1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00822)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
12 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00822)
Later today, I will visit Forth Valley College in Stirling to open its new state-of-the-art £20 million campus building. That cutting-edge facility is one of the most advanced college premises in Scotland and demonstrates this Government’s unwavering commitment to the college sector.
It is astonishing that the Government’s definition of “unwavering commitment” is the cutting of colleges’ budgets by 20 per cent.
So, Nicola Sturgeon is the new minister for shovel-ready projects and Alex Neil gets a hospital pass. As I look round the chamber, I can see that not everyone is smiling—not Jamie Hepburn, who was passed over for the crime of sticking to party policy on NATO, and not Kenny Gibson, who is never the bridesmaid and is not even invited to the evening reception. The First Minister is not so much rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic as swapping the mop heads on the Vital Spark.
It is not just the First Minister’s back benchers who are unhappy. Anyone in the country who is looking for a full-time job and any business that is looking for opportunities is unhappy. Why has the First Minister reduced the ministerial responsibility for economic recovery to a part-time post? Why is running the national health service less important than running his referendum?
So, Nicola Sturgeon is the new minister for shovel-ready projects and Alex Neil gets a hospital pass. As I look round the chamber, I can see that not everyone is smiling—not Jamie Hepburn, who was passed over for the crime of sticking to party policy on NATO, and not Kenny Gibson, who is never the bridesmaid and is not even invited to the evening reception. The First Minister is not so much rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic as swapping the mop heads on the Vital Spark.
It is not just the First Minister’s back benchers who are unhappy. Anyone in the country who is looking for a full-time job and any business that is looking for opportunities is unhappy. Why has the First Minister reduced the ministerial responsibility for economic recovery to a part-time post? Why is running the national health service less important than running his referendum?
I cannot believe that Johann Lamont is accusing someone else of not smiling.
Let me deal with the college sector first. I have been looking at the massive capital investment programme in the Scottish college sector—in Dundee, Forth Valley, Kilmarnock, Inverness and, of course, Glasgow, where £200 million of capital investment is coming to City of Glasgow College. I have been looking at what that will do to the college budget—current and capital—over the next couple of years. It means that the college budget moves from £574 million to an expected £655 million in 2014-15, which means, for example, a capital programme in that year of £184 million. That is the extent of this Government’s commitment to the college sector in Scotland. Ten years ago, the Labour Party’s capital programme in our college sector was £21 million. I repeat: £21 million.
On the Government changes, Johann Lamont is in a position in which she has to select her shadow cabinet from outwith the ranks of members of the Scottish Parliament, such is the dearth of talent. I am in the fortunate position in which every single member of this Government is focused on economic recovery and public services in Scotland, and every single member of this Government is looking to secure for this nation the economic and political powers that we need to ensure a prosperous and just future.
Let me deal with the college sector first. I have been looking at the massive capital investment programme in the Scottish college sector—in Dundee, Forth Valley, Kilmarnock, Inverness and, of course, Glasgow, where £200 million of capital investment is coming to City of Glasgow College. I have been looking at what that will do to the college budget—current and capital—over the next couple of years. It means that the college budget moves from £574 million to an expected £655 million in 2014-15, which means, for example, a capital programme in that year of £184 million. That is the extent of this Government’s commitment to the college sector in Scotland. Ten years ago, the Labour Party’s capital programme in our college sector was £21 million. I repeat: £21 million.
On the Government changes, Johann Lamont is in a position in which she has to select her shadow cabinet from outwith the ranks of members of the Scottish Parliament, such is the dearth of talent. I am in the fortunate position in which every single member of this Government is focused on economic recovery and public services in Scotland, and every single member of this Government is looking to secure for this nation the economic and political powers that we need to ensure a prosperous and just future.
I will never, ever apologise for drawing on the expertise of ordinary people across this country, including students, who know what the First Minister is doing to them. The reality is that the gap between what the First Minister says is happening and what is actually happening on the ground is growing wider by the day. Ask any college principal, and that is what they will tell you.
Let me get this right. In the morning, Nicola Sturgeon will deal with Scotland’s biggest decision for 300 years. In the afternoon, she will deal with the greatest economic crisis since the depression in the 1930s. What on earth will she do over lunch? Will she split the atom?
On Tuesday, the First Minister said:
“There has never been an economic recovery without a recovery in the construction sector”—[Official Report, 4 September 2012; c 10899.]
This is the man who cut £86 million from the housing budget. Now he has downgraded the post of minister for construction to a part-time job. How does he explain to someone who is looking for work that the issue is on Nicola Sturgeon’s to-do list—that it is for some point when she gets past what she really cares about, which is the constitution?
Let me get this right. In the morning, Nicola Sturgeon will deal with Scotland’s biggest decision for 300 years. In the afternoon, she will deal with the greatest economic crisis since the depression in the 1930s. What on earth will she do over lunch? Will she split the atom?
On Tuesday, the First Minister said:
“There has never been an economic recovery without a recovery in the construction sector”—[Official Report, 4 September 2012; c 10899.]
This is the man who cut £86 million from the housing budget. Now he has downgraded the post of minister for construction to a part-time job. How does he explain to someone who is looking for work that the issue is on Nicola Sturgeon’s to-do list—that it is for some point when she gets past what she really cares about, which is the constitution?
Let me deal with the consequences of London rule over Scotland, which is supported by Johann Lamont and her friends in the Conservative Party. The capital budget for Scotland that was outlined by Alistair Darling—the capital budget in which cuts were to be “deeper and tougher” than the cuts that were imposed by Margaret Thatcher, as Alistair Darling himself predicted—would reduce by 37 per cent in real terms between 2010-11 and 2013-14. Through the munificence of the Conservative-Liberal Administration and additions through consequentials, that cut has been reduced from the 37 per cent that was planned by Alistair Darling to 33.4 per cent next year.
Can Johann Lamont make a possible connection between a 33 per cent cut in the capital budget and the consequences that that has for people in Scotland? Does she not understand that almost 90 per cent of Scotland’s budget is controlled by Westminster? Can she explain to the Scottish people why she wants to continue with a situation in which Scotland suffers from the cuts that have been ordered by successive Tory and Labour Chancellors of the Exchequer?
Can Johann Lamont make a possible connection between a 33 per cent cut in the capital budget and the consequences that that has for people in Scotland? Does she not understand that almost 90 per cent of Scotland’s budget is controlled by Westminster? Can she explain to the Scottish people why she wants to continue with a situation in which Scotland suffers from the cuts that have been ordered by successive Tory and Labour Chancellors of the Exchequer?
The First Minister makes my case for me. If the Tories are attacking Scotland in the way that he says they are, why, in the face of that, does he not have a minister actively focus on protecting the people of Scotland, rather than focusing on the referendum?
If the First Minister wants to talk about working with the Tories, perhaps he had better speak to his Westminster colleagues, who I hear are saying that they will back the Tories on cutting the number of Scots MPs we send to Westminster. That will be a case about representation.[Interruption.]
If the First Minister wants to talk about working with the Tories, perhaps he had better speak to his Westminster colleagues, who I hear are saying that they will back the Tories on cutting the number of Scots MPs we send to Westminster. That will be a case about representation.[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The fact of the matter is that the First Minister’s problem is that his priorities are not those of the people of Scotland. We know that he is fond of quoting opinion polls. Let me quote from one that was published this morning. When asked what subject they would raise with the First Minister, 68 per cent of young Scots said that they would raise jobs and the economy. Only 5 per cent said that they would raise the constitution, which came behind jobs, crime and the health service, yet the First Minister has downgraded jobs and the economy and has placed less importance on hospital care—all because of his obsession with breaking up the United Kingdom. Does he not see that he is out of touch and that he does not care about jobs, other than his own?
First, I will deal with the health service. Nicola Sturgeon was in post as health secretary for five and a half years. That is more than twice as long as anybody in the history of devolution, and is almost as long as Nye Bevan—who founded the national health service—was in post. That is not a bad comparison since Nicola Sturgeon, as health secretary, restored the principle of health care being free at the point of need to the Scottish people.
Under John Swinney’s leadership on the economy, we have jobs in Scotland: a better employment rate, a lower unemployment rate and lower inactivity than the rest of the United Kingdom. That is notable performance when set against the restrictions of the Tory Government at Westminster.
If Johann Lamont does not like Tory rule from Westminster—except of course when she shares platforms with the Tories throughout Scotland—why on earth does she support the continuing Exchequer rule over Scotland, which is forcing the cuts not only in the areas that we control and in which we can try to give protection, but in areas such as welfare, through which the Westminster Government is putting hundreds of thousands of Scottish people into poverty? Why does Johann Lamont support that kind of policy from Westminster?
The best opinion poll that I saw over the summer was from that Labour Party affiliated organisation, the Fabian Society. Through YouGov, it asked people in Scotland what words they associate with the Labour Party. The top three—remember this is a Fabian Society poll—were “out of touch”, at 35 per cent; “incompetent”, at 29 per cent; and “boring”, at 26 per cent. If that is what the Fabian Society thinks that people think of the Labour Party, what do the rest of the population think?
Under John Swinney’s leadership on the economy, we have jobs in Scotland: a better employment rate, a lower unemployment rate and lower inactivity than the rest of the United Kingdom. That is notable performance when set against the restrictions of the Tory Government at Westminster.
If Johann Lamont does not like Tory rule from Westminster—except of course when she shares platforms with the Tories throughout Scotland—why on earth does she support the continuing Exchequer rule over Scotland, which is forcing the cuts not only in the areas that we control and in which we can try to give protection, but in areas such as welfare, through which the Westminster Government is putting hundreds of thousands of Scottish people into poverty? Why does Johann Lamont support that kind of policy from Westminster?
The best opinion poll that I saw over the summer was from that Labour Party affiliated organisation, the Fabian Society. Through YouGov, it asked people in Scotland what words they associate with the Labour Party. The top three—remember this is a Fabian Society poll—were “out of touch”, at 35 per cent; “incompetent”, at 29 per cent; and “boring”, at 26 per cent. If that is what the Fabian Society thinks that people think of the Labour Party, what do the rest of the population think?
The First Minister might want to reflect on the fact that the people of this country do not think that his obsession—the referendum—is their priority. That is the biggest gap that he has to deal with.
If I was concerned about the health service, I do not think that I would be putting in charge of it a man who, in his previous job in relation to the economy, presided over a slash in the housing budget and exported £700 million to boost the economies of China, Spain and Poland.
Last May, Nicola Sturgeon was in charge of another campaign—a campaign to take over Scotland’s biggest city. She made her campaign not about the priorities of the people of Glasgow, but about Glasgow being a stepping-stone to independence, and she got roundly thumped. It is clear that the First Minister has learned nothing from that. The people’s priorities are jobs, paying their bills and putting food on the table when, in Salmond’s Scotland, thousands of families now need food parcels. The First Minister cannot keep Scotland on pause for the next two years. When will he realise that it is not independence that Scots families care about? It’s the economy, stupid.
If I was concerned about the health service, I do not think that I would be putting in charge of it a man who, in his previous job in relation to the economy, presided over a slash in the housing budget and exported £700 million to boost the economies of China, Spain and Poland.
Last May, Nicola Sturgeon was in charge of another campaign—a campaign to take over Scotland’s biggest city. She made her campaign not about the priorities of the people of Glasgow, but about Glasgow being a stepping-stone to independence, and she got roundly thumped. It is clear that the First Minister has learned nothing from that. The people’s priorities are jobs, paying their bills and putting food on the table when, in Salmond’s Scotland, thousands of families now need food parcels. The First Minister cannot keep Scotland on pause for the next two years. When will he realise that it is not independence that Scots families care about? It’s the economy, stupid.
Given that I am now on my fourth Labour Party leader since 2007, I do not think that Labour should talk about people getting “thumped” in elections in Scotland; Labour has had plenty of that.
As far as Alex Neil is concerned, I think that he epitomises the values of the national health service better than any member of the Labour Party in this Parliament—with the possible exception of Malcolm Chisholm, who was, of course, unfortunately removed as health minister by the Labour Party. The health service is safe in the hands of Alex Neil, rather than in the hands of a Labour Party that has been lying down on privatisation of the health service south of the border.
As regards Johann Lamont’s explanation of why people are happy with her alliance with the Tory party, I do not believe that it is universal in the Labour Party ranks. Another former leader of Glasgow City Council and former MSP, Charlie Gordon, said on Twitter:
“Only halfway through recession. Jobless youngsters’ benefits threatened. Devolution can’t protect them. Better together with the Tories?”
I think that there are questions in the minds of Labour MSPs as well as in the mind of every Labour supporter in Scotland about the alliance that Johann Lamont has made with the Conservative party front bench.
I go back to the Fabian Society’s opinion poll. It was not all bad news for the Labour Party. Some people felt that the Labour Party in Scotland has “plenty of ideas”. That number was 8 per cent. I think that that 8 per cent is a massive figure, given the desultory and negative performance of the Labour Party in this Parliament since 2007.
As far as Alex Neil is concerned, I think that he epitomises the values of the national health service better than any member of the Labour Party in this Parliament—with the possible exception of Malcolm Chisholm, who was, of course, unfortunately removed as health minister by the Labour Party. The health service is safe in the hands of Alex Neil, rather than in the hands of a Labour Party that has been lying down on privatisation of the health service south of the border.
As regards Johann Lamont’s explanation of why people are happy with her alliance with the Tory party, I do not believe that it is universal in the Labour Party ranks. Another former leader of Glasgow City Council and former MSP, Charlie Gordon, said on Twitter:
“Only halfway through recession. Jobless youngsters’ benefits threatened. Devolution can’t protect them. Better together with the Tories?”
I think that there are questions in the minds of Labour MSPs as well as in the mind of every Labour supporter in Scotland about the alliance that Johann Lamont has made with the Conservative party front bench.
I go back to the Fabian Society’s opinion poll. It was not all bad news for the Labour Party. Some people felt that the Labour Party in Scotland has “plenty of ideas”. That number was 8 per cent. I think that that 8 per cent is a massive figure, given the desultory and negative performance of the Labour Party in this Parliament since 2007.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 6 Sep 2012 →- Paddle Sports Questions · 7
- Scottish Development International (Links with Turkey) Questions · 4
- Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland and Historic Scotland (Merger) Questions · 4
- Naloxone Programme (Benefits) Questions · 6
- Infrastructure Projects (Delays) (North-east Economy) Questions · 6
- International Culture Summit 2012 (Benefits) Questions · 5
- Hospital Patients’ Accommodation (Consultation) Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- BBC Scotland (Job Losses and Gaelic News Service Reduction) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- CalMac Ferries (Services) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Rolls-Royce Group (East Kilbride Plant Proposed Closure) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- “River City” Members’ business · 9
- Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 138
- Local Government Finance (Unoccupied Properties etc) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Junior Ministers Debate · 11
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.