1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00701)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 4
The record
16 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00701)
I will be taking forward matters of importance to the people of Scotland.
These are tough times. People across Europe are fearful of what will happen if Greece defaults on its loans and leaves the euro zone. The situation in Spain, Portugal and Italy is also looking increasingly perilous. If Greece leaves the euro, and others may follow, what are the First Minister’s estimates of the impact on the Scottish economy?
It is precisely because of the seriousness of the situation that we have identified Government time next week for a debate on exactly that subject. The Government will contribute our thoughts on the matter and I am sure that the Labour Party and other parties will contribute as well. Clearly, it is a very serious situation and there are potentially substantial implications for the United Kingdom and for the Scottish economy.
It would have been good if the First Minister could have shared some of his thoughts now, since that was the question that I asked him.
The last time that our banking sector hit crisis, a Labour Government immediately rescued our banks so that ordinary families in this country could still get money out of the cashpoints. That included Scottish banks, of course. There was no question, no hesitation and no negotiation. It was the kind of action that the Greeks and the Irish can only dream of. Our banking system was saved by one of the most successful economic unions in history—the United Kingdom.
Is not the real lesson of the euro crisis that you cannot share a currency and have monetary union without a fiscal union and a political union?
The last time that our banking sector hit crisis, a Labour Government immediately rescued our banks so that ordinary families in this country could still get money out of the cashpoints. That included Scottish banks, of course. There was no question, no hesitation and no negotiation. It was the kind of action that the Greeks and the Irish can only dream of. Our banking system was saved by one of the most successful economic unions in history—the United Kingdom.
Is not the real lesson of the euro crisis that you cannot share a currency and have monetary union without a fiscal union and a political union?
I gently remind Johann Lamont that the governor of the Bank of England, who was in office during the period that she talks about, published last week the most devastating assessment of the delay and dithering. In fact, he accused the last Government and its lack of action of being responsible for the depth of the recession.
If that is what the governor of the Bank of England, who was in office when Alistair Darling was chancellor and Gordon Brown was Prime Minister, says, I do not think that I have to add to that by pointing out that Labour’s absolute responsibility for the depth of the recession is clear on the record and cannot be escaped by any member of the Labour Party.
Johann Lamont says that a monetary union must inevitably carry with it a fiscal union. There are two totally different situations. In the case of the euro, we are talking about a situation in which the productivity rate of Greece is about 40 per cent below that of Germany. That creates huge difficulties and tensions within the euro area.
It would be better at this juncture if people came forward with positive ideas as to how to give opportunities and hope to the people of Greece within that euro area, rather than merely carping from the sidelines, which seems to be what the United Kingdom Government is doing. To be absolutely frank, I have not heard anything from Ed Balls that is a substantial argument as to how the euro zone can be maintained in its current condition.
I hope that, when we come to the debate next Wednesday, Johann Lamont will come with not just a bit of remembrance of the past and Labour’s absolute responsibility for the mess that the economy was in, but also some positive ideas for the future.
If that is what the governor of the Bank of England, who was in office when Alistair Darling was chancellor and Gordon Brown was Prime Minister, says, I do not think that I have to add to that by pointing out that Labour’s absolute responsibility for the depth of the recession is clear on the record and cannot be escaped by any member of the Labour Party.
Johann Lamont says that a monetary union must inevitably carry with it a fiscal union. There are two totally different situations. In the case of the euro, we are talking about a situation in which the productivity rate of Greece is about 40 per cent below that of Germany. That creates huge difficulties and tensions within the euro area.
It would be better at this juncture if people came forward with positive ideas as to how to give opportunities and hope to the people of Greece within that euro area, rather than merely carping from the sidelines, which seems to be what the United Kingdom Government is doing. To be absolutely frank, I have not heard anything from Ed Balls that is a substantial argument as to how the euro zone can be maintained in its current condition.
I hope that, when we come to the debate next Wednesday, Johann Lamont will come with not just a bit of remembrance of the past and Labour’s absolute responsibility for the mess that the economy was in, but also some positive ideas for the future.
This is the man who said that the problem with the banking system was that it was overregulated. We also note that he refuses to confront the logic of his own position that the Bank of England would be the lender of last resort for a Scotland that was outside the United Kingdom.
People in this country and throughout Europe are looking for certainty and stability in an uncertain world. The First Minister used to say that we needed a Scottish pound because interest rates set in London were bad for Scotland, yet now that is what he advocates. He used to say that we would join the euro because the pound was failing. Now, louder than William Hague ever did, he is saying, “Keep the pound.” You know, consistency is a wonderful thing.
Is not the real reason why the First Minister keeps changing the economic case for leaving the UK that he cannot find one that adds up?
People in this country and throughout Europe are looking for certainty and stability in an uncertain world. The First Minister used to say that we needed a Scottish pound because interest rates set in London were bad for Scotland, yet now that is what he advocates. He used to say that we would join the euro because the pound was failing. Now, louder than William Hague ever did, he is saying, “Keep the pound.” You know, consistency is a wonderful thing.
Is not the real reason why the First Minister keeps changing the economic case for leaving the UK that he cannot find one that adds up?
When I heard the words “consistency is a wonderful thing”, the three words “council tax freeze” came to mind as far as the Labour Party is concerned.
The former Labour Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, argued in a speech that there should be no-touch regulation of the financial sector. He actually argued that position. The Labour Party was in favour of adopting the euro, and it was going to have a referendum to consolidate that position when Tony Blair was Prime Minister. Lectures from the Labour Party on economic consistency with regard to the euro area absolutely take the biscuit in this chamber.
It will substantially assist the Scottish economy if we have fiscal control—that is, if we control Scotland’s taxes and resources and have the ability to manage our economy on that basis. Independence will give us that strong position and there seems to be no other option available that could offer a strong position. I would have thought, despite Alistair Darling wanting cuts that were tougher and deeper than Margaret Thatcher’s, that there would now be agreement between the Scottish National Party and the Labour Party that direct capital spending is necessary to revive our economy. We have articulated that case with our Labour colleagues in the Government of Wales to try to convince the chancellor in London that that is the right mechanism to use right now to revive the economy. Would it not be better if we as a Parliament could just decide to get on and do that with independence, instead of having to go cap in hand to UK Tory chancellors? [Applause.]
The former Labour Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, argued in a speech that there should be no-touch regulation of the financial sector. He actually argued that position. The Labour Party was in favour of adopting the euro, and it was going to have a referendum to consolidate that position when Tony Blair was Prime Minister. Lectures from the Labour Party on economic consistency with regard to the euro area absolutely take the biscuit in this chamber.
It will substantially assist the Scottish economy if we have fiscal control—that is, if we control Scotland’s taxes and resources and have the ability to manage our economy on that basis. Independence will give us that strong position and there seems to be no other option available that could offer a strong position. I would have thought, despite Alistair Darling wanting cuts that were tougher and deeper than Margaret Thatcher’s, that there would now be agreement between the Scottish National Party and the Labour Party that direct capital spending is necessary to revive our economy. We have articulated that case with our Labour colleagues in the Government of Wales to try to convince the chancellor in London that that is the right mechanism to use right now to revive the economy. Would it not be better if we as a Parliament could just decide to get on and do that with independence, instead of having to go cap in hand to UK Tory chancellors? [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Instead of the First Minister giving us his greatest hits in lines of not answering the question, he should take responsibility and reflect on what is happening in Europe now and the consequences that that will have for Scotland. We have all heard that the First Minister is planning a big day out at the pictures tomorrow. For many of us, the cinema is a form of escapism, but evidently, for the First Minister, his economics are escapism. Europe is facing the greatest economic crisis since the depression, but instead of looking up E for “Economists” in his address book, he is looking up C for “Celebrities”. I suppose that that makes a change from dialling M for Murdoch. [Interruption.] This is a serious business.
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Like people across Europe, Scots fear what will happen to them if the euro zone collapses, but the First Minister’s message to them is, “Turn off the news and put down the paper. There is nothing to worry about.” I think that we know now what will be showing at the multiplex in Fountainbridge tomorrow: “Alex in Wonderland”. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I hope that by the time that Johann Lamont gets to the debate next Wednesday, which has been called in Government time so that the Parliament can seriously address a serious issue, she will have something more to say than she has managed this afternoon.
The economy is a huge and abiding concern for the Government. That is why we are working daily to bring jobs to Scotland. We take some satisfaction from recent employment figures in Scotland rising and the unemployment figures falling, but we are not complacent about that. That is why we are calling for direct investment in shovel-ready projects around Scotland and why we are making the case for having control over the fiscal levers of the economy, which can come only with independence.
The idea that we are the only party that is planning and getting arrangements made for a constitutional debate seems to me to be rather wide of the mark. I read in The Mail on Sunday—it was the first time that I had read that newspaper—that
“Senior aides to David Cameron took part in a secret all-party ‘council of war’ at former Labour Chancellor Alistair Darling’s Edinburgh home ... The six men spent three hours discussing their battle plans at the meeting held a month ago at Mr Darling’s home in the Abbotsford Park area that has become their unofficial HQ.
Fortified by tea and sandwiches ... they agreed that the only way to defeat Mr Salmond”—
The economy is a huge and abiding concern for the Government. That is why we are working daily to bring jobs to Scotland. We take some satisfaction from recent employment figures in Scotland rising and the unemployment figures falling, but we are not complacent about that. That is why we are calling for direct investment in shovel-ready projects around Scotland and why we are making the case for having control over the fiscal levers of the economy, which can come only with independence.
The idea that we are the only party that is planning and getting arrangements made for a constitutional debate seems to me to be rather wide of the mark. I read in The Mail on Sunday—it was the first time that I had read that newspaper—that
“Senior aides to David Cameron took part in a secret all-party ‘council of war’ at former Labour Chancellor Alistair Darling’s Edinburgh home ... The six men spent three hours discussing their battle plans at the meeting held a month ago at Mr Darling’s home in the Abbotsford Park area that has become their unofficial HQ.
Fortified by tea and sandwiches ... they agreed that the only way to defeat Mr Salmond”—
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
I think that we get the gist, First Minister. Could you just get to the answer?
That was described as the “Abbotsford accord”. If that is what the no campaign has to offer, the campaign that will be launched tomorrow will be fundamentally successful.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 24 May 2012 →- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Languages (Improving Opportunities) Debate · 62
- Rural Policing Questions · 8
- Prisons (Independent Monitoring) Questions · 4
- Flood Prevention (Scotland) Act 1961 Questions · 6
- Air Rifles (Regulation of Use) Questions · 4
- Fife Energy Park (Foundry) Questions · 4
- NHS Ayrshire and Arran (Patient Care) Questions · 4
- Aberdeen City Council (Planning) Questions · 6
- Scottish Enterprise (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Economy (Euro Zone Impact) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Lockerbie Bombing (Criminal Investigation) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Ministry of Defence (Radioactive Contamination of Land) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Supported Employment (Public Contracts) Questions · 6
- British Geological Survey (Meetings) Questions · 4
- A90 Upgrade (Balmedie to Tipperty) Questions · 5
- Victoria and Albert at Dundee (Transport Infrastructure) Questions · 4
- Scotland’s Digital Future Questions · 6
- Community-led Regeneration (South Scotland) Questions · 5
- Borders Railway (Construction Costs) Questions · 4
- Veterans Associations Questions · 4
- Affordable Housing (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 6
- Council Houses (Right to Buy) Questions · 4
- Arts and Culture (Local Authorities) Questions · 6
- Cultural Initiatives (Aberdeen) Questions · 8
- Historical Artefacts (Inventory) Questions · 5
- Charles Rennie Mackintosh Buildings Questions · 7
- Public Library Services Questions · 6
- Major Events (2017) Questions · 4
- Aung San Suu Kyi (Visit) Questions · 5
- Edinburgh Festivals Expo Fund 2012 Questions · 6
- St Andrew’s Day Questions · 4
- Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 40
- Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 39
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
- Glasgow Epilepsy Genetics Service Members’ business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.