1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00405)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 2
The record
14 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00405)
I am delighted to announce that, later today, I will officially open the new headquarters of the global financial services firm FNZ, which supports more than 200 jobs in Edinburgh and recruits a large number of graduates. It is yet another example of a global company that supports jobs and investment and is expanding its operations in Scotland.
I am sure that we were all shocked yesterday to learn that every day for the past three months 200 Scots have lost their jobs. Unemployment has gone up 10 per cent over the same period, there has been a 25 per cent rise in the number of women who are unemployed—which must have an impact on families—and over the past year there has been a 123 per cent increase in long-term youth unemployment. In the light of those figures, what changes can we expect in the First Minister’s budget bill when it is published tomorrow?
As Johann Lamont is well aware, the Scottish Government places the highest emphasis on job creation. That has been the hallmark of all the budgets.
The unemployment figures here are extremely serious, as the unemployment figures across these islands are, but Johann Lamont should understand that we in Scotland do not currently have the ability to increase demand in the Scottish economy. That ability lies with the Westminster Government. That is exactly why in the past month the First Minister of Wales, the First Minister of Northern Ireland and I have repeatedly called for the United Kingdom Government to change economic direction and give us either an increase in demand now or the economic tools to do the job for Scotland.
The unemployment figures here are extremely serious, as the unemployment figures across these islands are, but Johann Lamont should understand that we in Scotland do not currently have the ability to increase demand in the Scottish economy. That ability lies with the Westminster Government. That is exactly why in the past month the First Minister of Wales, the First Minister of Northern Ireland and I have repeatedly called for the United Kingdom Government to change economic direction and give us either an increase in demand now or the economic tools to do the job for Scotland.
I know that there is a pattern, but I did not expect to get “hunt the alibi” quite so early.
This is not a game. We can trade figures, but we need to confront them. The reality is that although the First Minister is saying that job creation is his highest priority, it is not working. It seems to me that, although the First Minister has been in power for five years, he simply does not get it. Last summer, he claimed that the unemployment figures demonstrated not that they were not the Scottish Government’s fault, but that
“the economic policy of the Scottish Government is delivering, and is continuing to create and safeguard jobs across our communities”.
When the figures are good, the First Minister is fabulous, but when they are bad, where is that alibi? With 200 Scots losing their jobs each and every day on his watch, does he still stand by the statement that he made in the summer?
This is not a game. We can trade figures, but we need to confront them. The reality is that although the First Minister is saying that job creation is his highest priority, it is not working. It seems to me that, although the First Minister has been in power for five years, he simply does not get it. Last summer, he claimed that the unemployment figures demonstrated not that they were not the Scottish Government’s fault, but that
“the economic policy of the Scottish Government is delivering, and is continuing to create and safeguard jobs across our communities”.
When the figures are good, the First Minister is fabulous, but when they are bad, where is that alibi? With 200 Scots losing their jobs each and every day on his watch, does he still stand by the statement that he made in the summer?
If Johann Lamont cares to reacquaint herself with the statements that were made in the summer, she will find that they made it quite clear that the growth in jobs and activity that we saw in Scotland over that period would be put at risk unless the United Kingdom Government was prepared to change course. She and Labour members seem to think that only the Scottish National Party holds that view. I have Labour’s five-point plan for growth, which was announced in November 2011, before the admission last week that Labour’s new economic policy is identical to the Conservative Party’s economic policy. The five-point plan includes a £2 billion tax on bank bonuses, a temporary reversing of January’s VAT rise, a one-year cut in VAT to 5 per cent on home improvements, and a one-year national insurance tax break. Each of those is the province of the Westminster Government. The only area that is the province of the Scottish Government—the switch to capital investment—is exactly the policy that is being pursued by John Swinney, both by transferring revenue to capital and through the non-profit distribution programme.
I do not mind so much—well, I do mind, but I think that people in Scotland mind even more—that the Labour Party is now in cahoots with the Tories both on the constitution and on economic policy. However, I do mind that the Labour Party is in cahoots with the Tories in denying this Parliament the economic tools that it needs to do the job for Scotland.
I do not mind so much—well, I do mind, but I think that people in Scotland mind even more—that the Labour Party is now in cahoots with the Tories both on the constitution and on economic policy. However, I do mind that the Labour Party is in cahoots with the Tories in denying this Parliament the economic tools that it needs to do the job for Scotland.
I am sure that that response will be a great comfort to the 200 people every day for the past three months who have lost their jobs. The First Minister’s response to the serious situation that those families are in is, “It wasnae me. I didn’t do it. Somebody else did it—and by the way, you’ve all got problems and I haven’t”.
This is a man who takes himself seriously—we know that—but it is about time he also took his job seriously. What concerns me is not just his breathtaking complacency about the horrendous unemployment figures, but the fact that he clearly did not see it coming. He now has in his back pocket more than £0.5 billion extra from Westminster as a consequence of budget decisions. Will the First Minister give us and the people who are confronted with unemployment in our communities an assurance that every coin of that money will be spent on tackling unemployment and on giving our young people some hope for the future?
This is a man who takes himself seriously—we know that—but it is about time he also took his job seriously. What concerns me is not just his breathtaking complacency about the horrendous unemployment figures, but the fact that he clearly did not see it coming. He now has in his back pocket more than £0.5 billion extra from Westminster as a consequence of budget decisions. Will the First Minister give us and the people who are confronted with unemployment in our communities an assurance that every coin of that money will be spent on tackling unemployment and on giving our young people some hope for the future?
Johann Lamont sounds ever more like her predecessor: he pursued that theme week after week, but it did not do him a great amount of good. The people of Scotland know where the economic power lies at present, which is precisely why they are demanding the economic powers from Westminster.
The classic illustration is the £500 million figure that Johann Lamont has just mentioned. Is she not aware that two thirds of that spending—which is specified by Westminster—is directed into the second part of the comprehensive spending review?
We believe that Scotland needs investment in the economy now. That is precisely why we have jointly with the Labour First Minister of Wales been calling for the change in the economic course of the UK Government that will allow us to deploy those funds. While we have been calling for that change of course, the UK Labour Party has decided to back the Tories on the economy.
The classic illustration is the £500 million figure that Johann Lamont has just mentioned. Is she not aware that two thirds of that spending—which is specified by Westminster—is directed into the second part of the comprehensive spending review?
We believe that Scotland needs investment in the economy now. That is precisely why we have jointly with the Labour First Minister of Wales been calling for the change in the economic course of the UK Government that will allow us to deploy those funds. While we have been calling for that change of course, the UK Labour Party has decided to back the Tories on the economy.
I have said it already: I am not playing a game, and I am not pursuing a theme. I am talking about the issues that are of concern to the people of Scotland. At the moment, 200 Scots a day are losing their jobs, and the First Minister settles for party-political jibes.
Given the seriousness of the situation, and the First Minister’s pathetic response, I fear for the people who have lost their jobs and for those who are worried about losing their jobs. An uncaring Prime Minister, and what looks increasingly like an ultracomplacent First Minister, are uninterested in what the people of this country are talking about.
A man who has been in the job for five years must at some point surely take responsibility, but this is a man who wanted Scotland to join an arc of prosperity, which is now an arc of insolvency. This is a man who graduated—[Interruption.]
This is a man who graduated from the Fred Goodwin school of economics and backed the deal that broke the bank—[Interruption.]
Given the seriousness of the situation, and the First Minister’s pathetic response, I fear for the people who have lost their jobs and for those who are worried about losing their jobs. An uncaring Prime Minister, and what looks increasingly like an ultracomplacent First Minister, are uninterested in what the people of this country are talking about.
A man who has been in the job for five years must at some point surely take responsibility, but this is a man who wanted Scotland to join an arc of prosperity, which is now an arc of insolvency. This is a man who graduated—[Interruption.]
This is a man who graduated from the Fred Goodwin school of economics and backed the deal that broke the bank—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Can we have a bit of quiet, please?
I think that members sometimes have a problem with what they are hearing. The reality is—[Interruption.] The reality is that, in the real world, 200 people each and every day are losing their jobs on the First Minister’s watch. When will the First Minister stop congratulating himself on how well he is doing his job and come up with a serious plan to create jobs for the people of this country?
I am afraid that the apolitical script that has been written by Paul Sinclair is no better than the scripts that were written by previous advisers.
Let us have a look at the detail of one of the really serious issues—[Interruption.]
Let us have a look at the detail of one of the really serious issues—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Okay. Can we settle down, please? Enough!
I do not think that the Labour Party will want to look at the detail. Let us have a look at the detail of one of the really serious issues. Unemployment among women in Scotland is 7.8 per cent, which is far too high. The figure is 7.8 per cent in England and 4.7 per cent in Northern Ireland. We might judge from that that Northern Ireland has the best position, but if we look at employment in Scotland—the number of people in jobs—and look at economic activity among women in Scotland, the figures are much higher than in any other part of these islands. However, 7.8 per cent is a substantial and worrying critical figure. That is precisely why the Scottish Government now has 25,000 new modern apprentices in Scotland—40 per cent more than we inherited from the Labour Party. In 2010-11, nearly 10,000 of those were young women, and 45 per cent of modern apprenticeships in Scotland are now started by women, compared to the level of 27 per cent that we inherited from the Labour Party. The same applies to training for work in Scotland, with the number of women getting that opportunity rising fast and, at 36 per cent, the 40,000 women in Scotland who have benefited from European structural funds is a much higher figure than was previously the case. We are doing our bit with the powers that are under our control to rebalance and preserve justice in the economy in Scotland.
Those are the detailed figures. The Labour Party wants detail but does not like it when it gets the detail because it shows up the record that it had. We have an Opposition that has an economic plan that depends on economic policies being changed at Westminster. However, it will not call for the powers for the Scottish Parliament to do that and it now actually supports the economic policies in the House of Commons. It is little wonder that, when I was in the Gulf this week, gaining jobs and investment for Scotland, The Gulf Today led with the headline, “Labour faces poll disaster” on the forecast from Unite the Union.
Those are the detailed figures. The Labour Party wants detail but does not like it when it gets the detail because it shows up the record that it had. We have an Opposition that has an economic plan that depends on economic policies being changed at Westminster. However, it will not call for the powers for the Scottish Parliament to do that and it now actually supports the economic policies in the House of Commons. It is little wonder that, when I was in the Gulf this week, gaining jobs and investment for Scotland, The Gulf Today led with the headline, “Labour faces poll disaster” on the forecast from Unite the Union.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 19 Jan 2012 →- Local Government Elections 2012 Debate · 107
- Seabird Breeding Colony Special Protection Areas Questions · 9
- Single Police Service (Governance and Local Accountability) Questions · 6
- Tribunals (Devolution) Questions · 4
- Independence Referendum (Franchise) Questions · 6
- Young Carers Questions · 6
- Retail Sector (Support) Questions · 4
- Campus Police Officers Questions · 4
- Job Losses (Vector Aerospace) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- International Business Connections First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Further Education Colleges First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Robert Wiseman Dairies (Sale) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- European Commission (Status of an Independent Scotland) Questions · 6
- Year of Creative Scotland 2012 (Rural Areas) Questions · 6
- Artworks of National Importance Questions · 6
- Broadcasting and the Arts (Diversity) Questions · 5
- Cultural Priorities 2012-13 Questions · 4
- Year of Homecoming 2014 Questions · 6
- International Development Funding (Consultation) Questions · 5
- Cultural Legacy (Rural Scotland) Questions · 4
- Construction Jobs (A96 Upgrade) Questions · 7
- A83 (Upgrade) Questions · 4
- Social Rented Housing (Glasgow East End) Questions · 6
- Broadband Take-up (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Railway Investment (Highland Main Line and Inverness to Aberdeen Line) Questions · 6
- Noise and Vibration (Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway) Questions · 4
- Scottish Water and Business Stream (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Construction (Lanarkshire) Questions · 4
- Agenda for Cities Debate · 67
- Decision Time Decision time · 13
- “Introducing in Scotland” Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.