1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2932)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Fergusson 5
The record
19 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2932)
Later today, I will meet the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth, who is visiting the global asset management firm Blackrock Investment Management. Blackrock is establishing its new global centre for fund accounting in Edinburgh, creating up to 250 jobs. I am sure that the whole chamber will wish to welcome the project and Blackrock’s on-going expansion, which is a substantial boost to the financial services sector in Scotland.
The fiasco of the gathering continues to dog the First Minister’s reputation. Around £700,000 of taxpayers’ money was lost. According to Jim Mather, in a reply to a parliamentary question, the First Minister called Steve Cardownie, the Scottish National Party group leader on the City of Edinburgh Council, on 9 October 2009. Mr Mather says that in that call the First Minister discussed with Mr Cardownie
“the financial difficulties of The Gathering 2009 Ltd”.—[Official Report, Written Answers Report, 10 January 2011; S3W-36917.]
Is that true?
“the financial difficulties of The Gathering 2009 Ltd”.—[Official Report, Written Answers Report, 10 January 2011; S3W-36917.]
Is that true?
If I remember correctly, the call was to invite the City of Edinburgh Council to a meeting, which took place. These matters were examined extensively in committee. The answers that I gave there are the answers that stand. I was happy to appear before the parliamentary committee that dealt with the issue and to answer its questions. I suggest that Iain Gray consults the record to inform himself.
I have consulted the record, and these matters have been looked at extensively. The trouble is that questions remain to be answered. Mr Mather says that the First Minister discussed the financial difficulties of The Gathering 2009 Ltd with Mr Cardownie, but on 3 November Mr Cardownie told the Public Audit Committee, with reference to the same call:
“The First Minister did not apprise me over the telephone as to what the issue was.”—[Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 3 November 2010; c 2119.]
Mr Mather and Mr Cardownie cannot both be right. The First Minister was on the call. It is his reputation that is on the line. Who is telling the truth?
“The First Minister did not apprise me over the telephone as to what the issue was.”—[Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 3 November 2010; c 2119.]
Mr Mather and Mr Cardownie cannot both be right. The First Minister was on the call. It is his reputation that is on the line. Who is telling the truth?
I point out that Councillor Cardownie is the representative in Edinburgh who is in charge of events, hence the call to him. As Iain Gray has consulted the record, he will realise that I invited a range of other people to the meeting, which was held in St Andrew’s house. The subject and purpose of the meeting were the future of the gathering and to see how we could sustain the event, which generated £10 million for the Scottish economy, and how it could go forward in the future.
As I said before the committee, I regret that we were unable to follow through on a plan that would have both secured the future of the gathering for the city of Edinburgh and recompensed the outstanding creditors. However, surely Iain Gray is not seriously suggesting that inviting the City of Edinburgh Council and other people to a meeting with the intention of doing two things—securing the financial future of the event and securing the event for the future of the Scottish economy, for which it generated £10 million—is in any sense a bad thing. That is the sort of thing that Governments should be doing. Incidentally, if the committee had found anything untoward about the series of answers that I gave, no doubt its members would have wanted to pursue the matter. Rather than second-guess what the committee did and did not do, Iain Gray should accept that the Government’s intention was to secure the future of an event that generated £10 million for the Scottish economy.
As I said before the committee, I regret that we were unable to follow through on a plan that would have both secured the future of the gathering for the city of Edinburgh and recompensed the outstanding creditors. However, surely Iain Gray is not seriously suggesting that inviting the City of Edinburgh Council and other people to a meeting with the intention of doing two things—securing the financial future of the event and securing the event for the future of the Scottish economy, for which it generated £10 million—is in any sense a bad thing. That is the sort of thing that Governments should be doing. Incidentally, if the committee had found anything untoward about the series of answers that I gave, no doubt its members would have wanted to pursue the matter. Rather than second-guess what the committee did and did not do, Iain Gray should accept that the Government’s intention was to secure the future of an event that generated £10 million for the Scottish economy.
Knowing what to believe matters here. What followed from the meeting that the First Minister refers to was a press release, written by the First Minister’s officials but issued by the City of Edinburgh Council. It contained the sentence:
“DEMA”—[Interruption.]
“DEMA”—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. Mr Gray is entitled to ask about whatever subject he wishes to ask about.
I can understand why the First Minister does not want us to keep pursuing this issue. The press release contains this sentence:
“DEMA”—
that is, the council—
“will take on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s remaining private-sector obligations”.
One hundred and three small businesses that are owed money believed that commitment. However, the SNP council leader now denies that he ever made that promise. While the First Minister and his SNP colleague in the city chambers are playing pass the parcel, the creditors are carrying the can. Who is liable for those obligations—Steve Cardownie and the council, or the First Minister and the Scottish Government?
“DEMA”—
that is, the council—
“will take on The Gathering 2009 Ltd’s remaining private-sector obligations”.
One hundred and three small businesses that are owed money believed that commitment. However, the SNP council leader now denies that he ever made that promise. While the First Minister and his SNP colleague in the city chambers are playing pass the parcel, the creditors are carrying the can. Who is liable for those obligations—Steve Cardownie and the council, or the First Minister and the Scottish Government?
For no other reason than that it is a point of fact—and, if one is asking a series of questions, it is reasonably important to try to get a few facts right—Steve Cardownie is the deputy leader of the City of Edinburgh Council. As I understand it, the leader of the City of Edinburgh Council is a Liberal Democrat. That is just a point of straight fact. I know that Iain Gray has a great attachment to a factual basis for questions—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
The committee report examines the matter of the council press release in some detail, and I think that Iain Gray should again familiarise himself with the contents of the report that the committee concluded.
I am struggling to understand. If Iain Gray wants to ask as many questions as he chooses on this matter from now until the end of this parliamentary session, then fair enough. However, I suspect that a number of people in Scottish society would regard the economy, jobs, the fuel tax—[Interruption.]
This is probably a case of the dog that did not bark. What is revealing about Iain Gray is not the questions that he asks but the questions that he is frightened to ask in this Parliament—[Interruption.]
I am struggling to understand. If Iain Gray wants to ask as many questions as he chooses on this matter from now until the end of this parliamentary session, then fair enough. However, I suspect that a number of people in Scottish society would regard the economy, jobs, the fuel tax—[Interruption.]
This is probably a case of the dog that did not bark. What is revealing about Iain Gray is not the questions that he asks but the questions that he is frightened to ask in this Parliament—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
I know exactly who Steve Cardownie is: he is the person who is carrying the can for the First Minister. I think that the people of Scotland believe that the reputation of their First Minister is a matter of some importance.
Let us consider this affair. It started with a secret loan from the First Minister, now written off. Then, he tried to sell off The Gathering 2009 Ltd, without the knowledge of its own directors, and he failed. Then, he tried to pass liability to the City of Edinburgh Council, but that fix failed too. Councillor Cardownie faces a no-confidence vote; creditors face ruin—103 local businesses; and taxpayers potentially face multimillion pound legal bills. When will the First Minister finally face up to his responsibility for this fiasco?
Let us consider this affair. It started with a secret loan from the First Minister, now written off. Then, he tried to sell off The Gathering 2009 Ltd, without the knowledge of its own directors, and he failed. Then, he tried to pass liability to the City of Edinburgh Council, but that fix failed too. Councillor Cardownie faces a no-confidence vote; creditors face ruin—103 local businesses; and taxpayers potentially face multimillion pound legal bills. When will the First Minister finally face up to his responsibility for this fiasco?
My responsibility was to try to repair the finances of the individual event and to secure the future of the event for Scotland. That is a governmental responsibility because the event itself generated £10 million for the Scottish economy and £8 million for the city of Edinburgh.
Blithe assertions have been made about a no-confidence motion. As I understand the situation in the City of Edinburgh Council, the motion is a Labour opposition motion of no confidence in the administration of the council—or, perhaps, a Conservative party motion of no confidence, which no doubt the Labour Party will want to support—[Interruption.]
Blithe assertions have been made about a no-confidence motion. As I understand the situation in the City of Edinburgh Council, the motion is a Labour opposition motion of no confidence in the administration of the council—or, perhaps, a Conservative party motion of no confidence, which no doubt the Labour Party will want to support—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
I hear the surly tones of Lord George Foulkes. I would have been delighted to answer Lord George’s questions at the Public Audit Committee if he had bothered to turn up and ask some. The committee members who turned up asked a range of questions, which I was delighted to answer—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
What emerged from the committee, I think, was the purpose of the Government to secure the future of the event and the wish of the Government to do everything that it could do to help the position of the creditors.
I regret that the City of Edinburgh Council was not able to follow through with the plan that evolved from the meeting. I regret it because of the effect on individual creditors and because the gathering was a magnificent event, which would have been fitting of the Edinburgh calendar for the future.
Will Iain Gray accept at some point that the people who participated in the meeting and in supporting the gathering—me, Councillor Cardownie, the various other officials who were involved and the politicians who supported the event—did so in a positive way, to secure something of value for the Scottish economy and the city of Edinburgh? I have to say that from start to finish I have seen nothing positive from the Labour Party in its view of the event and only occasional, rather incompetent attempts to seize some little political advantage.
Of course, the reason why Iain Gray did not want to ask about fuel tax—just in case anyone missed this—is that when the rest of the Parliament voted against the rises in fuel tax, he decided to lead the Labour Party into another abstention.
I regret that the City of Edinburgh Council was not able to follow through with the plan that evolved from the meeting. I regret it because of the effect on individual creditors and because the gathering was a magnificent event, which would have been fitting of the Edinburgh calendar for the future.
Will Iain Gray accept at some point that the people who participated in the meeting and in supporting the gathering—me, Councillor Cardownie, the various other officials who were involved and the politicians who supported the event—did so in a positive way, to secure something of value for the Scottish economy and the city of Edinburgh? I have to say that from start to finish I have seen nothing positive from the Labour Party in its view of the event and only occasional, rather incompetent attempts to seize some little political advantage.
Of course, the reason why Iain Gray did not want to ask about fuel tax—just in case anyone missed this—is that when the rest of the Parliament voted against the rises in fuel tax, he decided to lead the Labour Party into another abstention.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 3 Mar 2011 →- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Scottish Parliament Elections Debate · 11
- “Session 3 reports of the Public Audit Committee—key themes” Debate · 40
- Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) Questions · 8
- Child Poverty Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 Questions · 5
- Community Hospitals Questions · 8
- Renewable Power Questions · 4
- University of Glasgow (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Fisheries (Firth of Forth) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Criminal Justice System (Appeals) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Scottish Sensory Centre First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Enterprise Network First Minister’s Questions · 4
- There is a Better Way Campaign Members’ business · 22
- Cities (Sustainable Growth) Questions · 4
- Businesses and Jobs (Inverclyde) Questions · 6
- Scottish Budget (Financial Recovery) Questions · 4
- Flood Alleviation Schemes (Moray) Questions · 4
- Co-operative Enterprises Questions · 4
- Planning Application (Milngavie) Questions · 10
- Oil Price Questions · 4
- Economic Growth (North Ayrshire) Questions · 4
- Economic Activity Questions · 4
- School Buildings (Local Authority Funding) Questions · 6
- Business Rates (Ballater) Questions · 4
- Scottish Investment Bank Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Tram Project Questions · 4
- Public Sector Absenteeism Questions · 6
- Railway Station Car Parking Questions · 6
- Damages (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 16
- Damages (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 16
- Property Factors (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 31
- Property Factors (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 18
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
- Grampian Police Members’ business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.