Right.
Official Report · Committee
Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill: Stage 1
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 67
- Dr Lancaster 40
- Mark Harrower Edinburgh Bar Association 23
- Kingsley Thomas Scottish Legal Aid Board 20
- Roderick Campbell SNP 15
- Alison McInnes LD 10
- Jenny Marra Lab 10
- Oliver Adair Law Society of Scotland 9
- Ian Moir Law Society of Scotland 8
- David McLetchie Con 8
- Graeme Pearson Lab 8
- Elspeth Molony Capability Scotland 6
- John Finnie SNP 5
- James Wolffe 5
- Professor Miller 4
- James Wolffe QC Faculty of Advocates 1
- Professor Alan Miller Scottish Human Rights Commission 1
- Dr Colin Lancaster Scottish Legal Aid Board 1
The record
241 contributions · showing 201–241This is all very illuminating, but it is not transparent and it is not my idea of 21st century access to justice.You heard Mark Harrower from the previous witness panel say that this is basically a back-door attempt to reduce solicitors’ fees and that you know that they will not be able to collect the fees. If the Government had concluded that you should collect all the contributions for the summary cases and the other cases, would you be telling us that it was such a good idea?
That contributions were a good idea?
Yes.
We think that, in principle, contributions are absolutely right. In the paper, “A Sustainable Future for Legal Aid”, the cabinet secretary made it clear that, as a general principle, those who can pay should pay; those who can afford to make a contribution towards the costs of the assistance that they are provided with should pay towards those costs. That happens in ABWOR cases and in civil legal aid. There seems to be no reason why we should have in criminal legal aid a system that requires us to grant free legal aid for a case that will cost £300 to someone whose disposable income would require them to pay a contribution of £2,500 were they to have a civil case. It seems absolutely reasonable for a person in those circumstances to make a contribution or, indeed, to meet the whole cost of their case, but the current system does not allow that.
You said earlier that collecting fees and charges was your daily bread and butter. Why would your collecting all the charges not be the most efficient way of rolling things out?
I think that we said that assessing eligibility and taking decisions on cases was our bread and butter. On the civil legal aid side, we also collect contributions.You mentioned collecting fees. This is where the discussion is a little bit strange. We are talking about a system whereby the state pays fees to solicitors on behalf of people who cannot pay those fees. We are talking about a system in which we would collect the fee from the client and give it to the solicitor, rather than the client give their fee to the solicitor for the work that the solicitor is doing for them. It is the solicitor’s fee, so it would seem unnecessary for us to become involved in that process. We do not get involved in that process for private clients. I am not sure why one would say that we would need to collect the fee from a client who was receiving legal aid when solicitors have mechanisms to collect their fee from their private clients. They would not suggest that we should be an intermediary in those circumstances.
You heard the previous panel say that it made administrative sense to do it that way, because we do not want to see further churn in the system at intermediate diets, at which people say that are not ready to roll because they are not sure that they will get paid. Do you not think that that confuses the whole landscape?
I am not aware of solicitors turning up in court and saying that they cannot proceed with a case for a private client because the private client has not given them the latest instalment. I am not sure, but that does not sound like a legitimate reason to give to the court for seeking an adjournment. Not having been provided with funds by a client is not the same as not being ready to proceed, and I do not think that solicitors do that in private cases.I will try to put the issue in context. Again, we can provide this information after the meeting. We looked at a number of firms to find out how often they would have to collect contributions and what the scale of those contributions would be. We looked at a number of medium-sized firms that have fair volumes of summary and solemn business. I will give an example.Between December 2010 and November 2011, a firm in Glasgow received 256 grants of summary criminal legal aid. We reckon that 17 of those would involve a contribution and that the total value of those contributions would be just under £5,000. That is in the context of the firm earning £138,000 from summary criminal legal aid. As a whole, the firm would be looking at collecting contributions worth £8,300. Its total income from legal aid is £323,000. In total, contributions would have to be collected from 29 clients out of 396 cases a year. We are talking about a small percentage of the firm’s business and a very small percentage of its income. At that level, we are talking about less than 3 per cent of its total income from legal aid being obtained directly from its clients.Our best estimate is that between 5 and 10 per cent of many firms’ criminal income comes from private clients. We are talking about firms being required to collect a lower value of contributions than the value of the contributions that they are currently collecting from private clients. When firms say they have no mechanisms to collect fees, I do not know how they get their private fees.
Why bother?
Why bother collecting from private clients?
Why bother means testing a contribution system? If there is such a substantial number of summary cases and such a substantial number are already on benefits, and we are putting in place a system that will possibly—just possibly—save £3.8 million, that is a small saving for a lot of work. We heard earlier that there could be ramifications in some cases—perhaps not the majority—for human rights, the pursuit of justice, and self-representation.12:00
The evidence from England and Wales is that since contributions were introduced in Crown Court cases in 2010 there has been no change in pleading patterns and the number of unrepresented accused. There has been an increase in the number of privately funded accused.
I understand that in England and Wales, clients can recover their contributions if they are successful and are acquitted—
And so can private clients—
But we do not have that, so it is comparing not apples and apples but apples and pears.
The English system is different. The recovery of costs from the state is part and parcel of the criminal justice system in England and Wales. It is not part and parcel of the criminal justice system here.
Sorry, I had to come in there because I thought that you were getting away with some stuff—not to put it as roughly as that, but I wanted to persist a bit more with you.
Professor Miller, in your written submission you pointed out that you would like clarification of the Government’s intention in section 17 of the bill. Will you elaborate to the committee your concerns about seeking legal advice while in detention?
In answer to that, but also more broadly, the issue of who should recover contributions is clearly one of concern. Is it solicitors? Is it SLAB? The level of eligibility is a real concern. I do not want to dwell too long on those individuals who might bring solemn business to law firms. I am more concerned about the individuals we all know who come into contact with the criminal justice system because of various vulnerabilities, for example mental health issues and physical disabilities. We heard from Capability Scotland about where such individuals come from in society and their socioeconomic status.If we take a step back from the mechanics—legitimate though they are—and look at access to justice, fairness and proportionality, I am not at all convinced that a sufficient assessment has been done of the impact of the bill on vulnerable individuals who come into contact with the criminal justice system and are unable to pay for proper legal representation. They will either have to represent themselves—which can cause difficulties for them and for the criminal justice system—or, as we heard this morning from the Law Society of Scotland and others, it is easier and cheaper just to plead guilty than to go through it all. That is where we will have invisible human rights breaches. They may not be in the newspapers and they may not go to the European Court of Human Rights.After three years, we have just finished mapping the extent to which human rights are realised in Scotland, particularly by the most vulnerable. What we have found is that although the laws and the policies appear to be quite good, for many people, real life gets in the way and they do not get the outcomes that all of us sitting round here assume that they do. Those are invisible human rights breaches, whether they affect older people, disabled people or those who are charged with criminal offences and do not have access to effective representation.That is why I said earlier that we need more assurances that that will not happen. A lot of the assumptions that are being made by the Government and by my friends and colleagues here are a bit superficial and life gets in the way of some of them.
I wonder whether Professor Miller can expand on his comment about the lack of clarity in appeals in which the appellant dies but would have been entitled to have their expenses met.
We can discuss only what is in front of us and I believe that there are enough unknown risks about that. Indeed, I think that the policy memorandum’s statement on human rights, which says that there are no risks attached, is grossly inadequate.Of course, there are a lot of unknowns. I am not going to get into the whole Donald Rumsfeld thing, but the fact is that we know some of them. For example, we do not know what the levels of contribution will be or anything about a deceased’s contributions in appeals. An awful lot has been left to either subsequent regulation or the discretion of the Scottish Legal Aid Board, and the legal profession—or at least some of it—is sceptical about relying on either of those things. The committee needs a lot more information up front about the impact of not only what it sees, but what it does not see, and a proper impact assessment would benefit the committee in its efforts to weigh up what is being said in the bill’s defence and what appear to me to be legitimate concerns about its impact on real life and real people.
You have largely answered my question, but my understanding is that the equality impact assessment has not yet been produced. Disability issues have featured quite strongly in our discussions, but is there any flesh that you want to put on anything else? What other matters should the impact assessment cover?
You are fortunate, because your first evidence session was trying to do what an impact assessment should have done. There is no public association for the accused that can tell the committee, “This is our experience—listen to us.” The closest you have to that is Capability Scotland, which represents a section of the community that comes into contact with criminal justice, and the lawyers who have daily face-to-face understanding of what life is like for many of those who come into contact with the system. Their evidence raises a very big question mark over the human rights policy statement in the bill that there is no risk to the right to a fair trial.Without being excessively legalistic, I think that we all sign up to values and principles such as access to justice, fairness and proportionality. Article 6 of the European convention on human rights, which covers the right to a fair trial, is the hard-wired guarantee on this matter, and it is largely missing from the policy assessment and the debate about the collection of fees and eligibility levels. The question is whether there is a real risk that someone will not a get a fair trial under the measures proposed in the bill. You might think that that is inevitable. If so, the next question is whether that is a risk worth paying. Are the savings so good that we are prepared to run the risk and hope that no one gets an unfair trial? Are the savings proportionate to the risk that we seem to be running and the thin ice that we seem to be skating on—given the problems that the Law Society has identified—and sufficient to outweigh those concerns, legitimate though they might be? That is a matter for the committee, but I think that it must be open to question.
Dr Lancaster, did I hear you say that changes to contribution rules in England and Wales had not changed pleading behaviour?
Yes. Over the past five years, the percentage of people pleading guilty has remained pretty much flat.
I find it slightly difficult to square that evidence with paragraph 11 of the SLAB submission, which states that alignment of the rules for ABWOR, criminal legal aid and so on will effect change as a result of “changes in pleading behaviour”.
It will surprise you to hear that I do not think that those two positions are inconsistent. That part of our submission relates to the timing of a plea rather than entering a plea of guilty where one would not otherwise do so.The issue at present—as the example that I gave earlier suggests—is that some people are not eligible for ABWOR and if they wanted to have a lawyer represent them when they appeared in court, including for any subsequent plea in mitigation or deferred sentence, their only option would be to apply for summary criminal legal aid. In other words, they would enter a plea of not guilty and apply for summary criminal legal aid so that they could get funding under the disposable income and due hardship test.Under the proposed change, if a plea of guilty is the appropriate plea to make at the outset, people will be able to do that with the benefit of a lawyer representing them because they will be more likely to qualify for ABWOR than they are at present. The change actually increases eligibility for ABWOR.
Yes, I can see that, but your evidence on behavioural change—although, as someone once said, “They would say that, wouldn’t they?”—seems directly to contradict Mr Harrower’s responses to my questions. He seemed to think completely the opposite to what your submission and the Scottish Government’s consultation document say. There must be some way of reconciling that, must there not?
I think that we may have been looking at slightly different parts of the evidence and the provisions. We are talking about people who do not qualify for ABWOR pleading not guilty so that they can get the benefit of summary criminal legal aid.In future, there will be no reason for those people to enter a plea of not guilty to apply for summary criminal legal aid. They will be able to enter the plea that they want to make, and they will have taken advice from a solicitor on the consequences of doing so. If the advice is that that is the best thing to do, and the client is instructed that a plea of guilty should be tendered at the pleading diet, they will be able to do that and a grant of ABWOR will be made to cover it.When changes were made to payment regimes under summary justice reform, there was a big increase in the number of people who were pleading guilty at the pleading diet. There was no increase in the number of people who were pleading guilty overall, so there is no suggestion that those pleas were inappropriate, but people who would in the fullness of time have pled guilty at the intermediate diet, or possibly at the trial diet, were pleading guilty more often at the pleading diet, which is the most appropriate point at which that plea should be tendered.We say that the financial arrangements currently pose a barrier to some people for whom that is the appropriate plea, and we will remove that barrier.
I was not a criminal practitioner, but I am sure that people might plead guilty later because the complaint has been amended and reduced, so they are not pleading guilty to the same thing.
No one is suggesting that the only point at which one can or should plead guilty is the pleading diet, because things might change. There are discussions between the Crown and the defence and, if new evidence becomes available, charges can be dropped or amended.
A solicitor raised the point that some very smart accused—there are quite a lot of smart accused—in a domestic abuse case, for example, would delay their contributions and refuse to pay them to delay their imprisonment and the criminal prosecution process. Could that be done?
Again, that all hinges on whether the solicitor not having been put in funds would be a valid reason for the continuation of a case.
I understand that. If the solicitor is not in funds they will not appear, and they have to ask the court for a continuation. There is a knock-on effect, and Professor Miller referred in a broad way to the impact on justice. I think that we all agree that it is a good idea that people who can afford to pay should pay when they are in court, but it is not as simple as that, as all those other issues that are now emerging show.
The individual’s behaviour is a key element in that regard. Someone on the previous panel talked about a safety net, which I think that we need to consider for that sort of scenario. Although the accused should not be able to dictate the terms of the criminal justice system by refusing to pay, we recognise that it is important for proceedings to be able to go ahead as scheduled.12:15
Mr Harrower said that some at SLAB would love to see an expansion of the PDSO, but the fact is that the PDSO is available and it could act as a safety net. In 1999-2000, when fixed payments were introduced and the Law Society, the Edinburgh Bar Association and the Glasgow Bar Association said that people up and down the country would be appearing without representation, regulations were put in place to provide for a safety net whereby the PDSO would act in circumstances in which an accused could not find a solicitor to act for them. The safety net was in place but it was never called upon.We could put a safety net in place for the proposed scenario as well. We could say that, if there was a risk to proceedings, we would appoint a solicitor to act for the accused for the purpose of those proceedings. To be honest, having the PDSO do that is simply a way of minimising any additional cost to the public purse. If the PDSO provides the safety net, there is no additional cost to the public purse.
Would that have to be put in the primary legislation?
No, I do not think so. We would have to consider whether regulations would be required for a transfer in those circumstances, but the kind of system that is being proposed would work.
We will have to pursue that. You are thinking about it, but we have a timescale and we have to ensure that there are no gaps.Dr Lancaster, we have had quite a good session. I want to put Professor Miller on the spot now. The bill is in two parts and we cannot reject one part without rejecting the bill in its entirety. Any such amendment would also sabotage the civil part of the bill. How should the committee handle concerns about the operation of the legislation to ensure that the bill proceeds, while taking account of all the serious points that today’s panels have raised? How do we resolve that?
The committee can take a number of steps to satisfy itself that the proposed legislation is good. A more thorough impact assessment is needed than has been done so far. A pilot could be done to test whether the measures work and whether the concerns that have been raised are legitimate or ill-founded. A sunset clause could be inserted that would allow the legislation to be evaluated to see what impact it had had after a period of time. All those measures are possible.It might be good to get some clarity on the PDSO issue. I think I picked it up correctly that Mr Pearson asked whether contributions would have to be made directly to the PDSO by the accused. My concern is about someone who is not trying to manipulate the system, but is simply unable to pay the contributions. Having the PDSO as a safety net would not be a safety net for that person if they had to pay. That is my continuing concern.
I was not talking exclusively about someone manipulating the system, but about either of those circumstances. We need to ensure that justice continues. That was useful; thank you.Thank you all for your evidence. We now move into private session.12:18 Meeting continued in private until 12:46.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Sep 2012 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Scottish Civil Justice Council and Criminal Legal Assistance Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 241
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.