PE1454, by Natalie Robb, is on hyperemesis specialist nurses. Members have a note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and a copy of the petition.I welcome Natalie Robb and thank her for giving up her time to get here in very bad weather conditions. I ask her to give a brief presentation of about five minutes, after which I will invite Mary Scanlon to make some comments. I will then kick off with a few questions and ask my colleagues to get involved.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Hyperemesis Specialist Nurses (PE1454)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Natalie Robb 27
- David Stewart Lab 9
- Chic Brodie SNP 9
- Adam Ingram SNP 8
- John Wilson SNP 6
- Anne McTaggart Lab 4
The record
63 contributionsI thank the committee for inviting me to talk about putting in place hyperemesis specialist nurses in Scotland. Hyperemesis is severe nausea and vomiting in pregnancy, which can cause serious complications for the mother and the baby. According to the BMJ, the number of hyperemesis pregnancies is unknown, but it is said to range from three in 1,000 to 20 in 1,000.I will explain exactly what I am petitioning for. Midwives, doctors and nurses are not given the training that is needed to care for women with hyperemesis. I contacted a senior lecturer in midwifery at Edinburgh Napier University to find out exactly what the students are taught. In the second year of their course, they have a complications in pregnancy module, in which there is only one session that covers hyperemesis. The session covers aetiology, incidence, midwifery and psychological management. That is nowhere near enough to educate a midwife about something that up to 2 per cent of their patients may suffer from.A research paper that was completed in 2004 by Dr Roger Gadsby of Warwick medical school in Coventry showed that the estimated cost of each hyperemesis admission is £470 a day. Obviously, in light of the date of that paper, the costs will now be far higher than that.In total, I spent 15 days in hospital. I required an ambulance and used an out-of-hours general practitioner service on several occasions, as well as my own GP weekly. I also required consultant-led care due to hyperemesis. Those services might not have been required if I had been given the correct treatment. My hospital admissions alone would have cost more than £7,050. A hyperemesis pregnancy costs the national health service far more than it has to. Putting in place a specialist nurse could hugely reduce the costs.Currently, there are no hyperemesis specialist nurses in the United Kingdom, but early pregnancy clinics throughout England and Wales—in Manchester, Birmingham and Cambridge, for example—treat women with hyperemesis as out-patients and administer intravenous fluids and medication as necessary. Many hospitals—the royal Berkshire hospital and the royal Cornwall hospital, for example—also have guidelines in place on how to treat women with hyperemesis as day patients.In Scotland, only one hospital—Forth Valley royal hospital—appears to have those guidelines in place. The majority of those who suffer from hyperemesis are young and healthy women who can withstand rapid fluid replacement as day patients and can be sent home to their own environment with medication.Many different routes could be taken to support women with the illness and reduce costs for the NHS. The role could be filled by a registered general nurse or a midwife. There could be support in a clinic in a hospital or in home visits in the community, perhaps. I think that a clinic in a hospital would be the best way forward. The nurse would be the point of referral from GPs for patients who may be at risk of becoming dehydrated and seriously unwell from sickness during their pregnancy.The nurse’s main roles would be to administer IV fluids, consider medication options for those who require it, monitor patients’ weight and blood pressure and carry out blood tests. They would also ensure that there were no problems with the baby and offer support and advice to patients, their families and other health professionals.I hope that the committee will consider placing hyperemesis nurses in Scottish hospitals, to help both the NHS and families who have to suffer from this awful illness.
Thank you for your presentation. My colleagues and I have some questions. I should correct the record: Mary Scanlon is here for the next petition. Of course, if she has any particular interest in this petition, she is welcome to raise it.Natalie, you mentioned Forth Valley royal hospital. Certainly, from the committee’s papers and your petition, it appears that Forth Valley provides a good example of how to operate services in Scotland. Would you consider Forth Valley to be an exemplar of best practice in Scotland?
Because Forth Valley royal hospital has guidelines in place, it is obviously the best hospital for hyperemesis in Scotland. However, I do not know how it treats women, what the care is like or how well staff are educated about hyperemesis; I am aware only of the guidelines.
The guidelines are certainly good practice.
Yes.
You mentioned that there are no specialist nurses in the rest of the UK. Have you gone further afield? Do you have any examples from Europe, for instance?
No. I am not aware of any other examples.
Thank you for your presentation. You said that the number of hyperemesis pregnancies can be 20 in 1,000. From your information—we have a good, concise report—do you know of any regional variations in Scotland where that might occur?
I do not understand you.
Are there more hyperemesis pregnancies in Glasgow, or more in Aberdeen, for example?
Not that I am aware of. The numbers are not very well known and not much research is done on the issue. The numbers vary on every site that is visited. I am not aware of any town or anything—
I was trying to establish how many specialist nurses we were talking about and what training might be needed.I know that you said that there was not a lot of research, but the clerk’s report states:“research has found maternal complications including weight loss, dehydration, acidosis, abnormal liver function and vitamin deficiencies.”Given that we know about deficiency of particular vitamins, is there any way that pregnant ladies can determine what vitamins they should take to try to avoid hyperemesis?
They should be given advice on what to take. I was not given any vitamins at all during my pregnancy, so I was very deficient.
Were you told about that only after the event?
Yes.
Thank you for your presentation. Does the illness recur?
Up to 80 per cent of women will have the illness in a second pregnancy.
Wow!You mentioned that you contacted the Royal College of Midwives and looked at training. I am not a doctor and neither are you, I suspect, but will you elaborate on the reason for not giving training?
I was not given a reason. The organisation was not very helpful, to be honest. It just told me what it taught and that it thought that that was enough.
So no specific tuition is given on the illness.
One of the lectures in one module covers hyperemesis. That is all the training that midwives are given.10:15
Good morning. Obviously it is quite worrying that we do not have any statistics; from what you said in your presentation, it seems that we have only the BMJ to tell us that 2 per cent of women might suffer from the condition. Do Scottish hospitals collect any figures on it? If not, why not?
I cannot find any figures for Scottish hospitals; the figures that I used come from research papers in England. I do not think that anyone is available to do the research in Scotland.
As far as you are aware, the incidence of the condition is not being recorded in Scottish hospitals.
It is not, as far as I am aware.
You have asked for the provision of specialist nurses to deal with the condition. Are you talking about nurses who concentrate only on this area or about nurses or midwives who can deliver general services but who specialise in the condition and can be called on to deal with any patients who present with it?
I am not talking about having people who would carry out only the specific role. There could be a midwife who has more knowledge of the area than others and who could hold a clinic a couple of times a week. We do not necessarily need someone who does only that specific job.
You said that, although NHS Forth Valley has put guidelines in place, you are not aware that it has nurses or midwives who deliver that kind of support service.
No. There are just guidelines.
So, the guidelines have been put in place but no one has been identified to deliver the service when it is required.
That is right.
Is this the condition that Kate Middleton—or perhaps I should say the Duchess of Cambridge—suffered from?
Yes.
When women become pregnant, are they advised to go on to the NHS inform website? Do they receive any pre-advice about what they should look at or what they should do if, say, they cannot keep down fluids?
No. I can talk only from personal experience, but my GP did not know what was wrong with me. The condition was recognised only when I was admitted to hospital severely unwell.
The point is quite important, because it applies not only to hyperemesis. Did you receive any advice about what conditions you should track?
No.
You were not told about the NHS inform website.
No.
I am sorry that I missed the earlier part of your presentation. What support did you receive for your condition from your GP or others, particularly in the early days?
I did not get any support. Because I was so ill, I saw my GP every week, but I was given no support. I was told that it was just sickness and was sent away with different medication; I was refused medication that worked for me. It was not until I was about 27 weeks pregnant that I was referred to a hospital consultant—that was the first support I received.
Are you aware that the Scottish Government has refreshed its framework for maternity care, part of which is an early pregnancy assessment service that people can be referred to? Did you ever hear of such a thing?
No.
You were certainly not referred to that service.
No.
Who referred you to the consultant?
A family member who worked with the consultant referred me. I was not referred by my GP or—
Or by anything in the system itself.
No. That is the only reason why I was referred.
Obviously you were very worried during those 27 weeks. Did you look for support from, say, Pregnancy Sickness Support?
I was not aware of that charity and did not find its website until well after the 20-week point.
Do you want national guidelines for health boards to ensure that some form of planned service is available to women who suffer from the same condition?
Yes.
It makes a lot of sense to continue this really interesting petition and get further information from the Scottish Government. Pregnancy Sickness Support has been mentioned; I know from experience that the National Childbirth Trust is a very good organisation, and the Royal College of Midwives is another organisation that jumps out at me.
If we are seeking GPs’ views, should we also contact the British Medical Association?
Certainly.
It might be useful to ask NHS Forth Valley why it felt it necessary to introduce guidelines on the issue and whether it has nursing staff or midwives who specialise in the condition.
That is a good point.
Given that NHS Forth Valley appears to be the only health board that is following the framework for maternity care, we should ask the Government to survey the health boards and find out exactly what is happening with the framework’s implementation. From Natalie Robb’s responses to me and Adam Ingram, it appears that, although the guidelines and the focus exist, no one is following them.
I agree.
In addition to Mr Brodie’s suggestion, we should ask for consideration of a guideline from the Scottish intercollegiate guidelines network on the condition, which is clearly distressing to those who suffer from it.
That is a fair point. It would also be interesting to ask the Royal College of Nursing for its views. After all, this is all about putting specialist nurses in place. If members have no other points, I think that members are happy with the course of action that has been outlined.Thank you for your evidence, Natalie—we certainly appreciate your contribution. As you have heard, we are very interested in your petition. We will continue it, seek evidence and, when we get that evidence, consider our next steps. The clerks will keep you in touch with developments.I suspend the meeting to allow a changeover of witnesses.10:23 Meeting suspended.
10:25 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Jan 2013 →- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 1
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 63
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 58
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 1
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
- 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 10:00 Correction Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.