Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 9 questions

What its response is to reports that £45 million has been loaned to Ferguson Marine, and whether this is related to the provision of two new ferries being built under contract to CMAL.

Started with S5T-01217 on 17 Sep 2018; latest 26 Sep 2018. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
8
longest chain 1 step
Span
9 days
17 Sep 2018 to 26 Sep 2018
Answered
8 of 9
by Derek Mackay, Paul Wheelhouse
Asked by
1
Jamie Greene

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S5T-01217 17 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Oral

    To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to reports that £45 million has been loaned to Ferguson Marine, and whether this is related to the provision of two new ferries being built under contract to CMAL.

    Oral · 18 Sep 2018
  2. S5W-19039 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered

    (Official Report, c. 7), what advice it received regarding whether the loan to Ferguson Marine (a) was legal, in particular with regard to state EU state-aid rules and (b) constituted a loan under commercial terms.

    Derek Mackay, 23 Oct 2018: Scottish Ministers have provided two commercial loan facilities to Ferguson Marine Engineering Limited. The Scottish Government has taken appropriate legal and commercial advice on this matter. Both loans were negotiated on fully commercial terms following appropriate due diligence and advice. On this basis we conclud…
  3. S5W-19041 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), what correspondence it has had with the (a) European Commission and (b) EU Directorate-General for Competition regarding the loan to Ferguson Marine.

    Derek Mackay, 11 Oct 2018: Scottish Ministers have provided two commercial loan facilities to Ferguson Marine Engineering Limited. These were negotiated on fully commercial terms following appropriate due diligence and with the benefit of independent third-party verification. On this basis we concluded there was no state aid present in the loan…
  4. S5W-19042 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), what discussions it has had with (a) Ferguson Marine and (b) Caledonian Assets Maritime Ltd (CMAL) regarding moving the development of the ferries to another shipyard for completion.

    Derek Mackay, 6 Nov 2018: As part of its approach to risk management mitigation, Transport Scotland had discussions with Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd on the potential time and cost implications of moving the two new ferries to an alternative location for completion.
  5. S5W-19043 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), in light of the cabinet secretary's comment that, "of course due diligence has been conducted", whether it will publish details of this.  

    Derek Mackay, 23 Oct 2018: Lending by Scottish Ministers is governed by a series of controls that ensure the public purse is protected. This includes appropriate due diligence supported by independent third-party verification on matters commercial and legal. The nature of information disclosed to the Scottish Government in the course of commerc…
  6. S5W-19044 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), what knowledge it had of the overruns regarding the ferries, and when it was made aware of these issues.

    Paul Wheelhouse, 23 Oct 2018: Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL) made Transport Scotland aware of cost and time overruns of the two new ferries project in July 2017 when CMAL were advised by Ferguson Marine Engineering Ltd (FMEL).
  7. S5W-19045 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), how many of the 400 jobs associated with the work on the ferries are seasonal or temporary, and what information it has regarding how many of the employees are domiciled or resident in Scotland.

    Derek Mackay, 12 Oct 2018: Workforce levels, terms and conditions of employment, the domiciliary arrangements and residency status of the workers employed at Ferguson Marine Engineering Limited are all matters for the business and individuals concerned. The Scottish Government does not hold the information requested.
  8. S5W-19046 25 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), what the repayment conditions are of the loan to Ferguson Marine; what interest rate is being charged; when the repayment is due, and what enforcement options are available to it if payment is not received or is withheld.

    Derek Mackay, 11 Oct 2018: Scottish Ministers have provided two commercial loan facilities to Ferguson Marine Engineering Limited on fully commercial terms. The terms and conditions of the loan agreements are commercially confidential. The Government has a duty of care to protect such sensitive commercial information and not to disclose materia…
  9. S5W-19075 26 Sep 2018 Jamie Greene Con Answered follows S5T-01217

    (Official Report, c. 7), when (a) the cabinet secretary was and (b) its officials were first advised that there was an overrun of costs on the contract for Ferguson Marine to build the ferries, and whether it will publish any correspondence pertaining to this.

    Paul Wheelhouse, 24 Oct 2018: I refer the member to the answer to question S5W-19044 on 23 October 2018. All answers to written parliamentary questions are available on the Parliament's website, the search facility for which can be found at http://www.parliament.scot/parliamentarybusiness/28877.aspx . In terms of correspondence, on 16 August 2018,…

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads