Parliament Workbench

Question thread · 12 questions

For what reason it does not support a ban on the export of live animals.

Started with S5T-00925 on 5 Feb 2018; latest 5 Feb 2020. Each later question says it follows up an earlier answer.

Follow-ups
11
longest chain 3 steps
Span
730 days
5 Feb 2018 to 5 Feb 2020
Answered
11 of 12
by Fergus Ewing, Mairi Gougeon
Asked by
2
MSPs

The thread, in order

Each answer’s opening lines; open a question for the full text
  1. S5T-00925 5 Feb 2018 Christine Grahame SNP Oral

    To ask the Scottish Government for what reason it does not support a ban on the export of live animals.

    Oral · 6 Feb 2018
  2. S5W-14461 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell Green Answered

    (Official Report, c. 7), what discussions it has had with the UK Government regarding a ban on the export of live animals for fattening and slaughter.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: Scottish Government officials have had routine meetings on animal transport with their counterparts in other UK administrations at which a possible ban on live exports for slaughter was discussed.
  3. S5W-14462 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell Green Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), how many (a) sheep, (b) cattle and (c) poultry were exported for breeding in (i) 2016 and (ii) 2017 to (A) the rest the UK and (B) other countries outside of the UK, and how much these exports were worth.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: The Scottish Government has identified the following data for movements of cattle and sheep. The internal UK data are from Rapid Analysis and Detection of Animal-related Risk (RADAR)and apply to movements from Scotland to England, Wales and Northern Ireland. The non-UK exports are from the Trade Control and Export Sys…
  4. S5W-14464 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell Green Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), what assessment it has made of how a UK-wide ban on the export of live animals for slaughter could impact on the quality livestock sector in the (a) Northern Isles, (b) Western Isles and (c) rest of Scotland.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: As there are currently no exports of animals from Scotland for slaughter to continental Europe, there would be little impact of a ban on these movements.
  5. S5W-14465 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell Green Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), what consultation it has had with (a) animal welfare groups, (b) farmers' representatives and (c) other stakeholders regarding the impact on Scotland of a UK-wide ban on the export of live animals for slaughter.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: The Scottish Government has had initial discussions with stakeholders about DEFRA proposals to consult on this issue.
  6. S5W-14467 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell Green Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), how many (a) sheep and lambs and (b) cattle and calves were exported for slaughter or fattening in (i) 2016 and (ii) 2017 to (A) the rest of the UK and (B) other countries, and how much these exports were worth.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: The Scottish Government has identified the following data for movements of cattle and sheep. The data are from the Trade Control and Export System compiled by the Animal and Plant Health Agency. Information on movements within the UK are only available for movements to Northern Ireland. Exports Sheep and Lambs 2016 Sh…
  7. S5W-14468 6 Feb 2018 Mark Ruskell Green Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), what tonnage of (a) sheep meat and (b) beef was exported in (i) 2016 and (ii) 2017 to (A) the rest of the UK and (B) other countries, and how much these exports were worth.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: Quality Meat Scotland’s ‘The Scottish Red Meat Industry Profile 2017’ reports the value of sheep meat and beef trade to other countries for 2016. Data is not currently available for 2017; the tonnage of meat exported is not reported. Beef to the value of £420 million and £36.5 million was sent to the rest of the UK an…
  8. S5W-14474 7 Feb 2018 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), in light of the cabinet secretary's comment that "the export of live animals from Scotland is done for other reasons—breeding and production. Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs has indicated that the value of that totals £50 million a year", how many animals have been exported for (a) slaughter and (b) breeding and production in each year since 2015, broken down by breed.

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: Information supplied by the Animal and Plant Health Agency lists 48,883 animals as having been exported for slaughter, breeding and production from Scotland to Northern Ireland and countries outside the UK for 2017. Information is not held for 2015 and 2016. Data broken down by breed is not available. 2017 Live Export…
  9. S5W-14485 7 Feb 2018 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S5T-00925

    (Official Report, c. 7), in light of the cabinet secretary's comment that "the export of live animals from Scotland is done for other reasons—breeding and production. Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) has indicated that the value of that totals £50 million a year", what information it has regarding how HMRC calculated the figure, including how much of this represents exports for (a) breeding and production an…

    Fergus Ewing, 13 Mar 2018: The Scottish Government understands that Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs collect information from Customs declaration forms to estimate the value of live animal exports from Scotland. This figure includes all live animal exports to countries outside the UK.
  10. S5W-15655 26 Mar 2018 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S5W-14474

    How many of the (a) cattle, (b) sheep, (c) pigs and (d) goats that were exported in 2017 for (i) slaughter, (ii) breeding and (iii) fattening/production had (A) Northern Ireland, (B) the Republic of Ireland, (C) France, (D) Belgium, (E) Spain, (F) Italy, (G) Germany and (H) the Netherlands as their final destination.

    Fergus Ewing, 1 May 2018: The Scottish Government takes the welfare of transported animals seriously, whether within the United Kingdom or for export purposes. Animals should be exported only in line with strict welfare standards, which ensure freedom from harm and sufficient rest and nourishment, and ensure that transport welfare rules are fu…
  11. S5W-22448 1 Apr 2019 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S5W-14474

    How many animals were consigned from Scotland to continental Europe on journeys via England for (a) breeding, (b) fattening/production and (c) slaughter in each year since 2017, broken down by species.

    Mairi Gougeon, 24 Apr 2019: Information supplied by the Animal and Plant Health Agency lists 2,421 animals as having been consigned from Scottish holdings to continental Europe on journeys via England in 2018. 2018 Live Exports Cattle Sheep Pigs Goats Breeding 2,231 170 0 0 Fattening/Production 0 20 0 0 Slaughter 0 0 0 0 The number of animals ex…
  12. S5W-27324 5 Feb 2020 Christine Grahame SNP Answered follows S5W-15655

    How many of the (a) cattle, (b) sheep, (c) pigs and (d) goats that were exported in 2018 for (i) slaughter, (ii) breeding and (iii) fattening/production had (A) Northern Ireland, (B) the Republic of Ireland, (C) France, (D) Belgium, (E) Spain, (F) Italy, (G) Germany and (H) the Netherlands as their final destination.

    Mairi Gougeon, 19 Feb 2020: The Scottish Government takes the welfare of transported animals seriously, whether within the United Kingdom or for export purposes. Animals should be exported only in line with strict welfare standards, which ensure freedom from harm and sufficient rest and nourishment, and ensure that transport welfare rules are fu…

How this thread is put together

Follow-up
A question whose text says it is “further to the answer to question …” (or reply, response, or asks for a “substantive answer” to an earlier question). The question it names is its parent.
Several citations
When a question cites more than one earlier question, the most recent one we hold is used as the parent; the others are listed as “also cites”.
Thread
Follow parents back to the first question; every question that leads back to it is in this thread. Branches are shown in date order.

All question threads