Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Wednesday 2 May 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 15 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00641)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Given the further revelations in the past few days, why does the First Minister still believe that Rupert Murdoch is a fit person to run an international media company?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I have said that that should be judged by the relevant authorities—that means the Office of Communications, in terms of broadcasting, and in general terms the Leveson inquiry. That is where those matters should be judged in an independent manner.

The Labour Party’s actions yesterday on a House of Commons committee served only to split that committee on political lines and were not advisable. [Interruption.] It is a statement of fact that the committee was split on political lines, when it was meant to be unified in pursuing an inquiry. That is exactly what happened. Incidentally, I note that the Labour leadership in London, unlike Johann Lamont, when asked that very question, said that the matters should be judged by Ofcom and the Leveson inquiry.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I presume that the First Minister is content to be on the same side as the Tories in their view of Rupert Murdoch. I would have a bit more respect for the First Minister if he allowed his back benchers to say what they think in our parliamentary committees.

The First Minister has in the past accused me of hypocrisy in raising the issue.

Members: Yes.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I agree—he has persisted in arguing that line lots of times. However, let me give him a real example of hypocrisy. I quote:

“The prospect of one person, especially Mr Murdoch, having more influence over the media in the UK would be a matter of concern, especially in Scotland.”

Those are not my words, but the words of the Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, when Murdoch tried to take over ITV news. She was right then and I agree with her, so what made her change her mind? It cannot have been when she found out about phone hacking on an industrial scale. It could not have been when she found out that the phone of a murdered teenager was hacked. Surely it was not when she found out that Joan McAlpine’s phone was hacked. Did she change her mind when the First Minister told her to after he realised that he is the last person left defending Rupert Murdoch?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I condemn phone hacking regardless of who the victim is and who the perpetrators are. That has been my consistent position and it will continue to be my position. The most obvious explanation in answer to Johann Lamont’s question is that there were two different subjects. The first was about ITV, in which News Corporation did not have a controlling stake or major interests. The second was about BSkyB, in which News Corp already had a 39 per cent stake. Most people, including Ofcom, after assurances were given on Sky news, said that the issue would not be one of plurality—that is what Ofcom reported to the Government.

As for alliances with the Conservative Party, I have to say that Johann Lamont is on very weak ground. Not only do we have a weekly attempt to build the grand alliance with the Conservative Party in this Parliament but, of course, when it came to the budget, the Labour Party decided to vote with the Conservatives and against apprenticeships in Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
If the First Minister was so concerned about the Milly Dowler issue, he certainly would not have sought to rehabilitate Rupert Murdoch by inviting him to tea at Bute house. Further, he would not have sought to dissemble on who was responsible on the issue when he wrote an article in the first edition of The Scottish Sun on Sunday.

Is it not the truth that the First Minister’s relationship with Rupert Murdoch is preventing any real scrutiny of News International’s activities in Scotland? When the phone hacking scandal broke, the First Minister claimed that it was a London problem. Well, it is now well and truly on the First Minister’s doorstep. It is time that we had a proper inquiry here in Scotland that investigates who else has been hacked and the full extent of the media influence over politicians and Government. A former First Minister has been hacked and an aide to the current First Minister has been hacked. Has the First Minister himself been hacked? Why is he blocking a Scottish inquiry into the activities of his old friend Rupert Murdoch?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Perhaps we can now get to the nub of the issue. It is time that the Parliament realised the full seriousness of what it is intended to do in Scotland. At present, we have a live police inquiry in Scotland, which has up to 40 officers working on it. That is a huge commitment of resource by Strathclyde Police.

I know that, because of the inaction in the past of the Metropolitan Police, people are sceptical about police inquiries into these matters, but there is no reason to be sceptical about the inquiry by Strathclyde Police. It is a live inquiry, huge resources are being devoted to it and the expectation is that the force will pursue the evidence without fear or favour and produce effective results.

There are implications for what should be done elsewhere, because a police inquiry has primacy. That means that any committee of this Parliament could not impinge on information to that inquiry, that any witness would have to be warned against incrimination and that anybody who was subject to adverse publicity in a parliamentary inquiry could quote article 6 of the European convention on human rights and use that as a defence in a future criminal inquiry. In other words, there could be a significant risk that a criminal investigation or inquiry would be compromised. It is vital that members understand that a real police inquiry is now taking place in Scotland—would that that had happened in 2005, when the issues were being carried through.

Even the Leveson inquiry, which is a judicial inquiry, has to bear in mind the existence of a live police inquiry. For example, when the chief constable of Strathclyde went before Leveson, he could not be questioned on all the aspects that are being considered by the current police inquiry. That is exactly why Leveson is looking at a range of issues that go beyond the criminal investigations.

I shall be absolutely delighted next month to go to Leveson and account for my contacts with News International and News Corp over the years. I am not certain that members of the Labour Party will have such a comfortable experience.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I do not think that even the First Minister himself believed that, never mind his back benchers. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
This is our great, modern, new Scottish Parliament. We see a Tory secretary of state being brought before the House of Commons, we see a Tory Prime Minister being brought before the House of Commons, where we also see a parliamentary inquiry. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
However, in the Scottish Parliament, the First Minister runs away from accountability.

These things are not incompatible, except in the First Minister’s own head. The First Minister told us that

“the people who live in Scotland are the best people to make decisions about their own future. Of that there can be no doubt”.—[Official Report, 25 January 2012; c 5603.]

Yet he is content to rely on a judicial inquiry in London and an inquiry that is being run by a parliamentary committee in London to determine the truth in Scotland. I look forward to hearing the First Minister answer a question under oath—indeed, I look forward to hearing him answer a question.

The question for the First Minister now is: why does he fear a parliamentary investigation here in Scotland? This started with Rupert Murdoch trying to take over BSkyB, but it turns out that he owns the Scottish National Party.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont gets her chance every week to ask me questions. The fact that she does not make a good job of it is hardly my responsibility.

I have already tried to explain the importance of police inquiries. Incidentally, Parliament can do exactly what it likes, but police inquiries take precedence on such issues.

I will now try to inform Johann Lamont about Leveson. The Leveson inquiry has been established under the Inquiries Act 2005, which means that the Scottish Government had to be consulted on the inquiry’s terms of reference—as, incidentally, did the other devolved Administrations. We tried to broaden and strengthen the terms of reference—I will put that correspondence with the UK Government in the Scottish Parliament information centre, so that every member can see it.

In common with other political leaders, I will be going to Leveson next month and will be able to account for all my meetings. I will account for every single one of the five meetings that I have had with Rupert Murdoch over the past five years. I am sure that Gordon Brown will be delighted to explain the 17 meetings that he had over three years and David Cameron the 18 meetings that he has had over the past five years. It will be the responsibility of every leading politician to explain their meetings because the Leveson inquiry is considering—under oath—relationships between the press and politicians.

Johann Lamont asked me why I believe that the Labour Party is guilty of hypocrisy on the issue. I will give her two explanations. First, the events that we are discussing took place on the Labour Party’s watch: it was in government in London and Edinburgh at the time. Secondly, the idea that, if the Labour Party complains hard enough, people will forget about 15 years of association with News International is for the birds. People look at the Labour Party and say, “Humbug and hypocrisy.”

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Council Tax Benefit (North Ayrshire Council) Questions · 4
  3. Business Start-ups (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  4. Research and Development (Small and Medium-sized Enterprises) (South Scotland) Questions · 4
  5. Credit Unions Questions · 4
  6. Council Tax Arrears Questions · 4
  7. Unemployment (West Dunbartonshire) Questions · 8
  8. Local Income Tax Questions · 4
  9. Small Business Bonus Scheme (East Kilbride) Questions · 4
  10. Renewables (Employment) Questions · 9
  11. Steel Industry (North Lanarkshire) Questions · 7
  12. Economy (Greenock and Inverclyde) Questions · 6
  13. Economic Activity (Perth) Questions · 4
  14. Renewable Energy (West Scotland) Questions · 4
  15. Regional Pay Questions · 4
  16. Welfare Reform (Further Provision) (Scotland) Bill Questions · 6
  17. Marriage Ceremonies Questions · 4
  18. Agricultural Support (Map Scale) Questions · 6
  19. Agricultural Rent Reviews Questions · 5
  20. Domestic Abuse (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  21. Transport Infrastructure (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
  22. Care Homes (Southern Cross Healthcare) Questions · 5
  23. Emergency Towing Vessel Service (Pentland Firth) Questions · 6
  24. HIV Prevention (NHS Tayside) Questions · 4
  25. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
  26. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  27. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  28. Local Democracy First Minister’s Questions · 6
  29. Khalil Dale First Minister’s Questions · 4
  30. Empty Commercial Properties First Minister’s Questions · 4
  31. National Performing Companies Debate · 35
  32. Advisory Committee on Hazardous Substances (Abolition) Order 2012 Debate · 2
  33. Business Motions Business motions · 9
  34. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 4
  36. National Multiple Sclerosis Week Members’ business · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.