4. To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s position is on the impact on business and tourism of having only one carrier between Scottish airports and Heathrow. (S4F-00845)
Official Report · Chamber
Air Links (Heathrow)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 4
- Colin Keir SNP 2
- John Scott Con 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
The record
8 contributions4. To ask the First Minister what the Scottish Government’s position is on the impact on business and tourism of having only one carrier between Scottish airports and Heathrow. (S4F-00845)
The air links to Heathrow remain vital for business and inbound tourism. The Scottish Government wants a restoration of competition on the routes between Scotland and Heathrow as soon as possible.
I thank the First Minister for his answer. Does he agree that the devolution of air passenger duty, as proposed by the Calman commission, would also increase competition on Scottish routes and be beneficial to not only my constituents in Edinburgh Western, but Scotland as a whole?
Yes, I agree. There is an overwhelming urgency in this matter. I will discuss aviation policy at next week’s meeting of the joint ministerial committee in London. I know that the other devolved Administrations share my view that air passenger duty is an important tool for attracting more direct flights to and from Scotland.
Even if there were to be a new runway at Heathrow—and that is a matter of some extraordinary debate within the coalition and indeed within the Conservative Party—the timescale for it would be extended and elongated and it would not solve the difficulty that we have when Heathrow is clogged up, as happened during the Olympics. It is not just a case of people having difficulty getting to Scotland, but rather that people are deterred from coming to Scotland as a result of the extraordinary congestion in the Heathrow hub.
Therefore, Scotland needs more direct flights and the use of air passenger duty is an important means of ensuring more direct flights. That has broad support across the devolved Administrations and it has extraordinary support among the carriers. It was one of the recommendations of the Calman commission and I hope that I can carry the support of this entire Parliament in making that case in London next week.
Even if there were to be a new runway at Heathrow—and that is a matter of some extraordinary debate within the coalition and indeed within the Conservative Party—the timescale for it would be extended and elongated and it would not solve the difficulty that we have when Heathrow is clogged up, as happened during the Olympics. It is not just a case of people having difficulty getting to Scotland, but rather that people are deterred from coming to Scotland as a result of the extraordinary congestion in the Heathrow hub.
Therefore, Scotland needs more direct flights and the use of air passenger duty is an important means of ensuring more direct flights. That has broad support across the devolved Administrations and it has extraordinary support among the carriers. It was one of the recommendations of the Calman commission and I hope that I can carry the support of this entire Parliament in making that case in London next week.
The First Minister is aware of the IAG takeover of BMI and the resultant lack of landing slots available to airlines other than British Airways flying from Glasgow airport to Heathrow. He will be aware of the damaging effect this is having on business connectivity to London and elsewhere in the world from Glasgow and the west of Scotland. Does he share my view—I think he does—that the lack of competition on that route is now unfair as well as damaging to Scottish interests? Will he tell the Parliament what he can do and is prepared to do to help to restore competition and connectivity on the route?
I share the concerns about the need to restore competition on the Glasgow to Heathrow route. As John Scott will be aware, the situation with regard to the Glasgow route is different to Edinburgh and Aberdeen as British Airways has been the only operator on the Glasgow to Heathrow route since April 2011, when BMI withdrew, and thus is not subjected to the competition process, which should help the situation so far as Edinburgh and Aberdeen are concerned.
This month, the Scottish Government will reiterate its support for the full implementation of the competition remedies in relation to Edinburgh and Aberdeen and at the same time raise its concerns about the lack of competition on the Glasgow to Heathrow route and what seems to us to be mounting evidence that it has been detrimental to passengers with regard to available space and, in particular, the prices that they are being asked to pay. John Scott can be absolutely certain that this subject and the evidence of what has happened to the Glasgow to Heathrow route since the absence of competition will be very much part of my presentation at next week’s joint ministerial committee meeting.
This month, the Scottish Government will reiterate its support for the full implementation of the competition remedies in relation to Edinburgh and Aberdeen and at the same time raise its concerns about the lack of competition on the Glasgow to Heathrow route and what seems to us to be mounting evidence that it has been detrimental to passengers with regard to available space and, in particular, the prices that they are being asked to pay. John Scott can be absolutely certain that this subject and the evidence of what has happened to the Glasgow to Heathrow route since the absence of competition will be very much part of my presentation at next week’s joint ministerial committee meeting.
link
In promoting this policy of cutting air passenger duty to stimulate more flights, the minister Fergus Ewing and VisitScotland admitted at this week’s meeting of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee that they had not even bothered to explore the policy’s compatibility with legally binding climate change targets. Will the First Minister agree to do what Fergus Ewing refused to do and write to the United Kingdom Committee on Climate Change, asking it to investigate the policy’s impacts on climate change before he promotes it further?
It is our responsibility to put forward an estimate in that respect and we will do so. However, although I accept Patrick Harvie’s position that we should build an evidential base for what is, to me, an apparently commonsense proposition, I suggest that in many cases having a direct flight between two destinations can be more environmentally efficient than taking two flights to get to the same destination. I would have thought that there was a commonsense argument for direct flights in environmental, convenience, economic and business terms but, as I said, I accept that we should build an evidential base for our case. That is our responsibility and that is what we will do.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 13 Sep 2012 →- General Questions Questions · 1
- Welfare Reform (Food Parcels) Questions · 4
- Robroyston (New Railway Station) Questions · 9
- Winter Festivals Programme 2012-13 Questions · 4
- Accident and Emergency Units (Waiting Times) Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games (Benefits Outside Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Childcare Places Questions · 4
- Broadcasting (Proposed BBC Job Losses) Questions · 5
- National Football Academy (Bidding Criteria) Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Air Links (Heathrow) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Food Banks First Minister’s Questions · 5
- College Places (Demand) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fife Diet Food Manifesto Members’ business · 12
- Renewables Obligation Scotland Review Statement · 31
- Electricity Market Reform Debate · 45
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.