The ninth current petition is PE1421, by Gail Robertson, on behalf of the Outer Hebrides Transport Group, on fair ferry fares. Members have a note by the clerk, which is paper 11, and the submissions.Rhoda Grant, an MSP for the Highlands and Islands, has kindly come along to the meeting for our discussion of the petition. Would you like to say a few words, Rhoda?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Ferry Fares (PE1421)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 7
- Rhoda Grant Lab 4
- Joe FitzPatrick SNP 3
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
17 contributionsYes. Thank you, convener. I appreciate the committee’s consideration of the petition. I ask the committee to keep it open until the economic impact study has reported, which will allow the committee to review that report. If the committee decides to do that, there are two issues that I am keen for it to look into further in the meantime. First, the issue of hauliers needing to retender for contracts that have already been won on the old pricing system has come to light. Where haulage costs have gone up by 50 per cent on ferries, hauliers need to recontract with the people for whom they carry to ensure that they recoup those costs, but sometimes they are tied into contracts, which has not allowed them to do that. Big cash-flow problems are being created when hauliers have to absorb the increased costs, and there is a limit to the time for which they can absorb them without going out of business. That issue needs to be looked at as a matter of urgency.Secondly, NorthLink and CalMac Ferries operate a traders rebate scheme, and I am sure that such a scheme operates under the new northern isles contract. Hauliers are offered a rebate of up to 15 per cent, based on their utilisation of capacity on the ferries. I have heard from people in the Western Isles that that offer was not open for road equivalent tariff routes, but now that the RET has been withdrawn from the Western Isles, some operators are able to claim the 15 per cent whereas others are being told that they cannot claim it.I lodged a question on that, in answer to which the Minister for Housing and Transport, Keith Brown, stated that there is a“Traders Rebate Scheme which offers hauliers a rebate of up to 15% ... other than on the current RET routes (Western Isles, Coll and Tiree).”—Official Report, Written Answers, 19 June 2012; S4W-07640.My understanding is that the RET has been withdrawn from the Western Isles, Coll and Tiree. However, there seems to be an issue. Some port offices are offering the traders rebate scheme in the knowledge that the RET has been withdrawn, whereas other port offices are telling hauliers that they are not offering it. A very unlevel playing field is operating in the islands with the traders rebate scheme. Given that the petition is about fair ferry fares, it would be useful if the committee looked into that issue and into where the additional costs go when people have already contracted services. The petition should be kept open until the economic impact has been reported.
To be clear, are you suggesting that those questions should be addressed only to the Scottish Government or that we go down some other route as well?
They could go to the Scottish Government to start with. However, it might not be aware of the retendering. The chamber of commerce and some of the haulier companies themselves will obviously be aware of whether companies have been able to recoup any of the additional costs and, if not, how long they will be able to absorb them before they are forced out of business.
Perhaps we could ask the Road Haulage Association those questions.
Yes.
The first issue is whether we should continue the petition. As we heard, an economic study is being carried out. It would seem sensible to keep the petition open until we know the results of that. What are members’ views on that? Angus MacDonald has some experience from the Western Isles.
Yes. Given the points that Rhoda Grant raised, it is only fair to continue the petition. It is also fair to say that, in my experience, the Outer Hebrides Transport Group does not represent the majority view of island residents or, indeed, all the hauliers in the Western Isles. It is therefore clear that there is more investigation to be done.
It is certainly worth while to continue the petition until there is a report back on the study. However, I wonder whether it would be appropriate for Rhoda Grant MSP to ask some of the questions that she has raised in her capacity as a regional member.
I have raised them. As I said, I lodged a question. It is unclear to me whether the Government looks on the routes as having had the RET removed from them or whether it is still treating them as RET routes. The petition is about fair ferry fares. Obviously, it is unfair if some hauliers are getting an additional 15 per cent discount whereas others are not qualifying for that. That issue needs to be raised, and it would be helpful to have it dealt with with the petition.
It is important that we continue the petition, given that we are waiting for the results of the study. Also, the questions raised by Rhoda Grant have not been answered—as a committee, we can ask the Scottish Government those questions.15:15
I note Joe FitzPatrick’s distinction between a member’s regional role and questions related to the petition. Obviously, I have an interest as well, but I think that the questions are relevant to our understanding of the petition and to our getting more information. I was not aware of some of the details in the questions, and that detail will be useful in understanding the petition. The Government will give us an official view, which will help us to understand a bit more how to deal with the petition.
I am concerned that the questions come from one particular angle. My feeling is that it is better that they are dealt with by Rhoda Grant as an MSP rather than by the committee. We should continue the petition until the report is out, but I would say no to the suggestion that the committee should write the proposed letters.
I take on board Joe FitzPatrick’s point of view, but the committee is listening to the evidence that we have received so far on the issue. Rhoda Grant, as a local member, has come along to the committee and made us aware of other issues that might be affecting the area. It is up to the committee to decide whether it wishes to proceed with the petition and take on board the issues that she has raised. If we are to give the petition full consideration, we have to do that.Members of this committee or other members of the Parliament are welcome to piggy-back on the petitions that are before us and raise their own questions with ministers. However, the committee is within its rights to take on board the issues that Rhoda Grant has raised and seek answers to them. In that way, we can investigate the petition in the round—because there are other aspects—rather than just as the petitioner sees it.We often take that approach. As we have heard today, petitioners will submit further questions and it is up to the committee to decide whether we wish to take them on board. In this instance, Rhoda Grant has raised a number of relevant questions. If the committee is to consider the petition fully, it has to ask ministers questions to get answers to the points that have been raised.
Is that a reasonable point?
I am not going to oppose that.
I thank the member for that and I thank Rhoda Grant for coming to the meeting.Do members agree to continue the petition until the work of the six-month study has been reported on and to write to the Scottish Government and the chamber of commerce about the two points that Rhoda Grant has raised?Members indicated agreement.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 26 Jun 2012 →- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 44
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 20
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 17
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.