Our third new petition is PE1452, by Vince Mills, on the people’s charter. Members have a note from the clerk and a SPICe briefing on the petition. I welcome to our meeting Elaine Smith MSP, who has an interest in the petition.I also welcome our witnesses, Vince Mills and John Foster, and thank them for coming along. I will ask Mr Mills to make a short presentation, of around five minutes, after which Elaine Smith can make some supporting comments. I will then ask a couple of questions before I ask for further questions from colleagues.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
People’s Charter (PE1452)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Vince Mills People’s Charter Scottish Committee 16
- David Stewart Lab 12
- Chic Brodie SNP 12
- John Foster People’s Charter Scottish Committee 7
- John Wilson SNP 4
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
- Anne McTaggart Lab 2
- Elaine Smith Lab 1
The record
56 contributionsI thank the committee for inviting us to present evidence here today. I will briefly set out the aims of the people’s charter and explain what we hope to achieve by petitioning the Parliament.The people’s charter should be seen primarily as a response to, and a refutation of, the politics of austerity. The charter outlines six key areas where we need to build a better life for the vast majority of the Scottish people. Those areas include: expanding the economy; creating more jobs; building decent homes; delivering good public services; and bringing about more equality and peace. The supporters of austerity will give us: recession; fewer jobs; poor services for the poor and decent services only for the rich; and greater inequality and continuous conflict. We would argue that that is precisely what is happening throughout Europe and the UK at present.The people’s charter is non-party political. It seeks support from people across all parties and all sections of society. The charter fully supports the “There is a Better Way” campaign of the Scottish Trades Union Congress, which also supports the people’s charter. We can therefore speak with some confidence when we say that we have the support of the organised labour movement in Scotland.On cuts in public expenditure, the people’s charter is absolutely clear that it opposes all cuts, whether they come from Holyrood or Westminster and even if they are delivered more slowly and less deeply than those that are currently being driven through by the UK Conservative and Liberal Democrat Government. We believe that the financial crisis that we are experiencing is the fault of profit-driven financiers, not ordinary people. Therefore, the majority of the Scottish people should not have to pay the price for the financiers’ greed. Instead, increased taxation and growth through increased public ownership and public spending are fairer ways out of the crisis.The specific measures that we suggest in the petition are examples of the kind of things that the Scottish Parliament could do to reverse the politics of austerity and inequality; they are certainly not an exhaustive list. On housing, for instance, we believe that there is a real need to go beyond the measures that we have suggested in our petition as a matter of some urgency.We have produced a document, which I believe the clerk has passed to committee members. In that, we have listed the committees that we believe may be able to take forward our proposals. We hope that the Public Petitions Committee will decide to forward our demands to those committees.Thank you for listening. We will do our best to answer any questions that you may have.
I thank the convener and committee members for allowing me to attend and to say a few words in support of PE1452 on the people’s charter. I should start by declaring an interest as a member of the Scottish organising committee of the people’s charter. I am also a member of Unite the union.I commend the people’s charter organising committee on bringing the petition to the Scottish Parliament in this way. I note that the charter has the support of many of Scotland’s trade unions as well as the STUC. The six demands are not radical demands but provide simple and achievable steps to start putting people first, before profit-driven financiers, at this time of austerity. The charter provides a commonsense approach that would allow us to move from arguing about whose cuts are the most vicious to instead concentrating on delivering more public sector building projects, creating better jobs and tackling poverty and inequality. The alternative to that seems to be unemployment, cuts and more despair.As the people’s charter representatives have said, the petition gives specific examples of practical measures that the Scottish Government could take, which the various parliamentary committees could perhaps look at in more depth. Once again, I welcome the petition’s arrival at the Parliament and thank the committee for its consideration of it.
Thank you very much. On a technical point—I am not prejudging the committee’s decision later on—we can refer the petition only to one other committee, so we cannot refer it to five different committees. However, not to worry, as we will discuss that later.Obviously, I congratulate the petitioners on the work that they have done on the people’s charter—I think that the petition includes 1,000 signatures collected offline to date. For the record, I attended one of the earlier people’s charter events and I am a member of Unison, which has signed up to the charter.Mr Foster should feel free to add his contribution at any stage.My first question is on the suggestion about social impact assessments for procurement, which I found quite interesting. Can you say a little bit more about how those might work in practice?
Sorry, convener, which number is that?
The suggestion is that, in the public sector in particular, there should be an assessment of the social impact of procurement decisions at each stage. That is mentioned in paragraph 5 of your letter.
Do you mean in reference to local authorities?
Yes.
Nowadays, this issue tends to come under the term “needs budgets”, which is why I was a bit slow in responding to you.Essentially, our concern is about the downward pressure on local authority budgets that has existed for some time. There are a number of reasons for that pressure, including the council tax freeze and the UK budget cuts. We think that it is important that local authorities make it clear to the wider public the implications of those pressures on what they need to spend, as opposed to what they are able to spend, so that people can make a proper assessment of the impact of the reductions in local authority budgets on local services.
My final question relates to the interesting comments on employee participation, which obviously has a long pedigree. When we took evidence previously from trade union colleagues and academics on employee involvement in the public sector, they highlighted how, although in one sense everyone talks a good game about employee participation, there is a great danger of having a very top-down management model in the public sector. Can you say a little bit more about employee participation and how that would work?
I am happy to do so. We argue that employee participation should go beyond the public sector. Back in 1975, the Bullock report argued for what would now be seen as a fairly radical model whereby overarching boards, with 50:50 representation from management and unions, would run enterprises. That is the kind of radical solution that we hope the Scottish Parliament might want to explore. Of course, that is not the only form of economic democracy. For example, trade union ownership of pension funds and worker ownership of company shares would also be within the compass of the proposals that we think should be considered.
Mr Foster, do you have anything to add?
On that subject, I would simply reiterate what Mr Mills has already said. However, I would like to make a contribution on housing at some point.
Good morning, Mr Mills and Mr Foster. Having read your proposal and your petition, I have some difficulty because the things that you have listed, such as fairer jobs, are what get me up in the morning. Personally, I agree with more employee participation; in fact, I effectively introduced that into some of the companies where I was a troubleshooter before I came to this place. I am sure that the charter’s proposals are well meant and well intended, but on a personal level I struggle to see how, in a democracy in which we have an effective Opposition, those points are not already being raised. For example, I am also a member of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, which has heard Stephen Boyd make similar points. I struggle to see where the charter is different from what we do in electing Governments and Oppositions, which raise those issues under the democratic umbrella. Where is it different?
I think that you are making the easy assumption, which can be challenged, that political parties necessarily represent what the vast majority of people believe in. For example, it is clear that the trade unions—
But that is what elections are about. People stand at elections and go through the democratic process.
That may be what elections are about, but you are making the assumption that political parties represent what the electorate demand.
I am not making any assumption, Mr Mills. I have been through the process—
If you are not making that assumption, the question that you asked does not make sense.
Okay, you go ahead and say what the assumption is.
The assumption is that there is a direct relationship between what political parties argue for and what the electorate want. However, the clear evidence of the people’s charter—which the STUC supports—is that political parties are not arguing for those things.
I beg to differ. As I said, I get up in the morning to try to make these things better for our fellow citizens. If you like, I am trying to follow a people’s charter, believing in what people need and want. Where are you different from the democratic process?
It is a question of broadening democracy, not narrowing it. I do not accept that you are advocating these things. For example, do you advocate bus regulation?
If there is an issue with that and with the policy that we set, and the Opposition agrees that there is, it can raise questions through the democratic process.
My point is that there is clearly a democratic breakdown, because despite the demand for the kind of thing that I indicated, there is no evidence of it being dealt with properly in the Scottish Parliament.
There are some economic issues, which I will not go through, regarding arguments that we have had about funding and so on. However, there are clearly sets of priorities. You are trying to have an add-on to the democratic process, but if Oppositions and Governments are working effectively—I repeat that that is why I get up in the morning and come here—I do not see the value-added of what you want.
If there were absolutely no other social pressures on political parties that shaped the policies that they advocated and there was a direct line between political parties and the electorate, I think that your argument would be sound. However, given the number of pressures that exist—for example, I note that through Neil Findlay the Parliament will explore the issue of lobbying—and the fact that political parties are obviously also shaped by interests other than the democratic one, it is not valid to argue that the Scottish Parliament deals absolutely democratically with all the issues that are of concern to the Scottish people.
I disagree. In terms of—
May I just come in on this? I think that one of the great strengths of the Scottish Parliament—certainly in its original vision—was the extent to which it responded to civic Scotland. It saw within the horizon both the political parties and civic Scotland, including the trade union movement, which it regarded as an important part of the democratic process.On the specific issue of employee participation, I think that you would agree that that has not in any way been taken forward with the effectiveness that it should have been—
In your opinion.
In my opinion, but I would have thought possibly in your opinion too, because you argue that you have to push that. We all know of structures of employment that are certainly not fulfilling those perspectives, to the great detriment of the employees and probably the overall functioning of the institutions, too. For that reason, I would have hoped that you would have welcomed on this issue—and on others, perhaps—the extent to which the organisations of civic Scotland have supplemented the pressures to take the issue forward.
Yes—civic Scotland and the trade unions all play an important part, which is why we try to have an open Parliament, with meetings like this and witnesses at other committees. Is it perfect? No. However, I still question what the value-added would be of having the charter in relation to the engagement with civic Scotland and our political process. The charter is well meaning—I am not demeaning that—but I do not see where it would add value. Of course, it would add value because input from everybody is important. However, in terms of enacting the charter’s demands—I will repeat this, then stop—what gets me up in the morning are the issues of jobs for people, a fairer economy, reducing the income gap and participation, even within the economic constraints that we have.
I welcome the petitioners to the Public Petitions Committee. I declare an interest in that I was a signatory to the charter and I have known the petitioners for a few decades, or perhaps slightly longer.Various issues have been raised in the present discussion. For example, in relation to John Foster’s comment about the Parliament being more open to the people, Chic Brodie made the point that the Public Petitions Committee is a commitment to that openness because it allows individuals and organisations to submit and speak to petitions.Irrespective of my membership of a particular political party, I am generally supportive of all the objectives in the charter. However, I think that there are issues around the political party element, because I do not think that any political party has fully signed up to the charter. Individuals from the political parties have signed up to it, but I am not aware of a political party that has done so.11:00
I have a couple of questions on the charter objectives. Section 2 of the original written submission refers to “More and better jobs” and makes the quite laudable comment, “Reduce hours, not pay.” We should not reduce hours and reduce incomes. However, you also talk about a minimum wage of half the national median earnings. Can you remind me what the national median earnings are at present?
No, I cannot.We are focusing on the specific suggestions that we made in the petition today rather than the overarching petition to which you were referring, which was not really the subject of this particular discussion.
I am trying to explore that point in the light of the Scottish living wage campaign—the Scottish Government and the majority of the parties in the Parliament have accepted the Scottish living wage objective of £7.45 an hour. I am trying to put that in the context of median earnings in the UK. From my rough calculations, the minimum wage is unfortunately about half the national median earnings but clearly it is not enough of an income to satisfy the basic needs of the majority of people who are on the minimum wage.I know that John Foster is interested in housing, particularly social or local authority housing. In the past five years, the Scottish Government has attempted to reinvigorate the social rented housing market and has openly encouraged local authorities to build council housing, which had been diminishing for about a decade. Local authorities are now increasing their stock, unfortunately at a time when stock is being sold off under the right to buy. Can we generate enough of an interest among local authorities so that they use their borrowing powers to increase council housing stock throughout the country, bearing in mind that Glasgow has no housing stock because it transferred the stock to Glasgow Housing Association a number of years ago?
A number of other local authorities have unfortunately done something similar. However, that avenue could certainly be adopted and the people’s charter would support local authorities that went down that road.A key issue is the immediate and long-term impact of the housing benefit changes on the viability of the entire social housing sector—both local, community-based housing associations and council housing. In Govan, where I am involved in the community council and I am secretary of the tenants association, the future viability of the three local community-based housing associations is seriously threatened by the changes in housing benefit regulation. In particular, it is threatened by the so-called bedroom tax, whereby there will be massive cuts in housing benefit—up to 25 per cent for having two unoccupied bedrooms and 14 per cent for having one unoccupied bedroom. The three housing associations in our area estimate that around 500 people will be in that category and will find their housing benefit cut to that degree within the next 12 months. It is an urgent problem for them.We have also been faced with a cap in housing benefit of 1 per cent that will be imposed from April next year. In terms of the overall population on housing benefit, that will generate deficiencies in the ability to pay rent, resulting in evictions of around 5 or 6 per cent within a couple of years because of the increase in rents.Those are big problems for the whole social housing sector and they are very serious problems for tenants. A meeting that was held a couple of weeks ago in Govan was attended by almost 100 people. People are being told that they will be evicted if they cannot pay the rent. There are not enough one-bedroom or two-bedroom houses within the social sector and very large numbers of people will be affected.That is an immediate issue. One of the aims of the people’s charter for Scotland is to say that the Scottish Parliament has certain powers and a certain amount of financial resource—although not very much—but in some areas, it can use those powers to the benefit of people or at least, in the current circumstances, to prevent great hardship. We propose that, in place of eviction, Scottish housing law should be amended to enable the normal course of debt collection to kick in rather than automatic eviction for significant rent arrears in the case of the bedroom tax.We also suggest that consideration should be given to rent regulation for the private sector. In Glasgow, one of the certain consequences of the new regulations—they have not been thought through at all, and I am sure that this applies in other cities and areas, too—is that people will be forced into the private housing sector. When people are evicted and become homeless, there is not enough accommodation in the social rented sector so they will be forced into the private sector.Inquiries by the Scottish Parliament have shown that the private rented sector is extremely uneven in the way in which it practises any care for tenants. There are areas in which landlords are totally unscrupulous and in which we can expect rents to be pushed up. That is why we argue that the Scottish Parliament has powers over housing legislation that would permit the regulation of rent, and a cap on rent increases that could be in line with the 1 per cent increase in housing benefit and which would offset the ability of unscrupulous landlords to exploit the situation.Those are our two specific proposals.
Thank you for that explanation of your proposal.You opened by talking about the welfare and benefits reforms that Westminster is pushing through. The Scottish Government can make changes that will protect only to some extent tenants and other people who depend on public or private sector housing. The main issue is the raft of draconian welfare and benefits reforms that are coming out of Westminster. Housing is one of the areas in which we can see that the levels of rent benefits that could be paid to individuals could be capped and further capped under Westminster’s present system.Apart from the changes that you have suggested, how do you think the Scottish Government could protect people from the worst excess of a Westminster Government that is following a policy of massive public sector cuts as well as cutting benefits, all of which will impact on many citizens? The figure that is being quoted is something like a £2.5 billion loss of income for the Scottish economy as a result of the welfare reform proposals that are coming out of Westminster. How can the present or a future Scottish Government protect individuals against a Westminster Government that has the fiscal powers to impose such benefit changes?
I suggest that some limited measures could be taken. They were discussed at the meeting in Govan, which was attended by a minister of the Scottish Government and the leader of the Labour Party in the Scottish Parliament. One of those measures was the creation of two funds. The first is a fund that can be made available for acute emergency cases of tenants who are unable to pay their rent; the second is a fund that should be made available to assist housing associations that will find themselves in extremely difficult financial circumstances in a year or two. Those are two practical proposals. Obviously, they are limited by the funds that are available to the Scottish Parliament, but they could be followed.On the overall question, obviously it is a matter of finance. Again, that is a matter for wider debate.
Members will be aware that Parliament has a Welfare Reform Committee. One option is to refer the petition to that committee at some stage.
Indeed. Mr Mills and Mr Foster have raised a number of salient issues so far. It is clear that we could debate them for the rest of the day—and, possibly, all night.I would like to pick up on a point with Mr Mills. Public transport is mentioned in paragraph 4 of the late submission and bus regulation was thrown in a wee while ago. The figures that I have been provided with suggest that it would cost up to £1 billion to renationalise or reregulate bus services, so it is clear that we have a funding issue. A wish list is all very well—I have a lot of sympathy for that—but if the money is simply not available, that creates a difficulty.Paragraph 3 of the late submission mentions housing in particular and the concern“about the lack of social housing”.When I was a Falkirk Council pension fund governor, we initiated investigations into the possibility of using the innovative measure of building social and affordable housing through the pension fund, which would have ticked a lot of boxes. It would have given the pension fund a guaranteed rate of return and would have provided badly needed social housing, which is particularly needed, with up to 8,000 people being on the waiting list in the Falkirk area. What are your views on using pension funds, in particular local authority pension funds, for that purpose? Are you keen to support that approach?
On regulation, I do not have the figures to which you referred, obviously, but the buses currently get a substantial public subsidy. If you are talking about taking bus companies into social ownership—which is not what we are advocating as regulation—I assume that there would be considerable savings to be made over a long time.
Such initiatives would be welcome. They are limited and relatively small scale, but there could be productive results from them in terms of providing more social housing. However, on the people’s charter’s objectives at Britain level, we would certainly argue for creation of a new type of financial and banking system that would be under the public sector’s control and which would therefore be able to channel funds towards infrastructure projects on a much larger scale. That is one avenue by which to solve the Scottish housing problem. It is an expensive problem, but one that it is absolutely necessary that we tackle in the long run.
I believe that pension funds were used perhaps 50 years ago, so we are going full circle.
Rent regulation was also used.
I welcome the panel and declare an interest in that I have signed up to the people’s charter and its aims.I want to pick out paragraph 6 of the late submission, which mentions credit unions. Given that the convener and deputy convener of the cross-party group on credit unions are sitting at the table, perhaps we could take the issue back to that group to see how we could extend what credit unions do.Given the array and complexity of the issues that the petition raises, it might be better to refer it to the Welfare Reform Committee, which the convener mentioned, rather than the other committees that have been discussed, in order to provide a better scope and listening approach.11:15
We would welcome that. I am pleased that Anne McTaggart has picked up on our point about credit unions. As has become painfully obvious, people—especially those in low-income paid employment—are increasingly finding that they need to borrow money at unfavourable rates and sometimes from unsavoury lenders just to survive, so I appreciate that.
We are a little bit short of time. Do any other members wish to contribute?
I have a brief question. What engagement have you had with local authorities? It might surprise you to know that one local authority that is known to me underspent its budget by £7 million last year and had £4 million left after provisions and reserves.Have you engaged with local authorities to understand their financial position and how some of those programmes might be implemented?
We have engaged principally with the trade unions that represent the local government workers. Consequently, the perspective that we are putting forward—and which we share—is that of the local government workers.I do not know to which authority Chic Brodie referred, but I assure you that the trade unions would be most upset about an underspend of that magnitude, given that so many local authorities are currently cutting staff and services.
The trade unions are not the only ones who would be upset.
Colleagues have no more questions.There are a number of options. Normally at this stage, we would ask for more information before taking the next step. Members will recall my initial statement that we cannot refer the petition to more than one committee. Our petitioners have rightly identified a number of committees, and I also identified the Welfare Reform Committee, which would pick up Mr Foster’s point about housing.I ask Anne McTaggart to clarify whether she was talking about a separate committee.
No. I was referring to the Welfare Reform Committee.
We could continue the petition and ask the Scottish Government for its views. When that information comes back, we can make a decision about next steps. Alternatively, we could refer the petition to another committee now. I am in the hands of the committee and am quite relaxed about next steps.
I support continuing the petition with the Public Petitions Committee at present and writing to the Scottish Government. There are a number of other organisations from which I would like to seek opinions in relation to the issues that the petitioner raises. I highlight the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations, given the issues around cuts in pay and conditions in the voluntary sector, which we know has, in some parts, been hardest hit by the current recession.I suggest that we also write to the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations to ask for its views on housing issues; the Chartered Institute of Housing in Scotland, once again to ask about housing, particularly in the private sector because CIHS—believe it or not—sometimes represents private landlord interests as well as other interests; the Confederation of British Industry Scotland; Community Business Scotland Network Ltd; and last, but not least, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities.
If there are no additional suggestions for organisations that we should write to, are members happy with the suggestions from me and John Wilson?Members indicated agreement.
It is unanimously agreed that we will continue the petition and write to those bodies. When the information comes back, we will consider our next steps. The petition will remain active until our next appropriate meeting, which will be when we have the information back.I thank Elaine Smith for coming along and supporting the petition, and Vince Mills and John Foster for giving evidence. The petition is very thoughtful. We will keep it live until we get all the information that we require.11:19 Meeting suspended.
11:20 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Dec 2012 →- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 88
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 47
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 56
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 5
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 9
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.