I am absolutely clear that the primacy in policing decisions rests with the local commander or, in the event of a dispute, with the chief constable. That is the nature of policing. It always has been and always should be.The issue of the 32 local bureaucracies was rather succinctly covered by Kevin Smith and Andrew Laing when they referred to the fact that we cannot legislate for the mechanisms that are to be put in place to such an extent that they hamstring the organisation from delivering the service.We may be very good at producing glossy books and brochures to satisfy local authorities, but we tend to miss the point somewhat because, ultimately, what matters is the service that is delivered to the public. If the local commanders are going to spend their time going in and out of their local council headquarters nigh on daily, they will not be in a position to ensure that policing is delivered as effectively as it should be.17:00
Official Report · Committee
Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Margaret Mitchell Con 33
- Councillor Grant 24
- Joe FitzPatrick SNP 22
- Kevin Stewart SNP 17
- Chief Superintendent O’Connor 15
- Bob Jack Society of Local Authority Chief Executives and Senior Managers 14
- Chief Constable Smith 12
- Calum Steele Scottish Police Federation 11
- Alex Clark Chief Fire Officers Association Scotland 11
- Andrew Laing Her Majesty’s Inspector of Constabulary for Scotland 10
- Councillor Band 10
- Anne McTaggart Lab 9
- John Duffy Fire Brigades Union 9
- John Pentland Lab 8
- Professor McNeill 8
- Councillor Whyte 8
- Donald Urquhart Scottish Community Safety Network 8
- Bill Walker SNP 6
- George McIrvine Unison 6
- David Torrance SNP 4
- Gillian Campbell Scottish Police Services Authority 3
- Professor Fyfe 3
- Councillor Barbara Grant Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 1
- Chief Constable Kevin Smith Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland 1
5 more speakers
- Councillor Iain Whyte Scottish Police Authorities Conveners Forum 1
- Professor John McNeill Police Complaints Commissioner for Scotland 1
- Chief Superintendent David O’Connor Association of Scottish Police Superintendents 1
- Professor Nicholas Fyfe University of Dundee 1
- Councillor Bob Band Scottish Fire Conveners Forum 1
The record
258 contributions · showing 201–258So the definition in section 46 should be clarified or made more specific.
Section 46—I am working from memory, which is dangerous to do—
It is the definition of the local authority’s role.
Yes, it would be useful for that to be clarified.
We must remember that the police service is a disciplined service. We operate in an environment of command and control. Ultimately, commanders will be responsible to the chief constable for that discipline and for the command and control.We need to be clear about how the local policing arrangements that are set out in sections 46 to 48 will work. I have no doubt that the officers who go out and provide that service in local communities know that they will be accountable to their sergeants, inspectors and local commanders, who, ultimately, will still be accountable to the chief constable.
Do you have any concerns about the variation between areas in the seniority of local commanders and senior officers? Should there be a direct relationship between local authorities and the governing boards of the police and fire services?
I answered that question earlier. The answer is no, we do not have such an arrangement just now, but I am pretty sure that Comhairle nan Eilean Siar, Orkney Islands Council and Shetland Islands Council would not say that they suffered as a consequence. Relationships and the ability to function do not depend on the rank of the individual who happens to be in command of the area.
The important factors are the roles, responsibilities and spans of command within the local areas. It is clear that the 32 local authorities are of different size. Consequently, one size will not fit all in the new structure. Therefore, it would be wholly wrong to focus on the ranks of local commanders. We need to consider the span of command and control within the different local authority areas.
For community safety partnerships, it is important that, whoever the local commander is and regardless of the rank that they hold, they have the delegated authority to make local decisions to satisfy the local plans as they meet local needs and requirements.Effective partnership working is down to individuals understanding what partnership working is about. It is about using gumption—Kevin Stewart used that word—and being able to back that up with the authority to make decisions that can be implemented locally on behalf of the service, if the need arises.
I will make a brief comment about rank, roles and responsibilities. Recently, we did a piece of work in Northern Constabulary on policing in remote rural environments. Officers of a relatively low rank there have to develop a striking range of skills because they work in isolated communities.At an event that we ran, somebody asked the participants whom they would rather have working on their team: a sergeant who had worked their whole career in an urban environment or a sergeant who had worked their whole career in a rural environment. They all said that they would prefer the person who had spent their time in a rural environment because of the responsibilities that they would have had to handle. That is interesting.
There are no further questions, so I thank the witnesses.17:04 Meeting suspended.
17:07 On resuming—
We now have the final panel of witnesses for today’s lengthy evidence session. I am pleased to welcome Councillor Bob Band from the Scottish fire conveners forum; Alex Clark, chair of the Chief Fire Officers Association Scotland; and John Duffy, Scottish secretary of the Fire Brigades Union.I will kick off by asking whether you think that the national board’s size and make-up will be appropriate for a national fire service.
First, I point out that I am a very late substitute for the witness panel, so I may not give as polished a performance as the committee has had from others.I spoke to one of the ministers during the consultation process, and it was said then that the biggest difficulty in getting the message of a single service over was the constant comparison with the Scottish Ambulance Service and people not having representation on its board. Earlier, someone said that there should be at least 15 members on the board to allow for illness, other commitments and any other issue that could take somebody away, so that there would still be enough people. I know what it is like trying to run committees and boards in my local authority, and I do not think that it would be sustainable to have only seven members.
The arguments about the number of board members being limited to between seven and 11 have been well presented today and I do not intend to revisit them. However, it will be crucial that the make-up of the board brings the right skills to the table to enable proper scrutiny of the fire and rescue service’s activities. The skills can come from lots of sectors, and representation from local elected members who have experience of the fire and rescue service’s activities can add strength to the board’s scrutiny of the new service’s activities.What is fundamental is the skill set and the view that board members represent the fire and rescue service’s interests and not other interests when they participate in the board—they must leave any prejudices or other influences at the door. The fundamental role that they will perform within the framework of the board will be to contribute to ensuring that the service delivers the right outcomes for the communities of Scotland.
Do you have thoughts about the balance of councillors and other individuals in the board’s make-up?
I have no particular thoughts. Local authorities must have a good representation, to bring localism to the board’s make-up, but I have no particular percentage in mind.
The key priority is the scrutiny by and democratic accountability of the new board. The current arrangements lack oversight above the local fire board level. In my time in the Fire Brigades Union, I have been involved in preparing submissions and briefing notes for a number of parliamentary debates on the fire service. It is clear that the Parliament has an interest in the fire service operating and functioning properly. A key point that we look for is that the new board should be answerable to the Parliament, which is the right place for ultimate public scrutiny of the fire service.The current set-up of six joint boards and two unitary authorities has been regularly criticised by Audit Scotland for board and authority members’ lack of understanding of the service and their overreliance on chief fire officers. We can relate to that, but that is not a criticism of the individuals who are involved, because the system was flawed almost from its inception. The chief officer is the board’s adviser but is also given the task of developing and implementing policy and reporting on how well the service has done. The new service and the new board should avoid that dangerous closed loop.To open up the closed loop, the board must have some way of getting external expert—for want of a better word—advice and other opinion. Perhaps that is where the link into local government is significant, because there must be a way to undertake what was earlier called dispute resolution. There must be a place to voice any difficulties between local government and the national board and to bring in an external view. As the representatives of the uniformed staff in the service, we will look for an opportunity to voice our members’ concerns directly to the board, too.
When I talked to the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs some time ago, I made the point that I work on a number of committees and boards that include bodies like the FBU. In education, teachers have seats on the board; in housing and health, residents have seats on the board. I see no reason why the fire and rescue service board should not have a representative of the uniformed staff. I know that not all members of the Chief Fire Officers Association Scotland share that view, but I hold it, have expressed it at the conveners forum and have had support for it.
link
Will the bill restrict or enhance community planning partnerships and engagement? We in Fife have a tremendous record of community engagement in the fire service—it is second to none and is very impressive. How will the bill enhance that?
It is good that Fife has something going for it as far as the service is concerned. In Perth and Kinross, we have the support of Tayside Fire and Rescue service, its convener, its chief officer and his depute and assistant. I cannot see the bill making any difference to our community engagement, because we are heavily engaged already. Our mantra is “prevention, prevention, prevention”, starting with teaching youngsters to drive responsibly and going right through to fitting smoke alarms.17:15
I firmly believe that the bill brings opportunities to enhance community planning. Let us not forget that we are not starting from the beginning; we are already well embedded in community planning partnerships. The fire service is an exemplar of good community engagement and integration, and of trying to make a visible difference in people’s lives. That is already happening across the country. Contrary to what some people might think, I believe that with the local senior officer arrangement the bill brings an opportunity for us to allocate more resource to local authority areas and to improve our contributions at the local level. Key to success, though, will be how we manage the expectations of local authorities and other partners within the community planning environment. There might be a belief, for example, that the 32 local authorities will get their own fire brigade, and that would be a big expectation to manage. As we engage more in the community planning partnerships and start to make a difference, we have to be careful to manage local authorities’ expectations sympathetically and with our eyes open.
We see absolutely nothing in the bill that would restrict, prevent or damage the work that is being done in community planning partnerships. I agree with Alex Clark that a great deal of work is going on around Scotland with the fire service’s involvement in the partnerships, and that can only be enhanced. One of Alex Clark’s colleagues has said that at least one of the organisations involved in a community planning partnership will know the name of the next fire death victim. It is about how we draw that information out and how the service taps into and best uses the knowledge that the housing department, the police and social services have.I suggest that a key point is how we drive down the level at which community planning partnerships work, so that fire stations and their crews are much more involved with other agencies at their level, because that is where the snippets of information can be gathered and utilised. During the bill process we will be looking for as much as possible of the responsibility within the service to be devolved to local stations and local areas, so that they can best use the knowledge that is gained from being within structures such as community planning partnerships.
I think that the witnesses have partly answered one of my questions. Will the local authorities have sufficient influence over local fire and rescue plans, including budget setting and resource allocation?
The obvious issue there, which has often been mentioned, is that the plan has to be agreed. What will happen when it is not agreed? How do we have an influence at that point?
The ambition is for local authorities to be fully involved in developing the local plan, because there must be that engagement early on if the fire and rescue service is to respond to local needs. Without that, the situation will become one of the fire and rescue service saying that it knows best and telling local authorities how to deliver the local plan to meet local needs, without there having been a dialogue to determine what those needs are.Local authorities will be involved in developing the local plan, which, I understand, will be aligned with the national strategic plan, and we will then try to deliver the local plan and make significant differences in an area. I understand that the finances and budgets will be set at the top and devolved into the local authority areas, so, to reflect on what Councillor Band said, that would itself bring tension. If the money does not follow local priorities and is not enough to deliver against those priorities, tensions might arise. Many people have mentioned that already.There must be some clarity around the mechanism for achieving a resolution of such a dispute. If local needs cannot be met because of a lack of provision, how do we square that off? We need clarity in the bill on how to resolve such situations.
Notwithstanding the arrangements in the joint boards, our concerns about finance, particularly in relation to the two unitary authorities, have been highlighted. I am going to pick on Fife in particular—I mean no disrespect to our colleagues from there. In general, the question relating to the funding arrangements for the fire service in Fife is how much of a cut in the budget will be made, but that is the wrong way round. We should look at what we are trying to achieve in the service and then try to make arrangements to fund that.When we talk about consistency across Scotland, we know that there are differences in the make-up of communities across the country and in the risks, but the key is having a consistent methodology. The service should measure the risks and needs and then there should be resourcing, as opposed to trying to accommodate the particular influence of any councillor, a strong council or whatever.I noted from the evidence from the police that one of the significant differences between us is that the fire service currently has no ability to top up—councils have no opportunity to add additional resources. In considering that alongside our view on having a consistent methodology, we would say that, if a council wanted to add additional resources, we would still be adamant that those resources should be sent to cover the greatest risk. They should not necessarily stay with the council that is prepared to dig deepest into its pocket.
On consistency, have local authorities across the country been best served by the current fire boards, particularly when fire boards have bought equipment that cannot be used in other areas? Will the uniformity of a single fire service resolve some of those difficulties?
We hope so, as fire boards buy equipment that they cannot use even in their own authority areas. I do not want to sound too scathing, but things really cannot be much worse in some areas. One service in Scotland, which is being resourced from outside, is at the point of near meltdown. We must therefore be able to take down the borders—the lines on the map—if we are fully to support and resource areas in which there is the most risk and need.
Councillor Band probably has a slightly different take on that matter.
I hope that, when John Duffy spoke about taking down borders, he meant boundaries and was not referring to Lothian and Borders.My only experience is with Tayside Fire and Rescue service. We designed our own combined aerial rescue pump. I think that John Duffy recognises that it works perfectly well in our area and that we have a good arrangement for crewing, but I know that other areas have vehicles that they cannot use, which are passed on to other services to use in a different way. That is ridiculous.I agree that the single service will standardise some of the equipment, although, as far as I am aware, ours is standardised with that of our neighbours. Indeed, on Friday, we had a major, 10-pump issue and were able to source a high-volume pump to take water from the local river. That pump happened to be out on an exercise and it took half an hour to load it and bring it up to us, but that is a different issue.
The answer to the question is that having a single service will absolutely resolve some of those difficulties. When the eight services become one, the efficiency that will come from more effective procurement will deliver benefits to the service.That work is already under way through reform planning. A number of teams are looking at what the future arrangements will look like and are starting to build up knowledge of the current asset mix across Scotland. Work is being done on an asset replacement strategy that will harmonise things and enable us to move towards a single procurement route so that we can realise the efficiencies that have been alluded to.
I want to go back to the issue of local connectivity with the national board, which is summed up well in paragraphs 5 and 6 of the Scottish fire conveners forum’s submission. It says:“The reality of being able to shape priorities locally and engage more effectively with the service at local authority level is obviously influenced by the extent to which budget decisions are driven nationally or locally ... It is not clear what level of delegated budgetary control is envisaged and whether delegated responsibility will be provided to the local senior officer for the management of a local budget.”For the record, will you confirm that more clarity on that aspect of the bill is essential?
That is essential. We need more clarity on what the level of delegation of budgetary control will be. I keep harking back to other committees that I deal with. In education, for example, we have the devolved school management budget. In previous discussions, I have brought up the issue of what level the budget is devolved to. Is it devolved to local authority level? Is it devolved to area—Interruption. My apologies. My phone is switched off, but sometimes it does these things. Interruption. It is particularly persistent—it will not go off if it is doing something.
Perhaps you could get someone to take it outside for you.
That should be it now. I am sorry about that.We require more clarity on the budgetary situation—and on the plan.
From an operational command perspective and from a local commander or local senior officer perspective, there has to be clarity on the devolution of financial control. If we are truly to make a difference at local level, the local commander or local senior officer must have the flexibility to deploy resources and to contribute to the community planning agenda.Earlier, one of my colleagues mentioned that it is necessary to have the ability to commit resources in order to make a difference. Without that devolved responsibility, we will not achieve anything and the single service will not achieve what it is intended to achieve.
I reiterate my colleagues’ comments; indeed, I would go one step further and say that, as yet, we do not have any clarity on the national budget. Previously, the fire and rescue service was funded against national response standards. Once the service had put in place the resources that it required to meet those standards, it was inspected by Her Majesty’s chief inspector of fire services for Scotland and the funding was, in effect, signed off at that level.Since the introduction of the Fire (Scotland) Act 2005, that has continued to be the basis for the funding, with ad hoc increases. We are now at the point at which those increases have stopped and the budget is shrinking, but we do not know what the national budget is based on. That raises the issue that someone needs to tell the fire service what they want us to do. Do they want us just to meet the three statutory obligations that we have, or do they want us to have a wider role? I suggest that there is a public expectation that the fire and rescue service has a much wider role than it had previously. A generation ago, our activities in dealing with road traffic collisions and accidents were not a funded part of the service; they now are.However, none of the other things, such as water rescues and line rescues, is a funded part of the service. The Government must tell us what the basis is for its figure on the funding of the fire service and what the expectation is—what the Government wants us to do in exchange for the money.17:30
I will echo some of John Duffy’s points. An opportunity has perhaps been missed in the bill to recognise the broader role that the fire and rescue service plays in the prevention agenda and through our contribution to road safety work and water rescue activity. If the service is currently undertaking additional functions—in the absence of anyone else doing those things—the bill presents an opportunity to make that work part of the role of the fire and rescue service and to bring clarity to its functions. That would allow us to develop into a service that will deliver the functions far more succinctly.
I have two final questions. First, will you comment on the lack of a dispute resolution provision? Secondly, one aspect that we did not touch on with the police witnesses—although we should have—was the timescale for implementing the bill and establishing the national police force and the Scottish fire and rescue service. To clarify, I am not asking you to tell me what the timescale is; I just want you to say whether you have any concerns about it.
I mentioned that we need provision for how to handle disputes between the national and local agendas. I understand from previous evidence that there might be a belief or perception that such disputes will not arise frequently. I have a different view. In the early stages of the new service, disputes might well arise fairly frequently because of the issue of how we balance the expectations of local authorities and those of the national direction and strategic plan. The lack of a mechanism for that will undoubtedly make the job of local commanders and local senior officers particularly challenging. They will be trying to serve two masters, but who will they actually report to?The timescales for establishing the new service are challenging. In our written submission, we make the case for earlier appointment of the chief fire officer so that a shadow management arrangement can be established much earlier and we can move towards the new service far more quickly. At present, we are taking a collegiate approach. The services are involved in trying to develop the shape of the new service, but that is being done with no clear leadership and direction in decision making. Currently, we are eight individual fire and rescue authorities that service the needs of our fire boards. That is a difficult place to be.The early appointment of the chief fire officer and, subsequently, the management team will provide authoritative direction setting to allow us to move forward on some of the innovative ideas that are arising about what the new service can deliver. Until such time as we have that person in place, it will be difficult to make progress. The longer it takes to put that person in place, the more the timescales for implementation will be compromised.
That is helpful.
If a disputes procedure is put in place between authorities and the service, it will be used. Trust me—I am a trade union official.
I believe you.
It would be better to try to avoid that, but that requires a method by which the local authorities have direct access to the board.The timescale is challenging. However, I suggest that the fire service has never stopped changing and evolving and that the bill is just another part of the process. We are focusing on the fact that at some point next year a snapshot will be taken, at which point the service must look and feel a bit like a single service. If we continue to take the collaborative approach that we are currently taking, I do not doubt that we will be most of the way there. The work will certainly not be finished and there will be much to do, but I am sure that it will be possible for us to meet the timescales that ministers and the Government have set and to produce something that looks and feels like a single service.
I think that on the due date we will be on the cusp of getting down to the finer detail. As far as the dispute scenario is concerned, if we put it in the small print, no one will know that it is there.
I will ask a question that is similar to the one that I put to the police. I am pleased to say that in Fife, or certainly in west Fife, which is my part of the world, there is a pretty good relationship between the fire and rescue service and the communities, although in recent years the relationship was placed under a bit of stress when the fire station was moved from the west to the south of Dunfermline. I am told that the move worked out well and that response times are just as good if not better—I am subject to correction on that.Am I correct in thinking that you will face the same issues as the police will face in relation to the appointment of local senior officers who will have a relationship with local authorities? Local authorities are of different sizes. Perhaps more junior people will be appointed to deal with some authorities, or perhaps a more senior person will have to look after several local authorities. Mr Clark might be best placed to respond.
I agree with what some of your previous witnesses said. The rank of the local senior officer is not particularly important. However, from the fire and rescue service point of view, there is an additional complexity, in that the service has put in place role maps, which align a person’s responsibilities and activities with a pay grade, for example.We can test engagement at local authority level. A number of people in the fire and rescue service community have signed up to be pathfinders and establish the local senior officer arrangement across a range of roles, from group commander up to principal officer level, depending on the size of the local authority. The pathfinders are pilots and we will learn lessons about how to pitch engagement at the right level from the pilots’ successes and failures.It is worth mentioning an issue that has not emerged in the discussion. The model for the new fire and rescue service is completely different from the current one in the number of people who will occupy senior roles. We currently have eight chief fire officers; in future we will have one. The opportunities for talented people to rise to the top of the organisation will become significantly limited. The people who in the current system would become chief officers are in future likely to find themselves filling the role of local senior officers, because the opportunity to progress to chief officer level will be limited, by virtue of there being only one chief officer.Therefore—to answer your question—in future it will be the talented people in the organisation who perform the role of local senior officer. I am not too hung up on what is the appropriate rank for the person who is accountable to the local authority; it is about a person having the skill set that enables them to build the relationship and contribute effectively to the outcomes that they are expected to achieve through local engagement.
Many senior officers are FBU members and they are feeding back to us that they think that there are opportunities. Some of the services are already trying to organise themselves in a coterminous way with wards and the like. They see it as a huge opportunity to develop ideas from local circumstances and we are keen to explore with the service how that can be speeded up. The more experiments and trials there are of different ways in which to approach the problems, the more opportunities we have to find successful methods of working. We believe that there are opportunities to devolve down to the local level some of the service’s responsibilities and actions. I reiterate that the local senior officer is not the be-all and end-all; what is crucial is their ability to devolve down even further to station managers and station crews, because the crews are the point of contact with communities.
Undoubtedly, it is the crews, who turn up for the gala days and suchlike, who have contact with members of the public. I agree with John Duffy that we are looking for responsibility to go down to ward level and to the local fire station and to local people. I think that we can bring the community together on that.
With any reform or review, there is a tendency to look at the financial resource that is required to deliver the service or look at what efficiencies can be made. However, the other very important element is the human resource, which I think the panel has touched on. Are there any particular areas of concern that require both immediate, short-term solutions and, ultimately, long-term solutions? Should there be a direct relationship between local authorities and the governing boards of police and fire services?
On short-term solutions, there are clearly a number of areas of uncertainty and where there is uncertainty there is generally apprehension. Our approach is to work closely with our management colleagues in the service. Over the past few weeks, we have done a number of joint training courses with them to try to make the process easier. One of the things that we need to do is to separate the idea of the post from the person. I know that there has been some discussion about the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations with regard to terms and conditions, but that deals with the transfer and does not take account of the restructure, which will reduce the number of posts.The issue is how our organisation and the service deal with the people who find that when the music stops there is no chair. As a trade union, our number 1 priority is the people, but we will look to build relationships with senior management colleagues in the service. One of our problems is that there will not be a new employer until 1 April but a lot of the work that needs to be done now involves negotiation. We are all in untried territory here, but the commitment that we have seen in the early months is encouraging. If we can sit down and talk about the issues, we can find a way to deal with the process.I reiterate that the priority for us is the people rather than the posts. As has been said, we all appreciate that there will be fewer posts at chief officer and senior levels; the issue is how we deal with the people.
I echo John Duffy’s point about the union and the management in the service working closely together to try to resolve some of the issues that arise as we assess how to take things forward. That work has proved to be productive.On the question about the human resource side of things, our concern is how, in order to deliver the financial efficiencies—which have to be linked to the service that we provide—we deal with the financial implications of a business case that indicates that significant savings will be made by reducing the head count predicated on a retirement profile for the workforce when there is no requirement to retire. The numbers are aligned to the retirement profile of a firefighter who serves for 30 years and then retires, but that firefighter does not have to retire at that point, and many do not. Our concern is that it is anticipated that an efficiency can be gained through natural turnover of staff with no compulsory redundancies but, come the day, all those people may still be sitting in their seats, and we will have a financial envelope to satisfy while still paying their salaries. How do we do that without there being an impact on service delivery? Delivering within our cost envelope will be a challenge. Do we take action at the early stages to identify the people who will be affected in order to best manage that from now on? We need that direction to take those steps earlier, in order to ease the burden that will inevitably come.17:45
As has been said many times, on 1 April we will see no difference on the streets. Perhaps Aberdeen will have red fire engines instead of white ones, but that will be the only difference that we will see.If we are going to make these savings, we must consider what the expected savings from back-office staff will be. Only 12 per cent of the total establishment are back-office staff, so the required savings cannot all come from there. As John Duffy and Alex Clark said, something must be done now to slim down the workforce on a voluntary basis before we get too far along. Half of the 12 per cent who are back-office staff earn less than £15,000 a year, so there is not a huge saving to be made by dispensing with them. It is assumed that amalgamating the eight different services will cut out duplication, but there is not a huge saving to be made in that regard. We must make savings if we are going to make the expenditure on front-line services, but that is the difficulty that we face.
I will ask one final question, in fairness, because I asked Councillor Whyte to answer the same question from a police perspective. I know that Councillor Band is a late substitute and I do not want to put him on the spot, but I will ask the question anyway.Do you know how many leaders of councils or very senior councillors currently sit on fire boards?
I do not know about other fire boards. None of the three authorities on my own fire board is represented by senior councillors such as a leader or deputy leader.
The leader of the City of Edinburgh Council and the leader of West Lothian Council are both members of the Lothian and Borders fire board.
It looks as if John Duffy has no idea; he is shaking his head.There are no further questions for the panel. Thank you very much—you had a long wait. We now move into private session.17:48 Meeting continued in private until 18:15.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 Feb 2012 →- 14:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 7
- 14:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- 14:00 Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 258
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.