1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00102)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- John Swinney SNP 1
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
13 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-00102)
Later today, I am meeting the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth, John Swinney, to discuss, among other things, the job-creating powers that we need added to the Scotland Bill. We will be discussing the analysis that was published on general release at 9.30 this morning using the general equilibrium model of the Scottish economy, which shows that, over the next 20 years, a reduction in corporation tax of just 3 per cent would boost Scotland’s gross domestic product by 1.4 per cent, raise investment in the Scottish economy by 1.9 per cent and lead to an increase of 27,000 jobs in Scotland.
I am sure that when Iain Gray gets the chance to read that analysis, he will, like his predecessor Wendy Alexander would have done, welcome the idea that this Parliament should have access to such job-creating powers.
I am sure that when Iain Gray gets the chance to read that analysis, he will, like his predecessor Wendy Alexander would have done, welcome the idea that this Parliament should have access to such job-creating powers.
I would certainly welcome debate on the future of Scotland. In 2009, the First Minister said that the people of Scotland were ready to have their say on separation. Now he is scared to let them have that say because he is scared of the answer. Is that not the simple truth?
Obviously, as Iain Gray prepares for his imminent retirement—I do not know whether it is imminent, actually—he has not had time to glance at the opinion polls on the constitutional question, in which there are substantial movements in the direction of independence.
Iain Gray will remember the election campaign—I know that he will remember it because he spent the first 20 minutes of his speech yesterday talking about it. During that election campaign, we clearly set out, not least in the leadership debate in Perth, that the Scotland Bill and job-creating powers were the immediate constitutional priority, and that the referendum bill would be in the second half of this session of Parliament. Surely lain Gray would not want me to go back on a clear commitment to the Scottish people.
Iain Gray will remember the election campaign—I know that he will remember it because he spent the first 20 minutes of his speech yesterday talking about it. During that election campaign, we clearly set out, not least in the leadership debate in Perth, that the Scotland Bill and job-creating powers were the immediate constitutional priority, and that the referendum bill would be in the second half of this session of Parliament. Surely lain Gray would not want me to go back on a clear commitment to the Scottish people.
What I do not understand is why the First Minister goes back on a clear commitment that he made in 2009. Oh, actually, I do. The answer lies in the opinion poll that showed that 60 per cent of Scots reject his vision of the future of Scotland.
The delay would not matter if the First Minister’s ducking and diving was not damaging Scotland. Last week, the Confederation of British Industry said that it is damaging business confidence. These are the people who create wealth and jobs, and the First Minister told them that they should not blunder into politics. Is this Alex Salmond’s Scotland? Is this his independence debate: “agree with me or shut up”?
The delay would not matter if the First Minister’s ducking and diving was not damaging Scotland. Last week, the Confederation of British Industry said that it is damaging business confidence. These are the people who create wealth and jobs, and the First Minister told them that they should not blunder into politics. Is this Alex Salmond’s Scotland? Is this his independence debate: “agree with me or shut up”?
I remind Iain Gray of a little bit of recent history: 2009 was when the Labour Party in this Parliament blocked the referendum bill. In 2011, we stood for election and won a resounding majority. If, of course, having won that resounding majority, we had gone back on what we said during the election campaign, Iain Gray would be saying, “You’ve gone back on the election campaign. You’re not making jobs the priority.” He would be in the same ridiculous position as Michael Moore, who said that we should be concentrating on our own powers and then, in the same speech, demanded answers on independence.
On job creation and the reaction of the people who create jobs in Scotland, I point out to Iain Gray the recent announcements from Amazon, Gamesa, State Street, Doosan Power, Ryanair, EasyJet, Tesco Bank, Virgin Money, Blackrock, INEOS/PetroChina and Mitsubishi Power Systems—all companies creating jobs, partly thanks to the policies of this Government, and all companies that have confidence in the economic future of Scotland.
On job creation and the reaction of the people who create jobs in Scotland, I point out to Iain Gray the recent announcements from Amazon, Gamesa, State Street, Doosan Power, Ryanair, EasyJet, Tesco Bank, Virgin Money, Blackrock, INEOS/PetroChina and Mitsubishi Power Systems—all companies creating jobs, partly thanks to the policies of this Government, and all companies that have confidence in the economic future of Scotland.
Let us look at recent history. In 2007, when my predecessor, Wendy Alexander, said that she would not block a referendum, the First Minister would not have one. In 2009, when he knew that he could not have one, he wanted one. In 2011, when he can have one, he is not going to have one. That is the recent history on the question.
It is not just the CBI. Even the First Minister’s personal public relations outlet, the Scottish Sun, said this morning that the First Minister should get on with it.
It is not just the CBI. Even the First Minister’s personal public relations outlet, the Scottish Sun, said this morning that the First Minister should get on with it.
John Swinney
SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
Lovely—
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Mr Swinney.
The Sun agrees with the CBI. Is the First Minister going to give it the same answer? Is he going to drop a note to his penpal Rupert Murdoch, telling him that he should not blunder into politics?
I honestly do not think that Rupert Murdoch is the strongest line of questioning for the Labour Party, but I am touched by the bringing of newspapers into the chamber. At some point, Iain Gray will go online and then he will not have to bring the whole newspaper.
We said clearly in the election campaign that our fundamental priority at the moment is jobs and the economy. In his speech yesterday, Iain Gray took 21 minutes to mention the economy and jobs. We also said that the priority on the constitution was to get job-creating powers into the Scotland Bill, and that is what we are trying to do. We said that the independence referendum will take place in the second half of this parliamentary session, and that is what we will do.
I do not think that going back through the history is particularly comforting for Iain Gray. If I remember correctly, it was in response to Wendy Alexander’s declaration that Iain Gray had his speaking-Portuguese interview, as he tried to explain the contortions of Labour’s position. Then, when Wendy was removed as Labour leader, Iain Gray came in and immediately reversed the policy. Rather than take lessons in political strategy from Iain Gray, we will stand on the policy that won us such a resounding victory in this year’s election.
We said clearly in the election campaign that our fundamental priority at the moment is jobs and the economy. In his speech yesterday, Iain Gray took 21 minutes to mention the economy and jobs. We also said that the priority on the constitution was to get job-creating powers into the Scotland Bill, and that is what we are trying to do. We said that the independence referendum will take place in the second half of this parliamentary session, and that is what we will do.
I do not think that going back through the history is particularly comforting for Iain Gray. If I remember correctly, it was in response to Wendy Alexander’s declaration that Iain Gray had his speaking-Portuguese interview, as he tried to explain the contortions of Labour’s position. Then, when Wendy was removed as Labour leader, Iain Gray came in and immediately reversed the policy. Rather than take lessons in political strategy from Iain Gray, we will stand on the policy that won us such a resounding victory in this year’s election.
I am always interested to find out where the First Minister takes lessons in political strategy—sometimes he does so in surprising places. A friend went to a fortune-teller in Dundee last week, and there, displayed on Gypsy Amalia’s caravan, was a photo of the palmist’s celebrity client, Alex Salmond. Maybe we should ask Gypsy Amalia when the referendum will be, because the First Minister does not seem to know.
By the way, if anyone wants their fortune told, if they ask Amalia how much it is for a reading with her, the answer that they get is, “You can never tell, dear. It might be a fiver, it might be 30 quid.” Is that not exactly the First Minister’s plan for separatism: “Say yes first, and then I’ll tell you how much it costs”—the strategy of the snake-oil salesman down the ages?
By the way, if anyone wants their fortune told, if they ask Amalia how much it is for a reading with her, the answer that they get is, “You can never tell, dear. It might be a fiver, it might be 30 quid.” Is that not exactly the First Minister’s plan for separatism: “Say yes first, and then I’ll tell you how much it costs”—the strategy of the snake-oil salesman down the ages?
I recognise the name Gypsy Amalia. She is a regular attender at the Turriff show in my constituency. It is absolutely correct: in 2006, I visited her stall and she said that the SNP would win the 2007 election. [Laughter.] And lo and behold, it came to pass—and I did not even have to give her any money! Now I am going to make a return visit to Gypsy Amalia, and I am going to ask her the most difficult question in Scottish politics: not “Who is going to be the next Labour leader?” but “When is the contest going to be?”
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 8 Sep 2011 →- Scottish Government’s Legislative Programme Debate · 98
- Dairy Sector (International Investment) Questions · 6
- Social Care (Advice and Guidance) Questions · 6
- Cashback from Crime (Sport) Questions · 11
- Economic Growth (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) Questions · 4
- Wind Farms (Aviation Interests) Questions · 5
- RAF Leuchars Closure (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Fire Brigades Union Scotland (Discussions) Questions · 4
- Insulin Pump Therapy (NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde) Questions · 8
- Problem Alcohol Consumption Questions · 3
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Lockerbie (Access to Documents) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Universities (Access) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Economic Growth First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Scottish Executive Question Time Questions · 1
- Transport Scotland (Capital Infrastructure Projects) Questions · 8
- Clyde Maritime Rescue Co-ordination Centre (Closure) Questions · 6
- New Social Housing (Subsidies) Questions · 6
- Private Rented Housing (Support) Questions · 4
- Housing Benefit Reforms (Access to Social Rented Housing) Questions · 8
- Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Forth Replacement Crossing Questions · 4
- European Commission Officials (Meetings) Questions · 6
- European Council (Discussions with United Kingdom Ministers) Questions · 8
- Museums and Galleries Strategy Questions · 6
- Malawi (Aid Funding) Questions · 4
- Visual Arts Promotion (Aberdeen) Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Festivals (Support) Questions · 6
- Edinburgh International Film Festival Questions · 4
- Joint Ministerial Committee (Meeting) Questions · 6
- European Union (Scotland’s Representation) Questions · 4
- Digital Arts (Support) Questions · 4
- Police and Fire Reform Statement · 35
- European Union Involvement Debate · 61
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 10
- Flavour Fortnight 2011 Members’ business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.