Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 12 January 2012 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00390)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
We now know that the First Minister’s preference is that the people of Scotland will be asked to decide on Scotland’s constitutional future some time in the autumn in 2014. Nobody can be in any doubt about what a momentous decision that will be for the people of Scotland. What will the First Minister do to ensure that we and all of Scotland will have confidence in the timing, governance and scrutiny of the referendum?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I refer Johann Lamont to the amendment that we lodged to her motion for this morning’s debate, which states that in a couple of weeks we will publish a consultation paper for all Scotland—that includes political parties, voluntary organisations, the third sector, and all the people of Scotland—to make known their views. It will set out the terms, the procedures and the timetable for the referendum that we propose—the referendum, of course, for which we received an overwhelming mandate in the recent Scottish elections.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I noted the amendment that the First Minister lodged, and I have to say that I was disturbed by its tone and its prescriptive nature, and by the rejection of the genuinely made offer to come together to build consensus.

Last May, the First Minister told the Parliament that, despite the SNP’s majority in the Parliament, he does not have a monopoly of wisdom. Let me humbly offer him some of my wisdom. The fact of the matter is that his being able to drive something through the process does not mean that it is in his or in Scotland’s interests for him to do so. It would not be wise, in my view, for Parliament to go ahead with a referendum process that was underlined by a concern—even if it was a misconception—that it was somehow fixed. He must surely understand that he must dispel the perception that he is acting in the interests of the SNP and not those of Scotland.

I repeat my offer from earlier this week and this morning: will the First Minister not just meet party leaders to talk, but work with them to achieve consensus on the way forward for a referendum process that is fair and beyond question?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I think that Johann Lamont might well, in certain respects at least, be pleasantly surprised when she sees the consultation document. It will be in the interests not just of the governing party, but of the Parliament and Scotland—as I think will be clear from our consultation document—that the process is clear and transparent, and that it does this nation proud. When she sees the document, she will be reasonably surprised and perhaps encouraged—certainly by its tone.

I disagree with Johann Lamont in that it is extraordinary to talk about the Government being “prescriptive”. I heard representatives of the third sector—John Downie of the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations and Ian Galloway of the Church of Scotland—say explicitly on the radio this morning that they do not want politicians to foreclose on the options to be put before the people. However, Johann Lamont’s motion did exactly that in relation to the questions that should be asked.

I assure Johann Lamont that the Government is aware of its responsibility not just to the Parliament but to the people of Scotland. We will bring forward a genuine consultation document. It will certainly put forward our views, but the consultation will be prepared to listen not just to the political parties in the Parliament but to people across the spectrum of Scottish society, so that we can have a referendum of which we can be proud and a debate of which we can be proud. All people will know that they have had their full opportunity to contribute to the process on the most important decision that has faced the nation for 300 years.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The difficulty is that the First Minister does not know how to build consensus. As the leader of the Opposition, I ought not to be pleasantly surprised in a fortnight’s time; I ought to be part of the process of shaping the thinking on what the referendum will say.

I accept that the First Minister might not put a high price on the wisdom of the Labour Party’s leader, but I reflect on the wisdom of others. On the prospect of a multi-option ballot, Professor Qvortrup told us that

“Two questions on a ballot where people are asked to vote on both options is simply not feasible. There is a good chance that you would end up not knowing what people really want.”

Those who argue for a change to the devolution settlement want the union to work, whereas the First Minister wants to break it up. Surely he agrees that we need clarity on the result. Instead of resisting the United Kingdom Government’s offer to give legal clarity, surely he should agree with his fellow nationalist Jim Sillars, who said:

“If the Scotland Act, as it does, refuses to give Holyrood powers over the constitution it cannot, therefore, lawfully hold a referendum on independence.”

Surely the First Minister agrees that we can resolve this without rancour. We should recognise the consensus that has been built and reinforced by his Deputy First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, who said:

“The SNP, as it happens, has always said that our preferred option is a straight question, yes or no to independence.”

We seem to have agreement on that. We do not need to muddy the waters—all four parties agree that it should be a yes or no question. The First Minister has said that he will consult, but will he listen to and act on what he hears?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The Deputy First Minister said exactly what the SNP has said for a number of years—of course we prefer the independence question, which will be on the ballot paper. However, as I said after re-election, we do not have a monopoly on wisdom, which is precisely why we will listen to civic Scotland’s point of view. That contrasts markedly with the Labour motion, which referred to wanting to talk to civic Scotland but rejected one of the arguments that civic Scotland makes. We will listen and we will not prejudge what people have to say.

One of my problems with the words that Johann Lamont says in the chamber—I have no doubt that they are said genuinely—is the extent to which Labour is in cahoots with the Conservative Government at Westminster, which is now clear. I am a great student of body language. In the earlier debate, I watched Labour members every time the Conservatives said that they are standing shoulder to shoulder with them, and I saw a lot of discomfiture. There will be a lot more of that as we see the extent of the claims of Labour members’ Westminster colleagues about how they have worked hand in hand with the Tory Government to issue diktats to this Parliament and the people of Scotland.

I say to Johann Lamont that there is no difficulty whatever with a section 30 order. The difficulty is in the strings that the Prime Minister wants to attach to the order. Surely members of this Parliament—of all places—should agree that the referendum must be built here in Scotland. It must be led by this Parliament and produced in dialogue with civic Scotland, and the process must go forward to give us a debate and, I hope, a conclusion of which the nation can be proud.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The problem with the First Minister is that he offers a false prospectus: he says that the choice is independence or the Tories. Neither of those is something that Scotland particularly wants. The debate has to be conducted in terms that recognise that Scottish Labour has a positive vision for Scotland inside the United Kingdom.

I will offer the First Minister some advice. A signal of his recognition that he does not have a monopoly of wisdom would be not simply to find people who agree with him, and welcome the fact that they agree with him; it is to work with people who do not agree with him. That is the challenge to which he must he rise.

When the decision is made, depending on the will of the Scottish people, Scotland will separate from, or remain within, the United Kingdom. The day after the referendum, all of us in this chamber—indeed, every Scot—will have a responsibility to unite and to work together to make Scotland the best that it can be, whatever the constitutional arrangement. Will the First Minister accept his responsibility to be a national leader on the calls for us to come together on the process of the referendum, and to ensure that he is not operating simply as a party leader? Will he deliver and play a part in a free and fair referendum that everyone in this country can trust and will accept the day after the vote?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I welcome part of that question, because it contained sentiments of which I very much approve. Our amendment to Johann Lamont’s motion today talks about consultation of all the people of Scotland: I assure Labour members that that absolutely includes the Labour Party. When we publish the consultation document, some of the fears that Johann Lamont has expressed will be seen not to be strongly based.

There is another issue on which I agree with Johann Lamont. As we agree the process, I look forward to our getting on to the arguments that matter. I do not agree with the view that was expressed the Labour Party today that independence and devolution of powers to this Parliament are opposites. I campaigned with the late Donald Dewar in 1997 on the prospectus of increasing power for Scotland. The two issues are not opposites; they are part of a continuum. The decision of the people of Scotland was over how far to go in accruing powers to the Parliament. Powers affect what we can and cannot do in Scotland.

I have absolutely no doubt that Johann Lamont is as fiercely concerned as I am with levels of child poverty and the statistics that we have seen this week, but she must acknowledge that welfare reform at Westminster right now threatens to undo all the recent progress on child poverty. How on earth can we reconcile that acknowledgement with not realising that we require the powers?

Earlier in the debate, I heard the question asked about what the SNP is going to do about nuclear weapons in Scotland. I say to Sarah Boyack that the only basis on which the people of Scotland will be able to remove weapons of mass destruction from our soil will be our having the powers that an independent Parliament will bring.

I have every interest in ensuring that we have consensus on the process, and I will make every effort for us to achieve it. As is, I hope, every other member in the chamber, I am anxious to get to the nub of the arguments and to let the Scottish people decide their own future. The future will involve powers for this Parliament to create a prosperous economy and a just society.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Scotland’s Future Debate · 159
  2. Wind Farms Questions · 15
  3. Social Housing (Adaptations) Questions · 4
  4. Bankruptcy and Insolvency (Support) Questions · 4
  5. Drink Driving and Domestic Violence Campaigns Questions · 6
  6. Scottish Housing Regulator (Meetings) Questions · 4
  7. Housing Standards (Temporary Accommodation) Questions · 4
  8. Ferries Strategy Questions · 6
  9. Blue Badge Renewal Questions · 5
  10. First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 4
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. Independence Referendum First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Double Jeopardy First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Breast Implants First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Scottish Ambulance Service (Rest Breaks) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Healthy Diet Questions · 4
  18. Home Care (Needs Assessment) Questions · 8
  19. Dermatology Services Questions · 4
  20. Multiple Sclerosis Questions · 4
  21. NHS Orkney (Meetings) Questions · 4
  22. Rural Maternity Services Questions · 6
  23. National Health Service Boards (Meetings) Questions · 8
  24. Air Pollution Questions · 4
  25. Weight Reduction Programmes Questions · 4
  26. High Blood Pressure (Awareness) Questions · 4
  27. Cities Strategy Questions · 4
  28. Sporting Facilities (Young People) Questions · 4
  29. Waiting Lists (Lothian) Questions · 4
  30. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 4
  31. Telehealth Questions · 4
  32. Vitamin D Deficiency Questions · 4
  33. Young People (Improving Learning Outcomes) Debate · 69
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 13
  35. High-interest Pay Day Loans Members’ business · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.