Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 10 November 2011 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00255)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am delighted to announce to the chamber that, earlier today, a memorandum of understanding was agreed between Forth Ports plc, Scottish Enterprise and the City of Edinburgh Council. That agreement will unlock the vast potential of Leith port and will ensure that it will be transformed with the ability to serve a range of industries, thereby creating new jobs and economic growth both for Edinburgh and for Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
This week, the latest report by European experts Arabella Thorp and Gavin Thompson makes clear the cost to taxpayers of the requirement for a separate Scotland to join the euro. Our contribution to the bail-out fund would currently be around £8 billion. Is that a bill that the First Minister is happy to see Scotland pay?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I doubt that Iain Gray has properly read the report from the House of Commons library researchers, because it goes through a range of options. The idea that Scotland would be dragooned into the euro is totally wrong and completely without foundation. Scotland’s position will be the same as that of the rest of the United Kingdom as we become an independent country; we will have exactly the same rights and obligations. The idea that Scotland will be treated differently—as some sort of region—is shared only by those who do not understand the important and valid point that Scotland is not only a nation, but a European nation.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I have read the report. The First Minister needs to understand that he is not the only politician who can read. However, I wonder how much he has read, because he simply asserts that we would not have to join the euro.

Let us see how the evidence is stacking up. Those who disagree with him include Thorp and Thompson; Professor Jo Murkens of the London School of Economics and Political Science; Professor Robert Hazell of University College London; the First Minister’s own economic adviser, Professor Hughes-Hallett; the European Commission’s President Barroso, who says that there will be no more euro opt-outs; and the Maastricht treaty—I wonder whether the First Minister has ever read that.

On the First Minister’s side, who do we have? The ever-trustworthy First Minister’s spokesperson, who was this week reduced to misquoting the late Robin Cook. If the First Minister has crystal-clear legal advice on the question, will he publish it?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I refer Iain Gray to paragraph 2.3 of the Scottish ministerial code concerning legal advice, its assistance and its publication. Perhaps I can help him by citing some authorities. Lord Mackenzie-Stuart, the only Scottish judge to have been President of the European Court of Justice, was asked to address the point about Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom in the event of independence. He said:

“Independence would leave Scotland and something called ‘the rest’ in the same legal boat. If Scotland had to reapply, so would the rest. I am puzzled at the suggestion that there would be a difference in the status of Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom in terms of Community law if the Act of Union was dissolved.”

I think that we can reasonably say that the late Lord Mackenzie-Stuart was an authority on such matters, but I have no knowledge that he was ever friendly towards the SNP’s position. However, he looked at precisely that question and his argument was very clear from that quotation. Incidentally, “I am puzzled” is legal speak for “I don’t understand the argument that’s being put forward.” The point that he put forward very clearly is that Scotland and the rest of the UK would be in exactly the same legal position.

I will turn to what that legal position might be. I will quote Eamonn Gallagher, who is a former director-general of the European Commission and ambassador to the United Nations in New York. He said:

“Scotland and the rest of the UK would be equally entitled to continue the existing full membership of the EU.”

I am quite happy to quote to Iain Gray a range of other authorities. I hope that he accepts that they are important legal authorities whose views have been published. I hope that he has read them and that he will now abandon his attempt to suggest that Scotland, with its enormous natural resources, its dominant position in the European Union’s oil and gas resources and its great renewables resources, would somehow not be wanted by the rest of the European Union.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I read Mackenzie-Stuart and Gallagher this morning. The point is that they do not precisely address the question that I am putting to the First Minister. They both say, one on the evidence of the other, that Scotland would continue to be a member of European Union. What does the First Minister say to all the experts who accept that point but say that, as a member of the European Union, Scotland would have to join the euro? It might be that the interpretation is that the rest of the UK would be in the same position.

Members: Oh!

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Let the member finish his question, please.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I love it when they think they have discovered something.

What would Scotland’s position be? All those experts say that we would have to be in the euro and that it would cost £8 billion.

As for the legal advice, everyone knows that if Alex Salmond had legal advice that agreed with him on the point, he would have found a way to get it out. Fiona Hyslop says that letting Scotland know whether his policy will cost Scotland £8 billion would be contrary to the public interest. I do not think so. Does not she really mean that it would be contrary to the SNP’s interests, so they are going to keep it secret?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
We are making progress; Iain Gray has read—this morning—the legal advice of some of the most credible people to have addressed the question. Let me give him a quotation from another credible person. The first and longest-serving secretary general of the European Commission, Emile Noël, said that Scottish

“independence would create two new member states out of one. They would have equal status with each other and the other states. The remainder of the United Kingdom would not be in a more powerful position than Scotland.”

So we come to Iain Gray’s dramatic admission before the members in the chamber that it might well be that the rest of the UK would have to join the euro. Now we understand the entrenched opposition of the unionist parties to Scottish independence. It is not about Scotland: they are worried that England and the rest would be forced into membership of the euro. As successor states, both parts would inherit rights and obligations, including the opt-out that was negotiated by the UK.

I offer Iain Gray a further point of reassurance. Sweden—a new member—is not in the euro. Why is that? It is because the people of Sweden said that they did not want to join it, and the European Commission accepted that. Let us sweep away all the scaremongering and accept that Scotland is a European nation, and that right across Europe, people will be anxious to see Scotland have the same rights and obligations as other European Union members.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
In the face of expert opinion that says that an independent Scotland would have to be in the euro, the First Minister continues to assert on no evidence that that is not the case.

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Housing and Transport · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
link
Where is your evidence?

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Where is my evidence? I read out a list of expert evidence and opinion when I asked the question. That is where my evidence is.

The First Minister has a mandate to ask Scots whether they want separation, but he has no mandate to mislead them. He must give us all the facts before we decide. The experts say that a separate Scotland would have to join the euro and that it would cost at least £8 billion. On such an important question, does Alex Salmond really think that he can just stick his fingers in his ears and his head in the sand?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I think that that was a shimmy away from the dramatic admission that was made in the previous question. I have cited authorities—a former director general of the European Commission, the longest-serving secretary general of the European Commission and the only Scottish judge who chaired the European Court of Justice—but Iain Gray does not want to talk about them. So let us talk about the reality.

As successor states, Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom would inherit the opt-out that was negotiated by the UK Government. Even if that were not the case, we would be in the same position as Sweden—and Sweden has not joined the euro because the people of Sweden did not want to join the euro. Olli Rehn, the European Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs, says that membership of the euro is for the Swedish people to decide.

I have been in politics a fair time. I remember when the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom—a Labour Prime Minister—said that he wanted to have the courage of his convictions and join the euro. Most of us now say that we would not do that until it was in the economic interests of the country to do so. That would be decided by the people of Scotland in a referendum. We would have the same rights and the same obligations as the rest of the United Kingdom and every other European Union member. That is the reality.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Protecting Scotland’s NHS Debate · 39
  2. Keeping Communities Safe Debate · 81
  3. Cities (Community Rejuvenation) Questions · 4
  4. Road Safety (Young Drivers) Questions · 8
  5. National Health Service (Advocacy Services) Questions · 8
  6. Disabled Students Allowance Questions · 4
  7. A9 (Berriedale Braes Improvements) Questions · 4
  8. Factors (Accountability) Questions · 4
  9. Social Rented Housing (Environmental Sustainability) Questions · 4
  10. Same-sex Marriage Questions · 9
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. First Ministerial Visits (Qatar and United Arab Emirates) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Junior Doctors (Working Hours) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Public Health Levy First Minister’s Questions · 4
  17. Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth Questions · 1
  18. Employment and Regeneration (Cunninghame South) Questions · 4
  19. Social Economy Questions · 9
  20. Welfare Reform Questions · 6
  21. Small Business Start-ups Questions · 7
  22. Non-domestic Rates Questions · 6
  23. Non-domestic Rates Questions · 11
  24. Local Authorities and Enterprise Agencies (Meetings) Questions · 4
  25. Economy (Highlands) Questions · 4
  26. Employment (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  27. Third Sector Questions · 4
  28. Longannet Power Station (Carbon Capture Project) Questions · 4
  29. Credit Unions (Bank Charges) Questions · 4
  30. Non-domestic Rates Questions · 4
  31. Crown Estate (Finances 2010-11) Questions · 6
  32. Council Tax Freeze Questions · 6
  33. Non-domestic Rates (Impact on Post Offices) Questions · 4
  34. Economy (Architecture and Place Making) Debate · 74
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 19
  36. Air Discount Scheme Members’ business · 22

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.