Question thread · 5 questions
When the report on the dual role of the Lord Advocate will be (a) finalised and (b) published, and whether it will publish preliminary findings in advance of final publication.
Started with S6W-36190 on 24 Mar 2025; latest 29 Jan 2026. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.
The thread, in order
Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text-
To ask the Scottish Government when the report on the dual role of the Lord Advocate will be (a) finalised and (b) published, and whether it will publish preliminary findings in advance of final publication.
Angela Constance, 22 Apr 2025: The final report has been received and as agreed it will now be subject to peer review. I will provide a further update on progress as soon as that has been concluded. We are committed to publishing the report and will do so once the peer review process and any further action needed has concluded. -
When the peer review is expected to (a) commence and (b) conclude, and whether the final report will be published before the end of 2025.
Angela Constance, 6 May 2025: The research paper is currently with peer reviewers and is expected to be concluded by early June. We are committed to publishing the report and will do so once the peer review process and any further action needed has concluded. I expect to be able to do that no later than the end of 2025. -
whether the research paper into the dual role of the Lord Advocate, which was with the peer reviewers and which the Cabinet Secretary “expected to be concluded by early June [2025]”, has concluded, and, if so, when it will be published, and, if it has not concluded, for what reason this is the case.
Angela Constance, 29 Jul 2025: The peer review has now concluded and the feedback shared by the reviewers is currently under consideration by the research paper author, Malcolm McMillan. Once that process, and any further action has concluded, we will publish the paper and it remains that we expect to be able to do that no later than the end of thi… -
And if it is the case that the peer review of the final report into the dual role of the Lord Advocate has concluded as anticipated, when a decision on the related consultation will be made, and when this consultation will begin.
Angela Constance, 30 Jul 2025: The peer review has now concluded and the feedback shared by the reviewers is currently under consideration by the research paper author, Mr Malcom McMillan. Once that process, and any further action needed has concluded, including consideration of the consultation, we will publish the paper and it remains that we exp… -
Whether Malcolm McMillan has concluded his consideration of the conclusions of the peer review; if so, when; if not, and in light of it being six months later, what efforts it has made to assist him in his consideration; what its position is on whether there is "any further action needed"; when the paper will finally be published, and for what reason its expectation that it would be published "no later than the end …
Angela Constance, 13 Feb 2026: Consideration of the peer review undertaken on the research paper from Malcolm McMillan on the roles and functions of the Scottish Law Officers has taken slightly longer than anticipated and is now concluded. The paper has been updated accordingly and has now reached proposed final version, any further action is curre…
How this thread is put together
- Follow-up
- A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
- Several citations
- When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
- Thread
- Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.