1. I know that, like the rest of us, the First Minister will tomorrow celebrate with all of Scotland a wonderful summer of sport, which culminated in Andy Murray’s fantastic victory in New York. [Applause.] However, my question is about today.
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00849)
I have lots of engagements for the rest of day, but I suspect that they will be nothing like as enjoyable as the celebration in which we will jointly engage tomorrow. The entire Parliament congratulates Scotland’s Olympians and Paralympians on their amazing feat but, given the extraordinary events of this week, Johann Lamont is perfectly correct that we should send our particular congratulations to Mr Andy Murray.
Is there anything about independence that the people of Scotland should not know?
As is increasingly realised across Scotland and beyond, the great thing about independence is that it will give the people of Scotland the ability to determine their own affairs and to mobilise this country’s natural and human resources to create a more prosperous and just society.
Yesterday, the President of the European Commission said clearly:
“A new state, if it wants to join the European Union, has to apply ... like any state.”
That means that the new state of Scotland would first have to apply to be a member of the European Union. If it succeeded, we would have to adopt the euro as our currency. The First Minister has no legal advice that contradicts the President of the European Commission, does he?
Let me see whether I can help Johann Lamont on such matters, as I tried to help her predecessor. Scotland is not an accession state. We have been a member of the European Union for 40 years. Every single one of us is a citizen of the European Union—even Conservative Party members, whether they like it or not. We are not in the position of a country that is not part of the European Union. [Interruption.]
Order. We will hear the First Minister.
There must be negotiations, as I have said in the chamber before. However, the crucial point is that those negotiations would take place from within the context of the European Union.
Since Johann Lamont seems to have invented a range of things that she claims that President Barroso said—he never mentioned the euro in any of his interviews yesterday—I will tell her something that he actually said and which has not been widely quoted. His last sentence was:
“I see no country leaving and ... many countries wanting to join.”
Scotland is part of the European Union and will remain part of it as an independent country.
I listened carefully, but I did not detect an answer to my question.
The Scottish National Party’s position seems to be predicated on the fact that Scotland would not be a new state. I wonder for what the SNP has been arguing for the past 100 years.
If the First Minister has advice that contradicts what President Barroso said, why does he not remove all doubt and publish it?
“Dialogue between the people and their representatives is essential in a genuine democracy.”
Those were the wise words this week of Alex Salmond’s old deputy and friend Jim Sillars. Instead of telling the people of Scotland what advice he has received, the First Minister is using our money to fund a court action to stop us knowing what he knows. The Scottish Information Commissioner has ruled that
“it is in the public interest to know”
what information is being taken
“into account in developing policy in ... such a significant issue as independence.”
Surely the First Minister believes that it is in the public’s interest to know the consequences of voting for independence.
I reiterate to Johann Lamont, so that she understands, that there is a difference between a country that has 40 years of membership of the European Union—within that context—and a country that is trying to join the European Union for the first time, as Turkey is doing.
I remind Johann Lamont, from history, that even when a country was trying to leave the European Union, as in the case of Greenland, it had to negotiate its leaving from inside the European Union. Quite clearly, Scotland is part and will remain part of the European Union and the necessary negotiations will take place from within that context. Incidentally, as has been discussed with her predecessor, exactly the same thing applies to the rest of the United Kingdom, which, in the words of Lord Mackenzie-Stuart, will be in exactly the same legal boat.
Johann Lamont referred to the question of publication, or acknowledgment of existence of, legal advice. She must know, because she has been a minister and has dealt with exactly these things herself, what the Scottish ministerial code says on the matter, in paragraph 2.35. The fact that legal advice has been given to ministers, or the fact of its existence,
“must not be revealed outwith the Scottish Government”,
unless under some clear circumstances—
Members: Ah!
Order.
I say to the Parliament quite clearly that since I became First Minister I have been referred by the Opposition parties five times under the ministerial code—
Not enough.
Jackie Baillie says that that is not enough, but perhaps, given my track record of nothing out of five, I would welcome further referrals. Five times, the complaints have been comprehensively dismissed by the independent adjudicators on such matters. If I were to breach the paragraph of the ministerial code that I quoted, there would be no defence—as every minister in previous Administrations in this Parliament and Westminster has held.
I think that I have a solution for Johann Lamont that reconciles my obligations under the ministerial code and, I believe, the democratic imperative of information for the people of Scotland. We have set out our intention to publish the white paper on independence this time next year, and I give Johann Lamont my guarantee that that white paper, which will set out the full context of the independence proposition, will contain detailed assessment on the question of continuing membership of the European Union. I give her the guarantee that everything in the document will be fully consistent with the legal advice that we receive. That seems to me a reasonable solution on how we reconcile the requirements of the ministerial code with the imperative to let the people of Scotland see the full advantages of being an independent country.
I am not sure who the First Minister imagines would refer him under the ministerial code, in relation to giving us information that it is costing the state £100,000 to keep away from us—[Interruption.]
Order, Mr Swinney.
It is costing £100,000 to keep the information out of the public domain.
When I was a minister, I think that I made a bit of a difference, but in all that time I never posed a question that we have decided is the most important for 300 years. We are in those circumstances, and I suggest that in such circumstances the information could usefully be revealed. Otherwise, one has to ask what the First Minister has got to hide.
We have to get this right: President Barroso is wrong; the Scottish Information Commissioner is wrong; Jim Sillars is wrong. Only Alex Salmond is right, all the time. No doubt he will soon be blaming Mo Farah, Ellie Simmonds and Chris Hoy for unemployment going up in Scotland—oh, he did that yesterday.
Meaningless assertion on the pound has descended into deliberate deception on the euro. While Alex Salmond fails to provide a single shred of evidence, President Barroso provides evidence. Scotland would have to reapply to join the EU and would have to adopt the euro, with all the disastrous economic consequences that that would have.
Alex Salmond has to understand that although, when he says something, his back benchers agree, we expect more than simple assertion. He refuses to tell the people of Scotland the truth. When is he planning to tell them—now, never, or when it is too late?
I welcome President Barroso’s new spokeswoman to her position. Fortunately, President Barroso’s actual spokesperson said yesterday that he would like to clarify matters because there were misrepresentations of what was said about the European Commission’s position. No doubt the spokesman will have to clarify the misrepresentations from Johann Lamont.
President Barroso said no such thing—he said exactly what I quoted earlier:
“I see no country leaving and ... many countries wanting to join.”
Johann Lamont gives me her personal guarantee: what member would report me under the ministerial code if I was in clear breach of it? Well, Tavish Scott, Iain Gray, Hugh Henry, Jim Sheridan or Paul Martin might. I put it to the chamber that if I was reported under the ministerial code for tea and biscuits in Bute house, I think that I might be reported for a clear breach under these conditions.
I offered—this is the great disadvantage of Johann Lamont reading out the question that she prepared before she has heard the answer—what I think is a reasonable solution to the matter: to conform to the ministerial code and to provide the information that the people wish to have. [Interruption.]
Order.
On the publication of the white paper—a full year before the decision on the referendum—continuing European Union membership for an independent Scotland will be examined in great detail. Everything in that white paper will be fully consistent with and informed by the legal advice that we receive. That seems to me to be a pretty reasonable proposition, and folk in Scotland will be looking forward to reading that white paper—the passport to independence and freedom.