this right. In private, the First Minister and his colleagues question whether there will be a state pension; in public, he cannot tell pensioners—[Interruption.]
Let me get this right. In private, the First Minister and his colleagues question whether there will be a state pension; in public, he cannot tell pensioners—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Obviously, Scottish National Party members have still not read the document that was leaked to the rest of us.
In private, the First Minister and his colleagues question whether there will be a state pension; in public, he cannot tell pensioners what currency it would be paid in if it existed. He asserts—[Interruption.]
In private, the First Minister and his colleagues question whether there will be a state pension; in public, he cannot tell pensioners what currency it would be paid in if it existed. He asserts—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The First Minister asserts that we could keep sterling, but what would he do if the deal that was on offer from the Bank of England was unacceptable? What would he do if the fiscal constraints were too tight? What would he do if strings were imposed by London? [Interruption.] Would he go for a separate Scottish currency? [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. [Interruption.] Order—we will hear the member. [Interruption.] Order. Ms Sturgeon.
It is astonishing that asking serious questions creates the degree of derision among SNP back benchers—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order—there is too much shouting.
Of course, we know that they are never allowed to ask any of those questions of their front benchers, even if they know in their heart of hearts that their front benchers are incapable of answering them.
Would the First Minister go for a separate Scottish currency or join the euro? His own advisers say that he would need a plan B, and we are entitled to know what that is. He must have one in private; it is time that he made it public.
Would the First Minister go for a separate Scottish currency or join the euro? His own advisers say that he would need a plan B, and we are entitled to know what that is. He must have one in private; it is time that he made it public.
I differ from Johann Lamont in that she does not have a plan A, never mind a plan B.
On the reason for the hilarity about the strings pulled from London, I say seriously to Johann Lamont that I suspect that she voted for the Iraq war because strings were pulled from the Labour Party in London.
We are in favour of Scotland continuing in a sterling area, and we set out the reasons for that in the fiscal commission report, which, by any estimation, is a huge and serious piece of analysis.
That is the third time that I have answered Johann Lamont’s question. The key point that she has made and the scaremongering attack are about pensions. I point out three things to her. First, Scotland currently spends less on social protection as part of our total national product than the United Kingdom as a whole. In other words, we are better able to afford welfare and pensions than the UK at the moment.
Secondly, does Johann Lamont have no awareness of what is happening to pensions in the United Kingdom? Private sector and public sector pensions are being seriously jeopardised and undermined by the current Administration.
The third point is the key one. What other country in the world would have a unionist coalition suggesting that the immense wealth to flow from Scotland’s natural resources is somehow a handicap and a problem, instead of what every other country in the world sees it as: an opportunity to combine our natural and human resources to be used in an economically successful and prosperous Scotland?
On the reason for the hilarity about the strings pulled from London, I say seriously to Johann Lamont that I suspect that she voted for the Iraq war because strings were pulled from the Labour Party in London.
We are in favour of Scotland continuing in a sterling area, and we set out the reasons for that in the fiscal commission report, which, by any estimation, is a huge and serious piece of analysis.
That is the third time that I have answered Johann Lamont’s question. The key point that she has made and the scaremongering attack are about pensions. I point out three things to her. First, Scotland currently spends less on social protection as part of our total national product than the United Kingdom as a whole. In other words, we are better able to afford welfare and pensions than the UK at the moment.
Secondly, does Johann Lamont have no awareness of what is happening to pensions in the United Kingdom? Private sector and public sector pensions are being seriously jeopardised and undermined by the current Administration.
The third point is the key one. What other country in the world would have a unionist coalition suggesting that the immense wealth to flow from Scotland’s natural resources is somehow a handicap and a problem, instead of what every other country in the world sees it as: an opportunity to combine our natural and human resources to be used in an economically successful and prosperous Scotland?
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 14 Mar 2013 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- National Health Service (Bullying) Questions · 6
- Vion Food Group (Acquisition) Questions · 4
- Independence Referendum (Civic Society) Questions · 4
- Creative Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Congenital Heart Disease (Standards of Care) Questions · 4
- Air Source Heat Pumps Questions · 4
- Energy Skills Academy (Location) Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Disability Benefits Tribunals (Medical Information) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Prisons (Contraband) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Business Growth First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Miners’ Strike (Police Conduct) Members’ business · 47
- Children and Young People Debate · 55
- Local Government Finance (Scotland) Amendment Order 2013 [Draft] Debate · 29
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.