Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 15 December 2011 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 11 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00351)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Later today, I shall be witnessing the signing of a memorandum of understanding between Scottish and Southern Energy, Dundee City Council, Forth Ports and Scottish Enterprise, which will secure Dundee’s position as a vibrant hub for Scotland’s developing offshore renewables sector. Scottish Enterprise analysis shows that Dundee port has the potential to support around 700 jobs in offshore wind-turbine manufacturing, with further job opportunities in supply-chain development in the Dundee area. The announcement today is proof of our ambition to bring world-class offshore suppliers to Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Of course I welcome the potential for those jobs in Dundee, but the announcement comes at a time when 400 jobs are going every day. By Saturday, we will have lost more jobs than that memorandum of understanding promises. Four weeks ago, I asked the First Minister how many Scots had to be unemployed before he would admit that his plan MacB was not working. Since then, another 25,000 Scots have joined the dole queue. Will he now admit that it is not working?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Before I disagree with Iain Gray, I shall say a few words to the chamber about him. He has served his party with distinction as a minister and, most recently, as leader of the Opposition. I have greatly enjoyed our weekly jousts in the chamber and I know that, whoever his successor might be, he or she has a hard act to follow. I am certain that Iain Gray has a major role still to play in public life, and I wish him well for the future.

I have been looking across the range and, first, there is no disagreement between Iain Gray and me on the fact that unemployment, jobs, the economy and the interruption of recovery that is now a substantial threat are the most serious issues of all. I would, however, like to give him some comparisons. Under this Scottish National Party Government, the month-by-month statistics show that for 72 per cent of the time, Scottish unemployment has been better than the United Kingdom average, and that for 87 per cent of the time—including this month—Scottish employment has been better than the UK average. The figures when Labour was in control of this Parliament were 10 per cent and 30 per cent respectively. So, although we jointly agree that this is the most serious issue of all, I hope that we can also jointly understand that demand in the economy at present is overwhelmingly controlled by the UK Government. We should, therefore, put our claim for increased demand to confront the economic recession to the people who currently have the powers over us. Of course, I hope that we can also agree that those are exactly the powers that should come to this Parliament.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I thank the First Minister for his kind and gracious words, and I certainly accept them in the spirit in which they were said. I am going to miss this, so I hope that he will forgive me if I also disagree with him.

To try to play with the figures by looking at previous months and a particular aspect of the statistics is not to treat with respect the problem that so many Scots face. The 229,000 Scots who are on the dole do not believe that we are outperforming the UK. That is not just spin; that is what the Americans call “post-truth politics”—just repeating the same thing over and over again, even though it is demonstrably not true.

It is only three months ago that the First Minister was touring the TV studios, boasting:

“Scotland is the only place in these islands—the only nation, the only region, the only place—where unemployment is falling. Therefore, there must be something distinctive happening which is not happening in economies elsewhere in these islands. Plan MacB has a great deal to recommend it.”

Now he says that the problem lies somewhere else. He loves to claim the credit when things go well, but is he big enough to take responsibility when things go wrong?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
On 3 November, the Labour Party in Scotland published a five-point plan for growth. Four of the five points were directed at the UK Government and one was directed at the Scottish Government—to bring forward a long-term investment project plan, which Alex Neil has done in spades, as members will acknowledge. The four points that were directed at the UK Government were on bank bonuses, VAT and national insurance reductions.

Iain Gray said that I have been “touring the TV studios”, which is not something that I normally do, as members well know. However, in May, June, July, August, September and October, when the statistics showed that Scottish unemployment was falling, we put forward the argument that initiatives such as the acceleration of capital spending were a large requirement in, and a large part of the reason for, that falling unemployment. We asked the United Kingdom Government—not just on our own, but in conjunction three times with the other devolved Assemblies across the United Kingdom—to implement similar plans: that is, not just increased capital spending for 2014 and beyond but increased capital spending now, as we accelerated capital spending last year to impact directly on the economy at the time.

I can quote from each of those months as I toured the television studios. In each of those months I warned that unless that action was taken by the United Kingdom Chancellor of the Exchequer, there was every chance that recovery in Scotland would be derailed. Given that Labour acknowledged in its own plan where demand management lies in the United Kingdom at the present moment, and given that in each of those months when the Scottish employment provision was improving I pointed to that very fact, cannot we in this last exchange between us unite to agree that we should have in this Parliament the responsibility for bringing jobs and prosperity to our people?

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Of course we agree that the action that the UK Government is taking is wrong and is not working, but the action that Mr Salmond and his Government are taking is not working, either. That is probably because, in essence, they are doing the same thing: they are slashing the public sector and slashing capital investment.

However, the First Minister’s answer goes to the heart of the matter, because on Tuesday he claimed yet again that the answer to the problem is his referendum on separation and more powers, and he has repeated that today. In all sincerity I say this to him: 229,000 Scots on the dole need urgent action. If he really believes that the referendum is the answer and is really telling those unemployed Scots that his referendum is the solution that they need, why is he telling them that they must wait three, four or five years for it?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Let us deal first with capital investment, because it is something that Iain Gray has unwisely brought to the chamber a number of times. Thanks to the initiatives that are being taken by John Swinney in transferring from revenue to capital over the period of the spending review, and thanks to the non-profit distribution programme, capital spending will rise from this year at £2.685 billion to £3.365 billion in 2014-15. The point is that by taking the measures that we are taking we can increase capital spending over the next few years. Among the key components of the plan that we put to the chancellor was that something should be done about demand now. That can be done only by an increase in direct Government capital spending, which lies within the province of the United Kingdom Government.

The United Kingdom Government’s argument, incidentally, is that it is doing exactly the same thing as Alistair Darling planned: deeper and tougher cuts than Margaret Thatcher’s. However, Iain Gray and I should be able to unite in saying that that is not the right way; the right way is to increase capital spending now, as well as in the next few years.

In terms of the support for a variety of constitutional options, I will stick to the timetable that I laid out to the people in the election campaign. However, we had—had we not?—an interesting insight into the political support for the options or for political parties in Scotland just last Friday in a MORI poll that showed that not only is support for independence increasing, but that the percentage of people who want all economic powers to come before this Parliament is now running at 70 per cent. I say to the Labour members that, in that poll, their support was at 26 per cent, which I understand is an historic low for the Labour Party in Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The last poll I saw at the weekend said that two thirds of Scots want the referendum to be done quickly and out of the way.

I have been doing this for quite a while now, so I know that when Alex Salmond starts talking about what other people—Alistair Darling, Ed Miliband or whoever—have said, he wants to run away from what he has said. He said that in Scotland our economy was growing, our employment market was strengthening and we were outperforming the UK, but it was not true.

However, it is not just Alex Salmond. Nicola Sturgeon told us that she was not cutting the national health service, but today Audit Scotland has said that she is. Kenny MacAskill told us that he was cutting knife crime; this week, it turns out that knife murders in Scotland have soared. Mike Russell has been telling us for months that class sizes in our schools were falling; last week, we discovered that they have gone up. I saw that Alex Salmond arrived in China last week without his trews. Is that not the perfect metaphor for him and his whole Government? Even on their own beloved referendum, are they not always all mouth and no trousers? [Applause.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Not for the first time in answering Iain Gray’s questions, I have a range of possibilities to choose from. First, I gently point out to him that page 5 of the Audit Scotland report states:

“Territorial boards have received a real-terms increase in funding in 2011/12”.

Iain Gray will remember that during the election campaign he refused to commit himself to putting all the consequentials into health.

The MORI poll that Iain Gray refers to also shows SNP support at 51 per cent and satisfaction with this Government at 62 per cent. Whatever he and his band in this Parliament think, a lot of folk in Scotland think that this SNP Government is acting in the interests of our people and doing its best in difficult economic circumstances.

I have been thinking back on our exchanges over the past four years. Perhaps the highlight for both of us was Gypsy Amalia. I have reconsulted Gypsy Amalia, who is very optimistic about Iain Gray’s prospects and says that new opportunities will beckon in the new year. She understands that Labour leadership positions might be opening up in London; I think that Iain Gray would be the ideal candidate.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Integration of Health and Social Care Debate · 74
  2. Ovarian Cancer (Awareness) Questions · 4
  3. A9 Upgrading Works Questions · 6
  4. Long-term Medical Conditions Questions · 6
  5. Childhood Sexual Abuse Survivors (Identification) Questions · 4
  6. Reserved Matters (Scottish Government Position) Questions · 4
  7. Hidden Waiting Lists (NHS Lothian) Questions · 4
  8. Single Police Force (Headquarters) Questions · 4
  9. Grampian Police and Judicial Services (Discussions) Questions · 6
  10. Winter Resilience Questions · 5
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  13. Cabinet (Meeting) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  14. Prime Minister (European Union Summit) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. National Health Service (Spending Balance) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. "Powering Scotland" First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Employment Opportunities Questions · 8
  18. Aberdeen City Council (Meetings) Questions · 7
  19. Job Creation (Inverclyde) Questions · 6
  20. Growth Forecasts Questions · 12
  21. Small Business Bonus Scheme Questions · 4
  22. Capital Investment in Glasgow Questions · 4
  23. Small Businesses Questions · 4
  24. Solar Panels (Domestic Use) Questions · 6
  25. Council Tax Benefit Questions · 4
  26. Economic Growth (Capital Spending) Questions · 4
  27. Wind Farms (Guidance on Siting) Questions · 6
  28. Fossil Fuel Levy (Energy Demand) Questions · 6
  29. Small and Micro Businesses (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
  30. Renewables Projects (Employment and Economic Growth) Questions · 4
  31. Hotel Bed Levy (Edinburgh) Questions · 5
  32. Credit Unions (Membership) Questions · 8
  33. Infrastructure Investment Plan Debate · 94
  34. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 13
  36. University of Glasgow Members’ business · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.