Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Organ Transplantation (Cancer Risk) (PE1448)

Tuesday 11 December 2012 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30 Petitions 47 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

47 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Our second new petition is PE1448, by Grant Thomson, on improving awareness of the cancer risks in organ transplantation. Members have a note from the clerk and a SPICe briefing on the petition.I welcome our witnesses, Grant Thomson and Sean Argue, and thank them for coming along today. I invite Mr Thomson to give a short presentation of around five minutes. I will then kick off with the first couple of questions, which will be followed by questions from my colleagues. Mr Argue, please feel free to intervene in answer to any questions during the evidence session.

Grant Thomson
link

I have not prepared a written statement as such, as I was not entirely sure what to expect today. To be honest, I would much rather not be sitting here, given the circumstances surrounding the petition. The brief that I was given suggested that I should not go over ground already covered in the petition but perhaps elaborate on certain issues, so I will give a brief résumé.Sean Argue, to my left, was Sharon Argue’s father. Sharon Argue was my partner of 12 years and mother to my two children. She died in July this year, after a short battle with skin cancer. In 2004, Sharon received a kidney transplant—by coincidence the subject of the first petition discussed this morning—but she was never made aware of the risks of developing skin cancer. It struck me, when the question was put to the previous occupants of the chairs that we are sitting in, who have obviously done a lot of research into organ transplants, that that was news to them as well.The reason why I started researching the issue is that, about an hour before Sharon died, the consultant who was treating her commented that it would seem that, unfortunately, the likelihood was that her cancer was caused as a result of the medication that she was taking subsequent to her kidney transplant. She was taking ciclosporin, which is an immunosuppressant medication that prevents the body from rejecting the new organ. He referred to it as chemotherapy. Basically, ciclosporin is an extremely toxic treatment, but it is essential because, if patients are not provided with it, in 99.9 per cent of cases the transplant will fail.Let me be clear that the petition is not a campaign against the use of ciclosporin. In response to a question, the editor of the Evening Times said that he was sure that, if someone was told, “Well, you have six months to live unless you have a transplant, but the downside is that there is a high risk that you will develop skin cancer at some point post op,” they would without doubt take the transplant. I speak for Sharon—unfortunately, she is not here to speak for herself—when I say that I know for a fact that, if she had been told of the risk, even if it were that 80 per cent of patients would get skin cancer, she would still have gone ahead with it. A life on dialysis was not for her—I have seen what that can do to people. However, people who require a heart or a liver transplant do not have that option; if they do not get a transplant, they will die. I reiterate that the petition is not a campaign against the use of ciclosporin, which I suppose we might call a miracle drug. Ciclosporin has given life to tens of thousands of people around the world since its immunosuppressant properties were discovered in the early 1970s. However, there is an issue among both the medical profession and patients about understanding just how toxic and potentially damaging the medication can be.A week after Sharon died, I spent half an hour on Google—I have no medical background at all—doing simple searches on “ciclosporin”, “organ transplant” and “skin cancer”. The information that I presented in the petition came from that search. I still find it hard to believe that there seems to be such a lack of understanding of the matter. I can tell members only about my experience, which is anecdotal evidence, but there is no reason for me to sit here and make things up. Doctors to whom I have subsequently spoken have been shocked by just how high the risk of skin cancer is in transplant patients. A conservative estimate is that, post operation, 35 per cent of patients will develop skin cancer within 20 years; other estimates are that 40 per cent will, rising to 70 per cent in warmer climates.The issue is to do with ultraviolet radiation and the changes that the medication makes within the body when it is taken over a long period. After a person has a transplant, they must stay on the medication for the rest of their life. Its dose can be reduced, but its use has to be maintained indefinitely. Stopping it is not an option. That is my understanding through my uneducated eye from the limited research that I have done in the past four months. There are no alternatives; the medication is a necessity.Three issues have been included in the petition, two of which are about the awareness in the medical profession of how high the risks are, and the awareness among patients of how toxic the medication is that they are taking. Again, I will speak anecdotally, but I have no reason to make up what I am saying. I started a campaign on Facebook and have received messages from people whom I do not know, saying that it is not only organ transplant patients who are prescribed the medication; patients can be prescribed it for severe eczema, psoriasis and autoimmune diseases. People have contacted me to say that they are on the medication, they know somebody who is on it, or their child is on it for another condition, and they had no idea that there was such a risk with its long-term use. It is clear to me that there is a serious issue. People are unaware of the medication’s drawbacks.The third issue is that the warnings and patient information that the pharmaceutical company provides are nowhere near sufficient. The patient information leaflet that is provided with ciclosporin is 25 pages long. Skin cancer is mentioned on the 25th page, but it is listed alongside side effects such as nausea, dizziness and headaches. If a person read a list of the side effects of even common, day-to-day medications such as aspirin, they would probably not take them because they would think, “God, look at all the things that could happen,” but the evidence that I have seen, albeit on the internet, is that the medication in question causes cancer; it is an unavoidable drawback in some people. The substance is a group 1 carcinogen. The fact is that there are no greater health warnings on the medication, and that health professionals are prescribing it without being fully aware of how serious it can be. That needs to change.I have probably run on for a bit longer than five minutes, for which I apologise, but those are the reasons why we started the campaign.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Not at all, Mr Thomson. I know that it must be very painful for both of you to have to come to the meeting. On behalf of the committee, I give you our condolences for the loss that you have experienced.I have a couple of questions and then I will bring in my colleagues. Your petition makes it clear that some health boards have“education and awareness programmes and annual skin screening clinics for patients”and others do not. Have you worked out which health boards provide those things and which do not?

Grant Thomson
link

I received a message from a nephrologist who works in NHS Fife, who contacted me to say that he had read the details on Facebook and that he was dismayed that late diagnosis was still happening. He said that a large part of his job is educating people before and after transplant about how careful they must be when they go out in the sun, including the need to wear long sleeves and wide-brimmed hats, to cover their skin and to check themselves regularly for any abnormalities. He also said that high-factor sun protection is available on free prescription for transplant patients. That, again, was something that we were completely unaware of. This is a bit of a cliché, but I would sum up the situation as a postcode lottery. The doctor—I do not want to name him—asked for a copy of the petition so that he could circulate and sign it and give his backing to the campaign.Unfortunately, NHS Lanarkshire, where Sharon was treated, does not appear to be as switched on as NHS Fife. I do not know why that is. The consultant who treated Sharon up to her death was not a renal consultant but an infections consultant because that was the department she was admitted to. He said that plans had been afoot at Monklands hospital to introduce a skin clinic for transplant patients for some time, but that that had just never happened. I assume that that is, like everything else, a question of time and money. Anecdotally, I was told that dermatology has spoken to that doctor and said that the situation reinforces the need to get the clinic up and running as soon as possible.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I do not think that the postcode lottery is a cliché. The committee’s experience is that it happens quite regularly on a whole variety of health issues that one health board provides treatment and another does not, which makes a lottery of the treatment that people get.My second question is whether patients should be better informed about the risk of skin cancer prior to transplants taking place.

Sean Argue
link

Yes, they definitely should be better informed. Sharon looked after herself quite well. As Grant says, she would have taken the transplant regardless, for a better quality of life. If she had known the risks then, the spot could have been dealt with and it possibly could have been removed before the cancer moved into her bloodstream.

Grant Thomson
link

Sharon developed a small growth on her ear. It looked like a spot, but it turned out to be the primary source of the cancer. As Sean says, Sharon was fastidious about her health. If she had known the risks, she would have had it checked out immediately. In fact, she presented the growth to her renal consultant two weeks before she died.

Sean Argue
link

She met her doctor, who told her that she had an infection and gave her antibiotics. She visited doctors in the Monklands hospital, who said that it was a particular infection and that she should get a certain antibiotic. Before she went to her own doctor, I told her to mention her kidneys because I thought that that was where the pain was coming from. They did some blood tests, increased her iron tablets and asked her to come back the following week. That was when they admitted her and gave her a full check-up. We are talking about a five-month period.

Grant Thomson
link

It was a short time.

Sean Argue
link

Perhaps it was three months.

Grant Thomson
link

Sean is trying to convey that even, dare I say it, the renal specialist who was looking after Sharon thought that the growth—although it caused him concern—was an abscess, but it was skin cancer.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That was obviously a dreadful experience. The committee wants to look at what lessons we can learn for patients in the future and what preventative work can be undertaken.

Grant Thomson
link

Although it is obviously an emotive issue for us, we have tried to keep that out of it as much as possible and to make it clear that it is not a personal issue against a particular health authority or doctor. It is about changing things for the better. 10:30

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I reiterate the convener’s comment that we are sorry for your loss. I hope that we will be able to make progress with the petition and get some answers to the questions that you have raised.In your submission, you highlight the fact that organ transplant patients have a 40 to 70 per cent chance of developing skin cancer. That is quite high. You give some comparisons with the normal population. In relation to the post-transplant medication, do you think that the doctors had enough information or knowledge about the drugs that they prescribed?

Grant Thomson
link

I do not think so.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Mr Argue, you have said quite clearly that if the information about the risks of skin cancer had been made available, your daughter would still have gone ahead with the transplant, but she would have been more aware of the need to check her body for any growths following the procedure. Is there a need for more education, not only for consultants and patients, but for general practitioners?

Sean Argue
link

Yes, there is definitely a need for more education for GPs. The guy who wrote prescriptions for my daughter was not aware of the risks.A big problem for me is that Sharon could probably have been saved if the skin cancer had been picked up earlier. Everyone here will have had spots that they have ignored. If a spot is picked, bleeds and then heals, that is the end of it—there is no problem—but in Sharon’s case, the spot developed its own blood stream. Once it got into her liver, the cancer spread through her body rapidly.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I have no further questions. I wish the petitioners the best of luck.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I add my condolences to those that have already been expressed.On page of 2 of the petition, you say that the doctor advised that“skin cancer was a very common problem in transplant patients”,yet that knowledge does not appear to be that common across the medical profession.Mr Thomson, can you tell us, on the basis of the good work that you have done through googling and so on, what international information is available that supports your position? Have you had contact with people who are involved in melanoma organisations? We know what we are going to do but, on a personal level, how did you raise the profile of your partner’s situation?

Grant Thomson
link

I did that through social media. I contacted various NHS authorities on the matter. I also contacted the health secretary and the First Minister’s office and was told in brief correspondence that it was a constituency issue. My MSP, who is Jamie Hepburn, took up the issue, and I believe that Gregg McClymont, who is the Labour MP for my constituency, wrote a letter to the health secretary about it.I did not receive any feedback from any official body through social media. The feedback that I got was from patient organisations, one of which is based in west London. In my naivety, I had assumed that what had happened to Sharon was—dare I say it—the tip of the iceberg and that similar things were happening throughout the country, but it transpired that that is not the case. We and Sharon were just extremely unfortunate in that the health board in the area that she happened to be in was well behind the game.I heard from the West London Kidney Patients Association, which had received a message from a transplant patient since 2001 who stated that they had had it drummed into them pretty much from day 1 that they constantly had to be very careful and had to check themselves because with this particular medication there was a very high risk of developing skin cancer—

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I am sorry to interrupt, but I have to say that it concerns me that, in this particular and very difficult situation, that comment could be made in isolation. If anyone gets a transplant, sirens should be blaring and they should be told the upside and the downside of the procedure. You are telling us that that does not happen.

Grant Thomson
link

That is correct.

Sean Argue
link

If a GP prescribes the kind of medication that was given to my daughter, something should flash up saying, “Transplant patient—be aware of some risks.”

Grant Thomson
link

Touching on the discussion about the previous petition, I realise that getting through a heart, liver or kidney transplant is a big enough task for people and that they perhaps do not want to know that five, 10 or 15 years down the line they are going to get skin cancer. It is easy to say, but if it were me I would be thinking, “Let’s deal with that five, 10 or 15 years down the line. I just want to be here then.” It is not really a for and against thing but, as you have rightly pointed out, it is very disturbing.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I understand that, but this is a serious matter. After all, pharmaceutical companies spend a lot of money on research. If the problem is this common, we should be asking what research is being carried out in this area.

Grant Thomson
link

I agree completely.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I welcome the witnesses to the meeting and want to say that I am saddened by their loss.I am flabbergasted that such information is not readily available. You will have heard me ask the previous witnesses about their campaign, and it was clear that they were not aware of these side-effects. Indeed, until we read this petition, we were unaware of them. Mr Argue is right to say that that kind of information should be screaming out of screens.

Grant Thomson
link

When you read what is in the petition, you think that it cannot be true. However, the fact that it has the support of medical professionals, especially those in the field of nephrology, speaks for itself. They know that there is an issue that needs to be addressed.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I cannot tell you how much that saddens and angers me. Obviously, this is not about opting in or opting out of having a transplant—you said earlier that Sharon would have continued with it—but about ensuring that the information is available to allow people to make an informed choice with regard to aftercare. One of our duties is to ensure that information about the good and bad aspects of the process is available because, as I have said, people have to be able to make an informed choice.

Sean Argue
link

At the end of October, a friend of mine, Lynn Flower, went to a hospital in Glasgow with her sister, who is waiting for a heart transplant. They gave her all the information about the transplant but said nothing about the risks until Lynn, who is a headteacher, asked about them. The doctor was quite flabbergasted and asked how she knew about that sort of thing and whether she was in the medical profession. He just said that it was something to be aware of. There is just not enough information.

Adam Ingram SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

Thank you very much for coming along and presenting your petition. I think that you are providing a great service to the Scottish Parliament, because it is certainly the first time that I have heard about this issue. I understand that the transplant operation took place about eight years ago.

Grant Thomson
link

Yes.

Adam Ingram SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

What kind of follow-up support and provision did your partner have in that time? Were there, for example, any clinics for checking out skin problems and the like?

Grant Thomson
link

If I recollect rightly, post-op she would go fortnightly to have blood taken to check her renal function, that her body was not rejecting the new kidney, and that the kidney was working properly. It was. To all intents and purposes, the operation was a success. Her clinic visits were then reduced to every four weeks or six weeks to check blood levels and that the kidney continued to function. However, no aspect of those consultations was to do with skin checks or that sort of thing.

Sean Argue
link

Sharon got her tests done at Monklands. If there were any problems, they would phone her and she would go back up there and get them done again.

Adam Ingram SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

So everything was done within the Monklands area. There was no reference to consultants elsewhere.

Grant Thomson
link

She was originally in Glasgow but then—I cannot remember the exact date—NHS Lanarkshire established the renal clinic at Monklands. It might have been one or two years after her operation. She transferred there because we lived in Lanarkshire.

Sean Argue
link

She was in Stobhill hospital.

Grant Thomson
link

Yes. She attended Stobhill hospital prior to the operation and the surgical team was at the Western infirmary in Glasgow.

Adam Ingram SNP Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley
link

I find it astonishing that there was no proper communication between the experts in the field and that NHS Lanarkshire did not have a suitable unit set up for that purpose. I understand that it is now setting up such a unit. Is that a consequence of your experience and how you have followed it through?

Grant Thomson
link

I would hazard a guess that NHS Lanarkshire would officially say no to that but, in my opinion, our case is certainly a contributing factor.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry to have to draw things to a close; I am afraid that we are a bit short of time. I have just one question for you to clarify. You said that you wrote to Nicola Sturgeon when she was health secretary. When was that?

Grant Thomson
link

That would have been back in August.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you.This is a sensitive issue and you have brought an important petition to us. It is important for the committee to continue the petition and ask for the views of various organisations such as the Scottish Government, NHS Scotland and NHS Blood and Transplant. Do colleagues have any other suggestions?

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we write to the BMA, and individual health boards about the patient advice that they give to pre-op and post-op clinics. Could we also write to the melanoma society for its views?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are members happy to continue the petition?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank the witnesses for coming along. As you can hear, we are taking a great deal of interest in your petition. Our officials will keep you in touch with how it is going. I know that this must have been a painful event for you; thank you so much for giving up your time.10:43 Meeting suspended.

10:44 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 88
  2. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 47
  3. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 56
  4. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  7. 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  8. 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.