Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 4 October 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00891)

I welcome the First Minister back to his place. I am sure that he and others will want to join me in congratulating Paul Lawrie and the whole European team on their stunning victory in the Ryder cup. [Applause.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
For the rest of the day, I will deal with issues on taking forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

The victory in the Ryder cup was an exceptional achievement for the European team. Everyone in the chamber looks forward ever more to being in Gleneagles in two years’ time to see that victory repeated. [Applause.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Absolutely.

How is the First Minister going to make the almost £3 billion of cuts that are to come without anyone noticing?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The Government has set out its plans in the budget, as we have done for the past five years. Despite the enormous pressure from the Westminster Government, which Johann Lamont correctly identifies, we have managed to balance that budget, secure Scottish public services and, in particular, introduce vital social gains such as free education in Scotland. When I left for America, I thought that those things were largely agreed across the chamber. When I left for America, Johann Lamont was just appearing on the same platform as Ruth Davidson; now I am having to adjust to the fact that Johann Lamont is leading her party to become the Conservative Party of Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The problem with the First Minister is not just that he is surprised when he leaves for America, but that, when he is in Scotland, he is in denial about what is happening in the real Scotland outside this chamber. He talks about securing public services and says that we have free everything, but he has already brought in £2.7 billion of cuts, and the poor, the vulnerable and the hard-working families in this country have noticed. They have noticed the pensioner who needs help to wash, to dress and to feed themselves suffering the indignity of having just 15 minutes of care visits in a day; the family paying more for childcare than for their mortgage; the 18,000 Scots who are being denied a place at college; and the thousands of working-class students who have had their bursaries cut by £900 a year. They see his cuts; they do not see his Scotland where everything is free and everything is fantastic.

Who is going to pay when he delivers the next £3 billion of cuts?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont is correct to say that the Scottish budget is under severe attack from Westminster—that is true. Incidentally, it was under attack from the previous Labour Government as well. However, the solution to that surely cannot be to abandon concessionary fares, free prescriptions and free personal care, to reintroduce tuition fees or to abandon the council tax freeze. How would the working families of Scotland benefit from our adopting the policies that the Tory party has adopted south of the border? Johann Lamont was deeply wrong to talk about a something-for-nothing society. That is exactly the language of the Tory party of 20 years ago.

Yes, the cuts that are being imposed on Scotland are severe—there is no doubt about that—but they were set out in the comprehensive spending review. There is no difference in those things than when we fought the election last year and fought the local elections this year. When the Labour Party fought the election last year and fought the local elections this year, it was in favour of retaining concessionary fares, free prescriptions, free personal care and free education, and it was in favour of the council tax freeze. Indeed, it was trying to outbid the Scottish National Party on those vital aspects of social progress. So, the question that Johann Lamont must answer is: how, all of a sudden, has she been converted to sweeping away not just the gains introduced by this Government, but the gains of having a Parliament for Scotland?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I do not think that the First Minister listened to what I said about what is happening to people throughout the country. He says that nothing changes, but the question that we should be asking is: who is paying the price for the benefits that we all get from his spending choices?

The First Minister says that we tried to outbid the SNP. One lesson that we have learned is that it is impossible to outbid the SNP on recklessness. Instead, we will demand a serious Government that makes the hard decisions so that people do not pay the price.

It is no wonder that the First Minister thinks that he needs to spend £1 million on spin doctors to try to spin his way out of this. That tells us all we need to know about him. Care workers are losing their jobs or getting their wages cut, but more SNP spinners are hired.

The cuts must be brought in by 2016. Already, John Swinney has delayed half the cuts that he must make. Will we know more before the referendum in 2014 about where that £3 billion-worth of cuts will be made or will the Government continue to try to con the people of Scotland and treat us all as fools?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont called for a quality debate, so let us see whether we can give her one. The argument against means testing—which is her direction of travel—was set out famously in a document almost 20 years ago. It said:

“There is ample evidence that systems with benefits paid to the majority are considerably more popular as well as more efficient than those which reserve benefits solely for the poor.”

That comes from page 249 of the report of the commission on social justice that the late John Smith set up—Johann Lamont was chair of the Scottish Labour Party at the time. I do not understand why Labour has moved away from that fundamental principle.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I hear the cries from Labour members saying that they have not. If they have not moved away from that principle, why is Johann Lamont making speeches attacking the great gains in free education and free health for the people of Scotland?

I agree that the reintroduction of means testing would not be popular, and I also agree that it would not be efficient. One of the arguments is about holding society together. Certain things are so important—such as free education in Scotland—that we must ensure that the people who are lucky enough to be in a position to make a contribution to them through their taxation can see the social benefit as well. That is how we hold society together.

The introduction of sweeping means testing across those valuable areas of society would introduce inefficiency and social division. The Labour Party recognised and, by and large, stayed faithful to that point for many years but now is deserting totally to the Tory ground not only of Ruth Davidson but of Peter Lilley, who first introduced the phrase “a something-for-nothing society”.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister loves having straw men to cut down. The reality is that a much more serious debate is going on. He says that we should have a debate and then insults every family in the country that is worrying about its children in school, its young people in college and the care of its older people.

He talks about debate but forces his Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning to come to the chamber and recant a position that he held five years ago. We want to have a debate and test the evidence on where the balance, which the First Minister knows is needed, should lie.

I understand why the First Minister thinks that everything is free: he is on £130,000 a year, spends almost £2,000 a week on hospitality and then gets taxpayers to spend £1,300 a year for a television package to enable him to watch the films and sports events that he then gets them to pay for him to attend.

The First Minister does not live in the real world. He lives in a world in which it is fine to spend £400,000 to rent a gentlemen’s club in Pall Mall, but not to worry about the care worker who has had their wages cut by £4,000 a year. He is not an economist—he is a fantasist. No wonder that, from Hampden Park to the Ryder cup and from George Square to the Edinburgh tattoo, he is roundly booed wherever he goes.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
So much for the quality debate that Johann Lamont wants.

I will make three points to Johann Lamont. The argument that we put forward was not only put forward in our election manifesto, on which we were elected; it was enunciated when we set out our programme for government. I set out the social wage argument in the chamber on 26 May 2011, when I said:

“Free university education, no tolls, no tax on ill health and one bill—the council tax—that will not soar: that is the concept of the social wage. For the sacrifices that all of us are and should be making, there is a reward in the form of a society that is geared to our values. We do things differently here, not because we can but because we want to, and we should be proud of that.”

Iain Gray was the leader of the Labour Party then. His response was:

“I agree that Scotland’s path should be different from that pursued by the Tory-Lib Dem coalition in Westminster. There is a fairer, better way, and we will hold the First Minister to his promises on the social wage, as he has characterised it: on free personal care, concessionary travel, free prescriptions and free education.”—[Official Report, 26 May 2011; c 69 and 78.]

In the space of a year, the Labour Party has been transformed from demanding that the Scottish National Party holds to these policies on the social wage to being hand in glove with the Tory party in attacking those gains for the Scottish people.

Johann Lamont should be worried not just about the SNP’s reaction to her; let us talk about other reaction to her speeches. On the LabourHame blog site, for example, Alex Gallagher said:

“The phrase ‘something for nothing’ is badly chosen. It’s a Tory shiboleth”.

George Anders said:

“What are we doing?

Did we learn nothing from the ‘New Labour’ nonsense.”

David Wells said:

“Labour used to endorse policies like: free prescriptions, free tuition fees and the council tax freeze.”

As the Labour Party becomes the new Tory party of Scotland, its support, which is already diminished, will vanish like snaw off a dyke.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Budget 2013-14 Questions · 4
  2. Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Act 2009 Questions · 4
  3. Energy Academy Questions · 10
  4. General Practitioner Services (Out-of-hours Provision) Questions · 4
  5. Schools (Outdoor Activity) Questions · 5
  6. Speeding (Trunk Roads) Questions · 4
  7. Minimum Alcohol Pricing (Economic Benefits) Questions · 6
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  9. Secretary of State for Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 8
  10. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  11. Ryder Cup 2014 First Minister’s Questions · 5
  12. Police Staffing First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. Free Prescriptions First Minister’s Questions · 11
  14. Land Reform (Isle of Gigha) Members’ business · 33
  15. West Coast Main Line Statement · 32
  16. Employability Debate · 110
  17. Points of Order Procedure · 4
  18. Defamation Bill Bill debate · 2
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.