Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 26 January 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 11 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00430)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Later today I will write to all the party leaders in the Parliament and Margo MacDonald inviting them to round-table discussions as we take forward Scotland’s referendum consultation.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
We always welcome a sinner who repents and someone who pays attention to others within the chamber. I am absolutely delighted with that news. I believe that it is in the interests of the people of Scotland that we undertake that task together.

This week, of course, the First Minister unveiled the question that he wishes to ask the Scottish people in the forthcoming referendum:

“Do you agree that Scotland should be an independent country?”—[Official Report, 25 January 2012; c 5603.]

Members: Yes.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Well, we know what you think. Can the First Minister tell members what he means by “an independent country”?

Members: Oh!

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I mean a country that is free to make its own decisions, which stands on its own two feet financially, which operates in co-operation with other countries in the world and which is not, on major policy issues, subjected to a policy direction such as the current attack on people with disabilities; that policy is not supported by the Scottish population.

I suppose that by independence I mean the normal status of some 200 nations across the planet.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The attacks on the disabled are coming from the Tories; they are not doing that because they are English. The First Minister must understand that the choice in this country is not between the Tories and separation; there is another approach.

The First Minister conceded this week, significantly, that in his version of independence the Bank of England would be the lender of last resort. Does that mean that John Swinney will bring his budget to not only this chamber, but the Bank of England to ask how much he has permission to borrow, what his fiscal policies should be and how much he can spend? The First Minister told us this week that he is an avowed Anglophile. Is he not taking that a bit too far?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will take those points in turn. First, Johann Lamont’s idea that we can somehow separate out the fact that, under the current constitution, Scotland not just sometimes but much of the time gets Governments that we do not vote for, is a great mistake. One of the great advantages of the right of self-determination and independence is that people get the Government that they vote for, not the Government that somebody else votes for.

I am not quite certain that monetary policy is Johann Lamont’s best subject, but I heard her deputy leader say on the radio this morning that if Scotland had a monetary union and the Bank of England was the lender of last resort, Scotland would lose the ability to set interest rates. I have news for the Labour Party: politicians lost the ability to set interest rates on 6 May 1997, when Gordon Brown declared the Bank of England independent. It is that separation between monetary policy controlled by the monetary policy committee and the Bank of England, and fiscal policy controlled by the chancellor that perhaps Johann Lamont wants to catch up on.

Independence would mean that the Scottish finance secretary would be able to set our taxes and to govern our spending. For example, at the present moment he would be able to provide capital investment to revive the Scottish economy.

I am delighted with these questions because they are exactly the nub of the debate that will persuade people to vote for independence in the referendum.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I bow to the expertise of the ex-Royal Bank of Scotland economist, who of course was so wise and sensible that he wrote to Fred Goodwin to urge him to buy the bank that nearly broke the Royal Bank of Scotland. Perhaps some humility about our ability on the economy might be in order. The First Minister is telling us that he is content that the key decisions that will impact on people’s mortgages, savings and pensions will be made by a foreign bank with no remit to look at Scotland’s conditions and circumstances. Does he agree with his own chief economic adviser, Crawford Beveridge, that that is “not ideal”?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am not sure that Fred Goodwin is the strongest suit of the Labour Party. After all, I did not make him Sir Fred Goodwin—that was Jack McConnell—nor did I have him as one of my economic advisers—that was Gordon Brown.

When Johann Lamont has had the chance to look at my answer to her second question, I think that she will see the answer to her third question. The Chancellor of the Exchequer does not set interest rates any more—that has not happened since 1997, when the Bank of England was declared independent. It is quite interesting that the Labour Party was keener on independence for the Bank of England than it was on independence for its country of Scotland, but we will leave that to one side.

Such an arrangement is not uncommon in the world. There are some 67 countries that are in formal or informal monetary unions. That does not mean that they are not independent countries; it just means that they are in monetary unions. It has been suggested by some ex-Labour ministers such as Lord Myners that people in England might not wish to have that currency arrangement. Let us get it right. It is not possible to stop people using a tradeable currency—that was just a myth that was spread by the chancellor’s advisers.

I will give a couple of good reasons why I think that any chancellor would accept the idea of a currency union between Scotland and England. The first is to do with oil and gas. Scotland would get the revenues from our geographical share of oil and gas but, in addition, oil and gas provide £30,000 million of support for the balance of payments and therefore to the sterling area. Secondly, Scotland has international exports worth £24 billion, including £4 billion of whisky exports. Given the huge support that Scotland gives the sterling area, I believe that any chancellor would be biting off our hands to come to such a sensible arrangement.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
That comes to the nub of it—the First Minister hopes and believes that that will be the case, but it will not necessarily be so. The reality is that the people of this country want to have confidence in their pensions, their mortgages and their future.

We know that Alex Salmond thinks that he has the prescription for Scotland’s ills—it is the same one that he has had for the past 40 years. In that time, the world has changed and we have changed. We have the euro, the rise of China, the devolution of Scotland and technological revolution, but in good times or bad, feast or famine, high days and holidays, he always has the same answer—separation.

Is the truth not that the Scottish National Party’s push for separation, rather than being about people’s savings, their mortgages or their pensions, is about the First Minister’s blind faith that things will be better because he says so? Why is he prepared to take unnecessary risks with people’s mortgages, their savings and their pensions in the midst of the worst global economic crisis since the 1930s? There is no good reason, because political separation will mean that we will have less economic control to serve the people of this country.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am glad that Labour is living up to the boast that it will argue a positive case for the union.

When it comes to who is aware of developments in the modern world, the nub of the issue is that, over the past few decades, the number of independent countries in the United Nations has grown from 50 to 200. If we are talking about the tide of history, I would have thought that the tide of history was moving towards the status of independence. Since the second world war, 50 of those countries have become independent from London and, you know what, not a single one of them has applied to get back under London control.

Scotland would emerge as an independent country with the sixth highest wealth per head of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries. That, in itself, is not the argument for independence—the argument for independence is self-determination—but given that we would be the sixth most prosperous country in the developed world, most people in Scotland will have some degree of confidence in our ability not just to survive, but to prosper as a socially just, economically progressive society.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Public Transport Debate · 86
  2. Kinship Carers Debate · 70
  3. Unemployment (Glasgow Provan) Questions · 4
  4. National Health Service Boards (2011-12 Financial Outturn) Questions · 6
  5. Insulin Pumps Questions · 6
  6. National Housing Trust Questions · 10
  7. Scottish Agricultural Wages Board Questions · 6
  8. Khalil Rasjed Dale Questions · 4
  9. Court Closures (Consultation) Questions · 5
  10. Money Laundering (Land and Property Transactions) Questions · 4
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Benefit Reforms (Impact on Child Poverty) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Local Authorities (Fitness for Purpose) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Scotch Whisky (Overseas Promotion) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  17. Education and Lifelong Learning Questions · 1
  18. Universities (Co-operation and Collaboration) Questions · 4
  19. Gaelic-medium Education (Highlands) Questions · 6
  20. Further Education Budget Reductions (Vulnerable Groups) Questions · 4
  21. Secondary School Education Questions · 6
  22. Secondary School Inspections (2011) Questions · 4
  23. Modern Language Teaching Questions · 4
  24. Gaelic Action Plan Questions · 4
  25. Post-16 Education Reform (Consultation) Questions · 4
  26. College Student Support Budget Questions · 16
  27. College Budget Reductions (People with Learning Disabilities) Questions · 4
  28. Teacher Numbers Questions · 6
  29. NUS Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 6
  30. College Student Numbers Questions · 7
  31. Dyslexia Testing (National Guidelines) Questions · 4
  32. College Budget Reductions (Impact) Questions · 4
  33. Probationary Teachers (Employment) Questions · 8
  34. National Steering Group on Advocacy Support for Children and Young People (Meetings) Questions · 4
  35. Claim of Right Debate · 136
  36. Point of Order Procedure · 5
  37. Decision Time Decision time · 16
  38. Local Train Services (Glasgow) Members’ business · 63

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.