1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00480)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00480)
Meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Last week’s unemployment figures revealed that more jobs are being lost in Scotland than in any other part of the United Kingdom. This week, we have been presented with more grim forecasts for the construction and retail sectors in Scotland. The First Minister needs to realise that this is about real people and real jobs. The First Minister’s plan MacB—the one that he boasted about to all who would listen—has clearly failed. Why have one in three of all the jobs that have been lost in the UK in the past three months been Scottish jobs?
The unemployment problem in Scotland and, indeed, across these islands is extremely serious; of that there is no doubt.
Johann Lamont should, in fairness, remember that the employment rate—the percentage of people who are employed in the economy—is significantly higher in Scotland than it is in any other country in these islands and that the inactivity rate, which relates to people who are not in the labour market, is much lower. Those are good things about the job market.
However, the recession and the slow recovery are impacting on the lives of families in Scotland and across these islands. Therefore, should not we turn our attention to what can be done about that through the UK budget that is coming up, by increasing capital spending, which has been demonstrated to be a rapid and effective way of getting people back to work, and by increasing the funding to small and medium-sized businesses, which are the great drivers of employment in the economy, and in relation to which we now know that Merlin as an operation has refused to deliver the full goods that were promised? Let us turn our attention to what can be done. That is what the Scottish Government is doing, and I suggest that all members should act constructively and do the same.
Johann Lamont should, in fairness, remember that the employment rate—the percentage of people who are employed in the economy—is significantly higher in Scotland than it is in any other country in these islands and that the inactivity rate, which relates to people who are not in the labour market, is much lower. Those are good things about the job market.
However, the recession and the slow recovery are impacting on the lives of families in Scotland and across these islands. Therefore, should not we turn our attention to what can be done about that through the UK budget that is coming up, by increasing capital spending, which has been demonstrated to be a rapid and effective way of getting people back to work, and by increasing the funding to small and medium-sized businesses, which are the great drivers of employment in the economy, and in relation to which we now know that Merlin as an operation has refused to deliver the full goods that were promised? Let us turn our attention to what can be done. That is what the Scottish Government is doing, and I suggest that all members should act constructively and do the same.
As ever, the First Minister focuses on other people’s responsibilities and not his own. Never mind the budget at UK level—his own budget for jobs and growth could be done under the Trade Descriptions Act.
Last week, the number of young people who are unemployed broke the 100,000 mark. That is unacceptable. What was the First Minister’s response? He had nothing to say. Perhaps he was much too busy falling out with his old pal Donald Trump, falling in with Twitter fan Rupert Murdoch and arguing with the Prime Minister about who knows best how to run a referendum. All the while, more and more young people are being shut out of the job market, with long-term consequences that we should all fear.
To coin a phrase, when will the very man who launched a consultation document in a castle put people before prestige?
Last week, the number of young people who are unemployed broke the 100,000 mark. That is unacceptable. What was the First Minister’s response? He had nothing to say. Perhaps he was much too busy falling out with his old pal Donald Trump, falling in with Twitter fan Rupert Murdoch and arguing with the Prime Minister about who knows best how to run a referendum. All the while, more and more young people are being shut out of the job market, with long-term consequences that we should all fear.
To coin a phrase, when will the very man who launched a consultation document in a castle put people before prestige?
The position on youth unemployment is extremely serious. That is why this Government has appointed a Minister for Youth Employment. It is why we are bringing forward initiatives such as the provision of 125,000 modern apprenticeships over the next five years, which is some 60 per cent higher than the level of modern apprenticeships that we inherited. Of course, every modern apprentice in Scotland has a job. That is a critically important feature of our modern apprenticeship system. Above all, it is why we are offering to every 16 to 19-year-old in Scotland who is not in education, training, a job or a modern apprenticeship a guarantee that they will have a training or education opportunity. To me, that is very substantive action to tackle the issue that is before us.
Just a couple of weeks ago, we had a forum for youth employment in Scotland, which united the unions, the employers, a variety of people in the voluntary sector and, indeed, the other political parties. People united to drive against the evil of youth unemployment and the prospect of seeing a lost generation of the kind that was seen in the 1980s. Everyone at that substantial forum signed up to that joint effort. All that I ask Johann Lamont to think about is whether she can bring the good wishes and good will that were expressed on a cross-party basis in that forum into this chamber, and demonstrate to Scotland that every party and every MSP are committed to fighting the evil of youth unemployment.
Just a couple of weeks ago, we had a forum for youth employment in Scotland, which united the unions, the employers, a variety of people in the voluntary sector and, indeed, the other political parties. People united to drive against the evil of youth unemployment and the prospect of seeing a lost generation of the kind that was seen in the 1980s. Everyone at that substantial forum signed up to that joint effort. All that I ask Johann Lamont to think about is whether she can bring the good wishes and good will that were expressed on a cross-party basis in that forum into this chamber, and demonstrate to Scotland that every party and every MSP are committed to fighting the evil of youth unemployment.
Of course we support all those across the country who want something to be done. We want the First Minister to get on and do those things that need to be done, because what he is doing is not working.
The First Minister talks about his new Minister for Youth Employment. That is one job for one woman, but what about the other 399 women who are losing their job every day under the SNP Government? Although the First Minister talks about it, and despite the promise that was made by the First Minister at the election to protect public service workers, almost 24,000 people who were delivering public services lost their jobs last year. The First Minister chose to pass on 89 per cent of the cuts to local government, so it was inevitable that women would bear the brunt of those cuts. Female unemployment is at its highest since records began. Why has the First Minister broken his promise to protect those public sector jobs?
The First Minister talks about his new Minister for Youth Employment. That is one job for one woman, but what about the other 399 women who are losing their job every day under the SNP Government? Although the First Minister talks about it, and despite the promise that was made by the First Minister at the election to protect public service workers, almost 24,000 people who were delivering public services lost their jobs last year. The First Minister chose to pass on 89 per cent of the cuts to local government, so it was inevitable that women would bear the brunt of those cuts. Female unemployment is at its highest since records began. Why has the First Minister broken his promise to protect those public sector jobs?
I have two or three things to say about Labour’s approach to such matters. If I remember correctly, Labour demanded in this chamber the appointment of a minister for youth employment. What is the point of demanding something and then deriding it once the initiative has been taken? Labour voted against having 25,000 modern apprenticeships a year in Scottish society. Two weeks ago, Labour also voted against the increase in capital spending in the budget that John Swinney presented to members.
Labour is calling for action. Of course, it has its five-point plan for growth, four of which are issues for the United Kingdom Government. Four out of five of Labour’s points in its plan for growth are issues for the UK Government. How on earth can Johann Lamont say that we should not be calling on the UK Government to do things when that is what Labour’s plan is?
On the extraordinarily serious issue of women’s employment in the workforce, we should remember that female employment in Scotland is higher than it is elsewhere in these islands. Let me tell Johann Lamont what we are doing to ensure that women in our workforce are given their equal and proper status. In 2008-09, 2,857 young women went into modern apprenticeships; that was 27 per cent of the total of modern apprenticeships. Two years later, in 2010-11, in a much larger group, 9,656 young women went into modern apprenticeships, which was almost 45 per cent of modern apprenticeships. I would like to see that figure even higher.
It ill behoves a party that had a low number of modern apprenticeships and a minute percentage of women entering the programme to criticise a party that has increased modern apprenticeships by 60 per cent, and the number of young women who are taking that life opportunity by fully 20 per cent. Let us see whether Johann Lamont has the grace to welcome that substantial improvement in female participation in the workforce.
Labour is calling for action. Of course, it has its five-point plan for growth, four of which are issues for the United Kingdom Government. Four out of five of Labour’s points in its plan for growth are issues for the UK Government. How on earth can Johann Lamont say that we should not be calling on the UK Government to do things when that is what Labour’s plan is?
On the extraordinarily serious issue of women’s employment in the workforce, we should remember that female employment in Scotland is higher than it is elsewhere in these islands. Let me tell Johann Lamont what we are doing to ensure that women in our workforce are given their equal and proper status. In 2008-09, 2,857 young women went into modern apprenticeships; that was 27 per cent of the total of modern apprenticeships. Two years later, in 2010-11, in a much larger group, 9,656 young women went into modern apprenticeships, which was almost 45 per cent of modern apprenticeships. I would like to see that figure even higher.
It ill behoves a party that had a low number of modern apprenticeships and a minute percentage of women entering the programme to criticise a party that has increased modern apprenticeships by 60 per cent, and the number of young women who are taking that life opportunity by fully 20 per cent. Let us see whether Johann Lamont has the grace to welcome that substantial improvement in female participation in the workforce.
It is breathtaking complacency on the part of the First Minister, in the face of unemployment figures that must make his blood run cold, to find figures and suggest that everything is okay. On the very day that those shocking unemployment figures were released, the First Minister was in London giving a lecture about separation. Rather than lecturing people in England, perhaps he could take advice from the Labour Government in Wales and those in other parts of the UK where the figures have got better not worse. In Scotland, unemployment is heading towards the 0.25 million mark on the First Minister’s watch. Instead of focusing all his energies on running a referendum campaign, when will the First Minister get on with the job of running the country and addressing people’s real concerns?
I asked whether Johann Lamont would have the grace to acknowledge the huge improvement in the number of young women who are entering the workforce. Perhaps that was not a question that should have been asked, because the answer was pretty obvious.
Johann Lamont mentioned Wales, but I am not certain that that is the best route for her to take. Unemployment in Wales is currently at 9 per cent, which is high compared with the 8.6 per cent in Scotland. In the past year, the rate in Wales has gone up by 0.7 per cent compared with 0.6 per cent in Scotland. The unemployment situation in Wales and Scotland is serious, but it is slightly worse in Wales than it is in Scotland. That is why the First Minister of Wales and I have called jointly for the action from the UK Government that we realise is necessary to address the employment crisis.
One of the keys to addressing the issue is to do exactly what this Government did two years ago by bringing forward capital investment. The Conservative Party has adopted the Labour Party’s capital budget—the one left to it by Alistair Darling—which has deeper and tougher cuts than those of Margaret Thatcher. However, last week there was a chink of light. In my discussion with the Prime Minister, I said, “Isn’t capital investment the way to drive forward the economy, not in two or three years’ time, but at this particular moment?” He asked us to submit a list of shovel-ready capital projects for his consideration, and that is exactly what we will do. When that list of new school buildings, hospitals and roads, and a new repair budget, is submitted, I hope that the initiative will at least have the support of the Labour Party in order to try to break the stranglehold of Westminster Government on the capital budget of Scotland.
Johann Lamont mentioned Wales, but I am not certain that that is the best route for her to take. Unemployment in Wales is currently at 9 per cent, which is high compared with the 8.6 per cent in Scotland. In the past year, the rate in Wales has gone up by 0.7 per cent compared with 0.6 per cent in Scotland. The unemployment situation in Wales and Scotland is serious, but it is slightly worse in Wales than it is in Scotland. That is why the First Minister of Wales and I have called jointly for the action from the UK Government that we realise is necessary to address the employment crisis.
One of the keys to addressing the issue is to do exactly what this Government did two years ago by bringing forward capital investment. The Conservative Party has adopted the Labour Party’s capital budget—the one left to it by Alistair Darling—which has deeper and tougher cuts than those of Margaret Thatcher. However, last week there was a chink of light. In my discussion with the Prime Minister, I said, “Isn’t capital investment the way to drive forward the economy, not in two or three years’ time, but at this particular moment?” He asked us to submit a list of shovel-ready capital projects for his consideration, and that is exactly what we will do. When that list of new school buildings, hospitals and roads, and a new repair budget, is submitted, I hope that the initiative will at least have the support of the Labour Party in order to try to break the stranglehold of Westminster Government on the capital budget of Scotland.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 23 Feb 2012 →- Rail Services (Consultation) Debate · 47
- Road Equivalent Tariff (Commercial Vehicles) Debate · 93
- Living Wage (Discussions) Questions · 8
- Delivery Charges and Road Fuel Taxes Questions · 8
- Sustainable Economic Growth (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 7
- Firefighters’ Pensions (Discussions) Questions · 5
- Housing Association Board and Committee Members (Payments) Questions · 4
- Kincardine Bridge (Refurbishment) Questions · 4
- Bus Services (Regulation) Questions · 4
- Scottish Government Information Technology Projects (Audit) Questions · 4
- Bus Travel (Promotion) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meeting) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scotland to Heathrow Routes (Competition) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Construction Sector First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Rangers Football Club (Administration) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Naloxone Questions · 4
- Eating Disorders Awareness Week Questions · 6
- Deaf and Hard-of-hearing People (Scottish Borders) (Support) Questions · 6
- Neurological Health Services (Clinical Standards) Questions · 4
- NHS Dumfries and Galloway (Backlog Maintenance Risk Profile) Questions · 7
- Cancer Prevention (Lifestyle and Environmental Risks) Questions · 4
- Neurological Health Services (Clinical Standards) (Monitoring) Questions · 4
- NHS Ayrshire and Arran (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Individual Patient Treatment Request Process (Review) Questions · 6
- Tackling Poverty Questions · 6
- Scottish Care Information Gateway Questions · 4
- Economy and Recovery Debate · 115
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 23
- Fair Trade Members’ business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.