4. To ask the Scottish Government what recent discussions it has had with Aberdeen City Council regarding improvements to the Haudagain roundabout. (S4O-01339)
Official Report · Chamber
Haudagain Roundabout
Scottish Government Question Time Infrastructure, Investment and Cities
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Keith Brown SNP 4
- Mark McDonald SNP 2
- Richard Baker Lab 1
- Brian Adam SNP 1
The record
8 contributions4. To ask the Scottish Government what recent discussions it has had with Aberdeen City Council regarding improvements to the Haudagain roundabout. (S4O-01339)
link
Transport Scotland officials last met Aberdeen City Council, Aberdeenshire Council and Nestrans—the north east of Scotland transport partnership—on 12 April 2012 to discuss improvements to the Haudagain roundabout and other infrastructure projects. At the meeting, officials reconfirmed the Scottish Government’s commitment to starting improvements to Haudagain once the Aberdeen western peripheral route has been completed.
As the minister will be aware, the traffic modelling for the Haudagain roundabout improvements showed that the works would be effective only if the third Don crossing were developed as planned. Given that Aberdeen City Council’s Labour-led administration is now considering relocating the crossing or possibly scrapping it altogether, does the minister agree that such a move would put the Haudagain improvement works back at square one and would mean further expenditure by both council and Government and another lengthy planning and modelling exercise? Would it not be far better if the council administration stuck to the original plans for the third Don crossing, which would help to tackle congestion in the city?
link
I could not agree more with the point that Mark McDonald makes. It is worth saying that all options to emerge from the Aberdeen City Council Scottish transport appraisal guidance report require both the AWPR and the third Don crossing to be in place before the solutions work effectively. If the third Don crossing is not put in place, the proposed solutions at Haudagain will simply not be effective. However, it is clear that the completion of it and the AWPR would ease the strain on the Haudagain junction and assist during the construction process for delivering improvements at that bottleneck.
Could a revised plan for a third Don crossing not work well with the current proposals for the Haudagain roundabout? Is the delay to the improvements at the Haudagain not being caused by the minister’s insistence on bundling the project with the AWPR and not beginning work at the roundabout until the AWPR is completed? The work could begin right now—it is a shovel-ready project—so why does the minister not get on with it?
link
I will have to give the same answer that I have given to the same question from Richard Baker over a number of months. I have just made the point, as has Mark McDonald, that the studies that have been done show that the benefits to come from the Aberdeen western peripheral route require the improvements to the Haudagain roundabout to come afterwards. We have taken professional advice on the matter, including the STAG report that was mentioned, and are following it. That is the order in which to do the projects.
We are, of course, frustrated by the delays to the AWPR and await the outcome of the court process. However, in the meantime, we must ensure that we go about it in the right way, not only because it will be the most effective solution but because it is the most effective use of public resources.
We are, of course, frustrated by the delays to the AWPR and await the outcome of the court process. However, in the meantime, we must ensure that we go about it in the right way, not only because it will be the most effective solution but because it is the most effective use of public resources.
I accept that there are all sorts of consequences in the plans for the AWPR, the Haudagain roundabout and the third Don crossing. However, for the benefit of my constituents, the minister might want to consider whether the Government and the council can act a little more quickly to end the uncertainty for the residents whose homes are likely to be purchased by compulsory purchase orders when the upgrade to the Haudagain roundabout goes ahead. Could we have some clarity on that?
link
As I said in my answer to the first substantive question, of course we are willing to discuss with our partners, including Aberdeen City Council, how best we can expedite the process. The major decision is still to be taken and we are hopeful that it will be taken shortly.
I am well aware of the uncertainty that Brian Adam mentions. I am more than happy to work with our partners on that and to come back to him with a further update once we have done so.
I am well aware of the uncertainty that Brian Adam mentions. I am more than happy to work with our partners on that and to come back to him with a further update once we have done so.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 3 Oct 2012 →- Infrastructure, Investment and Cities Questions · 1
- Rail Services (Glasgow, Paisley and Ayr) Questions · 8
- Regeneration (Inverclyde) Questions · 7
- Haudagain Roundabout Questions · 8
- 4G Mobile Phone Services Questions · 6
- Properties at risk of External Sewer Flooding Questions · 4
- Construction Companies (Public Sector Contracts) Questions · 4
- International Development Questions · 7
- Youth Olympic Games 2018 Questions · 6
- Young Scots Fund Questions · 4
- Digital Participation Questions · 4
- World Festival of Flight 2013 Questions · 4
- Cultural Exchange (Non-EU European Nations) Questions · 4
- BBC Scotland Questions · 4
- Historic Built Environment (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 6
- Trade Unions (International Projects) Questions · 4
- Scotland’s Future Debate · 203
- Business Motions Business motions · 3
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 8
- Breast Cancer Members’ business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.