Yes. If we target the early years, there will be budgetary implications. Either we stop doing some of the back-end stuff and allow industry to do that work, while putting money into the early years—because only Government can do that—or we somehow find the resources to do both.
Official Report · Committee
Business Growth Inquiry
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Neil SNP 59
- Christine May Lab 30
- Mike Watson Ind 22
- Alan Wilson Scottish Council for Development and Industry 21
- Mary Greene Financial Services Skills Council 16
- Graeme Ogilvy Construction Industry Training Board 15
- Stephen Boyle Futureskills Scotland 14
- Susan Deacon Lab 13
- Kieron Gavan Sector Skills Development Agency 13
- Iain Duff Scottish Council for Development and Industry 12
- Shiona Baird Green 10
- Murdo Fraser Con 7
- Jamie Stone LD 6
- Dr Michalski 4
- Richard Baker Lab 2
- Dr Wolfgang Michalski Adviser 1
- Stephen Imrie Clerk 1
The record
249 contributions · showing 201–249The paper helpfully provides a much-needed focus for our inquiry and I am pleased that key areas have been identified. Jamie Stone picked up on Wolfgang Michalski's point about dynamic clusters. Our constituency interests come to the fore when we start to consider the regions that should be targeted and of course I think that Aberdeen should be included. However, business and economic growth in Scotland is slowest in peripheral communities, not in cities. It would be interesting and useful to make comparisons with other countries in Europe and to see how clusters have worked there, because many communities here are seeking reassurance.Public sector performance is a key issue. As Wolfgang Michalski said, health spending makes up a huge part of our budget—although if this committee were to sort out the problems in that area we would be going beyond our role. The Executive has identified long-standing problems—for example, Christine May and others spoke about the importance of investment in education.We have heard interesting evidence about the way in which our businesses connect with growing markets abroad. I hope that that can be part of our inquiry, perhaps under the third theme in Wolfgang Michalski's paper.
I welcome Wolfgang Michalski's paper, which gives us a framework for our work. It is useful for us to put our thinking into a broader context. The introduction to the paper is useful in giving us a sense of where we are on the timeline for the transitions that many developed countries are going through.In the title of the paper, and woven through its analysis, is social policy. That is very important. We have teetered on the edge of discussing social policy but I think that we should go a lot further when we move to the next stage of our inquiry. We have to consider social capital, and we have to ask the question that is parallel to the GDP question: what kind of society do we want to live in? Often there is a false juxtaposition with the desire for economic growth. That has been coming through in our discussions and the paper will help us to go further.The convener spoke about education and I have a specific point to make about the early years. One of the committee's papers today quoted Wolfgang Michalski saying that entrepreneurialism is not just about starting businesses but is also about wider cultural issues. If we are talking about building capacity in the early years, we have to be careful that we do not talk only about education. Huge issues arise to do with what goes on in communities and families.The phrase "early intervention" was coined for children who are five or over. However, all the evidence, and all our experience, tells us that the characteristics that will shape behaviours in later life are formed much earlier than the age of five. I was struck by what was said about that in the final evidence session. We have to consider early years but not only education in early years.The five themes in Wolfgang Michalski's paper are helpful. However, I wonder whether we should highlight governance—although we might come on to discuss it anyway, without any particular need to highlight it. It would come under themes 4 and 5. As I have said before, devolution is part of the tapestry of the context within which we now operate. He spoke about the machinery of devolution, but it goes wider than that. It is about the decision-making process—not just its machinery and rules, but its culture, ethos, speed of operation and so on. That is a different question, but it is linked to that of public sector performance. I wonder whether we need to find an explicit place for those governance issues in the inquiry.I also have some thoughts about the process of where we go from here, but I will end my reflections on the paper there.
When we come to discuss the forward work programme, I will bring you in again.
I return to what I said earlier about the challenges that we face in the 21st century, which is an aspect that is missing from the paper. We are not even beginning to look at the challenges of climate change and oil consumption at its peak, yet those issues will have a dramatic effect on the way in which the world economic climate develops in future years. I gather that Italy has started to look at the transition, but are we even beginning to do so? The issue needs to be at the centre of our radar. The paper gives the committee a wonderful opportunity to look forward to see what will be the real challenges to the economy in future—I assume that we are talking about the next decade or two.
I have two points to raise. Like everyone else, I think that the five priority themes are useful. I am particularly drawn to the first theme on demography, migration and so on. Wolfgang Michalski has rightly identified the fact that, although we train a lot of people, we do not get the benefit of doing so. Is there any way of finding out how many of our young people leave to gain or enhance their skills and come back? I suspect that the figure is higher than we imagine. We picked up on the issue from the Irish example. For years, Ireland was entirely about emigration, but nowadays many people are returning to Ireland, particularly those who went to the United States of America a generation ago. How do we take stock of the extent to which that is happening and encourage it in future? Demography is an issue, as are future birth rates. Stephen Boyle said that skills are not the issue, as demand can largely be met. His point was that somehow we have to increase demand, particularly among employers.My second point concerns what Wolfgang Michalski calls "dynamic clusters". I take Jamie Stone's point that Bremen and Hamburg are not of much relevance to the area that he represents in the Parliament. The inquiry is, of course, a Scotland-wide inquiry and we must consider it in those terms. Dynamic clusters appeal to me in part because I happen to represent a Glasgow constituency, and it is inevitable that many of the economic drivers are in the central belt, but that does not mean that we should ignore other parts of the country.Both of the German examples will be helpful to us in examining dynamic clusters and the idea of the city state, to which Susan Deacon referred. That said, I am not sure that the city state is quite what Wolfgang Michalski meant by a dynamic cluster, although the two are linked. I accept that dynamic clusters also relate to industries or sectors. We can hope to gain something from those ideas. I assume that we will move on to consider what we want to get out of the visits. Certainly, the geography of Sweden or Finland is more diverse than that of Hamburg or Bremen. At the same time, Hamburg and Bremen are devolved parts of a larger country, which makes them more like Scotland, whereas Sweden and Finland are autonomous countries. There, we want to examine not the regions but those countries' model of future business growth.
They are a model for the future.
Not in our lifetime.
Naturally, I will keep the issue that I raised on the back boiler. In fairness to Mike Watson, there is no doubt that Glasgow's economy has a huge effect on parts of the Highlands. One needs only to think of Argyll and Bute, the seat of the new Deputy Minister for Finance and Public Service Reform.
I was talking the other night to Sir Stewart Sutherland about an exercise that he had done. One of the points that he made was that, if we consider the areas with the highest levels of unemployment and deprivation and the lowest levels of educational attainment, the same postcode areas appear almost every time. If greater Glasgow were removed from the Scottish statistics, we would probably perform as well as, if not better than, the OECD level. For my money, the recognition is that a huge chunk of the entire country's population—about one fifth of it is in that city—has a concentrated problem. However, that is not without opportunity.
My point links with your comment. I am struck by the amount of reaction to our adviser's suggestion that we might need to think about the concentration of resources and so on. It is important to keep an open mind. If we decide further down the track that we disagree with a view or if people say that going down that road is politically too difficult, that ought to be explicit. It is important to try awful hard to stay open minded from early on in our discussion—there will be jaggy edges for all of us given our local interests. Something registered with me there.
I think that we all agree with that. One purpose of the visits is fact finding and examining how arrangements have worked.
My comments are on the same theme. None of us has examined the evidence that might exist about the external impact of concentrating on geographical clusters, for example, and how much trickle-down takes place.Another issue is that neither in this country nor throughout Europe are we explicit about the extent to which we are prepared to provide disproportionately large resources for less return to sustain more remote communities. We need to think about the extent to which we are prepared to do that, what return we expect, how we will measure that and when that becomes something that we are not prepared to do because the cost is so out of proportion to the return. That is difficult, particularly politically, but it is worth having broader discussions about.
We need to consider two other issues. One reason why we have a population problem is the relatively low birth rate. France adopted a policy of universal child care and the indications are that that is working, because the birth rate there is rising again. That ties in with the demographic problem, early-years intervention and the point that Susan Deacon made. Universal child care might be a way to tackle two big problems at once. Interruption. Keep an open mind, Susan.The other point is about the labour market. If we made substantial inroads into the 150,000 people who are still unemployed, that would have two effects. First, it would improve tremendously those people's lives and the growth rate of the Scottish economy, as it would become more productive. Secondly, it would go a long way towards tackling the problems that Wolfgang Michalski highlighted of a large proportion of the budget being for consumption and transfers. Unemployment costs the public purse a lot, which is right, because people who are unemployed need help. If that cost were significantly reduced, that would have a substantial impact on the public purse through lower spending and higher revenue. We should not lose sight of the labour market and tackling that residual pool of hard-core unemployment.
Gordon Brown would be pleased to have your support.
I ask Wolfgang Michalski to respond. We are not deciding our position; we are just discussing the framework for where we go from here.
I never know whether the fact that everything in economic and social affairs discussions is dependent on everything else is an advantage or an inconvenience. I fully agree with Christine May that we need to put more emphasis on education, but we need to consider education, the labour market and the budget together, so that we can see the interaction between them. We need to reduce consumption and bring people into work. Education is one of the means of doing that, but there are others.On the possible destinations for the committee's visits, I did not say in my paper that I had covered all the issues for all the destinations. In the paper, I discuss how to deal with peripheral areas in the section on Sweden, but, of course, one could ask the same question about Finland. Hamburg has a remote hinterland, which is in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern in the former East Germany, where the danger for economic development is that it will become more like Sicily than Hamburg. However, I expressly excluded such issues from the sections on Hamburg and Bremen, because I think that in considering those cities we should focus on the issues of competition for investment—both cities have succeeded in attracting modern industries—and on the fact that Hamburg is one of the most prominent examples of a Government succeeding, with the business sector, in converting huge areas that were devoted to old industries such as shipbuilding and harbour facilities into promising areas of new activity. Hamburg has become the second largest container port in Europe and the seventh largest in the world. It did so by using areas that were freed up by the decline of shipbuilding and the scrapping of all the refineries, because today's big tankers cannot reach them. In a huge new project that is now in its terminating phase, the city has also converted part of the harbour into an area of housing, business, offices and so on. In my paper, I also mention companies such as Airbus. In suggesting agendas for the possible destinations, my aim was to cover as much as I could without too much overlap.On the budget, certain transfers will always be needed. In principle, certain transfers are rational—there are policy actions in which one needs to compensate losers because otherwise one will not be able politically to get the actions through. That also applies to health care. My point is that when we consider budgets, we need to avoid the situation that we have with the budgets of the European Commission and the European Community, through which we spend seven times more on defending the past, which is agriculture, than we invest in the ventures of the future, which are in science, technology and innovation.Even if we accept that we have to compensate losers, the focus should be on the future and not on defending past structures that are no longer viable. That does not exclude the possibility that we pay for agriculture where there is an environmental benefit for the country and for the world. The only reason why I did not include climate change as a major issue in my paper is that we are discussing Scottish policies. Climate change is an issue of worldwide perspective and you need to discuss it in fora other than the committee's inquiry into business growth in Scotland.It would be interesting to know how many of the people who leave at a young age come back. I would have reservations if those people were migrants aged over 60 or 65. Such immigration imbalances the structure of the population. One has to consider how many of the people who leave when they are in their 30s come back when they are in their late 40s or early 50s, when they are still active.
I meant economically active.
Yes. The point about declining birth rates and the effectiveness of policy is completely unresolved. In Sweden, there had been a heavily declining birth rate, but suddenly the rate is going up and nobody knows why.
They all got asparagus.
France has a proactive population policy, with all kinds of tax breaks for child care and so on. However, many think that the rising birth rate is a new, short-term trend and is not the result of the policy; there are other explanations for it.I return to issues relating to the economy and society of the future and the interaction between technology, economy and society. Our societies were always co-determined by the underlying technology of the historical period. I have a short definition of the industrial society, which is about mass production, mass consumption and mass government. The question is whether those three things are the machinery that we expect for the future. My view is that the kind of knowledge-intensive society that I foresee for our countries will be determined not by mass consumption, mass production and mass government but by higher degrees of diversification and individualisation, increased flexibility and adaptability and governments that have to react much more rapidly than they do now and which confine themselves increasingly to creating the conditions in which the process of adaptation can take place.In my paper, I did not refer explicitly to the need to review the machinery for the same reason that I did not include a paragraph on the issue of governance. I refer only to governance by governments; there is also governance in families and companies. There is conflict in relation to the challenges that we will have to face in the future and the way that our Governments are organised. Our Governments are still organised in vertical structures with someone responsible for the environment, someone responsible for trade, someone responsible for the economy and so on. The real issues are horizontal. The second thing is that with all the attempts that are made within the present machinery to co-ordinate, we cannot meet the challenge of the future, which is to have decisions made rapidly. The co-ordination process, which is based on the vertical structure, makes decision making increasingly slow.
That has been extremely helpful. There is a lot to think about over the recess. We will also have a paper that will give us a bullet-point list of all the points that were made under each of the major headings in the evidence so that we do not need to wade through every piece of evidence.We must now agree our work programme, including how to proceed with the business growth inquiry. I point out that, this afternoon, the Parliamentary Bureau approved two trips, as the Conveners Group had pared the number of visits down from three to two. The Parliamentary Bureau has approved the trip to Sweden and Finland and the trip to Hamburg and Bremen for sometime after the recess. Wolfgang Michalski and others will be working on arranging appointments with people whom we want to see, but we will have time at our first meeting after the recess to finalise dates and arrangements and to have a serious chat about what we want out of each visit and who is going. We do not have time to discuss any of that tonight, but the fact that we have agreement in principle means that the clerks and others can start the process of planning the visits over the recess.Susan, do you have a specific point about the process for the business growth inquiry?
Yes, I do, although it is also a wider concern about the way in which we handle our work programme. I have an issue with the balance of the programme and individual meetings, which today typifies. I will obviously be influenced by how colleagues feel but, in my view, we place far too much emphasis on protracted evidence-gathering sessions. We keep ending up having the creative discussion and, sometimes, taking our decisions at the tail end of the meeting. Today is an exceptional example of that. I say that with all due respect to those who must grapple with the realities of organising a schedule—and organising us, for goodness' sake. We all have to take some responsibility for the problem—I certainly do; I have a strong sense of it. As far as the inquiry is concerned, we need far more sessions like the one that we have had over the past three quarters of an hour—both in formal, public meetings and in private or at informal meetings—than we do of the more plodding, two and three-hour evidence-taking sessions. I say that with the greatest of respect to the people who are giving us evidence, all of which is interesting—we all get engaged in the discussion once they are here.I know that an away day is scheduled for November, but that is a pretty long way off for it to feed into our thinking process. I know that there will be chances for informal discussions—not least on the visits, on which committee members will reflect and talk to each other. I have referred to my three and a half hours at the Audit Committee this morning and my capacity for creative thought by this stage is limited—please do not say that that is obvious. It would be awfully valuable to get some quality time as a committee sooner rather than later to refine our thinking and decide where we go from here.
I agree, although we have probably come to the end of the oral evidence that we can usefully hear, other than the evidence on education, for which we should be careful whom we ask to come before the committee—do we want someone who considers the future of education and who has some international experience to advise us? I have a suggestion: it is probably time for the committee to have an informal dinner—to go out for a pizza or something similar—so that we can have a much more in-depth discussion of the various issues. That would enable committee members who do not go on a particular visit to help to shape the thinking of those who do or, at least, to influence what committee members do on trips.
I am perfectly happy to do that, although I make the point that the attendance has not been great when we have done such things—I refer to the visit to Dundee, for example, when there was an informal session.
That is why I suggested dinner. Members have work to do on other committees during the day.
Absolutely, but attendance is sometimes not great at external events. I am happy to do as you suggest, but members must make a commitment that they will attend.
It must be accepted that it was difficult for many members to go on the all-day trip to Dundee, which was on a Tuesday, when other committees meet.
I accept that, but as a general point, attendance has not been great when we have done things outwith the hours of 2 o'clock to 5 o'clock on Tuesdays.
I will treat you all to pizzas.
So why do we not do more of those things between 2 o'clock and 5 o'clock on Tuesdays, which we agreed to do some time ago? That is my point. We should rebalance our efforts and energies.
Members are not disputing that. We want to try to do such things, but it must be remembered that we have to build into the work programme the other things that we must do—we must take evidence on the St Andrew's Day Bank Holiday Bill, for example. I take Susan Deacon's point, but it is not always possible to do such things and meet all our other requirements.Having a dinner or doing something in the evening is a good idea, which we will pursue. We will find out whether we can deformalise meetings a bit more and have more time for informal discussions. There is absolutely no objection in principle to doing so, but we have a wide remit. There is a fair amount of proposed legislation to deal with—there is the St Andrew's Day Bank Holiday Bill and the bankruptcy bill, which will involve months of formal evidence taking that will include very technical evidence. However, I take the point. We will consider how we can do more than is in the proposed work programme.I point out that since the paper was circulated, we have been told that no committee will be allowed to meet on 4 October in the Parliament because of the Carnegie awards. We were not consulted about that. I am in favour of the Carnegie awards, but this is a Parliament and committee work should be done first. We are not an Edinburgh version of the London Palladium. A full committee day will be lost. We could meet on a Monday or a Friday, but that might not be convenient.
Can the committee not meet somewhere other than in the Parliament? Why do we not meet somewhere else nearby?
Should not the people who are going to use the Parliament meet elsewhere?
You are right to ask that, but if that is not possible and no committee meeting can take place in the Parliament, let us hold a committee meeting somewhere else. We could meet in the Holyrood Hotel or the Tun, for example. We should not simply accept that we cannot meet on 4 October.
I think that we would need to obtain permission to do so from the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body and the Parliamentary Bureau.
If the committee wanted to have a formal meeting outwith the Holyrood campus, it would have to be approved, but I would be happy to look into the matter. Obviously, broadcasting, official report and security people would have to come along with us.
Committees regularly meet outwith the Parliament and we could meet outwith it too. I do not think that the committee has ever met outside Edinburgh. Committees should not be entirely Edinburgh-based.
link
We went to Campbeltown.
That is right—there was indeed a formal session in Campbeltown.
Some time ago, we agreed that one of our November meetings should be in the Highlands, so we had better keep that promise. That should also be in the paper.We will take on board the points that have been made by Susan Deacon and Christine May and will consider organising a round-table discussion in the evening in an atmosphere that will allow us to have a discussion without interruption.Bearing in mind those suggestions, are members happy with the work programme?
There is a minor point that I thought that Richard Baker might have made. I do not want to go on to another subject, but we said that the football inquiry should be wrapped up before the October recess. I see that it will not be and that it will continue until at least the middle of November. I presume that there is no way around that.
There is a possible problem with the meeting on 4 October, when we were to take a fair amount of evidence.
I simply wanted to make the point.
I hoped that the inquiry would be finished by now. There is no argument for its not being finished, if we look at the work programme.
I think that we all agree that one of the problems is that the committee's remit in covering the work of two departments is too wide. We had hoped to start the employability inquiry some time after the recess, but there is no way in which we can start it this year. We will juggle a bit more and see what else we can accommodate, but it is obvious that there are certain commitments that we must meet.
We had talked about that inquiry and I had noted that it had slipped.
We will consider how it could be brought forward, but that does not look possible at the moment.I wish everybody a happy recess and look forward to seeing you on 6 September, which is when the committee will next meet.
Meeting closed at 17:40.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jun 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Culture Committee Tuesday 28 June 2005 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 5
- Business Growth Inquiry Evidence session · 249
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.